This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 3647 of 2023) filed under Section 482 CrPC before the Kerala High Court by five accused persons (Irshad, Dilshan, Sharafudheen V.P., Ashik, Sanil) challenging the continuation of Crime No. 255 of 2023 registered at Guruvayur Police Station, Thrissur. The petition contends that the parties have resolved their dispute amicably, as evidenced by affidavits from respondents, and seeks quashing of the further proceedings and the FIR to restore peace and enable the parties to move forward. The prosecution had alleged offences under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 325 and 308 in conjunction with Section 149 IPC, arising from an incident on 29.03.2023 where the petitioners allegedly formed an unlawful assembly and assaulted the complainants causing injuries. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but acknowledged no other serious crimes against the petitioners. The Court relied on Supreme Court authorities (State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan; Gian Singh v. State of Punjab; Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab) that Section 482 can quash non‑compoundable offences with a civil character, especially when disputes are settled and there is no ongoing threat to public interest. The Court concluded that quashing would serve ends of justice and record the settlement, quashing the FIR and related proceedings against the petitioners.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 523 OF 2023 This is a criminal revision petition under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (DV Act) filed by the revision petitioners, Laila Beevi and Afirn Raji (represented by Laila Beevi), challenging an order of protection and a subsequent alteration of the residence order. The trial court granted a protection order under Section 12 of the DV Act permitting the revision petitioners to reside in a shared household. Respondents 1 and 2 sought to alter this arrangement by moving the petitioners to an alternate accommodation near Pangode junction, arguing that the shared residence was unsafe and unsuitable, and that the new rented house was more convenient. The trial court and the first appellate court upheld the alteration, finding the alternate accommodation to be suitable. The revision petitioners contended that the rented house is not fit for habitation and lacks facilities enjoyed in the shared household, and that the courts below failed to assess suitability. The High Court upheld the vires of the orders, indicating that the DV Act does not grant an indefeasible right to reside in a shared household and that a right to residence is subject to statutory procedure and judicial review. Citing Navneet Arora and Satish Chander Ahuja, the court reaffirmed that revisional jurisdiction is not a substitute for appeal. The petition is dismissed for lack of merit, with the court emphasizing that the revisional power should not reweigh evidence absent perverse or untenable findings.
This division bench of the High Court of Kerala deals with Suo Motu proceedings under DBP No. 9 of 2022 concerning the Travancore Devaswom Board’s management of Pamba Manappuram near Sabarimala. The Special Commissioner’s report, following a previous DBP, notes that Pamba Manappuram and adjacent river areas have shifted post-2018 floods, with the bed elevated by silt and pebbles, rendering it a vital transit point for pilgrims who perform ritual bathing, ablutions and balitharpanam. The Court had already directed removal of temporary structures erected by Shri Nandakishore Bajoria Charitable Trust for the Ramakatha program (Feb 2022) and held that permissions granted by the Board for such constructions were illegal. The pivotal question is whether Pamba Manappuram, leased for pilgrim facilities, may be used to erect large temporary structures, VIP tents, katha pandals or similar facilities for programmes. The Court analyzes the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 (Sections 15, 15A, 16, 31, and others), the Board’s statutory duty to maintain pilgrim facilities, and related safety and ecological considerations. It cites Gopalakrishnan, Mohanan Nair, Ajay Tharayil and others to underscore guardianship of temple properties, parens patriae and limits on development within temple lands, ultimately disposing of the DBP with directions restricting such constructions and regulating helipad use.
WP(C) NO. 12092 OF 2022; WP(C) NO. 7895 OF 2022; WP(C) NO. 10672 OF 2022 Geetha Kumar and others v. State Farming Corporation Ltd. and others, along with petitions by C. Thankachan and P.V. Varghese, challenge notices demanding refund of excess EPF (Employees Provident Fund) contributions paid by their employer, the State Farming Corporation of Kerala. The petitions trace the chronology of EPF contributions: initially 6.25% of wages (basic pay plus dearness allowance), raised progressively to 8%, then 10%, and eventually to 12%, with a government ceiling on the employer’s contribution being 12% of Rs.15,000 (basic + DA) with effect from 1 July 2014, as clarified by subsequent orders. The retirees contend that the earlier ceiling modification and the notices directing refunds were not properly issued, and that any recovery must follow due process. The Court notes that a previous Division Bench had considered the upper ceiling issue and, after boards’ reconsideration, notices were issued to the petitioners. The petitioners argue the notices amount to orders and sought relief from the Court. The judgment disposes of the three petitions by directing the State Farming Corporation to furnish computation details, grant a hearing, permit rebuttal, and keep the demand in abeyance until four months from receipt of a certified copy, ensuring fairness and compliance with law before any recovery is effected.
