The High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam disposed of Bail Application No. 2414 of 2024 concerning Crime No. 339/2024 of Aluva East Police Station. The petitioners (the 3rd and 4th accused) challenged their detention under Section 439 CrPC, asserting their innocence in a case alleging offences under IPC sections 323, 324, 325, 294(b) and 308 read with Section 34. The prosecution contends that the 1st and 2nd accused inflicted grievous injuries on the de facto complainant; the 3rd accused is alleged to have struck the complainant with an iron rod; the 4th accused’s involvement is less clear. The petitioners have remained in custody since 21.02.2024 and the investigation, including recoveries, is nearly complete. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, noting an overt act against the 3rd accused and seeking continued custody until final report. Relying on Supreme Court principles in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, Dataram Singh v. State of U.P., State of Kerala v. Raneef, Hussainara Khatoon v. Home Secretary, Bihar, and Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi), the court emphasized presumption of innocence and that detention prior to conviction is punitive. The judge granted bail subject to stringent conditions: bonds of Rs. 50,000 with two solvent sureties each, regular appearances, no tampering with witnesses, passport surrender if applicable, territorial limits, and conditions for potential cancellation of bail on violation, while permitting continued investigation and recoveries as warranted.
The petitioner, Sujith Simon, is the accused in S.T No.1269/2022 pending before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Perinthalmanna, alleging offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. He seeks transfer of the case to the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Adoor, contending threats from the complainant and his men, and that a non‑bailable warrant has been issued against him due to his non‑appearance. He argues that his presence at every hearing is not essential given the nature of the offence, and that a counsel can appear on his behalf, with his presence being deemed satisfied under Section 317 Cr.P.C. He proposes to file an affidavit undertak ing that a counsel will be present and that he has no objection to taking evidence in his absence, treated as his presence. The petition references Bhanujan v. Jayabhanu (1993) for Magistrate’s discretion under Section 205 Cr.P.C, Bhaskar Industries Ltd. v. Bhiwani Denim and Apparels Ltd. for prerequisites to permanent exemption under Section 205(1) Cr.P.C, Sarath v. State of Kerala on NBW not acting as a bar to Section 205 relief, and Moosa Pattupura v. State of Kerala for a liberal approach to Sections 205 and 317 Cr.P.C. The High Court concludes that personal appearance is not indispensable; it disposes of the petition, (i) setting aside the NBW, (ii) granting permanent exemption under Section 205(1), (iii) directing an affidavit, (iv) directing protection if genuine threat, and (v) allowing future transfer requests.
Petitioners Kumari Rajani S.R. and Ajith G. approached this Court seeking to block the enforcement actions under the SARFAESI Act following default on an overdraft facility extended by the 1st respondent bank. The account was said to have been maintained properly until 2020, after which defaults occurred, triggering proceedings under SARFAESI leading to Ext P5 notice issued by an Advocate Commissioner, and threatened possession of the security interest property to enable sale for recovery. The petitioners claim that the compensation to be paid by the 3rd respondent (NHAI) for the Vizhinjam-Navaikkulam Road project could or should be redirected; they sought a mandamus restraining the bank from taking possession and, in a related prayer, urged that the compensation payable to petitioners in connection with the acquisition would be directed to respondents 1 and 2. They contend there is no need for a writ where a comprehensive statutory remedy through the Debts Recovery Tribunal exists and that the petition should be entertained only when extraordinary circumstances are present.
At the hearing, Standing Counsel for respondents argued that the petition was misconceived because the loan account was not maintained; the petition is barred by the SARFAESI Act, and an efficacious remedy lies before the Tribunal. Relying on Supreme Court and Kerala High Court precedents, the court held that writ jurisdiction is not available against SARFAESI proceedings and dismissed the petition.
