Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 701 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WA 811 of 2020 (and connected cases)

WA 811 of 2020 (and connected cases) — In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These writ appeals arise from a common judgment dated 25 February 2020 by a learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No. 3846/2019 and connected matters, regarding entitlement to pension under the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995. The appellants (EPFO and officials) challenged the single judge’s direction that members are entitled to pension calculated without reference to the ceiling, upon remittance of higher contributions to the pension fund. The Division Bench order dated 21 December 2020 referred the matter to a Full Bench. The Full Bench, in a consolidated judgment delivered on 15 January 2024, relies on various Supreme Court judgments including Pawan Hans Ltd. v. Aviation Karmachari Sanghatana, Sasikumar P. v. Union of India (ILR 2019 Ker. 614), RC Gupta v RPF Commissioner, and Sunil Kumar B. v. EPFO, and holds that Sasikumar P. requires reconsideration in light of post-2014 amendments and the more recent Sunil Kumar decision. The court ultimately disposes of the appeals in terms of the law laid down by the Supreme Court in Sunil Kumar B. and directs EPFO to reconsider the entitlement to higher pension with appropriate actuarial input, while recognizing the need to protect the corpus and avoid erosion of fund resources. The judgment frames a cautious approach to extend or adjust the pension mechanism under policy that governs exempted establishments and the central pension scheme.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PETITION NO.798 OF 2022

Sethu Madhavan v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court revision petition challenges the discharge order dated 23 August 2022 in CMP 840/2019 arising from CC 387/2013 pending in the Judicial Magistrate of First Class-V (Special Court for Mark List Cases), Thiruvananthapuram. The 1st accused, Sethu Madhavan, along with the 2nd accused (who expired) faced offences under IPC sections 406, 409, 418, 420, 465, 468 and 471 read with 34 and 120B, in connection with alleged deceit involving sale of flats in Veeramani Deluxe Apartment, Guruvayoor. The de facto complainant contends that forged sale agreements (Annexures A2, A3) were created and blank papers signed to procure loan disbursements; a power of attorney was executed in favour of the complainant’s father for signing documents. The petitioner argues discharge should have been granted since the investigation was improper, jurisdiction allegedly lies elsewhere (execution in Thiruvananthapuram, not Thrissur), and the bank manager could not be liable as the bank was not a party to sale documents. The final report alleges loan disbursements prior to completion of construction, suggesting deceptive intent. The petitioner contends that, beyond jurisdictional and evidentiary issues, the court should not rely on extraneous materials. The High Court applies principles from Sanjay Kumar Rai, Yohannan M.M., and others, and finds prima facie grounds to proceed, holding that the discharge order was unsustainable. The revision petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 639 of 2016; CRL.A No. 683 of 2016; DSR No. 2 of 2016

State of Kerala v. Anu Shanthi and Nino Mathew (CRL.A. 639/2016; CRL.A. 683/2016; DSR No. 2/2016)

This is a combined judgment of the Kerala High Court in Crl. Appeal Nos. 639 of 2016 and 683 of 2016, along with DSR No. 2 of 2016, arising from Crime No. 491/2014 of Attingal Police Station. Accused Nos. 1 and 2, Nino Mathew and Anu Shanthi, were convicted by the Sessions Court in SC No. 1480/2014 for the murder of Omana (PW14) and Swasthika (PW1’s daughter), multiple offences including conspiracy under 120B IPC, and offences under the Information Technology Act (67A). The prosecution relied on circumstantial evidence: the sequence of events at the house, the, voice-identified phone call to PW1, testimonies of neighbours, recovery of weapons (MO1 MO2), ornaments, postmortem findings showing homicidal deaths, and electronic evidence (texts, videos, and photos) showing a planned relationship and navigation aids prepared by the accused. The High Court affirmed most findings, accepted the conspiracy between the accused, and upheld the conviction and most sentences. However, applying Bachan Singh, Machhi Singh, and Swamy Shraddhananda, the court converted the death sentence of the first accused for 302 IPC into imprisonment for life with a notional 25-year non-remission term, while directing concurrent execution of sentences and payment of compensation to PW1 and PW14’s kin. The appellate court disposed of the connected cases together with the DSR proceeding.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC 4360/2019

