This is a criminal appeal under Section 14A of the SC/ST Act, 1989, preferred by the appellants against an order of the Special Court for SC/ST (POA) Act dismissing their anticipatory bail application in Crime No. 1342/2023 of the Medical College Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram. The 2nd respondent, Priya G.S., alleges caste-based harassment and assault by the 1st appellant, who is her husband, and the 2nd and 3rd appellants, his mother and sister, leading to registration of offences including 498A IPC and provisions of the SC/ST Act (3(1)(r)/(s)/(c)). The trial court found prima facie that offences under the SC/ST Act were made out, triggering Section 18 Bar to anticipatory bail. The Kerala High Court, after hearing arguments, observes that the law on Section 18 requires a purposive interpretation and a prima facie evaluation of the allegations to determine if offences under the SC/ST Act are made out, citing Vilas Pandurang Pawar and Prathvi Raj Chauhan, and the Kerala decision in Ahammedkutty Pothiyil Thottiparambil. The court holds that the materials against the 2nd and 3rd appellants do not prima facie establish SC/ST offences, while the 1st appellant does. The appeal is allowed in part: anticipatory bail is granted to appellants 2 and 3 on specified conditions, while the 1st appellant’s anticipatory bail is dismissed.
CRL.A Nos. 1588/2008, 1628/2008, 2078/2008 These three criminal appeals arise from a conviction under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) of the NDPS Act, 1985, for illegal possession of ganja. On 13.11.2005, around 7:30 a.m., forest authorities intercepted a motorcycle near Mukkali Forest Check Post; 5.2 kg of ganja was recovered from a bag, with 50 grams of the substance sent for chemical analysis. The respondents relied on seizure lists, motorist searches, and confessional statements, while the trial court convicted the appellants. On appeal, the High Court scrutinized multiple irregularities in investigation and procedure: improper weighing and retention of the contraband, failure to produce the big bag and remaining ganja in court, a body-search conducted without a Gazetted Officer or Magistrate, Ext.P1’s defective execution, and unexplained delays in producing the seized articles and sample to the chemical analyst. It highlighted reliance on confessions to the investigating officer, which, per Tofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu (2021), cannot sustain conviction unless corroborated under Section 53-A of the Evidence Act. The court also criticized the “farcical” compliance with Section 50 of the NDPS Act and the absence of credible chain-of-custody. Ultimately, the Appeals were allowed and the appellants acquitted, with bail bonds discharged. The decision reinforces strict compliance with NDPS procedures and rejects the notion of “substantial compliance.”
CRL.M.C 288/2013; CRL.M.C 1461/2013 The Kerala High Court, Bechu Kurian Thomas, J., disposed of two criminal miscellaneous petitions (CrL.M.C. Nos. 288/2013 and 1461/2013) filed under section 482 Cr.P.C. challenging a further final report in CC No. 850/2011 arising from a money circulation scheme marketed as LIS Deepasthambam. The petitioners alleged that the ‘further investigation’ amounted to a fresh reinvestigation, that the investigating officer lacked jurisdiction, and that the inclusion of events after the final report rendered the proceedings illegal. The court examined whether the Assistant Commissioner of Police, Narcotic Cell, Kochi City, competent to conduct the further investigation, and whether incorporating subsequent events in the further final report was permissible. Relying on established jurisprudence, including State of Bihar v. J.A.C. Saldanha and Others; K.Chandrasekhar v. State of Kerala; and R.P. Kapur v. Sardar Pratap Singh Kairon, the court held that a ‘further investigation’ is a continuation of the original investigation under Cr.P.C. 173(8), not a fresh investigation, and that superior police authority can direct such investigation within the territorial jurisdiction. It also held that additions of instances after the final report do not invalidate the process, as such material may be examined at trial. The court ultimately dismissed the petitions but directed expeditious trial within ten months, noting unacceptable delay. The order discusses related S.L.P. and Supreme Court guidance and underscores the State’s obligation to advance justice.
