BAIL APPL. NO. 3719 OF 2023 This is the second regular bail application filed by the sole accused in Crime No. 782/2022 of Chandera police station, Kasaragod. The earlier bail petition (BA No. 896/2023) was dismissed on 15 February 2023. The police case diary records that on 7 September 2022, following a collision between vehicles, the accused’s car (KL-60-N-2871) contained 23.46 grams of MDMA inside and on his person, leading to his arrest on a charge under NDPS Act Section 22(c). The defense argues non-compliance with Section 50 NDPS, contending the recovery was a “chance recovery” after the accident and not a product of prior information; they plead for regular bail given the custody period since 7 September 2022. The prosecution opposes bail, stressing that Section 50 does not apply and highlighting the commercial quantity of contraband and the accused’s criminal antecedents. The court reinforces that bail in cases involving commercial quantity under NDPS Act.Section 37(1)(b) requires two conjunctive conditions: (i) reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty, and (ii) he will not commit an offence while on bail. It cites leading precedents confirming these standards and reiterates that the twin requirements are sine qua non. On evaluation of materials and arguments, the court finds no reasonable grounds to grant bail and consequently dismisses the application as withdrawn.
This appeal is filed by the legal heirs of late K. Janardhanan challenging the quantum of compensation awarded by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Palakkad, in OP(MV) No. 13/2014. The appellants contend that the Tribunal undervalued loss of dependency by adopting an inappropriately low notional income for a 20-year-old deceased and erred in denying other heads of compensation. Counsel for the appellants argued that, following Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd., the notional income should be standardized to Rs.9,000 with 40% future prospects, yielding Rs.12,600 as the baseline income; this would make the loss of dependency Rs.13,60,800. They also claimed entitlement to compensation for loss of consortium and loss of estate for the parents, while objecting to amounts awarded for loss of love and affection and for pain and suffering. The insurer contends the Tribunal’s award is just and fair, arguing that non-pecuniary heads should be limited in light of Pranay Sethi and that funeral expenses should be capped. The High Court finds merit in the submissions, noting the Tribunal’s underestimation of income and misapplication of Pranay Sethi guidelines. It standardizes income to Rs.12,600 and enhances the loss of dependency to Rs.13,60,800, awards Rs.80,000 for loss of consortium, Rs.15,000 for loss of estate, and deletes loss of love and affection and pain and suffering, while reducing funeral expenses to Rs.15,000. The enhanced amount is to be paid by the insurer with 9% interest from the filing date, excluding 794 days for delay, with proportionate costs.
This petition (OP(C) No.1439 of 2015) challenges Ext P4, the order in IA No.510/2015 in OS No.407/2011 before the Sub Court, Neyyattinkara. The plaintiff-petitioner alleges that crucial pleadings were omitted in the plaint and seeks leave to amend via Ext P3. The respondents oppose, contending that the application was filed after trial had commenced. The court below dismissed Ext P3 on the ground that it was filed post–commencement of trial. The High Court notes that the suit was only listed for trial and that, in principle, amendments should be liberally permitted, especially when omissions occurred in pleadings and where the same advocate office represented both sides, potentially depriving the petitioner of a full opportunity to plead. Relying on Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Sanjeev Building (P) Ltd (2022) SCC Online SC 1128, the court holds that Ext P3 is not disqualified under the usual restraints on amendments. The judge grants a lenient view, allows the original petition, sets aside Ext P4, allows Ext P3, and directs amendment of the plaint within time. Respondents may file an additional written statement to the amended plaint within one month, and OS 407/2011 should be disposed of expeditiously under Article 227. SD/-, 1.3.2023.