Shyamala Bhasker v. State of Kerala

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C) by Shyamala Bhasker, the 2nd accused in CC No. 637/2018, on the file of the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Court, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioner seeks to quash Annexure A2 final report in the connected proceedings arising from Crime No. 2502/2017 of the Medical College Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, where the defacto complainant, Jisha, has alleged cruelty under Section 498A IPC by the husband (1st accused) and others, including the 2nd accused. The petitioner contends that the 2nd accused’s role was that of a spectator, with no overt acts attributable to her under Section 498A, and that the material in the FIR does not justify prosecuting her. Citing the Apex Court decision Achin Gupta v. State of Haryana (2024 KHC OnLine 6257) on the abuse of process in matrimonial disputes, counsel argues that sweeping general allegations without specific instances amount to abuse of process and should be quashed. The respondents defend the maintenance of the charge, noting that the materials show abetment and cruelty in the records, including statements implicating the 2nd accused. The Kerala High Court, applying the Achin Gupta principle, finds the allegations against the 2nd accused to be general and devoid of specific overt acts, and quashes the final report against her, directing expedited trial against the 1st accused. The court emphasizes safeguarding against abuse of process in matrimonial disputes while ensuring proper scrutiny of actual overt conduct before proceeding to trial.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 7466 of 2014

N. Bharathi Amma v. State of Kerala and others

This writ petition concerns land acquired in the 1990s for formation of a tributary to the Thrikkaruva Distributory of the Kallada Irrigation Project. The petitioner contends that the land acquired in 1992–1997 under the Land Acquisition Act has not been utilized for the public purpose for which it was taken and argues for reconveyance to the original owner. She submitted Ext.P1, a representation to the Revenue Secretary seeking reconveyance; she had accepted the award and allegedly the Irrigation Department intimated it no longer required the land, with the land subsequently transferred to the Revenue Department. The petitioner asserts that no other department or authority needs the land and that the entire notification process has become obsolete since the public purpose no longer survives; she also highlights that part of the same notification for the Thrikkaruva Distributory was allowed to fail due to non-payment of compensation and that the project was not financially viable. The Government relied on Ext.P2 GO framed under a direction of the Apex Court in State of Kerala v. Bhaskaran Pillai and Ext.P3 judgment, which this Court distinguished. Drawing on Sivaprakashan v. State of Kerala, the court held that once land is acquired and compensation paid, the owner has no right to demand reconveyance, and public purpose must be continued. The petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
RSA NO. 897 OF 2020

T. Abdul Khader v Kannur Municipality

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a suit for refund of security deposits in a license/licensing arrangement for two rooms in Kannur market premises. The plaintiff, T. Abdul Khader, contends that he paid security deposits of Rs. 1,20,000 for Rooms 46 and 47 upon being allotted spaces in 2000, surrendered Room 46 in 2004 without refund of its deposit, and surrendered Room 47 in December 2008. He seeks refund of Rs. 1,20,000 (and claims additional amounts including 50% reduced rent during the period before electricity connection and related licence fee obligations), totaling around Rs. 2,06,287 claimed in the suit. The Municipality contends liability only for licence fees during vacancy and disputed the adjustments and the applicability of the limitation period. The Trial Court decreed refund plus interest; the First Appellate Court reversed, holding the claim barred by limitation and rejecting the 50% licence-fee adjustment. The High Court (Single Judge) held that Section 544 of the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994 does not bar a suit for refund of a refundable deposit and that the suit does not fall within Section 544(1) and 544(3); relying on Poona City decisions and other authorities, it set aside the Appellate Court’s judgment and affirmed the Trial Court’s decree. The matter culminates in appellate relief to the plaintiff and a confirmation of the refund claim.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.913 of 2016

L. Bindhu Ushus v State of Kerala and others

This writ appeal challenges the denial of regularisation or regular pay scale for L. Bindhu Ushus, who was engaged since 1 August 2003 as a Part Time Sweeper in the Kerala State Veterinary Council (KSVC), a Government establishment. The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition seeking regularisation or the regular pay scale on the ground that such relief depends on Government Orders and the financial framework. The appellant contends that Ext.P1 shows a sanctioned post of Part Time Sweeper in KSVC, that deputation was not feasible due to lack of available personnel, and that requests for regularisation were repeatedly supported by respondents 2 and 3. It is argued that Ext.P6 denial and the 50/50 cost-sharing regime under a Centrally Sponsored Scheme should not bar relief, and Ext.P7, Ext.P12 and Ext.P10 illustrate that similar postings (e.g., a driver) have been regularised in identical circumstances. The Government Orders—GOs dated 25.11.2005, 09.02.2010 (Ext.P9), 30.09.2011 (para 2(g)), and 2011 financial rules—are invoked to claim applicability to KSVC and temporary establishments. The Court anchors its reasoning on C.Madusoothanan v. State of Kerala (2009) and State of Kerala v. Radhamani P.K. (2021) to hold that temporary establishments fall within the scope of these orders and are eligible for regularisation. The Division Bench allows the appeal and directs regularisation with effect from Ext.P4 (28.09.2013) and payment of arrears within three months, modifying the earlier order accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 4896/2022