MACA Nos. 1146 & 2534 of 2009 These are two motor-accident claims appeals arising from a 10.10.2004 collision near Angamaly Junction between a KSRTC bus and a motorcycle ridden by Baby K.I. and pillion Joy, resulting in Joy's death and Baby K.I.'s injuries. The MACT at Perumbavoor partly allowed the claims, deducting 20% for contributory negligence against the motorcycle rider in OP(MV)457/2005 and directing recovery of 80% from KSRTC in OP(MV)2123/2004. The claimants challenged both the adequacy of compensation and the distribution of liability. The Kerala High Court found the contributory negligence determination unsustainable, noting that police final report and charge-sheet evidence should not be contradicted merely by scene mahazar and AMVI reports. It relied on New India Assurance Co. v Pazhaniammal to treat the charge-sheet as prima facie evidence of negligence but permitted re-evaluation if the charge-sheet was contested. The court also invoked Ramchandrappa to fix the notional income (Rs.3,500/month for Baby, Rs.4,500 for the deceased Joy) and applied 25% future prospects and appropriate multipliers to compute enhanced compensation. It concluded the bus driver alone caused the accident, with KSRTC vicariously liable, and directed deposit of enhanced sums: Rs.42,240 for Baby K.I.’s heirs and Rs.6,18,492 in Joy’s heirs' favor, within two months, with 7% interest, while dismissing any costs. The appeals are allowed to the extent indicated.
The petition challenges Ext.P20 withdrawal of recognition of the 1st petitioner’s B.Ed college by the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) and seeks directions to approve the change of management in favor of the 3rd petitioner. The background involves post-2014 NCTE Regulations: revised provisional recognition for a two-year B.Ed course with an annual intake of 50 students for the 2015-2016 session, with the college affiliated to the University of Calicut. The 3rd petitioner, a charitable trust, assumed management in 2018 following the death of a key member and financial difficulties, and purchased land with building for the college; NOCs/permissions were obtained from the Kerala Government Higher Education Department and the Central Hindi Directorate (P6/P6(a), P7). The 3rd petitioner filed Ext.P8 for approval of change of management; show cause notices (Exts.P9-P11) followed, and Ext.P12. The NCTE relied on Ext.P12, an internal clarification stating there is no regulation about change in management and that it would amount to commercialization, to withdraw recognition (Ext.P13). The petitioners challenged Ext.P12 and Ext.P20; the Appellate Authority’s Ext.P16 order remitted the matter for reconsideration, and the High Court ultimately held Ext.P12 lacks statutory basis, quashed Ext.P20, and directed reconsideration in accordance with law with a hearing within three months. The petition was allowed.
