Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 630 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
DBP No.89 of 2023

DBP No.89 of 2023 in the Matter of Travancore Devaswom Board – Report No.37/2023 in Complaint No.151/2022 – Complaint Filed by the Mathrusamithi of Keezhathadiyoor Thrukkayil Mahadeva Temple, Keezhathadiyoor in Lalam Sub Group of Ettumanoor Group – Suo Motu Proceedings Initiated

DBP No.89 of 2023 arises from suo motu proceedings based on Ombudsman Report No.37 of 2023 concerning Keezhathadiyoor Thrukkayil Mahadeva Temple managed by the Travancore Devaswom Board. The petition was filed by Remani Gopi, President of Mathrusamithi, Keezhathadiyoor, challenging the conduct of the Temple Advisory Committee that was constituted under Section 31A of the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950. The Ombudsman’s report (Annexure O4) contains adverse remarks against respondents 4 and 5 (members of the Temple Advisory Committee) and recommended excluding them from the committee. The Board moved to suo motu implicate the Board’s Secretary as 7th respondent; later, the 2nd respondent assisted by others joined. The case traces the statutory framework: Board management under Sections 3, 31 and 31A, and bye-laws framed under Section 31A(3); the Rules prescribe membership in the ‘registered mandalam’ and the election process. The court considers Santharam Roy T.S. and Chandu K. to interpret eligibility and statutory nature of committees, and cites Major Vellayani, Rajalekshmi P., and Sunil Kumar C. for governance and anti-fund-raising safeguards. Eventually, the DBP disposed of the petition with directions: the 1st respondent to decide on Annexure O4 after personal hearing within a month, steps to convene new elections within two weeks, and management by the department in the interim; Mathrusamithi role curtailed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 22071/2012, 20728/2012, 21868/2012, 22152/2012 (connected)

WP(C) Nos. 22071/2012 & Connected Cases (M.R. Geetha; V. Prem Kumar; S.S. Dayal; G. Santosh Kumar; S. Radhakrishna Pillai v State of Kerala & Others)

The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, heard WP(C) Nos. 22071/2012 and connected matters challenging an order dated 24 August 2012 that reduced the pay scales granted on account of promotions following an audit by the Accountant General. The petitioners—M.R. Geetha; V. Prem Kumar; S.S. Dayal; G. Santosh Kumar; S. Radhakrishna Pillai—alleged that the impugned order was issued without giving them any opportunity of hearing and without justification since the posts existed and the pay fixation had been done on bonafide grounds. They argued that the posts under TBGRI existed and that no misrepresentation had occurred; thus, any excess payment to the petitioners could not be recovered unilaterally. The Government contended that the posts did not exist and that the order merely rectified irregularities; however, it conceded the lack of hearing in the impugned order. After hearing the parties, the judge found that the order did not reflect any opportunity of hearing and admitted the writ petitions since 2012. Citing State of Punjab and Others v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), the judge held that where benefits are granted bonafide and without misrepresentation and there is fault on the part of the official respondents, the benefits should not ordinarily be recovered. The judge concluded that while some petitioners may warrant reconsideration, the impugned orders should be quashed and the writ petitions allowed, effectively granting relief to the petitioners.

High Court of Kerala
RPFC NO. 265 OF 2023

Shareef P. vs Raihanath K & State of Kerala

Shareef P., the revision petitioner, challenges the Family Court, Malappuram’s order in CMP(Ex) 166/2022 in MC No.64/2020 under Section 125 CrPC, which directed the petitioner to pay maintenance to Raihanath K at Rs 5,000 per month from 06.02.2020. The arrears amount to Rs 1,40,000 for 28 months until 05.06.2022, and the Family Court issued a distress warrant and ultimately sentenced the petitioner to civil imprisonment for 420 days (15 days per month of default). The petitioner did not contest the execution, and the court proceeded to arrest him, ordering imprisonment until payment. The revision argues four points: (i) the execution application is time-barred under the proviso to 125(3) CrPC; (ii) the petitioner has to maintain his parents and minor son; (iii) the 1st respondent is living in adultery; and (iv) the impugned order violates the proviso to Section 125(3). The High Court of Kerala, after considering the record, held the execution application timely (within one year of the due arrears date), rejected the adultery and parental maintenance defenses as improper in execution, and confirmed the Family Court’s order while granting the petitioner a chance to secure release by paying half arrears with a post-payment bond for the balance. The revision petition was dismissed, with conditions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 20374 OF 2015