Prathiba Developers (P) Ltd. v Malabar Regional Co-operative Milk Producers Union Ltd. (Malabar Milma) and others

Prathiba Developers (P) Ltd., a contractor, approached the Kerala High Court challenging Ext. P6, which rejected its technical bid in response to Ext. P1 Notice Inviting Tender for civil works at the Milk Powder Plant Building, New Boiler House, and allied works at Milma Malappuram Dairy Project site. Ext. P1 fixed an estimated cost of ₹15.60 crore including GST and required bidders’ turnover in the last three financial years to be not less than 80% of the estimated value. The petitioner contended that, since the GST element must be excluded for turnover, the relevant threshold should be calculated on ₹13.22 crore (excluding GST), yielding 80% of ₹10.57 crore, which the petitioner asserts it satisfies for 2017–18, 2018–19, and 2019–20, as evidenced by Exts. P2–P4. The respondents argued that the NIT’s ₹15.60 crore figure inclusive of GST was binding, with Clause 3.3.3 of Ext. R1(a) stating that the rates quoted must include GST and other taxes. The court relied on Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corp. and Galaxy Transport Agencies to emphasize deference to the tendering authority’s interpretation of tender documents, indicating interference is warranted only for mala fides or perversity. The court found no mala fides, and held Ext. P1 fixed the estimated value; thus, it declined to interfere and dismissed the petition.

High Court of Kerala
Tr.P(Crl).No.17 of 2024

Cliya Dalvin v. Shamim Hassan P.T and State of Kerala (Transfer Petition under Cr.P.C.)

Cliya Dalvin, the petitioner, is the accused in S.T No.1263/2022 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Perinthalmanna, for an offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. She seeks transfer of the case to the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Adoor, citing threats from the complainant and his men, which allegedly prevented her from appearing in court and compelled the non-bailable warrant. She contends that personal appearance is unduly burdensome given safety concerns and that a counsel may adequately represent her, with her own presence treated as her presence under Section 317 Cr.P.C. The petitioner relies on rulings that permit dispensation of personal appearance: Bhanujan v. Jayabhanu, which recognizes magistrates' discretion to dispense with appearance; M/s Bhaskar Industries Ltd v. Bhiwani Denim and Apparels Ltd., which permits permanent exemption upon conditions; Sarath v. State of Kerala, holding that NBW pendency should not defeat relief under Section 205; and Moosa Pattupura v. State of Kerala, endorsing liberal application of Sections 205 and 317. The court finds the petitioner’s circumstances do not necessitate her personal presence and accordingly disposes of the transfer petition by (i) setting aside the NBW; (ii) granting permanent exemption under Section 205(1) Cr.P.C.; (iii) directing filing of an affidavit; (iv) offering protection if genuine threats exist; (v) allowing future transfer requests.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.(Rev.) No.25 of 2024

RCREV.NO.25 OF 2024 (Rent Control Revision) High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam

This is a Rent Control Revision filed by landlords (petitioners) challenging the Rent Control Appellate Authority’s order of eviction under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The Rent Control Court had earlier held that the landlords’ need to demolish the petition schedule shop room for parking in the four‑storied commercial complex ‘Simax Tower’ was not bona fide, though it granted eviction under Section 11(2)(b). The landlords’ appeal before the Rent Control Appellate Authority (RCAA) reversed the finding on bona fide need and allowed eviction under Section 11(3), considering additional materials about the parking area and the overall necessity for the commercial project. The tenants challenged this revision on grounds that the bona fide need was pretextual and that the authorities failed to appreciate the evidence. The High Court, after analyzing the settled law on bona fide need (relying on Adil Jamshed Frenchman, Shiv Samp Gupta, Deena Nath, Ammu, Regy V. Edthil, and other decisions) concluded that the Appellate Authority’s reasoning was neither perverse nor illegal and thus declined to interfere with the eviction order under Section 11(3). The Court, however, granted five months to vacate, subject to conditions including affidavit filing, arrears payment, and continued rent payments, thereby balancing the landlords’ need with the tenants’ obligations.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1135 OF 2007