WP(C) No. 30318 of 2019 (lead) This batch of writ petitions before the Kerala High Court challenges the regime introduced by ICDS and the amendments to Section 145A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The lead petition (WP(C) 30318/2019) concerns PA Jose, a jeweller by business, who along with other petitioners (variously named entities like Josco Bullion Traders Pvt Ltd, Josco Jewellers Pvt Ltd, Alphonsa, Josco Gold Corp, JosGOLD, etc.) contends that Clause 16 of ICDS II (which mandates the use of FIFO or weighted average cost for inventory valuation) and the retrospective substitution of Section 145A by the Finance Act 2018 are ultra vires the Act and violate constitutional guarantees, particularly Article 14, 19(1)(g) and 265. The petitioners assert that prior practice of LIFO valuation is legitimate and that changes cannot override settled legal principles or lead to the creation of notional income. The Delhi High Court’s Chamber of Tax Consultants decision is discussed, noting its finding that ICDS and Circular 10/2017 were ultra vires, though the present judgment later acknowledges legislative amendments that restore ICDS validity. The Court examines the mechanics of stock valuation opening vs closing stock, the chronological adoption of ICDS, and the need for uniform accounting treatment, ultimately balancing statutory changes with constitutional constraints. The judgment partly allows the petitions, quashes the challenged notices, and directs acceptance of either LIFO or FIFO/weighted average for AY 2017-18, preventing two different stock valuation bases within the same year.
WP(C) No. 34739 of 2023; WP(C) No. 12007 of 2024 This judgment disposed of two writ petitions challenging the appointment of an Executive Officer for Sree Salathur Malaraya Daivasthanam by the Malabar Devaswom Board. WP(C)34739/2023, filed by Manjunatha Shetty (a hereditary trustee from the Bakrabail family), contends that the temple is a controlled institution under the Board but not a notified religious institution under Chapter VI of the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951; hence Section 66 cannot authorize a salaried Executive Officer, and Ext.P2 (dated 25.09.2023) is without authority. The petitioner urged alternative action under Section 58(5) by appointing a fit person to discharge trustee functions. WP(C)12007/2024, filed by Manamohana Shetty, seeks mandamus to implement Ext.P10 (also dated 25.09.2023) and to ensure the Executive Officer takes charge for the upcoming festival, along with related reliefs to appoint an alternate person and to conduct the festival peacefully under supervision. The court, after hearing, held that the Executive Officer appointment fell within the general superintendence powers under Section 20 of the Act, and that Section 66 applies only to notified bodies; it refused to interfere with Ext.P2, relying on governance duties and fiduciary principles and approving supervisory measures. It also directed the 1st and 2nd respondents to implement Ext.P10 for the festival starting on 08.04.2024 and to ensure the festival proceeds under the Executive Officer’s charge with safeguards, dismissing WP34739 and disposing WP12007 with directions. The decision emphasizes temple properties protection, guardian parens patriae, and the duty of trustees to manage with due diligence, citing multiple precedents.
BAIL APPL. NO. 2075 OF 2024 This is a bail application under Section 438 CrPC by two accused in Crime No.45/2024 of the Peramangalam Police Station, Thrissur, seeking pre-arrest bail. The petitioners, Goutham and Sreeraj, contend they are falsely implicated in offences including 341, 323, 324 and 326 read with 34 IPC, arising from alleged assault on a defacto complainant on 18 January 2024. The first accused allegedly struck the complainant with an iron pipe, causing a nasal fracture, while the second accused allegedly punched the complainant; according to the prosecution, the incident occurred while they restrained the complainant and his companion on a motorcycle. The petition asserts innocence, argues that the 2nd accused had no overt act and that no recovery is required; they urge that custodial interrogation is unnecessary and that investigations would be jeopardized if released. The Public Prosecutor counters, noting medical evidence of nasal fracture and ongoing investigation; she contends that granting bail would impede the inquiry. The Kerala High Court, after considering medical certificates and the surrounding evidence, observes prima facie that the 1st accused’s role in Section 326 IPC is established, while the 2nd accused has no overt act. Citing Supreme Court precedents, the judge emphasizes that anticipatory bail remains an exceptional remedy to be exercised with caution. The court dismisses the 1st accused’s application and grants pre-arrest bail to the 2nd accused subject to conditions, including surrender timelines, bonds, and cooperation with investigation. The order also contemplates specific surrender and production timelines and conditions on the 2nd accused related to bond and witnesses.
