Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 426 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
Cont. Case (Civil) No. 808 of 2022

Contempt of Court Case (Civil) No. 808 of 2022

This Contempt of Court Case (Civil) No. 808 of 2022 before the Kerala High Court concerns Muhammed Rafi, the sole accused in Crime No. 254/2022 (Wadakkancherry Police Station, Thrissur), who challenges the arrest as a violation of Supreme Court directions and statutory safeguards. The petitioner contends that his arrest on 18-03-2022, in a case under Sections 406 and 420 IPC, was made in gross contravention of the Arnesh Kumar judgment (Supreme Court) and without issuing notice under Section 41A CrPC prior to arrest. He points to Annexure-A3, a 2018 Sessions Court order, allegedly ignored by the police, and asserts that the failure to issue 41A notice rendered the arrest illegal and caused him 15 days of judicial custody. The respondent police defend the action, asserting the presence of serious charges and the necessity to arrest promptly to recover belongings and prevent external influence on witnesses; they attribute delays to new officers at Wadakkancherry and their apparent lack of knowledge about the older order. The court examined affidavits, permitted further affidavits, and ultimately accepted an unconditional apology from the respondent, deciding to drop the Contempt petition. The bench reiterated compliance with Arnesh Kumar and Satender Kumar Antil directions, and left open the petitioner’s rights to pursue compensation through proper legal channels. The order emphasizes that police powers cannot be misused and that court directives bind all authorities.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4986 OF 2023

Hariharan and Pyarilal v State of Kerala & Another

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case under section 482 CrPC challenges the final report in Crime No. 43/2020 of the Ernakulam Excise Range, which charges the petitioners Hariharan (shop manager) and Pyarilal (licensee) with offences under Sections 57(aa) and 56(b) of the Kerala Abkari Act for allegedly adulterating toddy by adding starch. The investigation followed sampling of toddy from Toddy Shop No.36/2019-2020 and chemical analysis confirming starch presence, which is said to violate the licence conditions. The petition contends that Section 57(aa) was introduced in 2018 as a specific offence for starch addition, while Section 56(b) is a general provision penalizing willful breaches of license conditions. They argue that combining both provisions in the final report is inconsistent with settled law, citing Ani & Another v State of Kerala & Another (2021) 6 KHC 176, which held that where a charge-sheet alleged a violation under Section 57(aa), there is no justification to simultaneously charge under Section 56(b). The court considered Annexure-A2 (Ani) and held that continuation of the prosecution under Section 56(b) is not permissible; consequently, Annexure-A1 to the extent it charges 56(b) is quashed. The case is decided in part: the petition is allowed to the extent of quashing 56(b); the petitioners remain open to compounding for the offences under the Abkari Act under Section 67A, subject to procedural compliance.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) Nos.491/2023, 9/2024, 17/2024, 394/2023, 416/2023, 443/2023, 490/2023, 517/2023, 560/2023

OP(KAT) Nos.491/2023, 9/2024, 17/2024, 394/2023, 416/2023, 443/2023, 490/2023, 517/2023, 560/2023 v. State of Kerala

This batch of original petitions challenges the Kerala Transport Service (Amendment) Special Rules, 2022, which inserted a qualification requirement for Joint Regional Transport Officer (Joint RTO) in the Kerala Transport Service Rules (1981) by mandating a Diploma in Automobile Engineering or Mechanical Engineering. The petitioners contend that the amendment, introduced by the Kerala Government under the Kerala Public Services Act, 1968, is ultra vires Section 213(4) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, as Central Government alone may prescribe minimum qualifications for officers in the Motor Vehicles Department. They rely on constitutional provisions (Entry 41 List II, Article 309) and precedent like Basheer v. Kerala Assistant Motor Vehicle Inspectors Association and S.Satyapal Reddy, among others, to argue that the State cannot impose a technical qualification for Joint RTO, a post viewed as administrative and not requiring such technical expertise. The respondents defend the amendment as a legitimate exercise of state rulemaking, invoking Article 309, the Kerala Public Services Act and the enabling nature of Section 213(4). The court engages in a harmonization analysis, noting that Central rules may prevail only where a direct conflict exists and that the State can prescribe conditions of service absent a higher Central prescription. Ultimately, the petitions are dismissed, upholding the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s findings that the Amendment Rules are valid and operative.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl.) No. 172/23

