The writ petition challenges Ext.P7, the fourth respondent’s order dismissing the petitioner’s appeal as time-barred in respect of the assessment year 2011-12. The petitioner had filed an income tax return for AY 2011-12 on 30.09.2011 and the assessment order was issued on 20.02.2014 (Ext.P1) with a demand notice on the same day (Ext.P2). The petitioner contends that Ext.P1 and Ext.P2 were served only on 11.03.2014, making the statutory 30-day period under Section 249(2)(b) begin from that date, i.e., the deadline would fall around 11.04.2014. The appeals were migrated to the National Faceless Appeals Centre (NFAC). Ext.P7, dated 22.03.2023, dismissed Ext.P3 as time-barred. The petitioner argues that since the appeal was filed before the faceless regime, the pre-existing calculation should apply, i.e., from service of the notice, not from the order date, and that the alleged delay (about 16 days) should be condoned; no opportunity was given to explain the delay. The court, invoking liberal, merit-based adjudication, held that the appeal should be decided on merits, granting relief under Article 226, quashing Ext.P7 and directing reconsideration of Ext.P3 on merits, with an opportunity to be heard. The proceedings pursuant to Ext.P1 were deferred pending Ext.P3 disposal.
The Kerala High Court, sitting as a single judge, hears CRL.MC No. 3752 of 2023 under Section 482 CrPC, seeking quashing of CC No.131/2019 before the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Pathanamthitta. Accused 1–4 faced preliminarily charges under Sections 341, 323, 324 read with Section 34 IPC for allegedly restraining and assaulting the de facto complainant at about 7 p.m. on 3.12.2018. The petition grounds center on an amicable settlement between the parties, supported by Annexure A2, and seek termination of proceedings to restore tranquility. The court had earlier directed investigation to verify the settlement and to assess antecedents. The Public Prosecutor raised reservations about using 482 CrPC to quash non-compoundable offences solely because of settlement, though conceded lack of other complaints. The court cites a string of Supreme Court decisions (Gian Singh; Narinder Singh; Parbatbhai Aahir; etc.) via State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan to articulate the settled framework: private disputes with civil overtones may justify quashing; however, heinous offences or special statutes (like 307 IPC or PCA) resist quashing, and the court may require evidence-based assessment. After weighing gravity, antecedents, non-serious impact, and the settled relations, the judge concludes quashing the proceedings would serve ends of justice. The petition is allowed; Annexure-A1 (Final Report) and CC No.131/2019 are quashed.
MACA Nos. 2532 and 2533 of 2008 These two Motor Accident Claims Appeals arise from a common award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Thodupuzha, in OP(MV) Nos. 781/2004 and 117/2005, linked to a single accident on 28 July 2004 in which a timber-laden lorry capsized. The claimants, including the legal heirs of Abdul Rahman, challenge the Tribunal’s exoneration of the third respondent insurer on the ground that the policy was an 'Act Only' policy. They contend that, even for gratuitous passengers in a goods vehicle, the insurer should initially compensate the claimants and then recover from the owner, following Supreme Court precedents (Saju P. Paul; Manuara Khatun) and Kerala decisions (Rijawana Jamshed Mulla). The insurer argues that liability hinges on policy terms and violations. After hearing, the High Court agrees with the appellants that complete exoneration is not legal and endorses the view that the insurer must pay the compensation at first instance with a right to recover from the owner. On quantum, the court revises the Tribunal’s figures in light of Ramachandrappa (notional income) and Pranay Sethi (future prospects, 25%, and 10% annual enhancement), applying a 14-year multiplier for the deceased aged 43. It increases transportation, funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of consortium while adjusting ‘love and affection’ awards. The orders culminate in reworked totals, with enhanced sums to be paid by the insurer and recoverable from the owner, with specified interest and time-bound transfer via NEFT/RTGS.
This Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case (CRL.MC 3730/2023) concerns a challenge under Section 482 CrPC to a Special Court for SC/ST POA Act/NDPS Act case, which cancelled bail previously granted to the petitioner, Navas, in NDPS case Crime No.11/2021 registered at the Excise Range Office, Tirur. The bail order, dated 24 May 2022, granted statutory bail with several conditions, including that the accused shall not involve in any other crime while on bail. On 13 October 2022, the petitioner was found in possession of narcotics (14.250 kgs of ganja and 850 gms of hashish oil) in a lodge, along with others, leading to Crime No.1024 of 2022 under NDPS and arms offences. The investigating officer sought cancellation of bail, arguing that the petitioner violated the bail terms by getting involved in a second NDPS crime within five months. The Special Judge held there were prima facie materials showing misuse of liberty and cancelled the bail. The petitioner contends mere registration of a subsequent crime cannot justify cancellation; reliance is placed on Godson and Renjith to argue that bail should not be cancelled for mere violation. The State counters with the Supreme Court’s P. v. Madhya Pradesh and Another, Edwin Thomas, and other precedents. The High Court distinguishes between setting aside an unjustified order and cancelling bail for misconduct, citing Gurcharan Singh, Puran, Ranjit Singh, Dolat Ram and others, CBI v. Subramani Gopalakrishnan, and Deepak Yadav. It ultimately holds that misuse of liberty justifies cancellation, but allows surrender and a fresh bail application under the NDPS Act; CrL.M.C is dismissed.
WP(C) Nos. 27817/2023 & 5277/2023 These are two writ petitions challenging the seniority and promotion rules within the Kerala Public Health Engineering Department. The petitions arise under the Kerala Public Health Engineering Subordinate Service Special Rules, 1966 and the Kerala Public Health Engineering Service Special Rules, 1960, which regulate Direct Recruitment and Promotion to the category of Assistant Engineer, and prescribe a ratio framework for diploma/certificate holders versus degree holders, including a 54% direct recruitment/open-market pool and a 6% in-service/direct recruitment from among diploma holders who later acquire a degree. Petitioners, including Sajithabai, Abdul Sathar U., Jona T. J. and Shamnadh A., contend that certain respondents (4–10) who joined as Draftsman Grade I with a Diploma and later earned a degree cannot be included in the Degree-Quota seniority list (Ext. P12) or promoted via Degree-Quota channels (Ext. P16–P18). The respondents argue that their in-service degree acquisition qualifies them for the Degree quota under the rules and that two streams (Degree and Diploma) must have respective seniority lists, with promotions governed by the applicable quotas. The court cites Chandravathi v. Saji and O.P.(KAT) 3719/2012, and notes the principle that diploma-quota entrants cannot switch to the Degree quota for further promotion. The judgment ultimately curtails the respondents’ claims by quashing Ext. P12, P16, P17, and P18 to exclude respondents 4–10 from the Degree quota seniority, and directs recasting of the promotion order (Ext. P17) accordingly, while dismissing the 27817/2023 petition.
This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC filed by five accused challenging CC No. 2068/2022 arising from Crime No. 1772/2022 registered by Thiruvalla Police for kidnapping under Sec. 363 r/w 34 IPC. The petitioners contend that the dispute between the parties has been amicably settled and they do not wish to pursue the prosecution; the victim has filed an affidavit indicating consent to quashing. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing based solely on settlement but conceded that a settlement exists. The court examined whether inherent power under Sec. 482 CrPC can be exercised to quash non‑compoundable offences, particularly when the dispute is private and entirely resolved. It relied on State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688 and the earlier decisions Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) and Narinder Singh and others v. State of Punjab (2014) to set out the governing principles: quashing is permissible where the offence is private in nature, the civil/intimate matter is settled, and the offence is not one of the serious categories or covered by special statutes; the court may examine the nature of injuries if S.307 IPC is involved and should not exercise such power during investigation. The court found the dispute private, the settlement genuine, and quashed the proceedings, thus allowing the Crl.M.C. The order reflects balancing private settlement with public interest and affirms the settled nature of the dispute.
The petitioner, Penuel Nexus Pvt. Ltd., engaged in direct marketing with GST registration, faced cancellation of its GST registration by Ext. P2 on 10.08.2022 and challenged Exts. P2 and P4 in a writ petition under Article 226. Ext. P3 appeal was filed on 07.03.2023, well beyond the period prescribed in Section 107(4) of the CGST Act, rendering it time-barred. The petitioner contends that the delay was caused by the Covid-19 pandemic and seeks relief by setting aside Exts. P2 and P4, arguing that denying the appeal infringes its right to life and fundamental right to livelihood; reliance is placed on Vinod Kumar v. High Commissioner Uttarakhand State GST and Ors. The respondents counter that Section 29(2)(c) of the CGST Act authorizes cancellation for non-filing returns and that an appeal must be filed within the time prescribed by Section 107(4), with a further one-month extension. They argue that the GST regime is a self-contained code and does not fall within the Limitation Act, which excludes condonation beyond the statutory window. The Kerala High Court notes that the law provides a strict timetable for appeals; it cites Singh Enterprises v. CCE, Punjab Fibres Ltd., and CCE & Customs v. Hongo India to reinforce that delay beyond the prescribed period cannot be condoned. Ultimately, the court dismisses the writ petition as meritless, preserving the time-bar and Exts. P2 and P4. The decision underscores the inbuilt mechanism of Section 107(4) and the exclusive nature of the CGST regime.