This High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, hears MACA No. 2960 of 2009, an appeal against an order of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakkuda, under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The appellants are the mother and brothers of Martin, the deceased, who died after sustaining injuries in a motor-vehicle accident on 31 October 2003; the accident involved an unidentified lorry hitting the motorcycle, which then collided with a second vehicle, MH 13 G 2521, owned by the 1st respondent and insured by the 3rd respondent. The Tribunal held the 4th respondent (the motorcycle’s owner) liable, exonerating the 1st-3rd respondents and the 5th respondent (insurer of the motorcycle) under an Act-only policy. The appellants challenged the exoneration of the lorry insured by the 3rd respondent and contended that, under Section 163A, liability extends to all vehicles involved in the accident if it arises out of the use of a motor vehicle. They relied on Exts. A1 (FIR) and A3 (final report), which described the chain of events and the involvement of the MH 13 G 2521 lorry. The High Court held that negligence is not required under 163A; it is enough that the accident arose out of the use of a motor vehicle, and thus all involved vehicles can be held liable. It reversed the Tribunal’s exoneration, ordering that the 3rd respondent pay, and revising the quantum to Rs.4,46,166. The judgment also discusses the rider’s liability under Ningamma and fixes the quantum in light of Ramachandrappa’s guidance on income, the Second Schedule, and the head of damages, directing deposit within three months.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No.3022 of 2022) challenges an order dated 27.06.2016 under Section 107 Cr.P.C. issued by the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Thalassery, directing the petitioner to show cause why he should not execute a bond to keep the peace for one year with two sureties. The impugned order invokes Section 107 after receiving information that the petitioner was likely to disturb public tranquillity, citing Crime Nos. 159 of 2010 and 341/506 of 2022. The petitioner’s counsel contends that the 2010 crime resulted in an acquittal on 27.06.2016 (Annexure A2) and that the 2022 offence is minor; there is no material establishing imminent danger or likely breach of the peace. The counsel argues that Section 107 proceedings require cogent material and compliance with Section 111 (conducted in writing, with grounds recorded), failing which the order is unsustainable and amounts to an abuse of power. The state, represented by the Public Prosecutor, counters that the DySP’s report shows a real threat to public peace and that Section 107 is preventive, not punitive. The court emphasizes that Section 107 proceedings must be grounded in credible information and proper grounds, citing Madhu Limaye and other authorities, and ultimately quashes the Annexure-1 order and all further proceedings, allowing the petition.
This is a Criminal Misc. Case (CRL.MC 3689/2023) decided by the Kerala High Court under Section 482 CrPC. Accused Nos. 1–5 (Sreejesh, Subilal, Vichu, Manikandan, and Ayyappan) faced offences under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 149, 294(b), 323, 324, 341, and 308 in SC No. 947/2018 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Pathanamthitta, arising from Crime No. 2832/2016 of Adoor Police Station. The prosecution alleged they formed an unlawful assembly and attacked the injured respondents 2–4 at night, causing injuries. The petition contends that the disputes between the parties have been amicably settled, supported by affidavits of respondents 2–4 (Annexures A3–A5), and urges termination of the proceedings so the parties can move forward in peace. The Public Prosecutor raised reservations about quashing non-compoundable offences, but conceded no other antecedents against petitioners. The Court surveys binding precedents (notably Laxmi Narayan, Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, Parbatbhai Aahir, among others) to delineate the scope of its inherent power under Section 482 CrPC, emphasizing that quashing is permissible where the offence is predominantly civil in character and the disputes are fully settled, while grave, heinous, or public-interest offences (e.g., murder, rape, dacoity; offences under special statutes) are not quashed unless justified by the evidence and circumstances. On balancing gravity, injury, antecedents, and the settled relationship, the Court quashes the proceedings, holding that continuing would not serve ends of justice. The petition is allowed; Annexure A2 Final Report in SC No. 947/2018 and all further proceedings are quashed.
Petitioner K.K. Velayudhan, a long-serving employee from Palakkad, belongs to the Thandan community, a Scheduled Caste in Kerala's pre-2007 framework. He challenged Exts P3, P4, P5, P6, P8, P12, P13 and P15, which denied his daughter's caste status and culminated in adverse career consequences. The petition traces a complex history of caste verification: certificates issued, contested, revised, and eventually nullified after the 2007 amendment to the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order. The Petitioner contends that Ezhuvas and Thiyyas known as Thandan in Cochin/Malabar were treated as SC until 30 August 2007, and that pre-amendment benefits could not be withdrawn retroactively, citing Pattika Jathi’s case, Palghat Jilla case, Milind, Sandeep Parate, Kavita Solunke, and Mahanudevan’s case, and R. Unnikrishnan’s interpretation of the 2007 amendment. The judgment assesses the 1996 Act regulating community certificates and the 2010 Government order in light of the amendment. It holds that while post-amendment rights under the SC Order may be limited, those who were beneficiaries before the amendment must be protected, and legitimate promotions or other benefits granted up to that date remain valid. The court sets aside Ext P12 and Ext P13, directs reconsideration consistent with Unnikrishnan, Kocha T., and the Milind principle, and clarifies that pre-2007 entitlements remain, with post-amendment rights not extending to Thandan status. The decision directs payment of all due benefits within three months and provides that costs shall be borne by the parties.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The petition, CRL.MC No. 3842 of 2023, seeks to quash CC No. 548 of 2021 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class-VIII, Ernakulam, wherein three accused are charged under Sections 341, 323, 324 and 506 read with Section 34 IPC for restraining and assaulting a de facto complainant on 21 February 2021. The prosecution alleges that the petitioners, in furtherance of their common intention, beat the complainant with a steel bangle causing injuries. The petition asserts that the dispute has been amicably settled; Annexure A3 contains a notarized affidavit by the second respondent substantiating the settlement. The matter had earlier been directed to verify the settlement, check for antecedents, and ascertain impediments to termination. The Public Prosecutor initially voiced reservations about quashing solely on settlement, while noting that no other serious crimes appear against the petitioners and that the de facto complainant states there are no lasting grievances. The court examines authorities such as State of MP v Laxmi Narayan and other decisions, holding that when the offence is private and inter-party disputes are resolved, the High Court may exercise its inherent power under Section 482 to quash non-compoundable offences in the larger public interest; here, the circumstances justify quashing. The petition is allowed; final report and further proceedings are quashed.
