Abdul Latheef C, the petitioner, approached the Kerala High Court challenging proceedings under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI Act) initiated by ICICI Bank. The petitioner seeks certiorari or other appropriate writs to call for records leading to Ext P2 and to set aside that notice, mandamus to permit paying off loan arrears in a reasonable time, and to regularise the account, as well as to keep in abeyance all coercive measures against the mortgaged property. He asserts that the outstanding liability has been misrepresented and notes a Court direction requiring remittance of ₹15 lakhs within two weeks. The matter concerns two loan accounts with a total liability claimed by the bank as ₹8,54,36,164.81. The respondents contend that SARFAESI proceedings are beyond the reach of writ jurisdiction and insist on the statutory remedies, citing United Bank of India v. Satyawati Tondon and later Kerala and Supreme Court authorities. The court surveys the established law: writs under Article 226 are not available against SARFAESI actions when an efficacious remedy exists. Relying on the Apex Court and this Court’s precedents, the petition is held not maintainable and dismissed, underscoring the primacy of the SARFAESI mechanism and the availability of Tribunal redressal. The decision reaffirms that extraordinary jurisdiction is not invoked where a specific statutory remedy exists.
The Kerala High Court, sitting in Ernakulam before Justice T. R. Ravi, heard a batch of writ petitions challenging police-directed freezing of bank accounts in cybercrime investigations across multiple banks and jurisdictions. The court noted that while freezing assets may be justified to preserve crime proceeds, blanket freezes can cause grave hardship and impede ordinary banking and business activities. It directed respondent banks to confine freezes strictly to the amounts mentioned in police requisitions/notices and to permit petitioners to operate beyond that cap, so long as the possession of funds is not proven to be tainted by crime. The police/govt authorities were asked to indicate whether continuing freezes are necessary beyond the specified amounts and, if so, for what period, with a ceiling of eight months from the date of the order. The court relied on and approved the reasoning in Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661) and cited related decisions in W.P.(C) 28155/2023 and other connected matters. The decision balances the state’s interest in investigating cybercrime with the petitioners’ right to access banking facilities, and disposes of the petitions with directions to implement the freeze limits and timelines while preserving petitioners’ ability to operate accounts within those limits.
Petitioner Said Fazal Hussain .V.T, holder of bank account No. 20190000028879 with the 6th respondent ESAF Small Finance Bank Limited, seeks a writ directing lifting of the debit freeze on the account. The bank asserts the freeze was imposed pursuant to police requisitions, with a total disputed amount of Rs 6,10,000 and a lien on the account; the petitioner contends the action is illegal, arbitrary and disproportionate, particularly since the petitioner is not an accused in the underlying crimes. The court considers arguments from the petitioner’s counsel, the Government Pleader, and the bank’s counsel. In line with Dr. Sajeer v. Reserve Bank of India (2024 (1) KLT 826) and Nazeer K.T v. Federal Bank Ltd (2024 KHC OnLine 768), the judgment emphasizes that freezes must be confined to the amount specified in police orders and that banks should obtain timely information from police on continued seizure. Relying on State of Maharashtra v. Tapas D Neogy, Teesta Atul Setalvad v. State of Gujarat, and Shento Varghese v. Julfikar Husen, the court holds that delays in reporting seizures can affect seizure validity and issues directions to police and banks. The writ petition is disposed with directions to narrow the freeze and to inform the bank of continued necessity, with liberty to approach the court again if needed.
WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & connected cases This judgment of the Kerala High Court (Single Judge, Justice T. R. Ravi) consolidates WP(C) Nos. 10612 of 2024 and connected petitions arising from police intimations that froze various petitioners’ bank accounts across multiple jurisdictions (Kerala, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Karnataka, Telangana, etc.). The petitions challenge blanket freezes imposed by banks (Federal Bank, ICICI Bank, Canara Bank, South Indian Bank, Axis Bank, RBI-directed blocks, and other financial institutions) in cybercrime investigations. The court records that while police seizures and freezing orders are part of anti-money-laundering/enforcement mechanisms, they must be proportionate and limited to the amounts specifically involved in the dispute. Drawing on prior jurisprudence, notably Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661), the court directs interim measures to confine freezes to the disputed sums and requires banks to maintain liquidity for basic transactions beyond the freeze limit. The order sets out procedures for police to inform banks about the extent/time period of freezing and for banks to implement the freeze accordingly, allowing petitioners to approach the court again if information is insufficient or inconsistent. Ultimately, the petitions are disposed of with directions to balance enforcement with the petitioners’ rights and banking operations, preserving the funds that are not touched by the police order.