Suseela Babu and Girija Velayudhan v. State of Kerala

Two writ petitions (WP(Crl.) No. 172/23) by Suseela Babu and Girija Velayudhan challenge the denial of ordinary parole to their sons who are inmates in S.C. No.705 of 2015 (IV Additional Sessions Court, Thrissur) and sentenced to life imprisonment. The petitioners contend the denial is arbitrary, discriminatory, and driven by extraneous political considerations. They point out that the prisoners have completed four years in jail and applied for ordinary parole; probation reports are in their favor, yet police reports alleged potential law-and-order problems upon release. Relying on Rule 397(l) of the Kerala Prisons and Correctional Services (Management) Rules, 2014, they argue that the only grounds for denying ordinary parole are the jail offences listed in Rule 397(l)(iii), and the offences alleged in Ext. P10 and P11 (e.g., possession of a mobile phone inside jail and a Section 151 Cr.P.C offence) do not fall within that category. They also note that one petitioner’s son received Covid-19 special leave for over a year without incident, and that other co-accused in the same case have been granted ordinary parole. They urge the High Court to grant ordinary parole in line with the Rules, highlighting favourable RTI responses and Probation Officer reports. The respondents’ counsel contends the prisoners are accused in a political murder and that the police reports indicate risks; they rely on the two jail-offence FIRs to justify denial. After considering the material, the court adopts the rehabilitative purpose of parole, cites Noushad v. State of Kerala for the correct scope of denial, and ultimately directs the respondents to grant ordinary parole to the petitioners’ sons as eligible under Rule 397, expeditiously and within one month of this judgment.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C.No.1695 of 2024

Shameem K.P. and Nabeesa K.P. v. State of Kerala and others

The Kerala High Court, in a Criminal Misc. Case (CRL.M.C.1695/2024) filed under Section 482 CrPC, entertained the petition to quash an FIR (Crime No.391/2023) registered at Chandera Police Station, Kasaragod, and the connected final report (CC No.1912/2023) against the petitioners for offences under Section 498-A IPC. The petitioners alleged an amicable settlement with the third respondent, who executed Annexure-A4 affidavit stating no objection to quashing and no subsisting grievance. The Investigating Officer corroborated that the dispute had been settled. The third respondent and the State contended that quashing is appropriate in light of the amicable settlement and the non-serious nature of the offences, with no public interest involved and remote chances of conviction. The court relied on precedents Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Prabhatbhai Aahir @ Parbatbhai Bhimsinhbhai Karmur v. State of Gujarat to justify invoking inherent powers to secure ends of justice where settlement exists and offences are not grave. After careful consideration, the judge concluded the matter qualifies for intrinsic power to quash and allowed the Crl.M.C, quashing the FIR, the final report, and all further proceedings in CC No.1912/2023 against the petitioners, thereby restoring harmony between the parties.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 3031 OF 2009

Lonappankutty s/o Anthony v. C.Tousephs/o Thomakutty, V.K. Sathian, and The National Insurance Co. Ltd.