Bobby Joseph, the absolute owner of 11.22 acres in Re.Sy. No.145/55 at Ollur, Thrissur, sought a residential building permit. The Thrissur Corporation, in Ext.P3 dated 02.04.2022, informed him of a proposed 12-meter road through his land under the master plan approved on 20.02.2021 and directed him to resubmit a plan excluding the road area. The petitioner submitted Ext.P4 under Section 67(1) of the Kerala Town and Country Planning Act, 2016, and the municipality issued Ext.P5 (purchase notice). Ext.P6, dated 22.09.2022, stated that since there is no order cancelling the master plan, a permit could not be granted. The petitioner contended Ext.P6 ignored the scope of Section 67; Ext.P7 (14.06.2023) was served after expiry of the two-year window, and the statutory period under Section 67(2) had lapsed, entitling him to pursue building rights under law. Respondents argued that the master plan sanctioned in 2021 renders the Section 67(1) application premature and must be considered only within the existing master plan, with Rule 3(3) of the Building Rules prohibiting contrary construction. The court cited Vinod (2019) and Joseph Jacob (2023) to emphasize time-bound state action and crystallization of rights after purchase notices. The court set aside Ext.P6 and directed the 2nd respondent to process the application in accordance with law within one month, disregarding the road proposal.”
Hebimon, a 42-year-old resident of Kollam, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC in connection with Crime No. 502/2023 of the Chadayamangalam Police Station, Kollam, for alleged offences under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, involving 53.860 kilograms of ganja found in a vehicle searched on 03.04.2023 near Nilamel Sastha Temple. The petitioner claims total innocence and that he was falsely implicated; he was arrested at Kaliyikkavila rather than at Nilamel, a point highlighted to challenge the reliability of the prosecution case. He had previously filed W.P.(Crl.)No.890/2023 seeking preservation of CDR/data, and Annexure-A2 ordered preservation for the period 02.04.2023–03.04.2023. The investigation has since concluded and the final report laid. The prosecution opposes bail, pointing to the petitioner’s conscious possession of commercial quantity contraband and his status as an accused in a separate case (Crime No. 276/2021, Chathannoor) involving 84 kg ganja, establishing a history-sheeter. Section 37 of the NDPS Act imposes stringent bail norms in cases involving commercial quantities, requiring the Public Prosecutor’s opportunity to oppose and that there be reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty and unlikely to commit offences on bail. The High Court applies the dual test of Section 37 in light of Supreme Court precedents such as Union of India v. Shiv Shanker Kesari, Mohd. Nawaz Khan, Prasanta Kumar Sarkar and Dheeraj Kumar Shukla, along with general Section 439 parameters, to conclude no reasonable grounds exist to release the petitioner. The bail application is dismissed.
This Regular Second Appeal (RSA No. 62 of 2024) arises from O.S. No.213/2019 on the file of the Munsiff Court, Pala. The appellant-plaintiff, Mariyam @ Beatrice, represented by power of attorney holder Boby Kurian, seeks relief in a Christian family succession dispute over property left by Chacko, S/o Mattathilaya Valiyaparambil Chacko. The core question is whether the possession and succession are governed by the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (ISA), or by the Travancore Christian Succession Act, 1092, as the late Chacko allegedly died intestate in 1938. The trial court held that Chacko died in 1938, applying the Travancore Succession Act, 1092, and dismissed the suit; the appellate court affirmed. The plaintiff contends that the ISA should apply (she claims a 1/5 share) and relies on Mary Roy v. State of Kerala & Ors. to argue extension of the ISA to Part B States. The respondents contend that because of the 1938 death, the Travancore framework governs, and ISA has no application; the trial and appellate courts relied on Exts.X1–X2 (death records) to support this. The High Court, invoking Part B States (Laws) Act, 1951 and the Mary Roy line of authority, ultimately holds that the Travancore Christian Succession Act stood repealed, and that the appeal lacks substantial question of law. The court concludes the plaintiff’s claim for partition under Section 28 is untenable, and the Regular Second Appeal is dismissed with all interlocutory applications denied.
In Bail Appl. No. 2742 of 2024 before the Kerala High Court, Sreejesh, the 3rd accused in Crime No. 1246/2023 of the Medical College Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC. The six accused allegedly formed a WhatsApp group for job aspirants and, posing as police officers and officials of the Public Service Commission, conducted a mock interview, duped aspirants, and extorted about Rs. 88 lakh. The funds were diverted to the account of the 2nd accused (the 3rd accused's wife) and then moved to the 3rd accused's account. Petitioner has been in custody since 23.02.2024. The learned counsel for the petitioner contends innocence and false implication; the offences charged appear not to attract in the given facts; the investigation is complete and recovery has been effected; thus detention is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor submits that the investigation is ongoing and bail would risk repetition of the offences. The court invokes Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh, and State of Kerala v. Raneef to emphasize presumption of innocence, bail as a rule and Article 21 protections. On considering the facts (45 days in custody, near completion of the investigation, recoveries), it grants bail on Rs.1,00,000 bond with two solvent sureties, subject to conditions including regular IO appearances, avoiding tampering, surrender of passport, and compliance with possible recoveries.