BAIL APPL. NO. 3596 OF 2023 This is a Kerala High Court bail application under section 438 Cr.P.C. heard by Justice P. V. Kunhikrishnan on 9 May 2023 in respect of Crime No. 473/2023 of Thalayolapparambu Police Station, Kottayam District. The petitioners, Bhuvaneswaran, Akhil and Saneesh, are accused along with others of offences including 341 (wrongful restraint), 294(b) (obscene acts), 323 (voluntary hurt), 324 (voluntary causing hurt by dangerous weapon), 354 (outraging modesty), 506 (criminal intimidation), and various mischief offences under sections 142, 144, and 147 read with 149 IPC. The prosecution asserts that the petitioners and other accused formed an unlawful assembly and attacked the de facto complainant; a counter case exists with Annexure A2 FIR. The petitioners’ counsel contends that even if the entire case is accepted, no offence under section 354 IPC is proved, and the counter case undermines the credibility of the allegations; the Public Prosecutor opposes bail. The court notes this is a case and counter-case, and custodial interrogation may not be necessary. Relying on the principle that bail is the rule and jail the exception, the court permits bail with stringent conditions: appearance before the IO within ten days, bond of Rs 50,000 with two sureties, continuous cooperation, prohibition on leaving India without permission, avoidance of similar offences, and weekly appearances on Mondays until final report. The order underlines the need to avoid pre-judging entries under 354 IPC and to safeguard a fair trial.
This Kerala High Court judgment (K. Babu, J.) on 4 August 2023 in Crl.M.C. No. 3540 of 2023 involves Salini V. Sasi, the petitioner, challenging an order/judgment in SC 140/2022 of the Fast Track Special Court, Chengannur. Accused No.5 in Crime No.1167/2019 of Kayamkulam Police Station, the petitioner faced various IPC offences (Sections 366, 354, 376 and 34) allegedly committed by multiple accused in 2018–2019. The prosecution alleged sexual offences against the victim by the husband (accused No.1) and others, with the trial of several co-accused (accused Nos.1, 3, 4, 6, 7) resulting in acquittals. The trial record showed the victim’s statements were said to be given under compulsion, and the Forensic report did not reveal semen or spermatozoa, while other witnesses lacked direct knowledge. The court relied on Moosa v. Sub Inspector of Police (2006 (1) KLT 552) and Manik Thaneja v. State of Karnataka (2015) 7 SCC 423 to hold that where the substratum of the case is lost, and mens rea is absent, continuing the prosecution would amount to abuse of process of law and is not warranted. The High Court quashed the SC No.140/2022 proceedings against the petitioner, allowing the Crl.M.C. petition.
Aravind C v. The State of Kerala and Others is a writ petition challenging the government-aided admission process for B.Sc. (Hons.) Agriculture at Kerala Agricultural University. The petitioner contends that Ext. P10, a 3.09.2015 Government Order, reserved one seat in the course for a student who had won state-level agriculture awards, and that the reservation’s scope is limited to such awardees. He argues that the fifth respondent, aged about 32 with multiple degrees, cannot be deemed a “student” eligible for the reserved seat, and that he was selected in preference to the petitioner in contravention of the reservation policy. The respondents maintain that Exts. P10 and P11 do not restrict the reservation to school students with awards, and that the selection was made by an expert committee; the fifth respondent scored higher on the entrance examination, justifying the selection. The court notes Tajvir Sing Sodhi v. State of Jammu and Kashmir (2023) for the principle that where selection involves a high degree of expertise, courts should not substitute their judgment for that of the selection body. After hearing, the judge held that Ext. P10 and P11 do not conclusively show the reservation was limited to school awardees, that the fifth respondent was not disqualified from admission under the reservation, and that his higher marks warranted the outcome; accordingly, the writ petition was dismissed.
This writ petition challenges the supplementary examinations results for the Bachelor of Commerce course conducted by the University of Calicut’s School of Distance Education. The petitioner, Soorya R Chandran, who completed the B.Com in 2018-21, had a backlog of four papers in the fifth semester and appeared for supplementary examinations in November 2021. In the paper Fundamentals of Investments, she initially scored 38 marks—two marks short of the passing threshold of 40. She sought revaluation on 29.06.2022, and obtained copies of the question paper, answers, and the answer key. On comparison, two MCQ questions (Nos. 2 and 5) were found to have been erroneously valued; the correct answers per the key were MCX stock exchange and None of these, respectively. If those questions were revalued, the internal marks would become 11, altering the total marks to 40 (11 + 29). The respondents contended that even after revaluation, total marks would still not yield a passing score when internal Part I (9) and external (26) are combined, totaling 35, or 37 with the corrected 11 marks for questions 2 and 5; thus the candidate could not pass. The petitioner relied on a Supreme Court decision (Ran Vijay Singh v State of U.P.) holding that courts may examine the answer key and presume its correctness in certain contexts. The Kerala High Court allowed the writ petition, holding that the petitioner passed with 40 marks on revaluation and declared the subject passed.