Lonappankutty s/o Anthony filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakkuda, for injuries sustained in a road accident on 19 March 2005. The accident involved a car owned by the 1st respondent, insured by the 3rd respondent, and driven rashly by the 2nd respondent, with the appellant sustaining a segmental fracture of the left femur and multiple injuries. The Tribunal allowed the petitioner to recover Rs 1,89,250 from the insurer, in part, and the appellant challenged the quantum. The 1st and 2nd respondents were ex parte; the insurer contested liability, arguing the accident resulted from negligence of the claimant and sought exoneration. The appellant produced Exts. A1–A11 and a disability certificate Ext. A9, claiming higher earnings and disabling impairment. The High Court re-evaluated: it determined the appellant’s net monthly income as Rs. 9,543 after tax deductions in line with Kalpana Raj; fixed functional disability at 10% (contrary to the Tribunal’s 4.5%) and adopted a multiplier of 13 (Sarla Varma) given age 49. The court held that Pranay Sethi governs compensation calculation and that the claimant’s true income should be used, rejecting the Tribunal’s scaled income. It recalculated loss of disability and loss of earnings, enhancing total compensation accordingly, and ordered the insurer to deposit the enhanced amount with 7% interest within 60 days, with the Tribunal disbursing thereafter.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC Nos. 808/2020, 822/2020, 848/2020, 861/2020, 4661/2021, 2852/2022, 3281/2022, 7583/2023, 7681/2023, 7802/2023

GTL Infrastructure Limited v. Kuthanur Grama Panchayat & Others

These connected Criminal Misc. Cases arise from prosecutions under Section 210 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, for recovery of arrears of tax/cess by village Panchayats. The petitioners include GTL Infrastructure Limited (and in a separate matter Dishnet Wireless Limited, Eswaravelan, and Kinakkool Abdu Salam) who are accused in multiple cases before various Judicial Magistrates. The core challenge is that prosecution under Section 210 KP Act is not maintainable unless the Panchayat first pursues revenue recovery by distraint and only if distraint is impracticable. The petitions argue that the complaints lack essential averments—such as details of recovery steps taken and reasons why distraint was impracticable—and rely on printed annexures that do not show compliance with the prerequisites for prosecution. The Kerala High Court, after analyzing the statutory scheme and the Rules under the Act, notes that prosecution is a last resort; the complaint must plead that revenue-recovery steps were initiated and that distraint was impracticable. It also emphasizes that Rules 14 and 15 of the 1996 Rules prescribe notice and distraint procedures before prosecution. The Court finds multiple procedural infirmities in the complaints and holds the prosecutions to be an abuse of process, quashing the proceedings in all listed CRL.MCs. It reserves the Panchayats’ right to recover the due amounts in accordance with law and clarifies that the recovery can proceed by appropriate lawful means.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 21894 of 2021

V.N. Public Health & Educational Trust v. State of Kerala and others

V.N. Public Health & Educational Trust, a charitable entity promoting medical education, sought Essentiality Certificate (EC) and Consent of Affiliation (CoA) to establish a private medical college at Walayar, Palakkad. The petition traces a long history of EC issuances (2004, 2009, 2011, 2014, 2015) and subsequent rejections, with the Centre (MCI/NMC) and KUHS involved in time-bound eligibility and CoA requirements. The Trust faced repeated government refusals on grounds of non-compliance with time schedules and changing state policy. Past interim orders directed consideration of fresh applications on merits, and the Supreme Court’s Ext. P8 (AIR 2021 SC 2673) held that EC and CoA are not ministerial acts and that withdrawal of EC is permissible only under specific conditions, while also emphasizing that EC is a prerequisite to establish medical education standards. In 2021 the state rejected EC for 2022-23 based on DME inspection findings highlighting deficiencies in infrastructure, clinical material, and faculty, amid broader policy concerns about private medical colleges. The Kerala High Court ultimately held that policy-based denial cannot stand, sustained the EC rejection on grounds of DME findings, but left open the possibility of fresh EC/CoA applications once NMC criteria are satisfied, disposing of the petition accordingly with costs denied.