This DBA 2/2024 arises from the Travancore Devaswom Board’s bid to install a Golden Dhwajam at Parassala Sree Mahadeva Temple, a temple under the Board’s management. The Board proposes to melt gold offerings and other metals, purify the gold, and electroplate the Dhwajam with 24-carat gold, outsourcing purification to CGR Metalloys Pvt. Ltd., and electroplating work to Smart Creations, Chennai. The proceedings trace a sequence of court postings, affidavits, and orders (notably Annexures A6, A10 and A11) and discuss control measures such as standardisation (carat), weighing, sealing, and security of materials. The matter involves officers from the Temple Advisory Committee and local audit authorities, with the Board required to file detailed records and obtain instructions on procedural compliance. The Kerala High Court grounds the case in the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, citing Sections 15A, 25, 26 and 31 to describe the Board’s fiduciary and administrative duties over Devaswoms. The Court criticises laxity in earlier communications and directs adherence to prescribed procedures in Annexure A10, including a tripartite agreement among Thiruvabharanam Commissioner, the Temple Advisory Committee, and Smart Creations. The order disposes the DBA with conditions: proceed under Annexure A10 clauses 1–11 after the tripartite agreement, ensure videography and recording, and submit audited accounts and a maramath report (DBAR) for Devaswom oversight, with supervision by defined officials.
SaifunNisa, the petitioner, is the owner of 1.42 ares of land in Chelavur Village, Kozhikode Taluk, Kozhikode District. She challenged Ext.P3, by which Ext.P2 Form 5 application for removal of her land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 was rejected by the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) relying solely on the Village Officer’s report. She contends the land is garden land and not a paddy land or wetland, and thus not amenable to Data Bank inclusion; further, the RDO failed to independently assess the land’s status as on the Act’s date, instead relying on an unverified report. The Court recalls controlling principles from prior decisions: the RDO must determine whether the land was paddy land on the date of coming into force of the Act and whether it is suitable for paddy cultivation; merely marshy land, or a fallow field, does not automatically classify as wetland or paddy land; independent verification is essential, and the LLMC’s or other authorities’ prior declarations cannot substitute for individual assessment. The judgment cites Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP, Muraleedharan Nair, Aparna Sasi Menon, Jessy Abraham, and Mather Nagar decisions to emphasize independent evaluation and the need for concrete evidence, including KSREC/KSRSEC reports. The court sets aside Ext.P3 and directs the RDO to reconsider Ext.P2 in Form 5, obtain a KSREC report at the petitioner’s expense, and proceed within specified time, while the petitioner must secure the KSREC report and comply with directions.
CRL.A No. 639 of 2016; CRL.A No. 683 of 2016; DSR No. 2 of 2016 This judgment of a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court disposes of two criminal appeals (CRL.A. Nos. 639 of 2016 and 683 of 2016) arising from Crime No. 491/2014 (Attingal) and connected proceedings (DSR No. 2 of 2016). The prosecution alleged adultery-tinged conspiracy: accused 2 Anu Shanthi and accused 1 Nino Mathew allegedly plotted to murder PW1, Omana, and Swasthika to facilitate their illicit relationship, and to eliminate witnesses. The Sessions Court convicted both, holding that they conspired and that MO1 (chopper), MO2 (bag), MO5 (gold), MO11–MO12 (apparel), and other exhibits linked the crime to the accused, with IT Act 67A involved for exchanging sexually explicit material and navigational footage to aid escape. The High Court upheld the conviction on most counts, and while affirming guilt on the murder charges, converted the death sentence of the first accused under Section 302 IPC to imprisonment for life, with a direction that he shall not be released before 25 years, and with set-off of detention. The court reaffirmed the criminal conspiracy findings (120B IPC) and the IT Act offence (67A), and disposed of connected appeals and DSR. The judgment engages the law on conspiracy, the admissibility of electronic evidence, and the sentencing framework under Bachan Singh, Machhi Singh, and Swamy Shraddhananda, balancing aggravating and mitigating factors to avoid death.