This Suo Motu Special Commissioner report arises from the order dated 18 December 2024 in SSCR No. 79 of 2024 and concerns governance, sponsorship, and donor-privilege arrangements at Sabarimala’s Pranavam Pilgrim Centre. It centers on an agreement dated 29 December 2023 between the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB) and KK Vithani Foundation (CSR arm of Farmson Pharmaceuticals) for renovation of 38 rooms at Pranavam Pilgrim Centre, with a total sponsorship of Rs 86 lakhs (including consultancy). The agreement contemplates sponsor privileges such as display of sponsor details at renovated rooms and other privileges that run for 20 years from completion, subject to the master plan. Issues emerged when Sponsor donor Room No.117 was found in donor possession, with the key with the 4th respondent; inspection revealed an air conditioner and a fridge. Additional respondents 9 and 10 were suo motu impleaded, and affidavits were filed. The court invoked Travancore Devaswom Act provisions and Kerala Police Act security norms, and relied on Sajeev Sastharam and earlier Suo Motu orders concerning Virtual-Q management. The bench directed donor verification, regulation of occupancy, and firm adherence to statutory duties. The SSCR is disposed with directions that donor rooms be regulated (free five days, ten paid days per year for donors) and that a verification process be completed, with a report to be placed before the Devaswom Bench.
This High Court of Kerala, in MACA No.1174/2012, revisits an award under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 issued by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thrissur, for injuries sustained in a 2003 auto-rickshaw accident. The appellant/claimant contends that the Tribunal erred in limiting compensation and in underestimating his income and various heads of damages. The Tribunal held the driver responsible, with the owner vicariously liable and the insurer to indemnify; it awarded Rs.52,467 at 8% interest. The appellant argues that he was not shown to be abroad with proof, but claims a higher monthly income (Rs.10,000) and seeks enhancement across heads such as medical expenses, loss of earnings, bystander expenses, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities. The insurer contends that the award is just and reasonable and disputes the claimed higher income. The High Court cites Ramachandrappa to fix a notional monthly income around Rs.4,000 for 2003 and Raj Kumar for the principle that awards must fully restore the claimant to his pre-accident status, while distinguishing between pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages. After reviewing Exts.A5-A7 for medical treatment and the evidence, the Court recalculates damages, partially enhancements, and allows the appeal for an increased total of Rs.16,700 with interest, directing payment by the insurer within two months and noting costs to be borne by the parties.
This Bail Application under Section 438 CrPC concerns three petitioners (Gokul G Nath, Anoop A, Shameem B) in Crime No. 833/2023 of Kurathikadu Police Station, Alappuzha, alleged to have formed an unlawful assembly with common intention to murder the defacto complainant and others on the night of 18.12.2023 around 23:00 hours. The prosecution claims offences under Sections 143, 147, 148, 149, 323, 324, and 307 read with Section 149 IPC, with the accused assaulting the complainant and friends, causing grievous injuries including nasal bone and orbital fractures, and one person requiring ventilatory support. The petitioners contend total innocence and false implication, highlighting an out-of-court settlement evidenced by Annexure C affidavit wherein the complainant states no objection to grant of pre-arrest bail. They argue custodial interrogation is unnecessary and no recovery is anticipated, hence bail should be granted. The Respondents oppose, submitting that the accused acted in common with others, resorted to violence, and custodial interrogation is essential to safeguard the investigation and prevent tampering. The court cites Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra, Sibbia, and Jai Prakash Singh to emphasize case-specific discretion under a stringent framework, but ultimately concludes that custodial interrogation is necessary, and Pre-Arrest Bail is not warranted. The bail application is dismissed.
The petition challenges a judgment convicting the petitioner for offences under Section 279 IPC and Section 185 MV Act, based on a guilty plea recorded by the Judicial Magistrate, Kozhikode, in S.T. No. 984 of 2019. The incident occurred on 18.10.2019. The accused ostensibly appeared through counsel, pleaded guilty, and was convicted with fines of Rs. 750 under IPC 279 and Rs. 10,000 under the MV Act. The petitioner asserts that he did not authorize the counsel to plead guilty, was not present at the relevant proceedings, and that the procedure prescribed under Cr.P.C. for conviction on a plea of guilty (Sections 251 and 252) was not complied with. He relies on this Court’s decision in Raseen Babu KM v. State of Kerala, which emphasizes that “pleading guilty” must be a positive, informed act and not mere lip service. The State contends that the plea was recorded and the procedure may have been followed; however, the High Court scrutiny reveals a lack of compliance with reading of the particulars in the accused’s presence and assurance of understanding consequences. The High Court thus sets aside the conviction, remands for fresh consideration after issuing summons, and permits the petitioner to seek release of the deposited fine pending re-trial. The petition is disposed of accordingly.
