Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 654 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 11280 OF 2023

Ahammed Suhail v. State of Kerala

This High Court of Kerala bail matter concerns the first accused, Ahammed Suhail, in Crime No. 393 of 2023 (Manjeswar Police Station), NDPS offences involving 56.080 grams of a concealed narcotic. The petitioner seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC on the grounds that he is innocent and that the investigating officer allegedly violated mandatory procedures under the NDPS Act and the 2022 Rules by consolidating seven packets seized from his body into a single packet, thereby compromising inventory accuracy and the sampling process. The prosecution maintains that the contraband, though later found to be methamphetamine on chemical testing, was seized in a manner that invokes the rigour of Section 37 due to a commercial quantity, and that any minor procedural irregularities should be addressed at trial rather than at the bail stage. The court undertakes a detailed survey of the NDPS provisions (52A, 37, 76) and the 2022 Rules (Rules 3 and 10) and cites several Supreme Court and High Court precedents dating from Khet Singh to Yusuf @ Asif, Bharat Chaudhary, Baldev Singh, Mohanlal, Abeesh, and Sushila Aggarwal to emphasize the necessity of fair procedure, presence of the Magistrate for sampling, and the inventory’s admissibility as primary evidence. After weighing the arguments and the absence of criminal antecedents, the court concludes there are reasonable grounds to believe the petitioner is not guilty and exercises clemency under Section 37, allowing bail with conditions.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 2550 of 2024

Muhammed Arshad v. State of Kerala

This bail application before the Kerala High Court concerns Muhammed Arshad, the second accused in Crime No. 244 of 2024 registered at Infopark Police Station, Ernakulam, filed under Section 439 CrPC seeking bail in relation to offences under Sections 384 and 420 read with Section 34 IPC and Section 66D IT Act. Arrested on 17 March 2024, the accused is said to have, with others, impersonated Delhi Police to coerce the defacto complainant into paying Rs. 19,90,000, claiming it would exonerate him from an investigation and to route funds through an RBI-supervised account. The case portrays a serious economic offense involving impersonation and extortion. The defense contends innocence, alleging false involvement, arguing that the accused is a dealer in digital currencies (BITCOIN) and should not be held liable for the defacto complainant’s own transactions; also contends RBI oversight and that custody since 17.03.2024, with investigation completed and recovery effected, negates the need for further detention. The Public Prosecutor counters that investigation is ongoing, bail could enable tampering with evidence, and the accused may have other antecedents. The court relies on established bail principles extracted from Chidambaram P. v. CBI, Chandra Sarkar v. ... and Gurucharan Singh Ors. to assess gravity, tampering risk, and trial presence, ultimately concluding that the petitioner is not entitled to bail at this stage and dismissing the application as meritless, thereby maintaining custody.

High Court of Kerala
BA No.3347/2024

Rajesh Kumar R and others v. State of Kerala and Station House Officer, Perumpetty Police Station

This is a bail petition under Section 438 CrPC filed in the Kerala High Court by four accused in Crime No.153/2024 of Perumpetty Police Station, Pathanamthitta, alleging offences including 294(b), 323, 324, 332, 353 and 506 read with 34 IPC. The incident occurred on 14.04.2024 at around 17:20 hours when, allegedly in furtherance of their common intention, the first accused visited the Kerala State Electricity Board office and slapped the de-facto complainant for not restoring electricity, which had been disrupted for two days. The accused allegedly injured the complainant and prevented him from discharging his official duties. The petitioners contend they were falsely implicated; the complainant was inebriated and misbehaved; the FIR was registered due to his influence; they request pre-arrest bail. The Public Prosecutor opposed, citing incriminating material including an accident register/wound certificate, and argued custodial interrogation is necessary to safeguard investigation. The court issued a 41A notice interim, clarifying no benefit, and subsequently held that accused Nos.2 to 4 are entitled to pre-arrest bail, finding no necessity for custodial interrogation for them, while dismissing the first accused's application. The order emphasizes that the observations are limited to bail and not merits, and prescribes specific conditions, including surrender, bonds, appearance, no tampering, passport surrender, and restrictions on further offences.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.14875 of 2024