BAIL APPL. NO. 966 OF 2024 (CRIME NO. 830/2024) The bail application concerns Noufal, accused in Crime No. 830/2024 of Erumapetty Police Station, Thrissur, seeking pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC for alleged offences under Sections 419 and 420 read with Section 34 IPC. The Sessions Court had earlier dismissed similar relief. The prosecution asserts impersonation of police, interception of a vehicle carrying the defacto complainant, and seizure of passport and air ticket, supported by CCTV and vehicle ownership evidence, with the investigation at a nascent stage and the petitioner alleged to have prior criminal antecedents in similar offences. The petitioner’s counsel contends innocence and false implication, highlighting the absence of material linking Noufal to the alleged acts, and submits custodial interrogation is unnecessary; he is willing to cooperate and comply with conditions. The Public Prosecutor counters by stressing the seriousness of the offences, potential tampering with evidence, and witness interference, justifying custodial interrogation. The High Court cites controlling Supreme Court authorities—Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra, Sibbia case, and Jai Prakash Singh v. State of Bihar—in endorsing a discretionary, fact-specific approach to anticipatory bail, emphasizing factors such as gravity of the offence, antecedents, flight risk, and likelihood of repetition, with no rigid guidelines. After weighing the facts and considerations, the court dismisses the anticipatory bail application but, on surrender within 10 days, directs that the matter be considered on merits by the jurisdictional court and that arrest may proceed if surrender is not effected.
This Kerala High Court writ petition challenges the regularisation of unauthorised construction under the Kerala Panchayat Building (Regularisation of Unauthorised Construction) Rules, 2018, in respect of a hotel building at Adimali, owned by the 6th respondent. The petitioner contends that Ext. P1 application by the 6th respondent for regularisation was examined by the 4th respondent in terms of Ext. P3, with conditions including ramp, toilet facilities, parking as per KPBR, and prior NOC from other agencies. However, Exts. P4–P6 allegedly omitting several Ext. P3 conditions and RTI information (Ext. P8) allegedly reveal non-issuance of Fire NOC and PCB NOC. The 9th onward steps, such as Ext. P9 licence to operate, were challenged on grounds that they relied on incomplete compliance with Ext. P3. The petitioner seeks to restrain HRACC (South) and HRACC, New Delhi, from acting on Exts. P4 and P9 and to quash the regularisation process. The court eventually addresses locus standi concerns, referencing John Chandy and K.D. Sharma to emphasize liberal public-interest access subject to bona fide interest and full disclosure. In the end, the court concludes the petition lacks locus standi and dismisses the writ petition, noting potential costs but refraining from imposing them.
The petitioner, Hindhu Aikya Vedi, challenges Ext.P2 (O.A. No.5/2014) dated 05.04.2016 of the Deputy Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, and Ext.P3 (notice dated 25.10.2023) inviting applications for non-hereditary trustees of Sree Perumal Kovil, Kollengode, on grounds that these actions give more representation to the Brahmin community, discriminating against other Hindu communities. It also seeks quashing Ext.P4 representation dated 17.11.2023 and a mandamus to reissue a fresh election notice removing discriminatory provisions. The petition, filed under Article 226, was admitted for admission on 05.01.2024. The MB Board argued for maintainability, noting a statutory remedy under Section 61 of the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951, and that the petitioner should challenge Ext.P2 before the Commissioner. The court traced the discretionary nature of writ jurisdiction, citing authoritative precedents that ordinarily bars a writ petition where an efficacious statutory remedy exists, save for exceptional circumstances. Key authorities include Commissioner of Income Tax v. Chhabil Das Agarwal; Authorised Officer v. Mathew K.C.; Thansingh Nathmal; Titaghur Paper Mills; Wolverhampton New Water Works Co.; Neville v. London Express; Gordon Grant; Secretary of State v. Mask; Balkrishna Ram; and L. Chandra Kumar, among others. Ultimately, the court held that due to the statutory remedy under Section 61, the petition is not maintainable and is dismissed, though leave is given to pursue the statutory remedy.