High Court of Kerala
RSA Nos. 669 of 2023; RSA No. 673 of 2023; RSA No. 677 of 2023

Geetha and others v. G. Darmapalan and others

Regular Second Appeals filed under Order XLII Rule 1 read with Section 100 CPC challenge decrees in three suits (O.S. Nos. 34/88, 35/88 and 38/88) and the common appellate judgment (A.S. Nos. 87, 88 and 89 of 2019) of the Sub Court, Mavelikara, arising from O.S. 34/88, 35/88 and 38/88 before the Munsiff Court, Kayamkulam. The plaintiffs claim title to 42 cents of plaint schedule property based on Exts. A1 (18 cents), A3 (14 cents) and A10 (10 cents) purchase certificates issued under proceedings under the Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1963–77; the defendants contend that Exts. A1, A3 and A10 were obtained fraudulently and seek to defeat title and possession. The trial court decreed in favor of the plaintiffs, declaring title to the properties as per the plan and ordering possession against certain defendants, with costs. The appellate court upheld these decrees. The appellants argue that the certificates were fraudulently obtained and cannot confer title; the respondents stress the finality of the certificates and reliance on Section 102 of the Kerala Land Reforms Act. The High Court, under Justice A. Badharudeen, dismisses the appeals for lack of a substantial question of law, upholding the certificates’ validity and the trial court’s and appellate court’s factual findings. The Plan Ext. C1(a) shall form part of the decree.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.5593/2023

M.S. Anil v. State Co-operative Election Commission, Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Neyyattinkara Primary Co-operative Agricultural Rural Development Bank Ltd.

This writ petition challenges a surcharge order issued under Section 68(2) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969, against M.S. Anil, former President of the Marayamuttom Service Cooperative Bank Ltd., and its implications for contesting elections to Neyyattinkara Primary Co-operative Agricultural Rural Development Bank Ltd. The Government did not interfere with the surcharge, but in 2022 the court stayed only the recovery proceedings in Ext.P1, not the surcharge itself. The petitioner contends that Rule 44 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969 confines disqualification to the society in which the surcharge has been issued; a surcharge relating to Marayamuttom should not bar entry into Neyyattinkara’s Board/Managing Committee elections. The respondents submit that Rule 44(1)(l) is broad and disqualifies any member surcharged under Section 68 from contesting elections, irrespective of the society involved, to prevent persons implicated in losses from holding managerial positions elsewhere. The court examines the object of Rule 44, adopting a realistic, nexus-based approach to disqualification provisions, citing K. Prabhakaran and Shibu Soren for a practical interpretation rather than pedantic readings. It holds that the disqualification is triggered the moment an order of surcharge is issued, even if relating to another society. The petition is dismissed, but the petitioner may contest Neyyattinkara’s election after staying the surcharge order itself (not merely the recovery).

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.10612 OF 2024 & con.cases

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam – WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 and connected cases (consolidated)

This is a consolidated writ petition matter before the Kerala High Court concerning freezing of bank accounts in cybercrime investigations. Petitioners, who are bank customers, co‑operative banks, companies, travel agents and others, have had their bank accounts frozen by various banks on police/intimation across different jurisdictions. The Court notes that the accounts were frozen by different Banks on intimation received from Police Authorities in various regions and directed interim measures to protect the petitioners’ ability to operate within the freeze limits. The bench, presided by Justice T.R. Ravi, observed the need to balance effective investigation with due process and personal liberty, and relied on prior guidance in Dr. Sajeer v RBI to limit freezes to the amounts mentioned in police requisitions, while requiring the banks to communicate with police about continuation. The Court disposed of WP(C)10612/2024 and connected petitions with a set of directions, including confining the freeze to the specified amounts, requiring police notification to banks, permitting continuation for a defined period (up to eight months) if necessary, and reserving liberty to approach the court again if information is not yet provided. The judgment consolidates multiple petitions and reiterates the court’s supervisory role in ensuring that freezing actions do not unduly cripple legitimate business and financial activities while ensuring obedience to criminal investigations.