This is an interlocutory custody matter under O.P.(FC) No.83 of 2023 before the Kerala High Court (Ernakulam). The petitioner, mother Jinu Subin, sought permanent custody of her two daughters and interim relief for custody; the Family Court had earlier granted interim custody to the respondent on certain weekends and holidays (Ext.P6, 11.01.2023). The petitioner challenged this order under Article 227 of the Constitution of India before the High Court, arguing that the welfare and safety of the children warranted restricting overnight custody, especially since the respondent stayed in a lodge and had to travel for work. Counseling was arranged, and the parties, including the children, were subjected to multiple sessions with the Family Counselling Centre. The judgment relies on the principle that the welfare of the child is the paramount consideration in custody disputes, citing Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan to emphasise the best-interest standard and the right of a child to maintain contact with both parents, subject to safety and welfare considerations. While acknowledging the respondent’s affection and bond with the children, the High Court found overnight custody impracticable under the facts, and modified the interim order to grant day custody and regulated contact. The petition was disposed with a modified custody framework and avenues for future modification, preserving the child’s welfare as the guiding criterion.
Cont.Case (C) No.2266 of 2019 Contempt petition filed by petitioners 9, 10, 11, 16, 20, 22, 28, 29, 33, 37, 44 and 46 in W.P.(C) No.36731 of 2015 alleged willful disobedience of the directions contained in the judgment dated 12 October 2018 in that writ petition and connected matters. The petitioners contend that the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) failed to implement the directions of the 2018 writ court judgment, thereby affecting their entitlement to higher pension under the provident fund scheme. The judgment traces the background of the EPFO scheme and subsequent Supreme Court orders, including the dismissal and recall of the SLP against the 2018 judgment, culminating in the detailed 2022 Supreme Court judgment in Civil Appeals Nos. 8143-8144 of 2022 (Sunil Kumar B.) and connected matters. The Sunil Kumar B. judgment held that the provisions of Notification No. G.S.R. 609(E) dated 22 August 2014 are legal and valid, read down certain provisions, and directed amendments to the pension scheme, with extended time to exercise options and clarifications on who is covered by the post‑amendment provisions. In light of the 2022 decision, the High Court observes that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO. The court closes the contempt case, but reserves the EPFO’s right to reconsider entitlement in accordance with law and the apex court’s directions, and directs adherence to the 2022 judgment within the period contemplated. The petition is heard with the parties’ counsel, and the matter is disposed of accordingly.
Cont. Case (C) No. 604/2017 Melukavu Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. filed Contempt Case (C) 604/2017 seeking relief for non‑compliance with a decree arising from W.P.(C) No.13259/2012 dated 8 November 2016, affirmed by the Division Bench in W.A.No.280/2017 on 3 March 2017. The decree granted recovery of a principal amount due from the Kerala State Co-operative Rubber Marketing Federation Ltd., Cochin, with the petitioner contending that while the principal had been paid, approximately Rs. 1.5 crores remained outstanding as interest. The present petition notes that certain assets of the debtor were mortgaged to the Kerala State Co-operative Bank after a Memorandum of Understanding with the State Government, which raises questions about enforcement. The court relies on the principle stated in Chief Engineer (Irrigation), Trivandrum and Another v. K. Reghunathan (2014) 1 KHC 510 that such judgments can be executed through the Civil Procedure Code, allowing the execution court to recover encumbered property and to exclude any prior period from limitation. The learned Judge’s approach emphasizes that execution is the proper route to enforce the decree and that property encumbrances should not bar execution. On these grounds, with liberty as stated, the Contempt Case is closed, and the order of this Court is to be treated as a decree for purposes of execution, with permission granted to the petitioner to execute it accordingly.