State Bank of India v. Circle Inspector of Police, Angamaly Police Station and others

The petitioner, State Bank of India (SBI) as secured creditor, extended credit facilities to the 4th respondent, secured by an equitable mortgage over the loan properties, with the 2nd and 3rd respondents as guarantors. Due to irregularity in the loan account, SBI invoked the SARFAESI framework, and the account was classified as NPA. Pursuant to this, the Bank proceeded against the secured assets under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI) and the corresponding Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002. The 2nd and 3rd respondents challenged the measures by filing various petitions and appeals, including SA No.307/2022 before the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT), with related dismissals and withdrawals. Physical possession of the secured asset was ultimately taken by the Advocate Commissioner on 05.12.2023 under Section 14 of SARFAESI. The respondents allegedly trespassed into the asset on multiple occasions, prompting SBI to file police complaints and to proceed with sale of the asset (notice and sale notices were issued). Respondents contended there was no trespass and opposed the writ petition seeking police directions. The High Court, citing Kumaran A. A v. SP, Thrissur, affirmed that possession under Section 14 cannot be obstructed by trespassers and directed immediate police action to remove the trespassers, thereby upholding SBI’s possession and the security-sale framework.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No.630 of 2024

Praveen Kumar & Pradeep Kumar v. State of Kerala & Others

This is an appeal under Section 14-A of the SC/ST (POA) Act, challenging an order of 26.03.2024 passed by the Special Judge (POA Act), Alappuzha, rejecting anticipatory bail in respect of Crime No.1016/2023 arising from Poochakkal Police Station. Appellants 1 and 2 allegedly along with other accused formed an unlawful assembly on 21.12.2023 and trespassed into the courtyard of the defacto complainant’s family; appellant 1 abused the defacto complainant and his brother-in-law in filthy language, assaulted the complainant with a stick, and stomped the brother-in-law when he tried to intervene; appellant 2 allegedly stamped on various body parts. The defacto complainant belongs to the SC community, and the prosecution has alleged offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 447, 341, 323, 324, 294(b), 342 and 326 read with 149, along with Section 3(2)(va) of the SC/ST POA Act. The appellants contended that there is no prima facie case under the POA Act and that the matter involves inimical terms between the families; they argued that the bar under Sections 18/18-A POA Act does not apply if no prima facie case exists, citing Prathvi Raj Chauhan. The High Court, after reviewing precedents on anticipatory bail, held that prima facie evaluation and inimical terms negate an automatic bar, and granted anticipatory bail with specified terms. The appeal is allowed; the order denying anticipatory bail is set aside; bail is granted on arrest with bonds and conditions, including appearance timelines and non-interference with witnesses.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No. 3195 of 2024

Ali Badar and others v State of Kerala and Sufiyan

This High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam deals with a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC challenging the order in CC 191/2021 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Punalur, arising from Crime No. 33/2021 of Kulathupuzha Police Station, Kollam. Petitioners/accused Nos. 1–5—Ali Badar, Shan, Sameer, Muhammed Fayaz, and Ameen Shah—are charged with offences under Sections 341, 323, 143, 147 read with Section 149 IPC, for forming an unlawful assembly, wrongful restraint, and assault. The petition contends that the parties have settled the dispute amicably; the victim has sworn an affidavit in support of the settlement, and both sides wish to discontinue prosecution. The Public Prosecutor expresses reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but concedes the matter is settled, and no object to the settlement is stated. The court discusses the Apex Court’s jurisprudence starting with State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan & Others (2019) 5 SCC 688, explaining that under Section 482 CrPC, quashing is permissible for non-compoundable offences with predominantly civil characters when parties have settled their entire dispute, subject to exceptions for heinous offences or those under special statutes. The court notes the private nature of the dispute, accepts the settlement, and holds that the prosecution shall be quashed. The order ultimately quashes all further proceedings in CC 191/2021. The decision reflects a balancing of private settlements against public interest in criminal justice.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 11238 OF 2023