This judgment concerns a criminal miscellaneous case (Crl.M.C. No.2793/2021) filed by Mary KuriaKose challenging Annexure-III order of the Judicial First Class Magistrate-I, Perumbavoor, in CMP No.142(A)/21 in CC No.1570/2009. The petitioner is the de facto complainant and a relative of a workshop partner in a firm connected to the Idamalayar Project. The case arises from Crime No.822/2006, which alleged misappropriation and non-return of a bull dozer entrusted for repairs. The final report was filed, but the petitioner contends that vital documents were not seized or produced. She urged the police to conduct further investigation under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C. and asked the court to keep the proceedings in abeyance until a supplementary final report with fresh materials is filed. The Magistrate dismissed this request. On hearing, the High Court held that, although there is no rigid requirement for court permission for further investigation, the police may inform the court and proceed; it relied on the authorities in Gopalakrishnan P. alias Dileep v. State of Kerala and others, Hasanbhai Valibhai Qureshi v. State of Gujarat, Rama Chaudhary, A.S. Peter, Vinay Tyagi, and Ram Lal Narang, etc., to emphasize that seeking additional investigation is permissible to arrive at the truth. The court ultimately held the impugned order unsustainable, allowed the Crl.M.C., set aside Annexure-A3, and directed further investigation in accordance with law.
This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case under section 482 CrPC, filed by six accused in Crime No.118/2021 of Kollam East Police Station seeking quashing of the ongoing prosecution. The petition states that the parties have settled their disputes amicably and that there is no desire to continue with the proceedings. The accused are charged under IPC sections 294(b), 365, 323, 324, and 427 read with section 34, for abducting and assaulting the de facto complainant on 17 February 2021. The petition was heard after the investigating officer recorded the victim’s statement and reported that the settlement is genuine and no other impediments exist; the Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on settlement, but acknowledged absence of other transgressions. The court surveyed the law on CrPC 482, including the line of decisions culminating in State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan, which permits quashing non-compoundable offences with a civil character when disputes are resolved, while excluding heinous offences, offences under special statutes, and offences with significant societal impact. The judge emphasised that the gravitas of the offences, the injuries, and the accused’s antecedents are weighed along with the amicable settlement; the court concluded continuing the prosecution would not serve ends of justice. Accordingly, the FIR and all further proceedings against the petitioners were quashed.
MFA (F). No. 47/2017 (OA 13/2014) This Kerala High Court decision concerns MFA (F) No. 47 of 2017 (OA 13/2014) filed by the State of Kerala challenging a Tribunal for Ecologically Fragile Lands order under the Kerala Forest (Vesting and Management of Ecologically Fragile Lands) Act, 2003 (EFL Act). The Tribunal had allowed the O.A. 13/2014, setting aside Ext. B1 notification dated 04.10.2000, which declared the scheduled property as ecologically fragile land (EFL). The appellant-State, represented by the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, contends that the land lies adjacent to vested forests in Chundale, lies in the Chembra watershed, and is floristically rich with natural vegetation; Ext. B1 and related reports were prepared under the EFL Act’s framework and must be treated as conclusive on the date of notification. The respondent/applicant, M/s Vayitri Plantations Ltd., asserts the land is a long-standing coffee/cardamom plantation and not ecologically fragile; it relies on Exts. A1–A15 and witnesses to show past cultivation and limited natural vegetation. The Tribunal’s reliance on various documents (Exts. A6–A10, B8, C1–C7) to characterize the land as having natural vegetation is critically examined. The High Court reappraises S.2(b) and S.2(c) of the EFL Act, emphasizing the crucial date of notification (2.6.2000) and the standard of “principal cultivation.” It references Ammukunhi Amma and Rajagopal for the threshold test and Planters Forum for the non-obstante clause’s evidentiary weight. The Court concludes the Tribunal erred, distinguishes the relied-upon precedents, and reverses the impugned order. The O.A. is dismissed, and the parties bear their costs; the impugned tribunal judgment is set aside, effectively restoring the prior position under Ext. B1.