This Motor Accidents Claims Appeal challenges a Tribunal award in OP(MV) No.1338/2012 arising from a 2012 accident in which Shiji, riding pillion on a motorcycle, died after a collision with another vehicle. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Manjeri, awarded roughly Rs. 20.15 lakh as compensation to the claimants, while directing the Insurance Company to recover this amount from the fifth respondent for driving without a valid licence. The insurer contends the Tribunal’s award is excessive in several heads: Love and Affection, Loss of Consortium, Funeral Expenses, and Loss of Estate. It also questions the calculation under Loss of Dependency, arguing that notional income and the degree of personal expense deduction were incorrect. The respondents concede that no amount should be granted for Love and Affection but maintain that Loss of Consortium should be higher (Rs. 1.6 lakh per claimant) and that Funeral Expenses and Loss of Estate should be capped in line with Pranay Sethi (SC), i.e., Rs. 15,000 each. The court relies on Ramachandrappa and Anil Kumar v. N.K. Ayyappa to determine a just notional income (Rs. 8,500 for 2012) and adopts Pranay Sethi caps, ultimately recalculating the award. The outcome is a partial allowance of the appeal with a revised total compensation of Rs.19,61,814, payable by the insurer, with liberty to recover from the fifth respondent; other heads remain as awarded.
WP(C) Nos.23856 & 15042 of 2023 The petitioners, Mathews Kuruvilla and Stephen Kuruvilla, challenge the rejection of their Form-5 application under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet Land Act, 2008 (Section 13) as reflected in Ext.P6. They own 5.20 acres in Survey No.119/2 in Kurichithanam Village. They contend the land was converted before 2008 and has neither paddy cultivation nor potential for cultivation for decades; they also note that nearby lands have been removed from the data bank, implying a misapplication of the Act. The court notes that Ext.P6 solely relies on pendency of Section 13 proceedings and a revision petition—grounds that, per this Court’s precedents (Barathan Ramanathan; others), cannot bar an application under Rule 4(d) of the Act. The judgment cites Barathan Ramanathan (2022) and a line of previous decisions (Salim C.K., Lalu P.S., Joy, Arthasasthra Ventures) to stress that the data bank’s relevance, the land’s character on 12.08.2008, and the availability of scientific data (KSRSEC) must be considered when evaluating Form-5 applications. The court sets aside Ext.P6 and directs the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) to reconsider the Form-5 application within a defined timeline after obtaining the KSRSEC report, with site inspection and Rule 4(4f) factors in mind. For WP(C) No.15042 of 2023, the Government is directed to proceed with the revision based on the RDO’s decision, staying all coercive actions until resolution, and maintaining status quo. The petitions are disposed of accordingly.
This appeal (MACA No. 3296 of 2014) challenges a Tribunal award under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, for injuries sustained by the petitioner in a road accident on Paradise Road, Kochi, in October 2007. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, held that the car driver (2nd respondent) was rash and negligent and that the petitioner was entitled to compensation from the owner, driver and insurer jointly and severally. It fixed compensation at Rs 2,99,247, and ordered the 3rd respondent insurer to discharge the liability after deducting 20% for alleged negligence by the claimant for driving the motorcycle without a licence. The petitioner, who had suffered fractures and other injuries, contended that the Tribunal’s assessment was inadequate and that there was no evidence of his rash riding. The Tribunal also directed that the 3rd respondent pay the compensation with 9% interest. The High Court, in a detailed analysis of evidence, revised the income, corrected the disability multiplier from 18 to 17, and changed the appropriate parameters to compute loss of earnings and disability. It held that the claimant was not reckless in riding and, consequently, set aside the 20% deduction, directing the 3rd respondent to pay the full amount of compensation plus interest and costs. It also remitted procedure with regard to disbursal consistent with the Court’s circular. A 2024 RP correction subsequently adjusted the amounts.