This is a Kerala High Court writ petition filed by St. Mary’s Orthodox Church (Odakkali) and its Vicar seeking protection and enforcement of Supreme Court directions to allow the clergy appointed under the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church’s 1934 Constitution to conduct religious services in the Odakkali church and its associated properties, without obstruction by the Jacobite faction. The petition asserts that the 1st petitioner is a constituent church of the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church, presently controlled by a Jacobite faction, and that only vicars appointed under the 1934 Constitution should officiate Holy Mass and sacraments. It relies on Ext.P3 and Ext.P4 orders, and on the Supreme Court’s guidance in K.S. Varghese v. St. Peter’s & Paul’s Syrian Orthodox Church (2017) to contend that no parallel administration or intrusion by the Patriarch’s spiritual prerogatives can override the 1934 Constitution. The respondents contend the church is Jacobite and that the 1st Additional District Court’s Section 92 order and related court proceedings are not properly jurisdictional, arguing maintainability issues and that a writ is not the correct vehicle for civil disputes over church identity and property. The court reiterates that the Malankara Church is episcopal in character, the 1934 Constitution governs parish affairs, and that binding Supreme Court directives must be implemented. The judgment cites St. Mary’s Orthodox Church v. State Police Chief (SC) and Mar Miletius Yuhanonon and Marthoman Church cases to emphasize the duty of police to enforce binding orders and to prevent obstruction, ultimately concluding that the writ petition should be allowed and directing respondents to provide police protection so the 2nd petitioner and clergy may enter the church and conduct services within two months.
Musthafa, the appellant in MACA No.1711 of 2012, challenged the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Manjeri's dismissal of his claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act for injuries suffered in a road accident on 27 January 2008 while he was walking along the Nilambur–Manjeri road. The Tribunal held that the evidence failed to prove involvement of the offending vehicle, a lorry bearing KL 11R 8840, or that the driver was the first respondent, and it dismissed the petition despite Exts. A1–A5 and Exts. B1–B11 being produced. The insurer contended delays in filing the FIR (28 January) and late seizure/inspection of the vehicle, and argued the possibility that the injury occurred in another incident; it also highlighted that the criminal case ended in acquittal and relied on Pazhaniammal and Mohankumar jurisprudence to challenge the civil claim. The High Court, after hearing, reversed the Tribunal’s findings, holding that the claimant had established vehicle involvement and the driver’s control at the relevant time. It re-evaluated medical records showing serious injuries, FIR evidence, and treatment history, and rejected the view that delay or inspection negated the claim. The court also reassessed income, awarded enhanced compensation for medical expenses, 1% permanent disability (X1), bystander expenses, transport, clothing, and loss of amenities, totaling Rs.92,100 with 7.5% interest.
Crl. Appeal (V) No. 36 of 2022 The Kerala High Court, in a victim-initiated criminal appeal, examines whether an interlocutory order refusing the return of certain material objects seized during the trial can be challenged by the defacto complainant. The Sessions Court, in the underlying S.C. No. 439 of 2015, convicted A1 to A6 and directed in para 103 that MO1–MO5 be handed to PW1, the defacto complainant, while the accused filed appeals. The defacto complainant has since been impleaded as an additional respondent in those pending appeals, in light of the Apex Court’s dictum on victims’ participatory rights in criminal proceedings (Jagjeet Singh & Ors. v. Ashish Mishra alias Monu & anr., (2022) 9 SCC 321, paras 22–23). The appellant argues for restoration of MO1–MO5 to her as per the main judgment; the Sessions Court subsequently rejected this plea on 5.12.2019 in Crl.M.P. No. 979/2019 while the accused appeals continue. The State contends that Cr.P.C. Sec. 372 precludes such an appeal unless expressly provided; the proviso to Sec. 372 confers limited rights to victims in certain conviction/acquittal contexts and does not cover this interlocutory order. The bench analyzes Sec. 452(1) on disposal of property, reiterates that the 2016 directions remain operative, and concludes that the present appeal is not maintainable. The court, however, directs that the proper remedy lies in filing a Cr.P.C. Sec. 482 petition in the pending appeals, and dismisses the present appeal with liberty to pursue Sec. 482 filings.