Shanavas and four co-accused challenge criminal proceedings in SC No. 698/2021 before the Additional Assistant Sessions Judge, North Paravur, under Sections 143, 147, 323 and 308 read with Section 149 IPC. They invoke the extraordinary powers of this Court under Section 482 CrPC seeking quashing on the ground that the disputes with the de facto complainant have been amicably settled and both sides desire to terminate the proceedings to restore peace and allow their futures. Annexure 2 contains the second respondent’s affidavit supporting the settlement. The investigating officer was directed to verify the genuineness of the settlement and to report on any prior criminal antecedents and impediments to quashing. The Public Prosecutor initially opposed quashing, arguing that Section 482 should not be used to terminate non-compoundable offences where public interest is implicated. The court, after considering submissions and records, notes the legal framework laid down in leading decisions, including Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, and emphasises that quashing is permissible in private/ civil disputes when the parties have resolved their entire dispute and where no serious public-interest offences are involved. Having weighed the nature of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and amicable settlement, the court holds that quashing serves the ends of justice and peace, and the petition is allowed with quashing of SC No. 698/2021 and related proceedings.
WA Nos. 811 and 813 of 2023 These writ appeals arise from challenges to the Kerala Water Authority’s pre-qualification/eligibility determinations for a Jal Jeevan Mission water supply project (Phase II) in Kozhikode district. The petitioner-applicants (Laxmi Civil Engineering Services Pvt. Ltd. in WA811 and Reena Engineering and Contractors Pvt. Ltd. in WA813) assail Ext.P16 pre-qualification decision and Ext.P18/Ext.P12‑P18 related tender awards, arguing that their joint-venture experience certificates meet the tender’s modern-technology WTP criteria under Ext.P2/Ext.P1 and that the bidders disqualified by the Special Committee were either ineligible or improperly evaluated. The respondents, led by the Kerala Water Authority, contend that the prequalification criteria, especially Clause 7.17.1.2.8 (past experience in modern technology WTP), require specific performance, and the JV partners’ certificates do not satisfy the “modern technology” requirement as specified. The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petitions, upholding the Special Committee’s conclusions. The Division Bench, in a common judgment, concurs that tender evaluations are essentially executive actions and that the court should refrain from substituting the employer’s decision, particularly in technical matters, unless there is arbitrariness or mala fides. It dismisses both writ appeals, recognizing the need to balance public interest, contractual certainty, and judicial restraint in contractual/tender matters.
Saleesh V, a devotee of Thirunelli Mahavishnu Temple, challenged ongoing renovation works at the temple which he claimed were eroding its archaeological value. He alleged that a 15th-century structure’s sanctum sanctorum had been reconstructed, the chuttambalam (circumambulation) roofless, and other monuments of archaeological significance being replaced, threatening the temple’s historic integrity. He sought a writ of mandamus to require the Directorate of Archaeology to constitute a committee of experts to monitor and preserve the temple’s archaeological and architectural value, and asked for interim relief to restrain renovations by the temple authorities. The court appointed Advocate Commissioner M.R. Arun Kumar to inspect and report, and issued a temporary injunction restraining the temple’s Executive Officer from proceeding with further renovation for ten days, extended subsequently. The Advocate Commissioner’s report highlighted construction progress and concerns about water ingress, with the court directing completion of the Chuttambalam roof to protect the structure and restricting other works until expert input is obtained. The petition later sought removal of toilet complexes near the sacred Papanashini stream and restoration of natural forest, and protection of Vilakkumadom and Kalpathi as monuments. The judgment cites Prayar Gopalakrishnan, M.V. Ramasubbiar, A.A. Gopalakrishnan, and Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair to emphasize trustee duties, guardianship of deities, and the parens patriae doctrine. The petition is disposed with directions to obtain expert input and for reasoned orders by the concerned authorities.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C No.3561 of 2023) before the High Court of Kerala, challenging the proceedings in C.C.No.1062/2016 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Aluva, under sections 406 and 420 read with 34 IPC. The petitioners—Naveen, Pathrose, and Nithin—are accused in the above case. The prosecution alleges that the accused, to cheat, entered into an agreement for sale and furnished a cheque that was dishonoured. The petition seeks quashing under Section 482 CrPC on the basis that the parties have amicably settled their disputes (as supported by Annexure A3) and that continuing the prosecution would be a waste of time given the settled state of affairs. The learned Public Prosecutor opposed quashing, noting that 482 should not be invoked for serious or heinous offences or for offences under special statutes, and that settlement alone may not suffice to terminate proceedings. The Kerala High Court relied on a line of Supreme Court decisions including Gian Singh; Narinder Singh; Parbatbhai Aahir; and State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan, among others, to clarify that 482 CrPC quashing is permissible where offences are private in nature and the disputes are settled, after assessing gravity, antecedents, and public interest. The court finally held that quashing the proceedings would serve ends of justice, and allowed the Crl.M.C, quashing Annexure-A2 and further proceedings.