This Regular Second Appeal arises from a suit for permanent injunction filed by the respondent against the appellants/defendants (M. Abdul Kareem and others) restraining trespass into the plaint schedule room XIV/701 in Kottayam Municipality. The plaintiff purchased the property, issued a notice for rent arrears, and the first defendant surrendered the building after paying arrears on 30.07.1997. On 30.05.1998, the defendants allegedly trespassed into the room and a suit for injunction was filed. The defendants counterclaimed for recovery of possession on the strength of tenancy rights. The trial court held that though the plaintiff was in possession, possession was procured without the defendants’ consent and rejected the injunction prayer; it also found no landlord–tenant relationship and dismissed the counterclaim for possession, requiring that a declaration of tenancy be established before recovery. The first appellate court affirmed. The High Court, however, allowed the counterclaim, ruling that tenancy rights subsist despite forcible dispossession and that destruction of the building does not extinguish tenancy where the land remains, citing various precedents on the nature of tenancy and site as part of the lease. The court set aside the concurrent judgments, directing the plaintiff to pay Rs.10,00,000 as compensation for depriving the appellants of the premises over the years, with interest at 5.5% if unpaid, and costs to the appellants.
RP Nos. 449 of 2022 and 450 of 2022 This is a consolidated review petition matter before the Kerala High Court arising from two writ petitions (W.P.(C) Nos.4821/2022 and 3646/2022) which had challenged a common judgment dated 02.03.2022. The writ petitions concerned education loan denial by the State Bank of India on the ground that the co-borrowers had unsatisfactory CIBIL scores. The petitioners argued that the earlier decision relied on Pranav S.R. v. The Branch Manager, SBI (2020 KHC 4695), which held that unsatisfactory credit scores of parents cannot be a ground to deny education loans and that repayment capacity after education should govern the loan. They urged that the RBI circulars, the Credit Information Companies Act, and related rules/regulations were not properly considered, and that the Act does not regulate bank lending policies. The Bank respondents contended that the CIC Act and RBI guidelines, along with the Priority Sector Lending Directions, 2020, govern credit information and lending policies; they argued that the earlier pronouncement should not bind education loans in the face of these statutory instruments. After hearing both sides, the Court reaffirmed Pranav S.R.’s principle to some extent but ultimately found no error in the common judgment and dismissed the review petitions, keeping the education loan denials aligned with the regulatory framework and case facts.
Cont.Case(C)No.620 of 2020 Contempt of Court Case (Civil) No. 620 of 2020 in the Kerala High Court arises from alleged willful disobedience of the directions contained in Annexure A1 judgment dated 12.10.2018 in W.P.(C) No. 33245/2016 and connected matters. The petitioners (Petitioners 45, 48 and 71 in the 2016 writ petition) filed this contempt case under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, alleging that the Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) failed to implement the directions of the 2018 judgment and subsequent apex court orders governing pension-related schemes. The Supreme Court’s judgments in Civil Appeal Nos. 8143-44 of 2022 and connected matters, culminating in 2022 (7) KHC 12 (AIR 2022 SC 5634), held that the G.S.R. 609(E) notification of 22 August 2014 is legal and valid, and provided directions regarding the amended pension scheme, option rights under paragraphs 11(3) and 11(4) of the 1995 scheme, and extension of time for exercising options. In view of those decisions, the Kerala High Court held that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO. The court closed the Contempt Case, clarifying that EPFO may reconsider entitlement in accordance with law in light of the apex court judgment. The judgment was delivered by a Division Bench comprising Anil K. Narendran, J. and Sophy Thomas, J."