This anticipatory bail application BA No. 1823 of 2021 concerns M.A. Mohanan Nair, the petitioner, a peon of Konni Regional Co-operative Bank, who faced allegations of involvement in a large-scale misappropriation of Rs 5,39,15,655.35 through forged documents in Crime No. 796/2019 at Konni Police Station. The prosecution attributes forgery, breach of trust and cheating (IPC 468, 408, 409, 420 r/w 34) to the petitioner along with the President, Secretary and other bank staff. The petitioner contends innocence, arguing his limited role and that the primary accused are others at the bank; he seeks anticipatory bail. The Public Prosecutor counters that the offences are serious and the final report/charge sheet was filed on 22.07.2021 in CC 656/2021, with investigation complete. The judge notes the extraordinary delay in deciding the bail petition (filed 16.02.2021; interim order not to arrest) and highlights the broader concern that interim protection has sometimes impeded investigation. In addressing the issue, the bench emphasizes Supreme Court directives on timely disposal of bail applications (Hussain and Another v. Union of India; Satender Kumar Antil v. CBI) and directs timely posting of such petitions. Ultimately, the court disposes of the anticipatory bail application, granting the petitioner liberty to apply for regular bail, and directs the Registrar to ensure prompt posting of anticipatory bail matters henceforth to align with apex court directions.
This High Court of Kerala, sitting as OP (Family Court) in OP (FC) No. 241 of 2024, reviews a petition challenging an execution-related order in a long-running family law matter. The petitioner, wife Arunimap T., had sought dissolution of marriage (O.P. No. 251 of 2014) and related reliefs; after mediation the parties settled, but subsequent non-compliance led to an execution petition (E.P. No. 32 of 2017) filed in the Family Court, Muvattupuzha. The Family Court dismissed that petition on the ground that the decree-holder’s residence lay outside its jurisdiction, directing an transfer to the court in whose jurisdiction the judgment debtor resided. The petitioner then sought recall of the decree and transfer of the decree to Ettumanoor; this Court previously held in O.P.(F.C.) No. 681/2014 (2019) that the decree should be transferred to the relevant Family Court where the debtor resides. A Division Bench in another matter (O.P.(F.C.) No. 198/2020) later held that the Muvattupuzha Court had jurisdiction to entertain the execution petition, noting Arunima’s case as per incuriam for not considering Section 20 of the Family Courts Act. The present judgment reiterates that the decree’s execution should not be thwarted by a fluctuating residence of the debtor and sets aside Ext.P6, directing the Family Court, Muvattupuzha to reconsider the recall petition and proceed with execution in accordance with law. The decision emphasizes jurisdiction and the scheme of the Family Courts Act over technical procedural hurdles.
CRL.A Nos. 831 of 2008 and 925 of 2008 Two criminal appeals (Crl.A. 831/2008 and 925/2008) arise from a 2002 judgment of the Additional Sessions Court (Abkari Act cases), Kottarakkara, convicting three accused for possession of arrack in a toddy shop. The trial court held them guilty under sections 55(a) and 55(i) of the Abkari Act, and accused No.3 also under section 57(a), with terms of five years’ imprisonment and fines of Rs. 1 lakh each (and an additional one-year term and Rs. 50,000 fine for accused No.3). The prosecution case claimed that on 3 December 1997, about 3.5 litres of arrack were found in a jerry can at Thazham, Chakkuvarackal. On appeal, the appellants argued that the prosecution failed to prove the arrack was actually subjected to chemical analysis and, crucially, that the chain of custody was broken: the detecting officer did not produce a seal specimen; the seizure mahazar did not describe the seal; there was no evidence the seal was forwarded to the laboratory; and there was an unexplained delay in producing the properties. Citing Bhaskaran, Ravi, Rajamma, Ramachandran, and Daulat Ram, the High Court found that the chemical analysis report had no evidentiary value due to a broken chain of custody, and that the proper link to the contraband was not established. Accordingly, the appeals were allowed and the conviction set aside, resulting in acquittals and liberty for the accused.