The Peringode Service Co-Operative Bank Ltd v State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition challenges two official orders affecting the terms of service of respondents 3–5, who were engaged by the petitioner bank as clerks on daily wages and later on a contractual basis. They were disengaged on 16.10.1998, leading to industrial disputes (I.D. Nos. 136, 138, 139/99) and a common award dated 31.05.2001 directing reinstatement with the bank’s right to terminate under Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. In subsequent proceedings, the 2001 award was treated as permitting retrenchment, and respondents 3–5 were temporarily re-employed but retrenched by Resolution No. 21 dated 27.12.2007, an action not challenged. In 2013 the society invited applications for new posts (two peons and one night watchman) via Notification No. 79/11, published 14.02.2013; however, respondents 3–5 sought re-employment under Section 25H, arguing a preferential right. The Joint Registrar issued Ext. P7 (20.06.2013) directing retention under 25H, which was appealed and led to Ext. P8 and finally Ext. P9 (29.11.2014). The petitioner contends Ext. P9 is cryptic and thus not justiciable, while respondents contend 25H confers a re-employment right. The High Court ultimately held that 25H cannot be invoked to fill clerical vacancies and that Ext. P9 lacked reason, setting it aside and remitting the matter to the Appellate Court to consider 25H applicability and related factors with a four-month timeframe; this culminates in a remand for fresh consideration rather than a final grant of re-employment.

High Court of Kerala
Cr.M.C.No.6566/2022 & O.P.(Crl).No.549/2022

Cr.M.C.No.6566/2022 & O.P.(Crl).No.549/2022, High Court of Kerala

This Kerala High Court judgment, delivered by Justice A. Badarudeen, relates to two petitions challenging orders of the Family Court, Malappuram that refused or returned execution petitions seeking to enforce maintenance orders under Sections 125 and 127 Cr.P.C. The core issue is whether a court that passed maintenance orders can execute them against a respondent who resides outside its territorial jurisdiction. In Cr.M.C.No.6566/2022, the petitioners argued that under Section 128 Cr.P.C, a maintenance order may be enforced by any Magistrate in any place where the respondent may reside, and that the Family Court’s endorsement requiring execution at the respondent’s place of residence defeats the purpose of enforcement and could enable evasion. In OP(Crl).549/2022, a similar challenge was raised regarding a contrario order. The court examined interpretations of “may” versus “shall” in statutory language, citing a series of decisions (including Anoop Vijay v. Arunima P.T; Ramji Missar v. State of Bihar; Mohan Singh v. IAAI; Jogendra Singh; Aggarwal; Bhaskar Lal Sharma) to illuminate when “may” ought to be read as mandatory in order to effectuate justice and prevent evasion. The High Court ultimately held that Section 128 permits enforcement by the issuing court irrespective of residence, and that the Family Court retains the power to execute outside its jurisdiction. The orders impugned were set aside, and the Family Court, Malappuram was directed to accept execution petitions and enforce the orders in accordance with law. The petitions are allowed accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MCNO.3919OF2023

Abhiram, Sajalsanthosh and Muhammed Afreedh v. State of Kerala and Others

This Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case concerns three accused persons—Abhiram, Sajalsanthosh and Muhammed Afreedh—challenging criminal proceedings in Crime No. 260 of 2022 of the Vythiri Police Station for offences under Sections 457 and 380 IPC. The alleged incident occurred between 10:00 pm on 21.06.2022 and 5:30 am on 22.06.2022 at the 24 Market in Chungal, where provisions valued at approximately Rs. 18,000 were reportedly stolen. The petitioners contend innocence and submit that registration of the crime was mistaken; following registration, the de facto complainant filed an affidavit stating no further grievance. The court directed the investigating officer to record the victim’s statement and to report whether settlement between the parties had resolved the dispute and whether there were any impediments to terminating proceedings, including the petitioners’ criminal antecedents. The Public Prosecutor cautioned against quashing solely on the basis of a settlement, noting that the 1st petitioner has concurrent cases. The court observed the parents’ testimony that the son was falsely implicated, yet noted the 1st petitioner’s involvement in two other crimes. Relying on Supreme Court authority, including Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, the court held that CrPC Section 482 power can quash non‑compoundable private offences when the parties settle, if the court is satisfied that the settlement will not harm society. Consequently, the petition was allowed and FIR 260/2022 and all proceedings were quashed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl.) No.469 of 2023

