Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 529 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5010 OF 2021 (and connected cases: 5109/2021, 5809/2021, 6502/2021) and CRL.M.C. 4424/2021

Common Bail Applications in RC7(S)/2021-SC II/CBI/New Delhi (B.A. Nos. 5010/2021 and connected cases)

This is a consolidated bail order of the Kerala High Court, authored by Justice K. Babu, dealing with anticipatory bail petitions in Crime No. RC7(S)/2021-SC II/CBI/New Delhi, arising from investigations linked to ISRO espionage allegations against scientists in the 1994–1996 period. The petitioners across connected cases include P.S. Jayaprakash (accused No.11), Vijayanan (accused No.1), Thampi S. Durga Dutt (accused No.2), R.B. Sreekumar (accused No.7), Vinod Kumar Maini (accused No.17), and Dr. Siby Mathews (accused No.4 in the related Crl.M.C.), among others. The respondents include the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and state authorities, with several additional respondents impleaded as Addl. Respondents (Nam bi Narayanan, Fauziyyah Hassan, Mariyam Rasheeda). The court examines whether the non-bailable offences under IPC (sections 120-B read with 167, 195, 218, 323, 330, 348, 365, 477-A, 506), plus offences under the Foreigners Act and Official Secrets Act, have a prima facie basis directed at denial of anticipatory bail. Citing the Supreme Court’s bail jurisprudence (Gurbakhsih Sibbia, Sushila Aggarwal, Siddharam Mhetre) the court finds the materials insufficient to establish a prima facie case for those offences, but acknowledges the broader public interest in a thorough investigation. The court grants anticipatory bail to all petitioners subject to conditions including appearance, bonds, travel restrictions, witness protection, and cooperation, while noting the possibility of deemed custody for discovery/identification as per established doctrine. The order is a broad, rights-protective resolution in a sensitive, long-running investigative saga, balancing liberty with the integrity of the inquiry.

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos. 4911/2024; BA Nos. 4919/2024

BA Nos. 4911 and 4919 of 2024 (Raju George @ N.M. Raju and Grace Raju; v State of Kerala)

These consolidated bail applications arise from Crime No. 644/2024 of Thiruvalla Police Station, Pathanamthitta. The petitioners—Raju George @ N.M. Raju (BA 4911) and Grace Raju along with Alan George and Anson George (BA 4919)—are accused of offences under IPC sections 406, 409, and 420, read with section 34, and under the BUDS Act, section 4 read with section 12. They allegedly induced a de facto complainant to deposit Rs. 15 lakh in their firm, Nedumparambil Credit Syndicate, with a promise of 12.5% interest, failing to pay interest or return the capital. The firm claims licencing under the Kerala Money Lenders Act, 1958, and the deposit dispute is argued to be civil in nature, with the BUDS Act offence described as bailable. The petitioners were in judicial custody from May 7, 2024, for about 70 days. They contend lack of mens rea, voluntary deposits, and readiness to repay matured deposits; they rely on Arnesh Kumar and Satender Antil to claim statutory/bail relief. Opposing them, the State and intervenor(s) contend pervasive cheating across multiple crimes, with more than 100 cases; investigation is at an early stage; bail could jeopardize witness tampering and dilution of evidence. The court ultimately dismisses the bail applications, holding that for Section 409 IPC the investigation period may extend to 90 days and that the gravity of the alleged offences weighs against bail at this stage.

High Court of Kerala
MSA No. 1 of 2022 and MSA No. 2 of 2022

M/S. SANROYAL BUILDERS AND CONTRACTORS PVT LIMITED v RINTO ANTO (MSA Nos.1 of 2022 & MSA No.2 of 2022)

Two misc. second appeals under Section 43(5) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 challenge orders of the Kerala Real Estate Appellate Tribunal directing deposit of amounts payable to allottees, including the advance deposit, interest up to filing, and compensation. The promoter-appellants, M/S. Sanroyal Builders and Contractors Pvt. Ltd., contend that the Adjudicating Officer’s orders lack jurisdiction and, relying on the Supreme Court in M/S. Newtech Promoters and Developers Private Limited v. State of UP, argue that the Tribunal cannot entertain the appeal under the Proviso to Section 43(5) without deposit. The respondents–Rinto Anto and Rino Anto–maintain that the Tribunal was correct to require deposit under the proviso, calling the Act a beneficial statute with no discretion to entertain without deposit. The Kerala High Court notes the statutory scheme: Section 43(5) provides an appeal to the Tribunal and the proviso imposes a predeposit obligation before entertaining an appeal, except in the penalty context. The court also cites Ravinder Nath to explain the doctrine that a decree without jurisdiction is a nullity, but finds that the present case involves an interlocutory order and the cited authority is not directly controlling. The judge ultimately holds that the Newtech decision supports the deposit requirement, that the petitioner cannot challenge the Tribunal’s readiness to entertain the appeal, and refuses to interfere. Consequently, both MSAs are dismissed, and pending applications closed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 1957 OF 2022