This Kerala High Court (Division Bench) original petition challenges the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam, order dated 25 November 2022 in OA No.95/2022, which upheld Annexure A6 accepting the petitioner’s voluntary retirement with retrospective effect from 8 October 2021 and directed retirement from that date. Faziludeen, a Senior Accountant in the Office of the Director of Accounts (Postal), submitted Annexure A1 for voluntary retirement on medical grounds on 7 October 2021 and on the next day sought withdrawal (Annexure A2). The withdrawal was not accepted and the 3rd respondent issued Annexure A6 on 8 October 2021 accepting retirement, later denying withdrawal (A7). The applicant contends this violated Rules 48 and 48A of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, which require a three-month notice and pre-retirement withdrawal before acceptance. The respondents argued that retirement under Rule 48 was effected with notice waiver and that Annexure A6 was not retrospective. The Tribunal’s approach was faulted by the High Court, which emphasized that Rule 48-A(1) requires a minimum three-month notice, and that acceptance, curtailment under Rule 48-A(3-A), and withdrawal under Rule 48-A(4) must be evaluated fairly and on merits. The Court relied on J.N. Srivastava and Balram Gupta to underscore locus poenitentiae and fairness, and held the Tribunal’s decision unsustainable, quashing Annexure A6 and reinstating Faziludeen from 8 October 2021 with conditions and pensionary benefits counted but salary for non-work period not awarded.
Dr. Zubair P.K., appointed as a Homoeo Doctor on contract from 02-04-2022 to 31-03-2023 by the National Health Mission (NHM), challenged his termination dated 09-01-2023 (Ext.P6) in WP(C) No.1111/2023, which was adjudicated against him by the single judge. In WA No.360/2023, heard on 27-02-2023, the appellant contends that Ext.P6 is wholly illegal, arbitrary and not a true severance of service; it claims an enquiry was conducted behind the appellant’s back and the enquiry report formed the basis for termination. He relies on A.P. State Federation of Coop. Spinning Mills Ltd. v. P V Swaminathan (2001) 10 SCC 83 to argue that termination can be simpliciter or a result of enquiry. The respondents counter that Ext.P6 does not imply stigma; the severance is via pay in lieu of notice under Clause 13, while Clause 10 authorizes termination for insubordination, misconduct or non-performance/non-cooperation. The court highlighted clauses 10 and 13 of the Contract of Engagement, noting that termination under clause 10 was employed, with clause 13 providing compensation. The court held Ext.P6 does not amount to stigma and distinguished the cited Supreme Court decision as inapplicable to the facts. The appeal was dismissed, upholding the learned Single Judge’s order.
CRL.MC Nos. 7434 & 8429 of 2022 This is a connected pair of Criminal Miscellaneous Cases (CRL.MC Nos. 7434/2022 and 8429/2022) heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court. The petitions, filed by four individuals (Sujin Lawrence, Jijin Devidson, Joy, and Jerin D.) and by Anil Lucy, seek to quash prosecutions arising from Vizhinjam Police Station—Crime Nos. 2047/2018 and 44/2019, respectively. The first crime includes a possible offence under Section 307 IPC, but the medical evidence shows only minor injuries, suggesting that the charge may not reflect the gravity presumed by a non-bailable or heinous offence. The respondents include the State of Kerala, the District Crime Branch, Vizhinjam Police Station, and others. The learned counsel for petitioners argued that the dispute between the parties has been settled and that continuing prosecution would be unwarranted. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing purely on the basis of settlement but acknowledged the private settlement. The court examined the matter in light of Supreme Court precedents on exercise of its powers under Section 482 CrPC to quash non‑compoundable offences in private disputes where the parties have settled. It held the dispute to be private in nature, accepted the settlement, and found no necessity to continue the prosecutions. Consequently, both Crl.M.Cs were allowed and the proceedings quashed.