Jino v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition challenges Ext.P1, an externment order issued under Section 15(1) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007, restraining the petitioner from entering Thrissur District for one year, later reduced to nine months by the Advisory Board. The last cited prejudicial activity is Crime No. 720 of 2022 at Viyyur Police Station, with the incident occurring on 25.09.2022. The petitioner was arrested and bailed on 15.10.2022. On 12.11.2022 the SHO forwarded the initiation request; the sponsoring authority recommended on 28.11.2022; after an opportunity of hearing, the competent authority issued Ext.P1 on 28.12.2022 and communicated on 29.12.2022. The petitioner contends the externment is belated and that there is no live link between the last prejudicial activity and the initiation of proceedings, suggesting a lack of application of mind. The Government Pleader counters that there is no justification to interfere and that a live link exists. The court emphasizes the necessity of a live link, noting that a long delay without explanation may sever it, but also holds that the delay here is not sufficient to negate the mind’s involvement. Relying on Stalin C.V. v. State of Kerala, the court concludes the delay does not automatically invalidate the order. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed and Ext.P1 externment order stands. Appendix includes Exh. P1 (externment order) and Exh. P2 (Advisory Board order).

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 3863 of 2023

Rishad.K.M v. State of Kerala

Rishad.K.M., the 10th accused in Crime No.1015/2022 of Infopark Police Station, Ernakulam, seeks anticipatory bail in a second round before the Kerala High Court. Justice A. Badharudeen reviews the matter after dismissing the earlier common order dated 17.03.2023 in BA Nos. 928, 1004, 1140 and 1161, which related to pre-arrest bail petitions of co-accused. The prosecution alleges that on 23.12.2022 the accused trespassed into the defacto complainant’s office—‘Brawny Brute’ Family Studio Health and Bautique Clinic’— assaulted staff with a hammer and wooden stick, forcefully obtained a cheque, and looted files, a laptop, treatment equipment, an i20 car (KL-40-L 3141), ATM card, gold, clothes and other items valued at around Rs. 14.8 lakh, while allegedly simulating MDMA to intimidate the complainant. The FIR records offences under IPC Sections 452, 324, 384, 395, 427 and 506(ii) read with Section 212. The petitioners’ counsel contends innocence, asserts the cheque originated from a financial dispute, and argues lack of CCTV corroboration for 30 alleged participants; it is urged that changed circumstances after others’ regular bail justify relief. The State-PP counters with the gravity of the offences and the need to safeguard the investigation. While acknowledging the doctrine of deemed custody as permissible for investigation, the Court finds it insufficient to secure recovery of the stolen articles and accordingly dismisses the second anticipatory bail applications, directing surrender within seven days.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) No.296 of 2022

Sasidharan Nair G. and Subha v. Omana and Rajesh

Original Petition (O.P.) under Article 227 of the Constitution challenges a Family Court order on maintainability in I.A. No.1 of 2021 in O.P.526/2017, Nedumangad. The respondents sought a declaration that Omana was the legally wedded wife of Sasidharan Nair G. and that Rajesh was their legitimate son, with past and future maintenance. The petitioners contest the marriage between Sasidharan Nair G. and Omana and dispute paternity; they assert the marriage date as 03.07.1993 and contend the respondents were fully aware of the relationship. They argue that O.P.526/2017 is barred by limitation since the cause of action for a declaration arose in 1993 and maintenance claims depend on a declaration. The Family Court treated maintainability as a preliminary issue and held the petition maintainable. The Kerala High Court, however, held the petition is barred by the law of limitation, applying Article 58 of the Limitation Act, 1963, and tracing accrual of the right to sue as per the law. It cites Khatri Hotels and Azhar Hussain to discuss accrual and the conduct of proceedings, ultimately allowing O.P.296/2022 and dismissing O.P.526/2017 as time-bar, while setting aside the Family Court’s order.