CRL.MC NO. 1957 OF 2022

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No.1957/2022) before the Kerala High Court arises from a protest complaint challenging the cognizance taken in C.C.No.693/2018 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kollam, in the backdrop of Crime No.1175/2017. The defacto complainant (3rd respondent) alleged a conspiracy among the accused Nos.1,2,4–6 to cheat and dishonestly transfer his land, with offences under IPC sections 420, 468, and 506(ii) read with section 34. The police initially filed a refer report concluding the dispute to be civil in nature, after which the 3rd respondent filed a protest complaint, which the Magistrate cognizance of. Petitioners contend that since the refer report found civil nature, criminal proceedings should be quashed; they also argue Annexure-6 (the cognizance order) did not reference the refer report, violating established procedure. Respondents dispute these contentions, asserting that the protest complaint and sworn statements establish prima facie offences and that cognizance was properly taken in 2017. The Court emphasizes that the Magistrate must consider the refer report and the final findings before taking cognizance, citing Parameswaran Nair and Pepsi Foods to underscore the need for the Magistrate’s mindful order. The Court allows the Crl.M.C., sets aside Annexure-6, and remits the matter for fresh consideration after examining the refer report and the civil-nature issue.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.9019 of 2022

Savithri v. District Collector, Malappuram and Others

Savithri, a 68-year-old petitioner, seeks to pay land tax on 38 cents of land in Re-survey No. 28/1 (Ozhur Village, Malappuram) claiming Ext.P1 describes the property as 28/4 but the actual survey is 28/1 and that she and other co-owners have possessed the land for decades. The 2nd respondent, Tahsildar-Land Records, rejected the request to accept land tax via Ext.P9 after rival claims by the 4th respondent (Temple) and 5th respondent (Malabar Devaswom Board) that the land belongs to the temple deity. The petition relied on Ext.P3/Ext.P5 and the 2020 Kerala High Court direction to decide merits on the representation, and invoked a decision in S. Rajkumar v. Tahsildar to contend that refusal to collect land tax on a patta land is an abdication of duty. The petition contends revenue rectification is possible if there is a title error (survey number) and that the temple’s title to Sy.No.28/1 is disputed. The Court ultimately holds that the dispute concerns title and possession, which must be resolved by a civil court, not revenue authorities, and disposes of the writ with observations, directing that the petition be pursued in civil court with the temple and Devaswom board impleaded and their contentions preserved.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos. 384/2022, 389/2022, 402/2022

Writ Appeals Nos. 384, 389 & 402 of 2022 (WA Nos. 384/2022, 389/2022, 402/2022) against common judgments in WP(C) Nos. 24046/2018, 11640/2018 and 24032/2018, Kerala High Court

These writ appeals arise from a common judgment that dismissed three petitions by personnel at the National Centre for Aquatic Animal Health (the Centre), part of Cochin University of Science and Technology (CUSAT). The petitioners — Surya Sugunan (WA 384/2022), A L Soman (WA 389/2022), and Blessy Jose (WA 402/2022) — were engaged since 2001 as Aquatic Animal Health Assistants, Shrimp Farm Technicians, and Microbiologists, respectively. In 2016 they were re-engaged on temporary terms for a three-year period in the Centre, with remuneration paid from project revenues. In January 2018 the University rejected their requests for regularisation on the ground that they were project staff working on temporary engagements and not appointed against sanctioned posts; the writ petitions challenged this decision. The learned Single Judge agreed that these posts were project-based and not sanctioned posts, and dismissed the petitions. The appellants contended that continuous service since 2001 should lead to regularisation and relied on Nihal Singh v. State of Punjab. The respondents countered that absence of sanctioned posts precludes regularisation. The High Court, while noting the long service, upheld the earlier finding, distinguishing Nihal Singh and emphasizing the temporary, post-specific nature of the appointments and lack of permanent posts. Accordingly, it dismissed the writ appeals, holding that regularisation could not be claimed in the present circumstances. It also noted that the terms of appointment expressly limited employment to project work, with salaries drawn from project funds, reinforcing the non-permanent character of the posts.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.28461/2018 & con.cases