Ratheesh, the petitioner-accused in Crime No. 634/2023 of Kundara Police Station, moved a petition under Section 482 CrPC seeking quashing of the ongoing prosecution for offences under Sections 294(b), 324 and 308 IPC. The High Court of Kerala heard the matter on 7 June 2023. The prosecution alleges that on 9 April 2023, at around 10 p.m., the accused assaulted the defacto complainant with an iron pipe and a shovel. The petitioner contends that the parties have amicably settled their disputes, supported by Annexure A2, and that there is no desire to continue the prosecution. The investigating officer was directed to verify the settlement and to report on any criminal antecedents or impediments to termination. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing a case with serious offences but stated that there were no other complaints against the petitioner and that the respondents themselves stated they harbor no enduring grievances. Relying on a lineage of Supreme Court decisions, the court held that under Section 482 CrPC, quashing is permissible in non‑compoundable offences with predominantly civil character when disputes are settled between private parties, with exceptions for heinous or societal crimes. After weighing the gravity of the offences and the absence of ongoing public interest, the court concluded that quashing would advance the ends of justice, and allowed the petition, quashing the FIR and all further proceedings.
CRL.R.P.No.3079 of 2006 & CRL.R.P.No.242 of 2007 This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision in which Crl.R.P. No.3079 of 2006 and Crl.R.P. No.242 of 2007 were heard together. The petitioners, four accused in the trial court for offences under IPC Sections 447, 323, 324 and 326 read with Section 34, were convicted by the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Thodupuzha, and the Sessions Court modified the sentence. The petitions seek to compounding the offences under Section 320(8) Cr.P.C. read with Section 482 Cr.P.C., claiming amicable settlements with the co-accused/ complainants and asserting no grievance. The petition discusses the non-compoundable nature of Section 326 IPC but relies on the Supreme Court dictum in Ramgopal & Anr. v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2021 KHC 6543) that inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. read with Section 320 Cr.P.C. may be used in appropriate cases to terminate criminal proceedings when there is a voluntary, genuine settlement and public interest supports ending the prosecution. On 27 November 2023, the High Court allowed the applications, compounding the offences and acquitting the petitioners under 320(8) Cr.P.C. read with 482 Cr.P.C. The revisions were disposed of: the 3079/2006 petition disposed with acquittal; the 242/2007 petition dismissed as not pressed.
WA Nos. 632/2022, 634/2022, 684/2022 These writ appeals arise from a disciplinary dispute between Jagadeesh C.S. (workman) and the Karannur Service Co-Operative Bank before the Labour Court, Kozhikode. The bank terminated the workman after a charge memo issued by a disciplinary subcommittee. The Labour Court set aside the enquiry report and the dismissal, relying on the Division Bench’s decision in Kodenchery Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Joshy Varghese (2020) (4) KLT 129. The workman challenged the award, arguing that subsequent binding authority clarifies the legality of such charge memos and that the entire matter must be reconsidered on merits. The employer-bank, defending the Labour Court’s conclusions, contends the disciplinary process and penalty were proper. The Court notes a Full Bench decision in Mattannur Cooperative Rural Bank Ltd. v. Co-operative Arbitration Court ILR 2023 (3) Kerala 863, which held that a charge memo issued by the disciplinary subcommittee is legal and valid, thereby undermining the earlier Kodenchery ruling. Consequently, the High Court remands the matter to the Labour Court for merits-based reconsideration in light of the Full Bench decision, with directions to account for interim salary payments and to conclude the proceedings promptly. The outcome harmonizes conflicting precedents and redirects the inquiry to a fresh merits assessment.
This Kerala High Court judgment, rendered by Justice Raja Vijayaraghavan V, concerns the petitioner Sukesh B., an accused in CC No.878/2022 of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Hosdurg, for offences under IPC sections 451, 324, and 506(i). The criminal petition under section 482 CrPC seeks quashing of the ongoing proceedings on the ground that the parties have amicably settled their civil disputes and no longer desire to pursue the prosecution. The State, represented by the Public Prosecutor, initially expressed reservations but acknowledged the absence of enduring grievances from the defacto complainant. The court directed the investigating officer to verify the authenticity of the settlement and assess whether the petitioner has any prior criminal antecedents or impediments to termination. Relying on a cluster of Supreme Court authorities, including Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, the High Court held that the power under section 482 CrPC to quash non‑compoundable offences is permissible when the offences have a civil/private character, the settlement is genuine, and the prosecution does not substantially affect public order. The court also noted that offences such as 307 IPC or acts under the Arms Act are generally unsuitable for quashing under settlement. After weighing the gravity of the offences, injuries caused, antecedents, and the amicable settlement, the court concluded that quashing would not harm society but would promote ends of justice. Consequently, the petition was allowed and CC No.878/2022 and related proceedings were quashed.