CRL.M.C. No. 1723 of 2024 This is a criminal miscellaneous case (Crl.M.C. No.1723 of 2024) filed under Section 482 CrPC seeking to quash FIR No.043/2023 of Pattambi Police Station and the final report in CC No.47/2023 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court Pattambi. The petitioners, five accused in Crime No.43/2023, are Muhammed Muhsin, Akberali, Sainaba, MUFLAF and Noora. The second respondent is Shafin, the wife of the first accused; the first respondent is the State of Kerala. The matter arises from alleged offences under Section 498A read with Section 34 IPC. The petition argued that the dispute between the parties had been amicably settled, with the second respondent executing Annexure-A3 affidavit stating she has no objection to quashing further proceedings. The Investigating Officer reported that the matter had been settled, and that the petitioners and second respondent had resumed cohabitation. The Public Prosecutor and second respondent also supported quashing given the lack of subsisting grievance. The High Court invoked its inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC and relied on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Prabatbhai Aahir v. State of Gujarat, both emphasizing that where there is an amicable settlement and offences are not serious, continuing criminal proceedings would not serve the ends of justice. The court therefore allowed the Crl.M.C., quashing the FIR, the final report, and all further proceedings.
The High Court of Kerala deals with WP(Crl) No. 474 of 2021, challenging a detention order under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAA(P)A). The detenu, detained for one year from 04.09.2021, faced a cadre of accusations primarily centered on the procedural and substantive validity of the preventive detention. The petitioner contends a cascade of irregularities: (i) delay in forwarding the detention order to the Government, (ii) prolonged delay in disposing the Advisory Board’s representation (advocacy by the detenu’s counsel notes a 55-day disposal; representation dated 14.09.2021 and dispatched 30.10.2021, raising concerns about timing relative to order of confirmation), (iii) failure to supply earlier detention orders and bail orders to the Detaining Authority, (iv) last prejudicial act on 11.06.2021 and the detention order dated 01.09.2021 creating questions about the live link between the prejudicial act and detention (as discussed in Jimesh Jose), (v) illegible copies of some case documents, and (vi) the 107 proceedings under CrPC initiated before the SDM. The Government Pleader submits the forwarding and approval were timely, delays were explained by pandemic-related holidays, and 107 proceedings were properly considered. The Court finds several defects fatal: non-fulfilment of Section 3(3) forthwith forwarding, and non-supply of the bail order to the Detaining Authority, rendering the detention vitiated. While some arguments are rejected, the court quashes the detention, releases the detenu forthwith, and directs communication of the order to the prison.
DBP Nos.41 and 42 of 2024 This is a Division Bench matter before the Kerala High Court (DBP Nos. 41 and 42 of 2024) arising from Suo Motu proceedings initiated under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950. The Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB) sought urgent approvals for special repairs and maintenance of Sabari Guest House at Sabarimala Sannidhanam and the staff quarters building, with estimated costs of Rs. 1.76 crore and Rs. 94 lakh respectively (inclusive of GST). Ombudsman Reports No. 18/2024 and 19/2024 had highlighted dilapidated conditions—guest house (constructed 1995) with 56 rooms and the staff quarters (constructed 2004) with 80 rooms—where water lines, sanitary fittings, doors, windows, and tiling were in poor condition. The petitions outlined that tenders were invited electronically; three bids were received for the guest house, with the lowest bid at 13.48% below the estimated rate; one bid for the staff quarters was also received. Audit remarks largely supported the need for repair but urged post‑award verification and possible adjustments, including a proposed cap on European closets due to water consumption concerns. The court conducted an inspection on 08.05.2024 and received a consolidated report from PWD Buildings Division endorsing the repairs. Ultimately, the court disposed of both petitions by approving the works, subject to State Audit Department scrutiny, with the Board directed to furnish work and maintenance registers and tender documents for audit before proceeding further.
This is a Criminal Misc. Case (Crl.M.C. No. 7986 of 2022) filed under Section 482 Cr.P.C. challenging a common order (CMP Nos.1322/2022 and 1323/2022) in S.C. No.265/2018 before the Special Court for SC/ST (POA) Act, Mannarkad, Palakkad. The first accused, Hussain, sought quashing of the two CMPs which sought summons and copies of inquest/inquiry reports under Section 176 Cr.P.C. (1A) and related proceedings. The prosecution contends that the inquiry reports (by the SDM and the JMFC) relate to the cause of death of Madhu in custody and are relevant to whether police torture occurred, offering material for cross-examination and for or against the prosecution’s theory. The petitioner argued that such reports are not substantive evidence, are not admissible as public documents under Section 35 of the Evidence Act, and that non-disclosure and cross-examination issues render them inadmissible; reliance on Madhu v. State of Karnataka and other authorities was urged. The Public Prosecutor, on the other hand, urged that Section 311 Cr.P.C. permits summoning and admitting essential materials even if not furnished with the final report and that Section 5 and 35 of the Evidence Act permit such references as evidence of existence of facts. The High Court held that the common order summoning the witnesses under Section 311 Cr.P.C. is lawful and dismissed the petition, clarifying that the merits of the trial are to be decided independently by the trial court.