High Court of Kerala
Cont.Case (C) No.2103 of 2020

Cont.Case (C) No.2103 of 2020 (Arising out of WP(C) No.10053 of 2017), High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

A Contempt of Court petition (Cont.Case (C) No.2103 of 2020) was heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court comprising Justice Anil K. Narendran and Justice Sophy Thomas. The petitioners – five individuals (petitioners 15, 16, 19, 24 and 53) in WP(C) No.10053 of 2017 – allege willful disobedience of the High Court’s Annexure A1 judgment dated 25 February 2019, which followed Annexure A2 judgment dated 12 October 2018 in W.P.(C) No.32797/2016 and connected matters. The contempt petition seeks enforcement under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 for the directions contained in Annexure A1, anchored to the legal framework governing Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) pension matters. The narrative centers on the Supreme Court’s earlier dismissal and recall of a Special Leave Petition, culminating in the detailed 4 November 2022 judgment in Civil Appeal Nos. 8143-8144 of 2022 (Sunil Kumar B. v. EPFO), which held the 2014 notification G.S.R.609(E) legal and valid and read down certain pension-scheme provisions. The Kerala High Court accordingly held that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO in light of the 2022 apex judgment. The court closed the Contempt Case, while directing EPFO to undertake the reconsideration in accordance with law and without prejudice to the petitioners’ rights. Annexures A1–A6 form part of the Appendix.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.14669 OF 2020

N. Padmanabhan and others v Union of India and others

This writ petition, filed in the Kerala High Court, is by 29 retired employees (petitioners) of the 6th respondent, Madhyamam Daily (Ideal Publication Trust), who seek higher pension under the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, claiming entitlement under the option exercised by them. They contend that pensionable salary must be computed on the average monthly pay drawn during the contributory period in the 12 months preceding their exit from the Employees’ Pension Fund, and that 8 1/3% of the full EPF contribution made by the 6th respondent should be taken into account without artificial wage ceilings. They pray for a mandamus directing the respondents (EPFO and sub-offices) to re-fix pension, pay arrears, and provide revised pension in accordance with the pre-amended paragraph 11 of the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995. They rely on Ext P2, a judgment dated 12/10/2018 in WP(C) No.13120/2015, which is relied upon to support higher benefits, and seek entitlement to the benefits conferred by this line of authority. The respondents’ counsel counters that the issue is settled by the Supreme Court in EPF Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B and Others (2022), and requests disposal with directions. The court disposes the petition, directing the competent respondents to re-consider the petitioners’ claims in light of the Supreme Court dictum within three months of receipt of a copy of the judgment.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No. 139 of 2021

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, R.C.Rev.No. 139 of 2021

This is a revision petition under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, challenging eviction under Section 11(3) filed by a landlady against her tenants. The Rent Control Court, Mananthavady, granted eviction on the ground of bonafide need for the landlady’s dependent son to start a readymade shop in the petition schedule premises. The Rent Control Appellate Authority, Kalpetta, dismissed the appeal. The petitioners contended that the landlady possessed other vacant rooms and even sold some rooms, which would negate bonafide need and attract the first proviso to Section 11(3). The respondent-landlady contends those rooms were not suitable for the intended business, that the sale did not deprive her of the need, and that the petition was properly supported by evidence. The High Court reaffirms that a bona fide need must be genuine, real and honest, not a mere pretext, applying established principles from Adil Jamshed Frenchman, Shiv Samp Gupta, Deena Nath and others. It also emphasizes that the revisional jurisdiction under Section 20 is confined to legality, regularity and propriety, not re-appreciation of evidence. Ultimately, the Court dismisses the revision petition but grants six months’ time to surrender possession with conditions, including affidavit, rent arrears deposit, and compliance with licensing requirements.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No. 5387 of 2023