CRL.MC No. 11238 of 2023: State of Kerala v. Shanavas M.K., Asharaf K, Fasalu @ Fasaludheen M, Nisam M.A, Thafseer K, Seidu and others

This Criminal Misc. Case (Crl.M.C. No.11238 of 2023) before Hon'ble Justice Bechu Kurian Thomas arises from Crime No.559/2017 at Hosdurg Police Station, Kasaragod, and CC 1004/2018 before the Judicial Magistrate of First Class-I, Hosdurg. The petitioners, accused Nos. 1, 2, 4 and 7–9, challenge quashing of proceedings under Section 482 Cr.P.C. The prosecution alleges that on 23 May 2017, during a victory rally for a football tournament, the accused formed an unlawful assembly, restrained CWs from discharging duty, and thereby committed offences under IPC Sections 143, 145, 147, 341 and 353 read with Section 149. The petitioners’ counsel contends that the allegations are false, the accused were merely celebrating a trophy, and no incident of wrongful restraint or assault occurred; statements were taken with malice to frame them. The Public Prosecutor counters that the final report discloses the offences and that the remedy lies in trial, not quashing; one accused is involved in other cases. The court reviews the evidence and finds lack of specific attribution of restraint or assault, and notes the allegations are inherently improbable. Relying on Bhajanlal and Vishnu Kumar Shukla, the court holds that inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. can be invoked to quash. Consequently, the CRL.M.C is allowed and all further proceedings in CC 1004/2018 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 14231 of 2024

Shaji M.K. v. The High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam

Shaji M.K. filed this writ petition challenging the upgradation of the Overseer Grade-I post to Assistant Engineer in the Kerala High Court Service and the qualifications declared for promotion from Overseer Grade-II to that post. The petitioner, who joined as a Helper in 2011, argues that he possesses SSLC with ITI in electricity and a Diploma in Electrical Engineering and should be considered for promotion by relaxation, in line with the status of other incumbents protected by Ext. P7 and Ext. P12. He contends that the prescription limiting promotion to those with Plus Two or equivalent is arbitrary, illegal, and unconstitutional and seeks declarations and quashing Ext. P13, as well as a mandamus to promote him to the vacancy arising on retirement of the present Assistant Engineer. The respondent-State contends that promotions must be accorded to those meeting the minimum prescribed qualifications from 06.02.2014 and that Ext. P7 protected the incumbent, thus justifying Ext. P13’s action. The court, citing State of Jammu and Kashmir v. Shiv Ram Sharma and others, Roshan Lal Tandon v. Union of India, and the principle in T.R. Kothandaraman, held that government can prescribe qualifications and there is no indefeasible right to promotion; rules govern promotion. On this basis, Ext. P13 was deemed proper, and the petitioner’s relaxation request was rejected. The court dismissed the petition, clarifying that no declaration can be granted.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 714 OF 2019

Sajan Thomas v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.

This MACA 714 of 2019 is an appeal by the claimant, Sajan Thomas, challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakuda’s award in O.P(MV) 317 of 2016 arising from injuries suffered on 19 May 2015 while he rode as a pillion on a motorcycle. The tribunal awarded Rs 3,45,200 as total compensation with 8% interest from the date of petition. The appellant contends that the notional monthly income should be higher, supported by his alleged heavy-vehicle driving licence and a certificate of automobile engineering; he claimed potential earnings around Rs 18,000 per month. The insurer disputed the quantum. The High Court, while acknowledging the evidence gaps, reconsidered several heads: notional income, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities, and cited Ramachandrappa (SC) and Manusha Sreekumar (Kerala HC) to assess income norms and quantum. The court re-fixes the monthly income at Rs 12,500 (up from Rs 10,000) and, on account of the claimant’s heavy-vehicle licence, adds Rs 2,500. Pain and suffering increases by Rs 20,000; permanent disability and loss of earning power is recalculated to Rs 1,27,500; loss of amenities is increased to Rs 45,000. In sum, the appellate court increases the total to Rs 4,10,700 and allows the appeal, directing the insurer to deposit the enhanced amount with interest and costs within two months, after obtaining PAN/Aadhaar details.