WA 786/2021 (and connected WA 718/2021 & WA 750/2021) This intra-court appeal pertains to challenges against government-directed freezes of Dearness Allowance (DA) for CPSE employees during the COVID-19 crisis and the extension of those restrictions to workmen at BPCL's Kochi Refinery. The petitions, filed by workmen unions and associated bodies, questioned Ext. P-1 (Nov 19, 2020) which froze additional DA for executives and non-unionized supervisors, and its subsequent application to other employee categories despite Ext. P-2 (Jan 8, 2021) which clarified that Ext. P-1 would apply only to executives and non-unionized supervisors. The Union Government asserted the amendments were in the public interest and within the government’s policy framework; BPCL contended that the settlement with workers and the overall pay structure justified the continued restriction on DA, and that disputes should be resolved under the ID Act. The Kerala High Court (A. Thomas and V. Abraham JJ., Division Bench) held that Ext. P-1 cannot be applied to workmen after Ext. P-2, and that BPCL’s continued DA restrictions to workmen were illegal, ultra vires, and violative of Articles 14 and 16. The court emphasized the public-law character of the challenge, acknowledged the State/State-like status of BPCL, and directed release of withheld DA for the relevant period, while recognizing the availability of ID Act remedies but preventing automatic relegation to that route.
This is MACA No.1600 of 2012 before the High Court of Kerala (Ernakulam) challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakuda award in OP(MV) No.183/2008. The appellant, Abdullakutty C.A., sustained multiple injuries in a January 17, 2008 road accident when a car (KL-7/AA 2788) driven by the 2nd respondent hit him while he walked along the Kodungallur-Irinjalakuda public road. The car was owned by the 1st respondent and insured with the 3rd respondent. The Tribunal partly allowed the petition and held the 3rd respondent insurer liable to pay Rs.1,25,000 with interest and costs, after confirming the car owner’s liability and relying on Ext.A2 police final report. The appellant contested the quantum, arguing for higher compensation, including a higher notional income (Rs.5,000 per month instead of Rs.2,500), longer loss of earnings, and a larger award for permanent disability (10%) and loss of earning capacity, applying the multiplier of 11 from Sarla Verma. The insurer claimed negligence by the appellant or disputed liability and highlighted policy terms. The High Court re-evaluated the evidence, fixed Rs.5,000 as notional income, and, after applying appropriate multipliers and disability assessments, enhanced compensation. The appeal was allowed in part, with a further enhancement of Rs.64,460 plus costs and interest, to be deposited by the insurer within 60 days.
This is a revision petition under Section 125 CrPC filed by Abdul Shukur against an order of the Family Court, Palakkad, in MC No.19/2018, directing him to pay maintenance to his wife Mariamma. The respondent-wife had initially sought maintenance of Rs.15,000 per month, claiming matrimonial cruelty and that she had no means to support herself, having left the matrimonial home with two children. The Family Court consolidated the maintenance petition with ancillary proceedings (return of gold ornaments and child custody). The petitioner contends that his income is not Rs.50,000 as stated, arguing he is burdened with two children and elderly parents and is undergoing medical treatment; he asserts that he is unable to sustain higher payments. He challenges the escalating maintenance schedule—Rs.3,000 per month (Jan 2018–Jan 2022), Rs.4,500 (Feb 2022–Jun 2022), and Rs.5,000 (from July 2023)—as unsupportable and not grounded on cogent materials, and contends that a fixed amount should be fixed after determining his notional income. The learned judge cites Supreme Court jurisprudence emphasising maintenance as a social-justice measure and the duty of the husband to provide support, and notes that an escalatory order without proper materials is unsustainable. The result is a partial allowance of the revision: maintenance fixed at Rs.4,000 per month from January 2018, with arrears to be paid in three installments and liberty for alteration under Sec.127 on a change of circumstances.