Cont.Case (C) No. 2116 of 2020 This Contempt Case (Civil) arises from a petition filed by eight petitioners (petitioners 7, 16, 18, 20, 30, 43, 114 and 131) in WP(C) No.39275 of 2016, alleging willful disobedience of the directions contained in Annexure A1, the judgment of 12.10.2018 in WP(C) No.39275/2016 and connected matters. The petitioners invoke Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. The Supreme Court’s later pronouncements, notably in Employees Provident Fund Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B. (AIR 2022 SC 5634) and the related Civil Appeal Nos.8143-44 of 2022, are discussed as to the legality of the 2014 amendments (G.S.R.609(E)) to the pension scheme and the read-downs directed, with extended time for employees to exercise options under the amended scheme. The judgment also references RC Gupta and others v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, (2018) 14 SCC 809, to endorse the interpretation of proviso to paragraph 11(3) of the pre-amendment pension scheme. The Kerala High Court acknowledges that, in view of the 2022 SC judgment, the petitioners’ entitlement for higher pension requires reconsideration by the EPFO. Accordingly, the court closes the contempt petition, directing the EPFO to reconsider entitlement in accordance with law and the SC directions, while preserving the right to adjust entitlements under the amended scheme. Annexure A1 contains a certified copy of the 12.10.2018 judgment.
This Regular Second Appeal challenges the concurrent dismissal of a suit seeking a declaration that Ext.A9, an order of the Kerala State Housing Board, demanding arrears of rent, is illegal. The dispute centers on rent payable for a tenanted room in the Board’s shopping complex. Ext.A1, dated 02.05.1983, is a one-year lease with a renewal clause offering a 10% rent increase on terms to be agreed. The plaintiff continued in possession after expiry, paying the original rent, and no renewal deed was executed. The Board issued Ext.A3 preliminary order under Section 85(1) seeking eviction and later Ext.A4 under Section 86(1) demanding arrears, followed by Ext.A9 for arrears of rent, which the plaintiff challenged in OP 1737/1991 and WA 1050/1999. The trial court held the plaintiff liable for enhanced rent upon renewal; the first appellate court held there was a right of appeal and directed filing a civil suit after exhausting remedies under the Act. The High Court, however, examines whether the renewal clause can sustain enhanced rent in the absence of a renewal deed. It relies on Lalji Tandon’s principle that renewal requires a fresh deed, and on authorities that an “agreement to agree” in a renewal clause is unenforceable. The court ultimately concludes that Ext.A9 is illegal since no renewal deed exists, and the suit succeeds. The Regular Second Appeal is allowed, with costs.</n>
This Miscellaneous Second Appeal challenges an order of the Kerala Real Estate Appellate Tribunal appointing a Commission under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, and linked CPC provisions, to collect information for deciding disputes between promoter and allottee in REFA No.28/2023. The appellant, P. V. Nidhish, contends that appointing a Commission is not legally permissible and should fall under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC; he relies on Raveendranadhan v. State of Kerala to urge that additional evidence or materials must follow the CPC framework and the Tribunal’s powers are circumscribed. The respondent Sivaprakash opposed the application on the ground that such materials are outside the appellate record and that the Tribunal’s power to appoint a Commission is not restricted by the Act and is necessary to resolve the material issues. The High Court, after examining Sections 53 and 35 of the Act and the provisions of the CPC, held that the Appellate Tribunal has the power to regulate its own procedure and can appoint a Commission when needed to gather information for deciding the matter between promoter and allottee, beyond Order XLI Rule 27 CPC. Citing Nazir Mohamed, Kondiba Kadam, Santosh Hazari and Government of Kerala v. Joseph, the Court reiterates the need for a substantial question of law and ultimately dismisses the appeal as meritless. The decision upholds the tribunal’s exercise of power and dismisses the appeal accordingly.