RSA Nos. 1122/2006, 1172/2006, 35/2007, 40/2007, 262/2007 The judgment consolidates multiple Regular Second Appeals arising from concurrent suits filed by Viswanathan Nadar and family challenging boundary demarcations, partition and declarations on A, B, C schedule properties originally belonging to Kochukunjan Nadar and his heirs. The trial court decreed in O.S.654/1989 (leading case) and O.S.361/1992; the First Appellate Court affirmed. The appellants (various members of the Kochukunjan Nadar lineage and others) challenge Ext.A1, a settlement deed dated 16.12.1987, and related transactions, including a later cancellation deed Ext.A19, sought to fix boundary and obtain declaration of title. The central legal questions revolve around capacity to transfer by minors, validity of gifts or settlements, and the effect of resurvey under the Kerala Survey and Boundaries Act, 1961 (and amendments) on existing rights. The respondents contend Ext.A1 was valid and binding, and that the Partition/Boundary relief follows from the settled title, with the Survey Act provisions allowing correction by court. The High Court, after considering cross-appeals, holds that Ext.A1 was valid, the cancellation lacks effect, and the re-survey decisions can be challenged only within the Act’s framework, but in this case the appeals are devoid of merit and dismissed without costs.
Murukayya, the revision petitioner, was convicted in S.C. No. 541/2005 by the Assistant Sessions Court, Kattappana, and the conviction was affirmed on appeal, for offences under Sections 8(1), 8(2) and 55(g) of the Kerala Abkari Act, relating to possession of arrack and distillation implements. The High Court of Kerala, in a criminal revision, heard the matter on 6 October 2023. The prosecution case rests on seizure of 1.5 litres of arrack and 35 litres of wash with distillation equipment on 5 September 2003. The revision challenges alleged non-compliance with statutory formalities and chain-of-custody issues: unexplained delay in producing contraband before the court (production only on 12.09.2003), absence of seals on MO2 and MO3 (except MO1), and mahazar lapses. Counsel for the petitioner pointed to hostile independent witnesses and questioned the credibility of the seized material in view of missing seals and the late production. The court surveys authorities emphasizing strict compliance with Abkari Act formalities (Baburaj; Sathi; Sumathy; Sasidharan; Vijayan), the importance of proper safe custody (Ramachandran) and chain-of-custody (Vijayan; Vijay Pandey), and the limitation of relying on lab reports without proper link to seizure. The High Court ultimately holds that the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt and allows the revision, acquitting the petitioner and cancelling bail.
Venugopalan, a driver employed by Cheeni Packaging, sustained injuries in an accident on 18 September 2011 while the vehicle was being towed for repairs. He claimed lumpsum compensation for functional disability and medical reimbursement under the Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923 before the Employees’ Compensation Commissioner (Industrial Tribunal), Thrissur (ECC 1198/2016). The Commissioner concluded that the applicant had not suffered occupational disability and thus did not award compensation for loss of earning, but did award Rs 50,084 toward medical reimbursement after evaluating medical bills and the XI Medical Board Report. The applicant challenged the non‑disbursement of interest on the medical reimbursement, invoking Section 4A, which prescribes interest at 12% per annum for default in payment. The appellant argued that, since the accident occurred in 2011 and the reimbursement was quantified in the 2016 petition, interest should accrue from the date of the accident. He relied on Gineesh M.G. v. K.C. Ninan and Ors. (2020 KHC 139) and Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd v. Siby George (2012 KHC 4408). The respondents contended that Section 4(2A) covers actual medical expenditure and that no interest accrues thereon; any interest under 4A would commence from the date of the claim petition, not from the accident. The High Court allowed the appeal in part, holding that Rs.50,084 shall carry interest at 12% from the date of petition until realization, and modified the Commissioner's order accordingly.