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 535 OF 2023 This is a criminal revision petition under sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. filed by the accused, Saji Kumar, challenging a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act for dishonour of a cheque. The case arises from loans taken by the accused from Travancore Rural Development Producer Company Ltd. under a Mutual Benefit Fund Scheme; after an initial settlement, he issued a cheque for Rs 1,02,610 dated 16.10.2015 which was dishonoured on presentation. The trial court convicted the accused after evidence (PW1 and Exts P1–P10) and, despite 313(1)(b) questioning, defence testimony was not adduced. The Additional District Court & Sessions Court, Pathanamthitta, affirmed the conviction and sentence on appeal. The High Court, in revision, addresses (i) whether PW1 had authority to represent the company, which it upholds, and (ii) whether the penalty under Section 138 NI Act was within statutory limits, scrutinising the trial court’s imposition of double the cheque amount as fine and subsequent interest. Interpreting Section 138, the court notes that the maximum fine may extend to twice the cheque amount and that interest on the fine beyond the statutory limit is impermissible. The court partly allows the revision: conviction remains, but the sentence is modified to imprisonment for one day until rising of the court and a fine of Rs. 2,05,220, to be paid as compensation under Cr.P.C. 357(1)(b). Three months are granted to pay the fine; execution is deferred until 20.11.2023, with a further direction to appear on 21.11.2023 to pay the fine.
MFA (FOREST) No. 229 of 2009 This Kerala High Court decision concerns MFA (Forest) No. 229 of 2009, challenging a Forest Tribunal order under the Kerala Private Forest (Vesting and Assignment) Act, 1971. The appellant sought exemption for 25 acres of land in Re.Sy.No.289/A1 of Kattuseri Village, Alathur taluk, Palakkad District, arguing that 10 acres had been surrendered under the Land Reforms Act and that the property includes cultivable land and a residential building, with cultivation evidence outside the vesting area. The Tribunal found the property to be governed by the Madras Preservation of Private Forests Act, 1949, and that the applicant failed to prove intention to cultivate on the appointed day. On remand, the Division Bench considered whether 6.62 acres cultivated near the residential building could be excluded and whether the remaining 8.38 acres could be treated as non-vested. The court relied on the Supreme Court’s Joseph v. State of Kerala (2007) to frame the standard of “intention to cultivate,” which must be inferred from conduct around the vesting date. Ext.A1 described the land as forest, with MPPF Act sanction; Ext.A2 and Ext.A3 evidence showed cultivation at various times but were largely post-vesting, and the Land Board surrender for 10 acres was not proven. Ultimately, the High Court dismissed the appeal, upholding the Tribunal’s order and directing costs to be borne by the parties."
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC arises from C.C. No.1217/2023, pending in the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Chalakudi, Thrissur, in relation to Crime No.898/2023 of Chalakudi Police Station. The petitioner, Tittu K.J., is accused of offences under Sections 325, 341 and 413 of the Kerala Health Care Act, 2012. The prosecution alleges that on 27 July 2023 the petitioner restrained the second respondent, who was employed as a lift operator at a hospital, causing a fracture to the victim’s right forearm. The petitioner contends that the parties have settled their dispute and do not wish to pursue the prosecution; the victim supports the settlement via an affidavit, and both sides advocate quashing the proceedings. The Public Prosecutor, while acknowledging the settlement, expresses reservations about quashing solely on the basis of compromise, particularly given the private nature of the matter and the potential wider public interest. The High Court, relying on the three‑judge Supreme Court decision in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688) and the accompanying principles in Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, held that the power under Section 482 CrPC can be exercised to quash non‑compoundable offences where the dispute is private, the settlement is genuine, and there is no impact on society. After examining the records and the victim’s affidavit, the court concluded that the case involves a private dispute and that settlement can be accepted. Consequently, the court allowed the Criminal Miscellaneous Case and quashed all further proceedings in C.C. No.1217/2023.