Cont.Case (C) No. 2334 of 2019 This High Court of Kerala Contempt petition concerns alleged willful disobedience of directions issued by the Kerala High Court in W.P.(C) No. 31484 of 2016 and connected matters, as recorded in Annexure A’s judgment dated 12 October 2018. The petitioners, three retired employees (Daniel Stephen, Thomas Samuel, George P.M.) are contending that the Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) has failed to implement pension-related orders. The respondents, including the Chief Provident Fund Commissioner and the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, contend that the apex court’s 2022 decision in Employees Provident Fund Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B. authorizes a readjustment of the amended pension scheme and directs EPFO to undertake a lawful reconsideration of the petitioners’ entitlement. The judgment canvasses the apex court’s 2022 pronouncement (04 November 2022) holding the 2014 notification amendments legal and valid, reads down certain provisions for current members, and outlines directions on options under the pension scheme (pre- and post-amendment) in light of that decision. The Kerala High Court, after hearing, notes that the entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO in accordance with law, and accordingly closes the contempt case, while keeping open the petitioners’ right to seek relief if EPFO fails to comply again, in view of the 2022 apex court ruling.
The Travancore Devaswom Board filed DBA No.9 of 2023 seeking an extension till 30.11.2023 to submit the Annual Financial Statements for the year 2020-21 before the Joint Director, Kerala State Audit and Accounts Department. The matter had been repeatedly adjourned (05.11.2023, 27.11.2023, 12.12.2023, 21.12.2023) as the learned Senior Government Pleader sought instructions. Annexure-A2 contains the court’s judgment dated 13.04.2023 in DBA No.8/2022, which dealt with delays in furnishing accounts for 2018-19 to 2020-21 and emphasized that extensions should not be presumed; the court recalled that no proper extension applications had been filed despite reminders. Paragraphs 24–27 of that order recalled issues of accountability and the requirement to complete audits promptly under the Devaswom Fund Accounts Rules, including Rule 11 on the Double Entry System of Accounting, and Sections 32, 68, 102–105 of the Act. The 24.05.2022 order in DBAR No.4/2022 directed timely submission and required extensions to be sought with sufficient cause. In the present proceedings, the Board’s Standing Counsel sought withdrawal as the extension period had expired. The court disposed of the DBA by dismissing it as withdrawn, recording that proper extensions had not been pursued. Annexures A1–A3 accompany the petition.
WA 926 of 2016; WA 928 of 2016 This is a Kerala High Court writ appeal challenging a common judgment of a learned Single Judge (6 December 2016) quashing an interim arbitral order under Section 17 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, permitting repossession of secured vehicles with police help. Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. (appellant) had loan agreements with borrowers who defaulted, leading to an arbitral claim. The arbitrator issued an interim order under Section 17(1) for preservation/interim custody of the vehicles, to be enforced via an Advocate Commissioner. The Single Judge held that Section 17(2) does not empower the Arbitrator to enforce his order as a Civil Court and that enforcement must be through the Civil Procedure Code, with Court intervention under Section 94 CPC. The appellant contends that Section 17(2) creates a legal fiction that makes interim orders enforceable as court orders, circumventing the need for court proceedings; reliance is placed on Amazon.Com NV Investment Holdings v. Future Retail Ltd. (2022) and Union of India v. Vedanta Ltd. (2020) to support the limited nature of the fiction and the distinction between an award/decree. The respondent is supported by the view that the machinery of enforcement lies with the court and that the arbitrator cannot act as a court. The High Court ultimately agrees with the Single Judge that the interim order enforcing possession cannot be sustained, upholding the quashing of the Arbitrator’s interim order and confirming the need for court intervention for enforcement.
The petition challenges the inclusion of the petitioner’s land in a Data Bank and seeks corrective measures under the Kerala Land Utilization framework, including changing land status from nilam to purayidom and removing the land from the Data Bank, arguing the property is used for residential purposes and should be treated as purayidam. The petitioner submitted Form-5 seeking correction of revenue records; Ext.P7 (the Revenue Divisional Officer’s order) rejected the application without a speaking reason, relying largely on a committee report. The court notes the impugned order is non-speaking and cites two Kerala High Court precedents (Muraleedharan Nair and Aparna Sasi Menon) to stress that the RDO must independently assess the land’s status rather than simply endorsing a committee’s finding or relying on a report. The judge directs a fresh, reasoned consideration of the Form-5 application by the 5th respondent within three months, with opportunities for KSREC reporting and subsequent orders within a further three months if KSREC is sought, ensuring due process and proper application of law under the relevant acts. The judgment thus grants relief by setting aside the impugned order and mandating corrective action within specified timeframes.