Baby, S/o Thundupparambil William v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal appeal by Baby, the accused, challenging a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Fast Track Court No. II-Adhoc, Thrissur, for possessing 5 litres of arrack on 19.09.2003. The trial court convicted after examining PW1–PW5, Exts P1–P11 and MO1. The appellant contends the very sample tested in the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory was not shown to be the same sample seized at the scene, and raises a triad of defects: unexplained delay in producing seized properties to court; absence of the seal specimen; and seizure mahazar lacking seal description, with transit officials who handled the sample not examined. He asserts the chain of custody is broken, undermining the tamper-proof integrity of the sample and hence the reliability of the laboratory report. The prosecution relies on established precedents (Ravi v. State of Kerala; Sasidharan v. State of Kerala; Sathi v. State of Kerala; Bhaskaran K. v. State of Kerala) to urge stringent adherence to sampling, sealing and custody norms, arguing delays are not fatal if supported by other evidence. The High Court, however, finds no satisfactory explanation for the delay in production and analysis, notes the missing seal description and lack of witnesses on handling, and cites Krishnadas v. State of Kerala to emphasize delays undermine probative value. Consequently, the court acquits the appellant and allows the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.P NO. 1064 OF 2023

Dr. Radhakrishna S Naik v. State of Kerala

This criminal revision petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. challenges the order dated 05.09.2023 discharging the 2nd accused in S.C. No. 542/2022, a case under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO) before the Special Court, Hosdurg. The petitioner, Dr. Radhrakhna S Naik, is accused of examining a minor victim and, after obtaining a scan report indicating pregnancy, allegedly failing to inform the authorities that an offence under the POCSO Act had been committed. The prosecution contends that the 2nd accused had knowledge of the pregnancy and the offence and was under a statutory duty to report to the police under Section 19(1) POCSO. The defense argues that knowledge under Section 19(1) means awareness or state of mind rather than a duty to investigate, citing Dr. Sr. Tessy Jose v. State of Kerala and the interpretation in A.S. Krishnan & Ors. v. State of Kerala that “knowledge” denotes state of mind. The prosecution notes the minor’s age as 17 in some records; the record shows police were informed within hours of noticing the pregnancy, and medical staff informed the police. The court discusses the need for a deliberate omission to fasten liability and concludes there is no material showing willful omission by the 2nd accused. Consequently, the revision petition is allowed and the accused is discharged, setting aside the discharge order in the impugned proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.12745 OF 2018

S. Jayalekshmi v. State of Kerala and Others

The petitioner, S. Jayalekshmi, was appointed as Headmistress of the Easwara Vilasom UP School (6th respondent) on 30 June 2014. Her appointment was sent for approval but was declined on the ground that she was a protected teacher and therefore not entitled to be Headmistress. The approval rejection was upheld by the 2nd respondent, and a revision petition filed by the petitioner as well as those filed by the Manager and the 5th respondent were considered by the 1st respondent. Ext.P1, issued on 21 December 2017, disposed of three revision petitions, effectively leaving the petitioner's challenge pending. The petitioner contended that she was never treated as a protected teacher, and, supported by Ext.P3 (a seniority list), that she held seniority over the 5th respondent. The 5th respondent argued the petitioner’s protected-teacher status; reliance was placed on the decision in Manager, Mar Sleeba UPS v. State of Kerala (Supra). The court examined Rule 92 (Chapter XIV-A KER) and related provisions (Rules 44(2), 37(1), 45) and applied precedents on seniority lists, estoppel, and belated promotions. The judgment ultimately quashed Ext.P1, declared the petitioner’s appointment liable to be approved, and directed the 4th respondent to grant approval and release benefits within specified periods, apprising that the petition is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 30990 OF 2023

SOMASEKHARA J.S v. State of Kerala, Office of the Ombudsman for Local Self Government Institutions, and Savitha M.M.