This is a Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, single-judge decision under Section 482 CrPC quashing criminal proceedings initiated in CC No. 48/2020 before the Judicial Magistrate of First Class-II, Aluva. The sole accused/petitioner, Aslam@Jerish, faced charges under Sections 326 and 506(i) IPC arising from an incident on 8 September 2019. The prosecution case alleges injury caused due to prior enmity. The petitioner contends that the disputes between him and the de facto complainant have been amicably settled, anchored by Annexure 2 affidavit; the parties are desirous of ending prosecution to restore peace and mutual coexistence. On admission, the investigating officer was directed to verify the genuineness of the settlement and to ascertain any criminal antecedents or obstacles to termination. The Public Prosecutor opposed quashing purely on the ground of settlement, while acknowledging no other transgressions by the petitioner. The court, however, cites a cadre of Supreme Court decisions to synthesize the governing principle: quashing under 482 CrPC is permissible for non-compoundable offences with a civil-private character when disputes are settled, provided the offences are not heinous or of broad societal impact; not applicable to offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act or acts by public servants; and the court may assess antecedents and conduct. Balancing gravity, injuries, and amicable settlement, the court allows the petition and quashes the Final Report and all further proceedings in CC No. 48/2020.
This is a Kerala High Court writ petition (criminal) by Jameela challenging the detention order of her son under Section 3(1) of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988. The detenu, involved in Crime No. 444 of 2022 at Anchalumoodu Police Station for alleged possession of 46.350 grams of MDMA and 9.570 grams of cannabis, was detained on this basis. The detention order (Ext.P3, dated 08.03.2023) and the Government’s confirmation order (Ext.P4) are under challenge. The petitioner’s counsel submits that the detaining authority issued the detention order without adequately considering that the detenu had already been enlarged on bail; the order does not reflect due application of mind on whether the bail conditions would deter future prejudicial activity. The State contends that the fact of bail is noted in Ext.P3, and that the issue of sufficiency of bail conditions was not expressly considered. The court finds that even though the bail status appears in the detaining order, there is no recital to show due consideration of whether the bail conditions would deter the detenu from engaging in further illicit activity, nor is due consideration of material facts evident. Relying on Sushanta Kumar Banik v. State of Tripura, the court holds that failure to consider such material vitiates the subjective satisfaction and renders the detention order illegal. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed, the detention order quashed, and Mujeeb S. is ordered to be released forthwith, subject to any other legal requirements. The Register is directed to communicate this order to the prison authorities promptly, and the judgment reiterates that the efficacy of bail conditions is a factor to be weighed by the detaining authority.
WP(C) Nos.12471 & 12454 OF 2021 These writ petitions challenge the respondents' demand to pay GST on works contracts awarded by the Kerala State Transport Project (KSTP). The petitioner, EKK Infrastructure Ltd., carried out two roadworks under the World Bank-funded Rebuild Kerala Initiative: the upgradation of Painavu–Thannikandom–Ashoka Kavala road (Km 0+000 to Km 21+000) and the BC Overlay of Adoor to Chengannoor (part of SH-1) (Km 93+400 to 117+200). The bids were invited and required to quote a price excluding GST, with the tender documents stating that the stated contract price would be inclusive of taxes and duties; the petitioner submits that the online bidding format only allowed rate entry in the basic price column and that the financial bid must exclude GST, as per LOI formats Exts P1–P3 and P4–P5. The petitioner claims GST should be payable by the ultimate beneficiary, the KSTP, and relies on a 2019 Finance circular and on precedents such as Sebastian Jose v. State of Kerala and George C.A. v. State of Kerala. The respondents contend the contract price is inclusive of all taxes and that GST was the contractor’s liability by virtue of the agreement, particularly Clause 19.1.2. The court examined the contract terms, existing judgments, and held that where bids were required to quote excluding GST, the GST element must be paid by the KSTP; the writ petitions are allowed and the impugned orders set aside, with directions to process GST adjustments within two months.