Writ Petition (Civil) Nos. 28461/2018 and connected cases, High Court of Kerala

This batch of writ petitions before the Kerala High Court, led by KSRTC employees seeking regularisation under a bipartite settlement and subsequent Government orders, challenges termination orders issued by KSRTC for allegedly not meeting tenure and duty-day conditions. The court traces the evolution: the 2008 bipartite settlement; Government Order of 22.12.2011 fixing ten years of service as a pre-condition for regularisation; the subsequent 21.11.2013 clarification incorporating a 120-days-per-year duty requirement; Suresh Kumar v. State of Kerala (2013) held KSRTC could not append extra conditions beyond government orders; later developments culminated in Civil Appeals No.4435-4438/2017, and a Supreme Court order dated 24.03.2017 approving imposition of additional regularisation conditions. The petitioners, many regularised employees pursuing relief on the basis of earlier judgments, contend termination orders relying on these post-2011 conditions were improper and retroactive. The High Court ultimately holds that Supreme Court declarations bind all, including those with prior judgments, and directs KSRTC to grant hearing to each petitioner to substantiate ten years of service and 120 days of duty until 21.12.2011. If found eligible, regularisation shall be ordered within three months; if not, appropriate termination with pensionary considerations for eligible retirees. The judgment disposes these petitions by setting aside terminations and mandating a fact-intensive re-verification process, with six months for completion. Pension and family entitlements are addressed where applicable.

High Court of Kerala
ITA Nos.3/2021, 74/2019 & 4/2021

Calicut Educational Trust (Corporate College of Arts and Science, Emas Complex, YMCA Road, Kozhikode) now at TP Building, Muthalakulam, Kozhikode-673001 v. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax Circle 2(1), Kozhikode; Commissioner of Income Tax, North Block, Kozhikode

This is a Kerala High Court Division Bench judgment disposing of three Income Tax Appeals filed by Calicut Educational Trust (the trust) challenging the orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Cochin Bench for the assessment years 2003-04, 2007-08 and 2010-11. The appellant, a registered charitable trust with the object of promoting education and training, had obtained a certificate under Section 12AA of the IT Act. The Assessing Officer disallowed exemptions under Section 11, holding the trust to be not charitable and to run a parallel college/coaching center for profit. The first appellate authority affirmed the assessment. The Tribunal relied on several authorities, including Sole Trustee, Lok Shikshana Trust v. CIT, Mysore (1975) 101 ITR 234, Bihar Institute of Mining and Mine Surveying v. CIT (Pat) 1994 208 ITR 608 (Pat), and Education Foundation v. CIT (Guj.) (2005) 273 ITR 139, to hold that the appellant cannot be treated as an Education Trust under Section 2(15) of the IT Act and is not entitled to exemption. The appellant contends that once Section 12AA registration is granted, the Assessing Officer cannot re-examine the objects, and that Sole Trustee’s reasoning is distinguishable for this case. The respondents argue that the Trust’s activity—collection of fees for coaching—demonstrates a profit motive and thus non-charitable. The High Court, while recognizing that education under Section 2(15) must be understood with a case-by-case approach, upholds the Tribunal’s finding that the Trust’s activities are primarily coaching for profit and not systemic education. Consequently, the appeals are dismissed, upholding the denial of exemption under Section 11 and other tax provisions invoked.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 2200 of 2023

Fr. Thomas Peeliyanikkal v. State of Kerala and Others

Fr. Thomas Peeliyanikkal, the 5th accused in C.C. No. 299 of 2021, approached the Kerala High Court invoking Section 482 CrPC seeking quashing of criminal proceedings arising from allegations of offences under sections 468, 471, and 420 read with section 34 IPC. The prosecution case, based on records, alleges that on 08.03.2012 the petitioner, then Executive Director of Kuttanadu Vikasana Samithi, manipulated records to secure unlawful gain. Counsel for the petitioner contends that the dispute has been amicably settled with affidavits from respondents indicating no lingering grievances, and submits that quashing would promote peace and conserve judicial resources. The Public Prosecutor offers reservations about invoking inherent jurisdiction but concedes there are no other crimes against the petitioner. The Court examines settled law derived from Supreme Court decisions in Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, and State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan, noting that 482 CrPC can quash non‑compoundable offences with predominantly civil or private character where the parties have resolved their dispute, provided the offences are not heinous or covered by special statutes. The judge finds the settlement and the nature of the offences fit within these principles, holding that quashing would not harm society, and would serve ends of justice. Result: petition allowed; Annexure-A1 Final Report and all further proceedings in CC 299/2021 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.12378/22