CRL.M.C No. 5387 of 2023

This Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 CrPC concerns six accused in CC No.1780/2018 arising from Pudukkad Police Station Crime No.1263/2017. The petition seeks quashing of proceedings in CC 1780/2018 on the ground that the parties have amicably settled their dispute and do not wish to pursue prosecution for offences punishable under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 452, 447, 341, 323 and 324 read with Section 34. The learned counsel for the petitioners argues that quashing would serve the ends of justice, preserve peace and spare time and resources, given the absence of ongoing grievances, and with no other serious crimes by the petitioners. The Public Prosecutor expresses reservations, but notes no other serious offenses by the petitioners. The High Court references State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, to emphasise that Section 482 powers may be exercised to quash non‑compoundable offenses in private disputes where the settlement is complete, while not permitting quashing in cases involving heinous or public‑interest offences and certain statutes. After evaluating the gravity of the offences, injuries, antecedents, and the current amicable settlement, the court holds that quashing would not adversely affect society and proceeds to quash the final report and all further proceedings. The order thus ends the prosecution in the subject case.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.35861 of 2023

Manikandan and Biju v. Travancore Devaswom Board and others

This writ petition (WP(C) No. 35861 of 2023) is filed by devotees of Sasthamcotta Sree Dharma Sastha Temple challenging Ext.P5, a Devaswom Commissioner order dated 05.10.2023 that extended the term of the Temple Advisory Committee for six months (to 31.07.2024). The petitioners contend the bye-laws governing Temple Advisory Committees under the Travancore Devaswom Board provide a two-year term and prohibit further extensions beyond that period; Ext.P5 violates Clause 11 of Ext.P1 Rules and lacks application of mind, as recognized in earlier decisions. They seek quashing Ext.P5 and a mandamus preventing copper-drum coverage on the Flag-Mast pending decisions in related petitions. The respondents contend that extensions are permissible for development works or unavoidable rituals and are required for continuity in temple management, especially in light of the ongoing Flag-Mast installation. The court previously stayed Ext.P5 and directed management to be under the Sub Group Officer with supervision of the Assistant Devaswom Commissioner. The judgment sets aside Ext.P5, finding it in violation of Sunil Kumar C. and Chandu K. principles, and allows the 5th Temple Advisory Committee to continue only until 31.01.2024. It directs the 2nd respondent to reconsider any extension with a reasoned order within two weeks, with notice to petitioners and respondents 5–7, while ensuring prompt rites under Section 15A of the Act.

High Court of Kerala
RFA No.459/2019

Harbour View Residency (P) Ltd. vs Sree Gokulam Chit and Finance Co. (P) Ltd.

This Regular First Appeal (RFA No.459/2019) arises from a suit in OS No.29/2018 before the II Addl. Sub Court, Ernakulam, where the plaintiff chit-finance company claimed Rs. 1,53,68,581 with interest against the first defendant on liability arising from five chits bid on 12.12.2008 and terminated on 12.07.2010. The plaintiff contends that two cheques for Rs. 70 lakhs each, dated 02.11.2015, issued by the third and fourth defendants (guarantors) were given to discharge the liability of the first defendant; these cheques were dishonoured on presentation. The defendants argued that the cheques were issued as security for earlier chits (2005–06) and that the entire liability had been discharged, asserting the challenge was time-barred. The trial court reportedly framed issues under limitation rather than under Section 25(3) of the Indian Contract Act, and questioned the applicability of Section 64 of the Chit Funds Act, 1982, since this is not a chit-transaction dispute. The Kerala High Court ultimately frames the core issues under Sections 25(3) and 118 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, considering whether the 02.11.2015 cheques discharge a time-barred debt and whether they are supported by consideration. It relies on Bombay High Court precedents supporting treatment of cheques as promises under Section 25(3), while noting a contrary Karnataka decision. Citing Kotak Mahindra Bank, the court directs resettlement of issues and, upon analysis, dismisses the appeal with costs to both sides.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 23738/2021

M/S Four Star Naturals Private Limited v. Income Tax Officer, Ward 1(1), Thrissur & The Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle, Thrissur