High Court of Kerala
RP No. 472/2024 and RP No. 480/2024 in WP(C) No. 43954/2023

RP Nos. 472/2024 and 480/2024 in WP(C) No. 43954/2023, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This judgment disposes of two review petitions (RP Nos. 472/2024 and 480/2024) in WP(C) No. 43954/2023. The writ petition had challenged the grant of an environmental clearance and directed the writ petitioner to approach the National Green Tribunal (NGT) for redress, as the issues involved required substantial interpretation of norms in the Union Government’s environmental memorandum. The High Court acknowledged that it could not resolve such environmental-norm interpretations in Rule 226 proceedings and, while disposing of the writ petition, kept the interim order in force for a month to enable the writ petitioner to approach the Tribunal. In the review petitions, the respondents contended that since the High Court had not interfered earlier, it could not grant interim relief by final disposal for a month. The Court found force in this argument, and, reviewing the judgment, ordered maintenance of the interim relief only for the specified period to allow for Tribunal consideration. The court clarified that its observations on non-violation of norms and the decision to approach the Tribunal pertain to Article 226 and do not constitute a Merits decision. Ultimately, RP 472/2024 is allowed to the extent discussed, while RP 480/2024 is disposed of with the observations stated.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 43094 of 2023

Mujeeb Rahman V.A. vs Bank Manager, The State Bank of India, Koduvalli Branch; Station House Officer, Mancherial Police Station

This writ petition concerns the freezing of bank accounts in the wake of police requisitions. The petitioner, Mujeeb Rahman V.A., challenges a blanket debit freeze imposed by the State Bank of India, Koduvalli Branch, on his account, arguing that a freeze without a specified amount harms livelihood and due process. The High Court cites its earlier decision in Dr. Sajeer v. Reserve Bank of India (2024 (1) KLT 826), where it held that indefinite blanket freezes are deleterious to account holders and the banking system, and must be tailored to the actual needs of the investigation. In this case, the police requisitions reportedly seek freezing of all amounts in credit in the account, without indicating any precise sum. The court notes that such blanket freezing is incompatible with the prior ruling and proposes a measured approach to safeguard the investigation while protecting account holders’ rights. The bank is described as presently unable to operate the petitioner’s account due to lack of a specific amount in the requisition. Accordingly, the court directs the bank to obtain the exact amount to be kept frozen from the Investigation Authority within one month, and to limit any freeze to that amount if specified. If no information is received within two months, the petitioner may transact fully, subject to future information. An alternative course contemplates continuing the freeze for up to eight months if the police request the entire account to be frozen, after which the petitioner can approach the court again. The order strives to balance investigative needs with the account holder’s livelihood rights while providing procedural safeguards.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2386 OF 2024

SAJI @ SHAJI and ABHIN @ UNNIKUTTAN v. STATE OF KERALA and STATION HOUSE OFFICER, ANCHALUMMOODU POLICE STATION, KOLLAM DISTRICT