Iswariya, the appellant and legal heir of the plaintiff, seeks relief through Regular Second Appeal (RSA No. 63 of 2021) challenging the decree and judgment in AS No. 362/2016 of the II Additional District Court, Thiruvananthapuram, which dismissed the appeal for non-condonation of delay. The original partition suit was filed in 1996, with a preliminary decree in 1999 and final decree thereafter after commissioners’ reports, all culminating in a partition dispute that has persisted for decades. The present petition under Section 5 of the Limitation Act seeks to condone a delay of 352 days in filing the RSA, arguing that after the impugned order in the delay-condonation petition the actual delay is 72 days once certain periods are excluded in light of a Supreme Court order. The appellant attributes the delay to nonreceipt of copies, covid-19 restrictions, and lack of funds to engage counsel, asserting a bona fide, meritorious case that warrants adjudication on merits. The respondents contend that the delay is long, deliberate, and unsupported by sufficient cause, especially given a prior delay petition in the first appeal. The court surveys several principles that the expression sufficient cause is elastic and that substantial justice should prevail over technicalities, but ultimately finds the delay not sufficiently explained and dismisses the condonation petition, resulting in dismissal of the RSA with no costs.
W.P.(C) No. 23768 of 2022 This suo motu writ petition arises from a court directive in a previous judgment (W.P.(C) No.18418 of 2022) addressing concerns over shortage or wastage of Prathal vazhipadu prasadam and Athazha Oottu at Vaikom Sree Mahadeva Temple. The Kerala High Court had, in 2022, directed the Travancore Devaswom Board, the Assistant Devaswom Commissioner, Vaikom, the Administrative Officer of Vaikom Sree Mahadeva Temple, and the Temple Advisory Committee (represented by its Secretary) to monitor and prevent shortages by maintaining a permanent register recording the quantity of rice offered and the number of devotees attending Prathal and Athazha Oottu on each day. It required the display of the quantities on boards in front of the Oottupura and other places and directed the Advocate Commissioner to conduct periodic inspections. The case reaffirms the statutory framework under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, notably Sections 15A (duties of the Board), 31 (management of Devaswoms), and 31A (formation of Temple Advisory Committees). The present petition, filed suo motu, notes that Athazha Oottu was resumed from 17.07.2022 and seeks continued monitoring to ensure there is no shortage or wastage. The court disposes the petition with specific directions to implement and supervise these measures, including permanent registers, public display, and ongoing vigilance by the Temple Advisory Committee and relevant officials.
Mat.Appeal No.774 of 2020 This matrimonial appeal under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984 challenges an ex parte decree in O.P. No. 204 of 2017, decreed by the Family Court, Muvattupuzha on 29.12.2017, and the subsequent orders/dispositions in I.A. Nos. 694/2019 and 695/2019. The appellants, Fasal P.B and Haleema, seek condonation of a delay of 338 days in filing CM Appl. No. 1 of 2020 and to set aside the ex parte decree. They argue that depressive disorder and ongoing treatment at S.H. Hospital, Thodupuzha impaired their ability to obtain the certified copy and engage counsel timely, with the COVID-19 lockdown further restricting access to legal processes. A medical certificate dated 14.08.2018 is produced to substantiate the treatment and incapacity. The Family Court dismissed the delay applications, and the High Court, after considering broader principles of limitation and liberal interpretation of “sufficient cause,” found the reasons insufficient, noting that the delay commenced prior to March 2020 and there was no adequate diligence or convincing substantiation for the vast lapse. The respondents, parents and sister of the deceased wife, argue prejudice and lack of justification. While the appellants rely on Katiji and Esha Bhattacharjee to urge a liberal approach, the Court held that the evidence does not demonstrate a compelling, sufficient cause. Consequently, the delay was not condoned and the appeal, along with CM Appl. 1/2020, was dismissed, upholding the ex parte decree.