A private limited company engaged in spice extracts/substance production was subject to tax assessment after a survey under section 133A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The petitioner contends that Ext. P3 notice under section 148 dated 24.03.2020 and notices under sections 142(1) and 143(3) r/w 147 were served to the email address of its erstwhile auditors rather than the petitioner’s own email in the Income Tax Portal. The petitioner argues the Department did not duly update its portal details, and the notices were therefore not served in accordance with Rule 127, violating natural justice. The respondents claim notices were delivered to the portal’s address, based on system-generated communications, and that the petitioner failed to inform or update its contact details. The court discusses Rule 127 (electronic service) and Section 282, and cites Bhima Jewels v. P.C.I.T., EkM, and another, to emphasize the necessity of a proper opportunity to respond. It also references the Supreme Court’s I-ven Interactive Limited decision as a contrasting view. Ultimately, the court finds a violation of natural justice due to improper service, sets aside the assessment order (Ext. P6), and directs the petitioner to respond within two weeks; the assessing officer must pass a fresh order after hearing within a month.

High Court of Kerala
RSA 1326/2014 and RSA 1327/2014

Jayaraman v. Rajan @ Raju (RSA Nos. 1326/2014 and 1327/2014)

This Regular Second Appeal pertains to two suits (O.S. No. 221/2009 and O.S. No. 1/2010) filed in the Munsiff Court, Kattappana, by Rajan @ Raju seeking title over a plaint schedule land and vacant possession, and by Jayaraman seeking eviction of tenants. Both suits were tried jointly; the Munsiff Court decreed in favour of Rajan, declaring his title based on patta Ext.A1 and awarding vacant possession and a perpetual injunction, while dismissing O.S. No. 1/2010 filed by Jayaraman. The Sub Judge upheld these decrees on appeal. Jayaraman challenges the title on Ext.A1, arguing it does not confer title to Rajan because Ext.A5 (patta) and Ext.B1–B4 (assessment and utility bills in Jayaraman’s name) cast doubt on Rajan’s claimed title. The appellants rely on the contention that mere patta cannot confer title and that the house is in Jayaraman’s possession per assessment records. The High Court, noting that substantial questions of law were not framed for admission and relying on authorities on the formulation and maintenance of second appeals, holds that no substantial question of law arises; the appeals are meritless and are dismissed without admission. The decision relies on a long line of authorities clarifying the scope of second appeals and the necessity of a substantial question of law.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl.) No. 997/2022

Kashmira v. State of Kerala

Kashmira, the wife of the detenu Adarsh Chandrasekharan, challenged a preventive detention order issued under Section 3(1) of the Kerala Anti Social Activities Prevention Act, 2007 (KAA(P) Act, 2007) by filing WP(Crl.) No. 997/2022 before the Kerala High Court. The Detaining Authority (District Collector cum District Magistrate, Ernakulam) passed Ext. P1 on 29.05.2022 detaining Adarsh Chandrasekharan on grounds that he was likely to indulge in prejudicial anti-social activities. The order, along with records, was communicated to the Government under Section 3(3), and after approvals and advisory board reports (Ext. P2) the Government confirmed the order under Section 10(4). Kashmira contended that the detenu was already in judicial custody since 19.03.2022 after bail cancellation in crime 17/2021, the sponsoring authority’s report dated 17.03.2022 did not disclose this crucial fact, and Ext. P1 failed to reflect that the detenu could be released on bail and would, if released, likely indulge in further prejudicial activities. The petitioner relied on well-known precedents, including Dharmendra Chelawat and related decisions, to argue that without awareness of ongoing custody and cogent, compelling reasons, detention in custody cannot be validly sustained. The High Court examined the grounds, noting that Ext. P1 did not mention the crucial remand/custody facts, and that the decision-making process was vitiated. It quashed Ext. P1 and Ext. P2 and ordered the immediate release of the detenu, subject to non-contrary detention elsewhere, with directions for compliance.