This writ petition challenges Ext.P6, an order of the Ombudsman directing reinstatement of the third respondent as a Palliative Nurse on a contract that originally ran from 2011 to 31 March 2023 and was not renewed for 2023–24. The Grama Panchayat President, authorised by the Executive Committee, sought to challenge the Ombudsman’s order after complaints against the third respondent and the Panchayat’s decision on 15 June 2022 and 24 March 2023 not to renew. The petition traces the contract (Ext.P3) and its expiry, the complaint (Ext.P4) filed with the Ombudsman, and the Ombudsman’s Ext.P6, which allowed a review petition and directed the Panchayat to act within a week, with a view to reinstatement if a reason existed. The respondent third party argued that government orders Ext.R3(b) and Ext.R3(c) permitted continuation until project completion, but the court notes Ext.R3(b) only came into effect on 13 September 2023, after the contract had already expired and a new incumbent had been appointed. The court holds that the Ombudsman’s jurisdiction under Section 271J is limited to corruption or maladministration, and Ext.P4 does not allege such misconduct; hence Ext.P6 is without jurisdiction. The writ petition is allowed and Ext.P6 is quashed, clarifying that the Ombudsman cannot compel reinstatement in a contractual setting absent corruption or maladministration.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 890 of 2014

RSA No.890 of 2014

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a suit (O.S.243/2001) filed by Rajagopal seeking to invalidate Will Deed No.24/1997 (Ext.A4) of Parameswaran Pillai and to treat Will Deed No.3/1988 (Ext.A3) of Karunagappally S.R.O as the last Will. The trial court held Ext.A4 void and declared Ext.A3 the last Will. The District Court reversed; the Additional District Judge set aside the trial court’s finding and dismissed the suit, upholding Ext.B1 (Ext.A4) as a genuine Will and negating the trial court’s doubts. The High Court (A. Badharudeen, J., Single Judge) re-examines the legality of the Will under Sections 63 of the Indian Succession Act and 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, considering the burden on the propounder to prove due execution, the presence of suspicious circumstances, the credibility of attesting witnesses DW2 and DW3, and the location of execution (Sasthamcotta S.R.O. vs Karunagappally S.R.O.). It cites Santosh Hazari, Susamma v. Smitha Thomas, Murthy v. C. Saradambal, and other authorities to stress that an appellate court must apply mind and give reasons when reversing findings and that suspicious circumstances must be properly explained. Ultimately, the Second Appeal is dismissed, upholding the appellate court’s view and restoring the trial court’s conclusions with costs and vacating interim orders.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 15455/2023, 15707/2023, 15723/2023, 15746/2023, 16068/2023, 1931/2024, 12242/2024

W.P.(C) Nos. 15455/2023, 15707/2023, 15723/2023, 15746/2023, 16068/2023, 1931/2024, 12242/2024, In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These connected writ petitions challenge the calendar/regulatory regime for summer vacation classes in Kerala schools and seek authorisation to hold vacation classes for syllabus completion, particularly for CBSE/ICSE affiliated or non-KER schools. The petitioners argue that the calendar mandated under the Kerala Education Rules (KER) cannot automatically bind schools not governed by KER, and stress the right of the child to rest and leisure (Article 31 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child) and the State’s parens patriae duty to protect children’s welfare. They contend that the state’s executive power to regulate summer vacations must balance academic needs with children’s best interests, and that rigidly applying KER calendars to non-KER institutions would be inappropriate. The respondents rely on the KER framework to regulate school calendars and emphasize protecting children’s welfare through established statutory structures, while acknowledging the state’s general duty to regulate vacation practices in light of best interests. The Division Bench disagrees with the earlier I.S.S. (English Medium) decision, clarifies the panoply of authority, and lays down a nuanced framework to harmonize academic aims with children’s welfare across different types of schools.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 4097 OF 2024

Balakrishnan v. District Collector, Thrissur, and others

Balakrishnan, the absolute owner of 35.43 acres of land in Sy. No.205/4, Palissery Village, Thrissur Taluk, challenges Ext.P3, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer, which rejected his Form 5 application under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, to remove the land from the Data Bank. The petitioner contends the land is not paddy/wet land and was converted long before 2008, and thus should not be included in the Data Bank; he maintains Ext.P3 is vitiated by non‑application of mind and relies solely on the Agricultural Officer’s report, which cites coconut, castor, and banana trees under ten years old, and proximity to Cheruvatheri Padashekaram. He argues the RDO should independently assess status as on 12.08.2008 and consider KSRSEC’s status report, rather than depend on LLMC decisions or a single officer’s report. The Court, citing Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala, Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO, and Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO, holds that the RDO must perform an independent assessment to determine if removal from the Data Bank would affect paddy cultivation or wetlands, and whether land was paddy land on the date of the Act’s coming into force. Consequently, Ext.P3 is set aside and the matter is remitted for fresh consideration with a KSRSEC report at the petitioner’s expense, within two months, after the petitioner applies for the KSRSEC report within two weeks of this judgment.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 21395 OF 2023