CRL.M.C. No. 2555 of 2022 This collection of Criminal Miscellaneous Cases before the Kerala High Court, heard by a single Judge, arises under Section 482 CrPC challenging an Annexure-A1 complaint filed by South Indian Bank Ltd. under the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007 (PSS Act). The petitioners — RCI Industries & Technologies Ltd., its Managing Director Rajeev Gupta, and its Director Mamta Gupta — are represented by senior counsel Nandagopal S. Kurup, Abhiram T.K., and S. Sreekumar. The respondents include the State of Kerala, represented by the Public Prosecutor, and the South Indian Bank Ltd., with counsel P.A. Augustine and others. The core issues involve (i) whether a demand notice under Section 27(1)(c) of the PSS Act can be issued on the basis of information transmitted through the M1xchange platform (a RBI‑regulated TReDS system) rather than directly from a bank; (ii) whether Ernakulam has jurisdiction given an Annexure‑A3 master buyer agreement pointing to Delhi; (iii) whether the petitioners can be held vicariously liable under the NI Act; and (iv) whether the Magistrate’s initiation of process complied with Section 202 CrPC. The court examines the mechanics of TReDS, the role of M1xchange, and the settlement guidelines, ultimately holding that the cognizable offence and process were properly issued and dismissing the petitions. The judgment underscores the evolving interface between electronic settlement platforms and criminal liability under the PSS Act.
Ali was struck by an offending jeep on 28.12.1995 while he stood by a public road and suffered grievous injuries. He died on 08.02.1996. His legal heirs filed OP(MV) No.716/2001 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Manjeri, seeking compensation for the death and injuries. The Tribunal declined compensation for death, awarding only damages for injuries. The appellants argued that Ext.A5, a treatment certificate, shows Ali remained under hospital care after the accident; he developed cerebro-vascular insufficiency and aspiration pneumonia, conditions linked to the injuries and subsequent treatment, indicating a causal connection to the accident. The insurer argued there was no direct link since death occurred well after the incident. The High Court evaluated the medical records and held that the death was causally related to the injuries sustained in the accident. It set aside the Tribunal’s death-not-due-to-accident finding and directed recomputation of compensation under the head of death, applying the notional income for a casual labourer (Rs.2,000 per month) with 10% future prospects, multiplier 9 as per Sarla Verma, and deducting one-third for personal expenses per Pranay Sethi. The court also awarded funeral and loss of estate Rs.15,000 each and loss of consortium Rs.40,000 to each of seven claimants (total Rs.2,80,000), plus Rs.500 for transport and Rs.500 for loss of clothing. The Insurance Company was directed to deposit the amounts with 6% interest within two months; failure to deposit would render the award executable with interest and costs. The appeal is partly allowed.