This is a bail petition under Section 439 CrPC before the High Court of Kerala (Ernakulam) concerning Crime No. 243/2024 of Anchalamoodu Police Station, Kollam, in which accused 1 Saji @ Shaji and accused 2 Abhin @ Unnikuttan are charged with offences under IPC sections 294(b), 341, 323, 324, 506(ii) and 307 read with 34. The petitioners were arrested on 23 February 2024. The prosecution case alleges that on 21 February 2024, around 8:30 pm, the accused, moving with common intention and due to prior animosity towards the de facto complainant, assaulted him—first accused delivering a fist blow and the second accused stabbing him with scissors, while uttering obscene words. The petitioners contend innocence and false implication, arguing the Section 307 charge is not attracted and that investigation is nearly complete with recovery effected, hence continued detention is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor concedes recovery but maintains the investigation is ongoing. The court notes the petitioners have been in custody since 23 February 2024 (about 33 days) and that recovery has been effected; it holds that further detention is unnecessary. Relying on Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh and State of Kerala v. Raneef, it grants bail on Rs.1,00,000 bonds with two sureties, subject to conditions including weekly appearances before the IO, prohibition on tampering with witnesses, no new offences, passport surrender, and potential modification of conditions under law.

High Court of Kerala
RCREV.NO.293 OF 2023

E. Praseja v. Sudha S. Prabhu and others

This is a Rent Control Revision under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, arising from eviction proceedings initiated by the landlady (E. Praseja) under Section 11(2)(b) and 11(3) on grounds of arrears of rent and bona fide need. During the pendency of R.C.P. No. 15 of 2017 before the Rent Control Court (Munsiff), Payyannur, the tenant was directed under Section 12 to pay admitted arrears of Rs. 72,478 and to deposit any rent due subsequently, with further payments to continue until termination of proceedings. The tenant paid Rs. 72,478 but defaulted on subsequent rent, and the Rent Control Court, on 05.08.2021, invoked Section 12(3) and directed eviction, stopping further proceedings. The tenants challenged this via R.C.A. No. 35 of 2021 before the Rent Control Appellate Authority, which allowed the appeal and set aside the 12(3) order. The landlord seeks revision under Section 20. The High Court undertakes a thorough review of Section 12, including the interplay of 12(1)–(4), and the requirement of giving the tenant a reasonable opportunity to show sufficient cause for non-payment, as emphasized in Shaji M. and Narayanan lineage. It concludes that the Appellate Authority erred in setting aside the 12(3) order without proper regard to due process, and remands for fresh orders under Section 12(3), with directions for expeditious handling and a hearing date of 26.02.2024.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 10612 OF 2024 & con.cases

WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & connected cases, In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This judgment by The Honourable Mr. Justice T.R. Ravi addresses WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 and a swarm of connected petitions challenging the blanket freezing of bank accounts by banks in the wake of cybercrime investigations. Petitioners, led by Yasmin K.A (along with many others across sister petitions), contend that freezing banks’ accounts pursuant to police directives causes severe financial hardship, often rendering daily life untenable, and that blanket freezes should be restricted to the precise sums identified in the police requisitions and as proceeds of crime. The matter is heard in a consolidated manner, given the cross-jurisdictional and multi-bank nature of the petitions, which involve entities like Federal Bank, ICICI Bank, South Indian Bank, Canara Bank, Axis Bank, and others, as well as police cybercrime cells and the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal. The court recognizes the necessity of safeguarding proceeds of crime while ensuring that innocent account holders retain limited access to funds necessary for ordinary living. Relying on Dr. Sajeer v. RBI (2023 KHC Online 661), the court extracts directions to balance competing interests. It directs banks to confine freezes to the amount mentioned in police orders, requires police to inform banks about continuation and time limits, and permits petitioners to approach the court if information is not forthcoming. The petitions are disposed of with these directions, leaving scope for further action if needed.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 3173 of 2024