W.P.(C).No.12378/22

This writ petition, filed in the Kerala High Court, challenges the Kerala Public Service Commission’s ranked list for appointments to Last Grade Servants across government entities (Category No. 113/2017). The petitioners, seven rank-holders included in Exhibit P1’s supplementary list, contend that the PSC did not maintain a sufficiently large main list, resulting in their exclusion from timely appointment despite vacancies. They argue there were hundreds of vacancies and that the main list of 3207 candidates should be expanded to incorporate those in the supplementary list, so that unfilled vacancies could be advised from a broader pool and to avoid a long age-off before the next ranked list could be prepared. They rely on Ravidas M and Ashok Kumar Yadav as authorities supporting expansion of the list, contending judicial interference is warranted to protect their rights. The Respondent PSC counters that a large main list existed (3684) with a broader supplementary list (7560), that only 16 vacancies were available at the time of approval, and that thousands had already been advised; it argues that vacancies and shortlist size are decisions within the PSC’s domain. Citing OP(KAT) No.441/2020, the court emphasizes that the size of the shortlist and vacancy reporting are executive functions, not functions for micromanagement by the judiciary. Ultimately, the petition is dismissed with directions to pursue system-level reforms for timely vacancy reporting rather than expanding the main list through the petition.

High Court of Kerala
MACA.No.2540/2009

Dr. P.J. Mathew & Jannifer Mathew v. P. Pradeep & Ors.

Bhimal Mathew’s death in a 2000 road accident prompted his parents to challenge a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal award in OP(MV)1415/2001. They argued the Tribunal undervalued compensation and miscalculated the deceased’s notional income, age, and future prospects. The deceased was 19 and an engineering student at the College of Engineering, Thiruvananthapuram; Exts. A16–A20 allegedly showed that classmates received offer letters, suggesting high earning potential—possibly abroad. The Tribunal had fixed the notional monthly income at Rs.6,000, after deducting one-third for personal expenses until age 28 and a further one-third thereafter, and it declined claims for Loss of Estate, Loss of Consortium, and Funeral Expenses. Respondents’ counsel urged adherence to Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd., arguing the notional income should be capped at Rs.4,500. The appellants relied on Fathimath Zuhara and Sarla Varma to advocate Rs.12,000 as notional income with 40% future prospects and deductions for personal expenses, while recognizing other heads of compensation. The High Court adopted Rs.12,000 as notional income, adjusted the future-prospects framework, and corrected the multiplier, holding the claimant entitled to Loss of Estate (Rs.15,000), Funeral Expenses (Rs.15,000), Loss of Consortium (Rs.80,000), and Loss of Dependency (Rs.18,14,400), culminating in a total of Rs.19,29,400. The appeal was allowed in part, with 5% interest from the claim date and apportionment preserved as per the Tribunal.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.34479 of 2023

Elsamma Devasya v. State of Kerala and others

Elsamma Devasya, owner of 4.05 ares of Sy.No.395/16 in Block No.33, Noolpuzha, Wayanad, approached the Kerala High Court by filing WP(C) No.34479 of 2023 seeking to quash Ext.P6 (the Sub-Collector/RDO’s order) and Ext.P8 (order under Section 13 of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet Land Act, 2008). The property includes Building No.NPVII/751B and is adjacent to public road, other structures, a government veterinary hospital, coconut trees over 20 years old, and is not cultivated as paddy; she had already transferred registry to her name and paid basic and property taxes. She contends that the land was converted prior to the Act and did not constitute paddy land; Form-5 was filed to remove the property from the data bank but Ext.P6 rejected it largely on the LLMC and Agricultural Officer reports without independent assessment. Ext.P8 was issued under Section 13. The Petitioner argues that data bank determinations should reflect cultivable paddy land as of 12.08.2008, and that RDO must independently assess evidence, including satellite data if necessary, rather than relying solely on LLMC reports. The petition references Salim C.K. v. State of Kerala, Lalu v. State of Kerala, Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala, Joy v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Muraleedharan Nair R. v. Revenue Divisional Officer, and Aparna Sasi Menon v. Revenue Divisional Officer Irinjalakuda, to argue the correct parameters for Form-5. The court, in a detailed analysis, quashes Ext.P6, directs the 4th respondent to reconsider Form-5 in light of the law, and sets a three-month deadline for a decision, with Ext.P8 stayed pending reconsideration.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No.3303 of 2024