High Court of Kerala
BA No. 4092/2022

Liju Oommen v. State of Kerala and The Station House Officer, Mavelikkara Police Station

This is a bail application under the NDPS Act by the petitioner, the 1st accused in Crime No. 1479/2020 of Mavelikkara Police Station. The court reviews prior bail orders, the final report, and the changed factual matrix: the prosecution now contends that contraband was recovered from the house of the 2nd accused, where she resided with her minor children, and that the car in front of that house, registered in the petitioner’s wife’s name, contained contraband. The only direct link to the petitioner is that he was a frequent visitor to the 2nd accused’s house and that his car was involved in the incident; however, the quantity recovered from the car is not shown to be a commercial quantity. The petitioner argues that there is no material connecting him to the alleged recovery and that the earlier reliance on a “commercial quantity” should not apply under Section 37 of the NDPS Act; he also asserts malice and references judgments such as Mohammed Navas Khan and Pallulabid Arimutta to argue that material obtained by other means (CDR, WhatsApp chats) should not influence bail. The State counters with evidence of an ongoing drug nexus: the 1st accused’s alleged role as a mastermind, corroborated by WhatsApp chats, photographs, and the car seizure, and cites his involvement in numerous other cases. The court ultimately rejects the bail prayer, applying the stringent standards of NDPS Section 37, noting that the prosecution’s materials reveal a large-scale operation and that the presumption under Section 54 applies, justifying continued detention. The order emphasizes that no observation should prejudice the trial.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(C) No. 175 of 2017

O.P.(C) No. 175 of 2017 (Manu Vaidyar vs Parukuttyamma Indira Devi, Krishnan Nadar, and Binu Krishnan)

This Original Petition (Art. 227 of the Constitution) challenges the Principal Munsiff Court, Neyyattinkara’s order in I.A.4256/2016 in O.S.No.12/2012. The long-pending litigation traces to 1957, involving a mortgage of the plaint schedule property by the Karanavar of Punnakkulam Tarawad to Padmanabhan Ummini. The 2nd respondent (grandson of the mortgagee) and 3rd respondent (son of the 2nd respondent) obtained rights through later transactions and sought partition and possession of the mortgaged property, leading to petitions for injunctive relief and anti-waste orders. The petitioner, MD of the 278th defendant (Ofisina Builders and Realtors Pvt. Ltd.), contends that the documents relied upon by respondents 2 and 3 do not pertain to the mortgaged property and that the common judgment in several CRPs has already held the disputed sales deeds not to relate to the mortgaged property. The petition argues that the Advocate Commissioner’s appointment is unnecessary and designed to prolong litigation. Respondents argue the commission is proper to ascertain rights in a partition context and that discovery of waste and related details are essential before final adjudication. The High Court ultimately dismisses the petition, upholds the impugned order, directs expedited commission reporting, and orders disposal of the suit within six months of receiving a certified copy of the judgment.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 697 of 2006

Bhargaviammal and Krishnan Kutty v Paramu Achary and Ramakrishnan

The Regular Second Appeal (RSA No. 697 of 2006) arises from a suit for declaration of title and injunction over plaint schedule property, with Ext. A2(admitted marriage udumbady) and a release deed at the center of the dispute. The trial court decreed the suit for the plaintiffs; the first appellate court reversed, holding there was no valid marriage between the first plaintiff and late Kittan Achari, and that the second plaintiff could not claim under Section 16(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act. The appellants contended Ext. A2 shows a valid marriage by late Kittan Achari to the first plaintiff, relying on Section 32(5) and 32(7) of the Indian Evidence Act and precedent like Janaki Amma v. Rama Warier, as well as long cohabitation. The second defendant argued that Ext. A2 does not constitute a solemnization and challenged the inference of marriage; he asserted that the second plaintiff’s right under Section 16(1) cannot arise without a valid marriage, and raised res judicata and related issues. The Kerala High Court, after evaluating Ext. A2, the evidence, and the cited authorities, concluded that Ext. A2 does not prove solemnization; long cohabitation cannot substitute a valid marriage; Section 16(1) cannot be invoked. The appeal is accordingly dismissed, sustaining the appellate order. Costs follow the result, with each party bearing its own costs.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C.No.3206 of 2022