CRL.M.C. No. 3572 of 2023 This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.M.C. No. 3572 of 2023) heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court. The petitioners, accused Nos. 1–12 in ST No. 589 of 2023 before the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Muvattupuzha, are challenging the legality of the registration of Crime No. 300 of 2023 under Sections 7 and 8 of the Kerala Gaming Act, 1960. The prosecution alleges that on 11.02.2023, at about 10:45 PM, credible information led police to a premises where petitioners were allegedly engaged in card games at Sreemoolam club; cards and other items, including Rs. 3,96,650, were seized, and a crime was registered. Counsel for petitioners contends that the registration is void for non-compliance with Section 5 of the Gaming Act, which authorizes entry, search, seizure, and custody only when two preconditions are satisfied: a reasoned belief that the place is a common gaming house and recording of that belief. Citing Kunhikannan, Danykutty, Sunil and Sugathan, the petition seeks quashing of Annexure-2 final report and all further proceedings. The judge agrees that the record did not demonstrate compliance with Section 5 or the requisite credible information, following Sugathan’s formulation, and holds that the petition should succeed. The final report and related proceedings, including ST No. 589/2023, are quashed. The order reflects a cautious safeguarding of procedural safeguards in gaming-raw law and evidentiary seizure.
This Regular Second Appeal arises from the judgment and decree dated 28 July 2006 in AS 71/2003 passed by the Additional Subordinate Judge’s Court, Thalassery, in turn arising from O.S. 141 of 1997 before the Munsiff’s Court, Kuthuparamba. The plaintiff sought declaration of title, fixation of boundary and injunction over 15.89 cents of land in Re-Survey No. 91/1 (Old Survey No. 25) Payam AMSOM. The partition among Krishnan Nambiar’s heirs left 68 cents, subsequently divided among Parvathi Amma’s heirs and others; the plaintiff purchased the entire 17 cents from Velayudhan Nambiar. Boundary disputes arose when shallow trenches and later constructions allegedly disturbed lines separating the plaint property from neighbouring plots. The trial court decreed title to plots A and A1–A12 with a directional boundary fixed as per Ext. C8, and granted permanent injunction. The First Appellate Court affirmed. The respondent-plaintiffs’ case rests on title and possession derived from the partition deed and Ext. C8. The appellants contend that, under Rule 56 of the Kerala Survey & Boundaries Rules, 1964, a permissible error exists in the extent and that the case is not a traditional boundary dispute; they rely on title deeds and possession, not survey marks. The High Court re-formulated substantial questions, concluded that the plaintiff proved title to A and A1–A12, and dismissed the Regular Second Appeal, holding that title rights prevail over survey demarcation in this matter.
This Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA) arises from a 2010 road accident in which late TV Thomas, then 82 years old, was walking on the road when a vehicle driven rashly knocked him down. He sustained serious head injuries and required inpatient care for 16 days, after which he died four years later. He had filed OP(MV) No.2/2011 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, seeking a total compensation of Rs. 5,86,000 (limited to Rs. 5,50,000), but the Tribunal awarded only Rs. 3,62,500. On his death, his legal heirs—Jude Felix, Jose Thomas, and Jenson Sebastian—represented the appeal in MACA 3829/2016, contending that the Tribunal’s award was exiguous and undervalued losses for earnings, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities, especially in light of substantial medical bills (Exts. A7 and A8). The insurer's Standing Counsel urged dismissal, arguing the Tribunal’s computations were correct. The High Court, applying Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd (2011) 13 SCC 236, held that the notional income principle should apply for unascertained earnings and reviewed heads of compensation. It enhanced Loss of Earnings to Rs.48,000; Transport to Hospital to Rs.10,000; Pain and Suffering to Rs.50,000; Loss of Amenities to Rs.20,000, while leaving other findings intact. Interest was fixed at 8% p.a., with 115 days of delay excluded; enhanced sums to be deposited within two months.
This Rent Control Revision arises from eviction orders issued under Sections 11(2)(b), 11(3) and 11(4)(1) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The petition, filed by the landlords, seeks eviction of the tenant who had been operating a jewellery business from the shop allotted in 2001 as “Thrissur Pooram Jewellery.” The landlords contend the original tenant stopped business in 2011, and the second respondent now runs the business as part of a partnership, allegedly without landlord’s consent, with rent allegedly in arrears since 01.08.2011. They seek to use the premises for bona fide needs—starting a rubber and hill products business and to use the adjoining room as a godown. The tenants dispute, arguing that rents were paid, but receipts were not issued, and that no sub-lease exists; they claim the partnership arrangement is genuine, with books not properly maintained. The Rent Control Court and the Rent Control Appellate Authority found in the landlord’s favour, particularly under Section 11(4)(1), and this finding was upheld by the High Court. The High Court relied on Vidyadhar v. Mankikrao to justify a presumption against the absent tenant and noted the absence of a registered partnership as camouflage. Ultimately, the revision petition was disposed of with six months’ time to vacate on conditions, balancing landlord’s bona fide need and tenant protections.