M/S Concrete Aggregates Industries v State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA) Kerala and Others

The petitioner, M/S Concrete Aggregates Industries, a registered partnership, operates granite quarrying under a mining lease issued under the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1967, for 1.2121 hectares in Sy. Nos. 420/3, 420/4 and 420/1-2 of Pattimattom village, Ernakulam district, valid from 17 May 2006 to 16 May 2018. The writ petition challenges the requirement of environmental clearance (EC) under the Environmental Impact Assessment Notification, 2006, for mining activity up to 16 May 2018, citing directions in Deepak Kumar v. State of Haryana (2012) 4 SCC 629 and the All India River Protection Council v. State of Kerala and Others, 2015(2) KLT 78, which held that pre-18 May 2012 leases in areas below 5 hectares did not require EC. The petitioner contends that EC was not mandatory in its earlier operations and that interim orders allowing mining without EC were in place (Ext.P14). After obtaining a Letter of Intent for a fresh mining lease, it applied for EC for the expanded area, but the 1st respondent’s observations relate to earlier mining and were not considered in light of the earlier exemption. The court directed that the petitioner may file objections to the 125th meeting decision (Ext.P5) and that a final decision would be taken after a hearing, considering any prior orders or judgments favorable to the petitioner. The court clarified that its order does not decide the merits of the contentions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.34739 of 2023 & 12007 of 2024

Manjunatha Shetty v Malabar Devaswom Board and Others

These consolidated writ petitions challenge Ext.P2, dated 25 September 2023, by which the Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, appointed an Executive Officer for Sree Salathur Malaraya Daivasthanam, a controlled temple under the Board. The petitioner (Manjunatha Shetty) asserts hereditary rights in the temple’s management and contends that the Executive Officer appointment is unauthorized because the temple is not a notified religious institution under Section 66 of the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951; hence Ext.P2 exceeds power unless a fit person is appointed under Section 58(5) of the Act. The petition in WP(C) 12007/2024 by Manamohana Shetty seeks mandamus to implement Ext.P10 and to secure festival arrangements under the Executive Officer’s supervision. The Board and its counsel contend that Section 20 grants general superintendence and control over all religious endowments; Section 66 applies only to notified institutions; the Executive Officer appointment is validly under Section 20 to ensure proper administration, budgeting, and accountability, given long-standing deficiencies in inventories, vazhipadu registers, and kanikka accounting. The court cites landmark authorities on fiduciary duties and the guardian role of the High Court (parens patriae), while emphasizing the Board’s statutory supervisory duty. Ultimately, the court dismisses WP(C)34739/2023 and disposes of WP(C)12007/2024 with directions to implement Ext.P10 and ensure the forthcoming festival proceeds per customary practice, under supervision.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No.1902/2007

M. Rajagopal v. N.U. Vasanthy and State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court criminal appeal (CrL.A No.1902/2007) under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act challenges an acquittal in CC No.1015/2005. The trial court had held the accused not guilty for issuing a cheque dishonoured for insufficiency of funds, after concluding that the complainant failed to prove a legally enforceable debt and that the accused had rebutted the statutory presumptions. The appellate bench, presided by Justice Johnson John, re-examines whether the complainant established a debt, and whether the presumption of liability under Section 139 NI Act could be sustained given the defence’s theory that the accused’s husband borrowed money using her signed chequebook. The court scrutinizes evidence including Exhibit P6 (reply notice) and Exhibit D1 (alleged suicide note of the husband) and notes that Exhibit D1’s relevance is limited since the cause of death is not in issue under Section 32(1) EI Act. It highlights that the complaint did not disclose the transaction’s nature or date, and considers DW1’s testimony about a husband–not the accused–borrowing money as admissible under Section 11 EI Act. Citing Bharat Barrel & Drum Mfg. Co. v. Amin Chand Payrelal, Harbhajan Singh v. State of Punjab, and M.S. Narayana Menon v. State of Kerala, the court clarifies the standard of proof and the onus to rebut presumptions. It ultimately finds that the accused rebutted the presumption and dismisses the appeal, upholding the acquittal.