Visal v. State of Kerala

Visal challenges Annexure-1, an order dated 20.04.2021 passed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Kollam, under Section 111 Cr.PC read with Section 107 Cr.PC in MC No.255/2021, as a pre-emptive measure. The objection is that Annexure-1 does not disclose the substance of the information received or the factual basis on which the Magistrate formed the satisfaction to invoke Section 107 Cr.PC, thereby depriving the petitioner of a meaningful opportunity to defend the allegations and potentially stigmatizing him without adequate particulars. The petitioner places reliance on prior Kerala High Court authority emphasizing procedural strictness under Ss.107/111 CrPC: Girish P. and others v. State of Kerala and another, which stresses the necessity to reveal the information and the purpose of disclosure; Bejoy K.V v. State of Kerala and Another, which reiterates the mandatory specifics required in an order under S.111; and Moidu’s Full Bench decision, noting an imminent breach of peace must justify initiation under S.107. The court notes the lack of substance in Annexure-1 and holds that the order is not in tune with the statutory requirements of Ss.107/111 CrPC. Consequently, the criminal miscellaneous case is allowed and Annexure-1 is quashed, with leave to proceed afresh if a fresh cause arises under the law.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.No.930 of 2022 and W.A.No.1563 of 2023

W.A. Nos. 930 of 2022 and 1563 of 2023 (M/S Biverah Hotel and Suites, Kumarapuram v. Additional District Magistrate, Kerala State Electricity Board Ltd. & others)

These writ appeals arise from a common judgment dated 12.07.2022 in W.P.(C) Nos. 14176 of 2022 and 13879 of 2022. W.A. No.930 of 2022 is filed by the writ petitioner, proprietor of M/S Biverah Hotel and Suites, challenging Ext.P10, an order dated 06.04.2022 of the 1st respondent ADM under the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 and the Electricity Act, 2003, directing HT electric supply to the apartment of the 7th respondent through an add-on RMU route. W.A. No.1563 of 2023 is by the 4th respondent (KSEB) challenging the common judgment in the same writ petitions, and seeking to uphold police protection and action against incidents of criminal acts. The Single Judge, in the common judgment, dismissed W.P.(C) No.14176 of 2022 (quashing Ext.P10) and allowed W.P.(C) No.13879 of 2022 (directing police to assist tapping the RMU). The Court framed Regulation 24(2) of the Kerala Electricity Supply Code, 2014, and relied on provisions of the Indian Telegraph Act and Electricity Act to analyse the licensing and tapping routes. It considered Board orders clarifying HT connections via RMUs and held that the ADM’s order did not suffer illegality, irrationality, or procedural impropriety. The Division Bench affirmed, finding no illegality in the impugned route and that the petitioner had surrendered the RMU area, enabling tapping. The appeals were dismissed, upholding the common judgment. The matter thus resolves with the police-assisted tapping via the add-on RMU allowed for the 7th respondent’s premises, and the writ petitions facing respective outcomes.

High Court of Kerala
MFA (Forest) No. 19 of 2016

P.C. James v. State of Kerala and Ors.

An appeal by P.C. James challenges the Kerala Forest (Vesting and Management of Ecologically Fragile Lands) Tribunal’s dismissal of his application under Section 10 of the EFL Act (OA 15/2009). The 60-hectare scheduled property, Sy.No.175/1 in Muthalamada village, is claimed by Gemini Plantations as their jenmom estate, with title traced to transactions prior to the Act. The Raja of Kovilakam allegedly leased the land to develop an estate, and the land was historically planted with cardamom and later partially converted to coffee. Following notification under the EFL Act, the applicant sought denotification and restoration on the ground that the land is not ecologically fragile and that exempt cultivation of long-duration crops should apply. The Divisional Forest Officer’s statement and Exts supported that the property is part of Nelliyampathi Hills, with natural vegetation and forest-like characteristics, while Ext.B1 and related documents indicated eco-fragility. The Tribunal, applying S.2(b), S.2(c), and statutory definitions, concluded the land is ecologically fragile and rejected exemption under S.2(c) for long-duration crops, dismissing OA 15/2009. The applicant challenged, arguing that the Tribunal ignored the definitions and misjudged survey numbers and cultivation. The High Court, while recognizing discrepancies between the Commissioner’s report and expert opinion, does not disturb the core finding of fragility; it reiterates that the burden lies on the applicant to prove non-fragility and dismisses the appeal with costs. The Court also cites jurisprudence that such reports are nonadjudicatory and not binding, yet relies on the Tribunal’s conclusion.