NITISH AGARWAL v STATE OF KERALA

This High Court of Kerala bail application (B.A. No. 3173 of 2024) concerns Nitish Agarwal, the accused in Crime No. 15/2024 of the Cyber Crime Police Station, Thrissur. The allegations relate to offences punishable under Section 420 IPC and Section 66D of the Information Technology Act, arising from allegations that the petitioner, by posing as a sales executive of OM Enterprises and offering A4 papers for sale, cheated the informant and induced him to transfer Rs. 6,82,000 through two bank accounts between 17.01.2024 and 03.02.2024. The petitioner has been in custody since 01.04.2024. The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that there is no offence charged against the petitioner and that there is only civil liability, and the petitioner is willing to comply with conditions for bail. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, citing concerns about flight risk since the petitioner is from Ghaziabad and may not appear for trial, and alleging lack of cooperation with the investigation. The court considered the balance of convenience and potential prejudice to the investigation and concluded that continued detention is unnecessary; it directed the petitioner to stay within Thrissur District, appear before the IO on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, and comply with other conditions to ensure cooperation. The court also cited the principle that bail is the rule and jail is the exception, referencing Chidambaram P. v. Directorate of Enforcement to justify granting bail with conditions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 15274 OF 2024

Mujeeb Rahman v. Union of India & others

The petitioner, Mujeeb Rahman, holds an account with the respondents and his account was frozen following intimation from Police authorities. The Court had, at admission, issued interim directions to limit the freeze to the amount specified in the police notice, with the banks acting accordingly. The judgment references directions from a prior case, Dr. Sajeer v. Reserve Bank of India (2023 KHC OnLine 661), and extracts Paragraph 12 to outline the Court’s approach in such matters: (a) banks are to confine the freeze to the amounts mentioned in the police order; (b) police authorities must inform whether the freeze needs to be continued and for how long, within eight months of the judgment; (c) banks must adhere to these instructions; and (d) if no information is received, petitioners may approach the Court again with all contentions reserved. The decision disposes of the writ petition with these directions, emphasizing a balance between combating illicit proceeds and preserving legitimate access to one’s funds. The appendix lists petition exhibits related to online transactions and notices. Overall, the Court adopts a measured, interim-relief framework guiding banks and law enforcement in such freezing actions, ensuring proportionality and due process while not wholly halting account activity. The matter is resolved through specific directions rather than a broad ruling on freezing powers.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.43453 of 2023

Sureshkumar and Sukumaran Shasikala v. The Manager, South Indian Bank Limited; The Assistant General Manager (Regional Office), and The Chairman, South Indian Bank Limited

This is a writ petition under Article 226/transactions challenging SARFAESI proceedings initiated by the South Indian Bank Limited against borrowers who availed a loan of ₹2.50 crores in 2018 and defaulted in repayment. The petitioners seek quashing Exts.P3 and P4 notices, challenging the classification of their loan account (No. 0562652000000348) as NPA as of 30.04.2023, and contending that such actions contravene RBI guidelines and the moratorium scheme. They also seek protection against further proceedings without actual physical possession of the immovable property, and urge the court to consider Ext.P7 representation and issue directions for restructuring the loan within a timeframe the court may fix. The respondents contend that the loan account is being addressed under the SARFAESI regime, with a sanctioned proposal for releasing a portion of the mortgaged property on payment of ₹1.06 crores (with ₹20 lakhs already paid), subject to several conditions including signatories’ consent and a reservation of the Bank’s right to pursue remaining dues. The Bank’s decision is to be implemented subject to default consequences. The court, noting that the petitioners themselves sought a settlement and that the Bank’s proposal was framed in January 2024, dismisses the petition, citing a Supreme Court decision (SBI v. Arvindra Electronics) to refuse extension, while granting liberty to the petitioners to approach the Bank for further arrangements.