This High Court of Kerala, in OP(C) 1330 of 2014, examines whether an amendment to the plaint can be allowed to challenge the alleged fabrication of a receipt in a partition suit (OS 561/2012). The plaintiff Dasan filed the suit seeking partition; the defence by defendants 6 and 7 resisted. The plaintiff sought to amend the plaint via IA 993/2014 to allege that a receipt dated 28 January 1972, executed by Ammalu alias Meenakshi, is fabricated. The trial court (Principal Munsiff II, Kozhikode) rejected the amendment as it would contravene an averment in the written statement, prompting the petitioners to challenge Ext P4. The High Court held that the Supreme Court in Life Insurance Corp. v. Sanjeev Builders has laid down guidelines that amendments should be liberally considered unless time barred, or barred by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC, or would alter the nature of the suit. The court found the proposed amendment would not change the suit’s nature or prejudice the defendants; it could be safeguarded by permitting defendants to file an additional written statement. Accordingly, Ext P4 is set aside, Ext P3 is allowed, and the plaintiff must complete the amendment within statutory time; the respondents may file an additional written statement within one month; OS 561/2012 shall be disposed of as expeditiously as possible.
George Kutty’s CRL.R.P. No.3399 of 2006 challenges a 1997 conviction under the Abkari Act for possession of 2160 litres of spirit (10 barrels and four plastic jars) detected on 30.11.1996 in his residential premises at Pangottu Puthen Veedu, Ezhamkulam. The Judicial First Class Magistrate, Adoor, found him guilty under sections 55(a), 55(i) and 64-A of the Abkari Act and sentenced him to six months’ imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 30,000, with default sentence. The Addl. District & Sessions Judge (Adhoc) Fast Track Court III, Pathanamthitta, dismissed the appeal, maintaining the conviction. The High Court, in revision, examines serious defects in the prosecution’s adherence to statutory formalities under the Abkari Act, including unexplained delay in producing the contraband “thondi” articles (detected 30.11.1996, produced 02.12.1996), absence of specimen seals on Ext.P1 mahazar, and lack of a forwarding note. The court cites multiple judgments to underscore the stringent compliance required in these cases: Baburaj; Sathi; Ramachandran; Vikraman; Chandran; Vijayan; Nadarajan; Sasidharn; Gopalan; Vijay Pandey; and others, highlighting the risk of tampering and the necessity of a secure chain of custody. On this basis, it concludes the link between the contraband and laboratory analysis is not proved beyond reasonable doubt and allows the revision petition, acquitting the petitioner and canceling bail.
This is a writ petition (Civil) under Article 226 filed in the Kerala High Court by two petitioners, Lots Shipping and Trading Pvt. Ltd. and Lots Shipping Ltd., challenging the payment obligations under a salvage contract for the vessel MT Nu Shi Nalini. The first petitioner (Lot 1) is a Singapore-registered salvage service provider; the second petitioner (Lot 2) is an Indian-registered shipping company. The first respondent, United India Insurance Co. Ltd., had provided hull and machinery insurance for the vessel, while the second respondent, Arya Ship Charterers Pvt. Ltd., is the vessel’s owner/charterer. After an explosion on 13.06.2018 off Cochin, salvage operations were undertaken under Ext. P1; subsequent side agreements (Exts. P5–P7) and invoices were issued. The petitioners allege non-payment of dues, including GST, and claim the insurer’s obligation to honor the agreements and pay under those terms. There was prior Admiralty litigation in Bombay where the vessel was arrested and later sold; the petition was filed under the ‘liberty’ granted by Ext. P23 to pursue other remedies. The petition argues the State instrumentality should act in accordance with the contract and principles of fairness. The court, however, relies on binding public law principles and Joshi Technologies to hold that writ jurisdiction is not ordinarily applicable to pure contractual/monetary disputes lacking a public law element, and dismisses the petition as not maintainable.