High Court of Kerala
MFA(Forest) No.89 of 2014

State of Kerala v Girish Kumar S/o Vadakkekkara Sekharan and Custodian of Vested Forests Olavakkode, Palakkad District

This is a Division Bench judgment of the Kerala High Court arising from MFA (Forest) No. 89 of 2014, preferred by the State and the Custodian of Vested Forests (Olavakkode) challenging the Tribunal’s finding that item 1 of the scheduled land is not a private forest under the Kerala Private Forest (Vesting & Assignment) Act, 1971. The applicant (Girish Kumar) traces title through a chain of transfers from 1965 onward, asserting long-standing cultivation of coconut and rubber on the land, with a house and an old well, and claiming exemption from vesting as per sections 3(2) and (3) of the Vesting Act. The Tribunal had held that title to item 2 (40 cents) was not proved and, crucially, found that the land did not possess forest characteristics and that the notified area fell outside the MPPF Act’s reach. The Tribunal concluded the land was not a forest land and thus not governed by the Madras Preservation of Private Forest Act, 1949 or the Vesting Act’s exemptions. The High Court upheld these findings, emphasizing that the MPPF Act applies only to private forests exceeding 100 acres contiguously in Malabar/South Kanara, and that the specific land in question (≈25.24 hectares) does not meet that threshold or exhibit forest characteristics. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed with costs. The matter relies on statutory interpretation of vesting, exemptions and forest definitions as applied to historical land classifications.

High Court of Kerala
WA 725 OF 2023

WA NO. 725 OF 2023 & CON.CASES (In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam)

This batch judgment deals with a group of writ appeals filed against notices and tenders issued by the Kerala Water Authority (KWA) under Jal Jeevan Mission and related works. The key dispute centers on the demand for Additional Performance Guarantee (APG) allegedly required to be furnished item-wise by successful bidders when bids were below or near the tendered probable amount of contract (TPAC). The appellants, including M/S STREFA PROJECTS PRIVATE LTD, challenge the APG demand on the ground that the tender notices did not disclose any obligation to provide item-wise APG, nor did they reference the Government Orders relied upon by the KWA (GO 28/09/2015, GO 29/08/2016, GO 10/01/2019, and the later order dated 07.12.2019). They argue post-bid imposition of new terms violates established contracts’ principles, citing Delhi Development Authority and Suresh Kumar Wad-hwa, and Ramesan P. v. T. Asokan to support transparency in tender terms. The respondents contend the NITClause 7.21.1 and GO provisions clearly mandate APG, with item-wise calculation, and that bidders were aware of the rate framework via the committee’s published rates. The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench, ultimately allows the appeals, setting aside the single-judge order, and holds that (i) APG is not required if the overall rate is within 10% below TPAC, but (ii) APG is required for 11–25% below TPAC per the 10.01.2019 clarifications. The court underscores the need for tender notices to disclose terms and holds that reliance on post-tender orders not referenced in the NIT is unsustainable.