This High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, heard Bail Application No. 11403 of 2023, a pre-arrest bail plea under Section 438 CrPC by KaleSh @ Kannan (the first accused) in Crime No. 2437/2023 of Palarivattom Police Station. The accused, along with a second person, is charged under Sections 436, 120B read with Section 34 IPC for allegedly setting fire to a shop room owned by the defacto complainant in order to evict him, resulting in substantial loss. The prosecution submits that CCTV footage places the petitioner at the scene, the investigation is moving forward, and grant of anticipatory bail would impede the investigation and convey a negative public message. The petitioner contends his innocence, willingness to cooperate, and readiness to comply with stringent conditions, urging the Court to grant bail. The State and the defacto complainant oppose bail. In addressing the matter, the Court references Supreme Court precedents including Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra, the Sibbia principle on discretionary conduct under 438 CrPC, and Jai Prakash Singh v. State of Bihar, emphasizing that anticipatory bail should not be granted as a routine measure and must be grounded in the facts of the case. Ultimately, the Court refuses anticipatory bail but directs a surrender-based conditional path for future bail consideration.
This is a pre-arrest bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed in the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam by two accused persons, Chanthu S. and Sunil Kumar, in Crime No. 1595/2023 of Pooyapally Police Station, Kollam. The petitioners, charged with offences under IPC sections 294(b), 341, 323, 324, 326, and 308 r/w 34, contend that they are innocently implicated, and that offences under 326 and 308 will not be attracted; they offer to cooperate with the investigation and comply with stringent conditions. The respondent State, represented by a Public Prosecutor and with a Sr. Public Prosecutor Seetha S. appearing in court, opposes pre-arrest bail, pointing to the injuries sustained by the victim—fractures to ribs and right hand—and arguing that custodial interrogation is necessary as the investigation is at a nascent stage. The court cites Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra to emphasize that there are no inflexible guidelines for anticipatory bail and that grant or refusal must depend on the facts of each case; it also references Sibbia (Constitution Bench) and Jai Prakash Singh to underscore careful discretion and the notion that pre-arrest bail is an extraordinary privilege to be granted only in exceptional circumstances. After consideration, the judge finds no exceptional grounds to grant pre-arrest bail and dismisses the application, with a direction that surrender within 10 days allows for a merits-based reconsideration of bail on surrender.
CRP 353/2021; CRP 257/2022 This is a consolidated decision of the Kerala High Court in two Civil Revision Petitions (CRP Nos. 353/2021 and 257/2022) arising from the common order of the VI Additional District Judge, Ernakulam in O.P. (Electricity) No.515 of 2013. The petitioner in CRP 353, Jalaja Sivan, challenged the computation of compensation for trees felled and the diminution in land value caused by the laying of 400 kV transmission lines across her property in Koovappady, Ernakulam. The court below rejected the claim for enhanced compensation for trees, accepting mainly an Advocate Commissioner’s report and a solitary witness, and held that the contemporaneous valuation by the Corporation (and the commission reports Ext. C2/C2(a)) justified an enhancement of Rs. 4,10,404 for land-value diminution but denied further compensation for trees due to lack of independent evidence. The petitioner pressed for higher compensation for trees and greater diminution in land value, while the Corporation contended the enhancement was excessive and challenged the basis of Ext.A7 and the extant percentages. The Court evaluated the factors laid down in KSEB v. Livisha (2007) 6 SCC 792, including situs, distance of the line, extent of impact, and land use, and found the impugned order just and proper. The petitions were dismissed, with the Power Grid directed to pay the enhanced amount within three months of receipt of the order.
This is a revision petition under Section 125 CrPC challenging a Family Court, Kalpetta, order in MC No.36/2010 directing the revision petitioner (Saji) to pay maintenance to his wife and two minor children. The respondents—Khamaruneesa (wife) and her two minor children Nazeer Munna and Nushibha—alleged that the petitioner had the means to maintain them and thus sought monthly maintenance. The Family Court, after hearing evidence (PW1, Exts A1–A8; RW1, CPWs 1–2, Exts B1–B2) and considering the pleadings, partly allowed the application by directing the petitioner to pay Rs.2,000 per month to each of the two minors from the date of the application, totaling Rs.4,000 monthly. The petitioner contended that the order was erroneous because he had surrendered his passport in MC No.35/2009, which prevented him from continuing Gulf employment and earning, and that the quantum was excessive given his actual means. The respondents pressed for maintenance, arguing that the petitioner had sufficient means to support the children. The High Court, citing Rajnesh v. Neha and Anr, Captain Ramesh Chander Kaushal v. Veena Kaushal, and Bhuwan Mohan Singh v. Meena, reaffirmed maintenance as a social-justice obligation, while applying the principle that an able-bodied person is expected to contribute. Ultimately, the Court held no illegality in the impugned order and dismissed the revision petition, noting that arrears could be adjusted against deposits if any were made during interim orders.