High Court of Kerala
Bail Appl. No. 11110 of 2023

Akhil Kumar v. State of Kerala

This High Court of Kerala bail matter concerns Akhil Kumar, the third accused in Crime No.1953/2023 of the Chavara Police Station, Kollam. The applicant seeks pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC in connection with offences under Sections 294(b), 506, 332 and 333 read with 34 IPC, allegedly committed on 26 November 2023 near the Sankaramangalam Grand Supermarket when a de facto complainant Sub-Inspector and other police personnel were abused and manhandled, causing injuries. The prosecution alleges an overt act by the petitioner and provides evidence such as the accident register and wound certificate. The petitioner contends innocence, maintains there is no overt act attributable to him, and argues that custodial interrogation is unnecessary since co-accused have surrendered and the investigation is substantially complete with recoveries already effected. The State opposes the bail plea, insisting that custodial interrogation is necessary to advance the investigation. The court cites Supreme Court guidance—Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra and the Constitution Bench Sibbia decision—along with Jai Prakash Singh v. State of Bihar to emphasize a fact-specific, discretion-based approach rather than rigid guidelines. After evaluating the nature and gravity of the offences and the material before it, the judge holds that the petitioner is not entitled to pre-arrest bail, but directs a contingency: if he surrenders within ten days, he can be interrogated and may seek bail on merits, without prejudice to later arrest.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.R.No.297 of 2023

Beena Karayi and K.N. Dinoop v Shubha K.V, DINOOP SivaraJ, and Shabana SivaraJ

This is a Rent Control Revision before the Kerala High Court arising from eviction under Section 11(2)(b) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease & Rent Control) Act, 1965. The revision petitioners, Beena Karayi and K.N. Dinoop, tenants in RCP 242/2018, challenged the concurrent orders of eviction by the Rent Control Court Kannur (29.09.2022) and the Rent Control Appellate Authority, Thalassery (22.05.2023). The landlords alleged default in rent and arrears, while the petitioners claimed substantial sums were due to them by the landlords themselves. The petitioners contended that they were compelled to invest about Rs.2 crore to commence a beauty parlour in the leasehold building and paid Rs.75 lakh as security, and that the landlords hindered the project by withholding electricity, water, and lift facilities. They argued that the sums invested and the security deposit should be set off against rent arrears, and that any refund/adjustment lies in civil court rather than eviction proceedings. The respondents countered that there was a clear tenancy with default, and that the Kerala Act does not provide a mechanism to adjust such advances or deposits against arrears. The Court examined relevant precedents, noting that some decisions under other Acts suggested offset principles, but held that Kerala law does not permit such adjustment and that the remedies must be sought in separate civil proceedings. Ultimately, the Revision is dismissed and eviction upheld, with the lower courts’ orders affirmed.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.3152 of 2024

Mahesh Babu v. State of Kerala

Petitioner Mahesh Babu, aged 25, is among the accused in Crime No. 394/2024 of Thalayolaparambu Police Station, Kottayam, charged under IPC sections 294(b), 341, 323, 363, 365 and 368 read with 34. The bail application under Section 438 Cr.P.C. was heard on 19 April 2024. The prosecution case is that, following a verbal altercation in a cinema, the petitioner and three co‑accused trailed the de facto complainant, with accused 1 and 2 shouting obscene words and the others assaulting him; they allegedly took him on a motorcycle and concealed him in Chunkam area to deter his friends or family from intervening. The petitioner’s counsel contends that even if the allegations are accepted, no offence under Section 363 IPC is made out; there is a history of settlement attempts, with common friends seeking reconciliation, and the de facto complainant accompanied accused 3 and 4 to the venue to negotiate. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail. After hearing, the learned judge preferred to grant bail on stringent conditions, noting the petitioner’s age, absence of prior criminal record, and the well‑established principle that bail is the rule and jail the exception, citing Chidambaram P. v. Directorate of Enforcement. The court directed: (i) appearance before the IO within ten days; (ii) on arrest, bail on bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties; (iii) cooperation and no inducement; (iv) no leaving India without court permission; (v) no similar offences; (vii) appearance before the IO on Mondays and Fridays; (vi) authority to investigate and recover even on bail; (viii) bail can be cancelled for violation.