High Court of Kerala
Tr. Appeal (C) Nos.6 of 2024; Tr. Appeal (C) NO. 8 OF 2024

Tr. Appeal (C) Nos.6 of 2024 and 8 of 2024; Smitha Mary George v. Deepak Chummar

These transfer appeals challenge a common order dated 09.04.2024 of a learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court, which rejected two transfer petitions under Section 24 CPC transferring family-court proceedings from Aluva to Ettumanoor. The appellant-wife, Smitha Mary George, had instituted four petitions across Family Courts: G.O.P.1201 of 2023 (custody) and O.P.1133 of 2023 (divorce) by the husband; and O.P.(G&W) No.205 of 2024 (parental custody) and M.C. No.22 of 2024 (maintenance under Section 125 CrPC) by the wife. The wife sought transfer of O.P.1133/2023 and G.O.P.1201/2023 to Ettumanoor so that all four matters could be heard together, noting her residence near Ettumanoor and her unemployment. The trial judge found that two of the children were in the husband’s custody and schooling in Aluva, concluding that the transfer would prejudicially affect the children, and dismissed the petitions. On appeal, the bench rejected the narrow rule advanced by the husband based on a precedential view, and relied on the broader principle that in matrimonial disputes the wife’s convenience should prevail and that pending matters before different Courts should be tried together to avoid conflicting rulings. Citing NCV Aishwarya v. A.S. Sharavana (AIR 2022 SC 4318) and Reegan Jayakumar v. Shami Shahul (2015 (3) KHC 164), the court held that transfer to Ettumanoor would serve the interests of justice. Consequently, it allowed the appeals, ordering the transfer of G.O.P.1201/2023 and O.P.1133/2023 from Aluva to Ettumanoor, to be tried with the wife’s O.P.(G&W)205/2024 and M.C.22/2024.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 3812/23

Jaffar, Jaseer P.P. and Jamsheer P.P. v. State of Kerala and Others

This is a bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 3812 of 2023) filed in the High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, by accused Nos. 1–3 in Crime No. 176/2023 of Nadapuram Police Station, seeking anticipatory bail against an ongoing investigation. The petition, heard by a Single Judge (Hon. Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A.) on 15 June 2023, challenges an order/direction in CrMC 642/2023 of the District Court & Sessions Court, Kozhikode. The prosecution contends that the accused assaulted the de facto complainant (the first petitioner’s wife) on 03.04.2023 at her residence, demanding a pen drive and causing grievous hurt. Offences initially registered under Sections 341, 323, 324, 354, 354(A)(1)(i) and 506 r/w 34 IPC, with Section 326 IPC added subsequently, raising issues about the use of a weapon (shoe) and the possibility of outraging the modesty of a woman. The petitioners argue it is a matrimonial dispute, deny instrumental involvement, and rely on Praveendas v. State of Kerala and Ors (2019 (4) KLT 815) to contend that a firewood cannot be a weapon under Section 326 IPC. The respondents counter that wound certificates show grievous hurt and that the shoe used could constitute a weapon under 326 IPC, with ongoing investigation justifying denial of anticipatory bail. The court evaluates evidence, notes the premeditated sequence and motive (including recovery of a pen drive), and ultimately refuses bail, holding that release would not be in the interest of justice. The decision is a dismissal of the bail application.

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos. 3616, 3618, 3628, 3619, 3623, 3624, 3630, 3632 & 3634 of 2023

Salam v. State of Kerala & Station House Officer, Tanur Police Station

These bail applications, BA Nos. 3616, 3618, 3628, 3619, 3623, 3624, 3630, 3632 and 3634 of 2023, were heard by a single judge of the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam, presided by Justice P. V. Kunhikrishnan. The petitioners, all named Salam, aged 50, are accused in multiple theft-related offences under sections 379 and 413 read with 34 IPC, arising from crimes registered at Tanur Police Station, Malappuram district (Crime Nos. 488/2023, 494/2023, 491/2023, 485/2023, 490/2023, 492/2023, 489/2023, 493/2023 and 486/2023). They challenged the orders of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Parappanangadi, denying bail. The counsel for the petitioners argued that the accused are not the main culprits and that the petitioners are licensed scrap dealers with renewal receipts, and that the case is false. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, highlighting numerous cases against the petitioner and the risk of interference with investigations. After considering the material, the court observed that merely criminal antecedents cannot by themselves justify rejection of bail and cited Moulana Mohd. Amir Rashadi v. State of U.P. and Chidambaram P. v. Directorate of Enforcement to reinforce the presumption in favour of bail. The court allowed the applications with stringent conditions: Rs 50,000 bail bonds with two sureties, appearance before IO, no leave of India, no offence similar to the alleged crime, and potential cancellation on breach. The bail orders were granted accordingly.