Anoop v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Anoop, accused in Crime No. 225/2024 of Chavara Thekkumbhagam Police Station, Kollam, challenging an order in a case involving alleged offences under the Indian Penal Code. The prosecution accuses the petitioner of assaulting the de facto complainant, hurling abuses at police, and deterring police from discharging official duties, with charges including sections 294(b), 323, 324, 326, 333 and 506(ii) r/w Section 34 IPC. The defense contends innocence and argues that the police have inappropriately included sections 326 and 333 to deny bail; annexed FIR (Annexure A1) allegedly demonstrates that these offences would not be attracted. The petitioner has been in judicial custody for about 40 days and the investigation is practically complete with recoveries effected; thus, bail should be granted. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, maintaining ongoing investigation and the risk that release could impede inquiry and intimidate witnesses. To bolster the pro-bail argument, the court refers to established jurisprudence underscoring presumption of innocence and the general principle that bail is the rule and jail is an exception, including the right to life under Article 21. After due consideration, the court finds that further detention is unnecessary and grants bail subject to stringent conditions, including bond, sureties, regular appearance, non-interference with witnesses, and surrender of passport, with powers to cancel bail if conditions are violated.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P.NO.696 OF 2022

Gireesan v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal revision petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C., challenging a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The accused, Gireesan, was tried in the Temporary Special Court for NI Act cases (Judicial First Class Magistrate Court), Thiruvananthapuram, for two cheques issued in discharge of a debt, which allegedly dishonoured for want of funds. The trial court convicted him and sentenced him to simple imprisonment till rising of the Court and to pay a fine of Rs. 25 lakh, with an additional default imprisonment. The Sessions Court, in Crl.Appeal No. 19 of 2022, also confirmed the conviction. In the revision petition before the Kerala High Court, the learned counsel for the accused argued that the onus to prove the transaction and the execution of the cheques had not been fully discharged; mere possession of the cheques and the accused’s signature are not proof of guilt; there were lacunae in the complainant’s case. The High Court stressed that revisional jurisdiction is supervisory and not a substitute for appellate reappraisal of evidence, and that the courts below properly considered PW1’s testimony and Exts. P1–P9, while DW1’s evidence was found wanting. Reliance was placed on established precedents concerning presumption under Ss 118 and 139 NI Act, and the need for the accused to rebut that presumption by a preponderance of probabilities. The revision petition was dismissed, but four months’ time was granted to pay compensation with execution deferred to a future date.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.147 of 2022 & R.C.Rev.No.151 of 2022

M/S GREENIX VENTURES PVT. LTD. v. P.M. SALIM & OTHERS (R.C.Rev Nos.147 & 151 of 2022)

These Rent Control Revisions arise from parallel eviction disputes under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, in Kochi. Landlords (Greenix Ventures Pvt. Ltd. and related/represented party Saritha Babu) challenged the eviction orders stemming from Section 11 petitions and the Rent Control Court’s order under Section 12(3) directing tenants to vacate for non-payment of admitted arrears. The tenants disputed the quantum of rent and arrears and contested the validity of the Appellate Authority’s directions. The Rent Control Court had directed arrears of Rs.20,80,000 (Rs.1,60,000 per month for 13 months from 01.01.2020 to 30.01.2021) to be paid by 30.03.2021, failing which eviction would follow under Section 12(3). The Rent Control Appellate Authority (RCAA) confirmed the eviction but granted tenants a three-month window to clear the admitted arrears, accepting the landlords’ claim and the tenants’ failure to deposit or pay since filing. The revisions under Section 20 were heard together due to common issues. The Kerala High Court allowed Revision No.147 filed by landlords setting aside the Appellate Authority’s three-month extension and dismissed Revision No.151 filed by tenants. The court reiterated that Section 12(1)-(3) imposes a mandatory deposit/pay­ment regime to contest eviction, and that extension of time under Section 23(1)(i) cannot override the Section 12(3) consequences when sufficient cause is not shown. The judgment provides extensive analysis of precedents on time extensions, opportunity to show cause, and the independence of Sections 11 and 12.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5737 OF 2024

Subramanian v. State of Kerala

Subramanian, aged 44, is the petitioner in Bail Application No. 5737 of 2024 before the Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, under Section 482 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). The prosecution alleges that on 03.06.2024 around 20:00 hours, 20 litres of Indian Made Foreign Liquor were seized from the petitioner’s residence, indicating saleable quantity and involvement in offences under Section 55(i) of the Kerala Abkari Act. The petitioner seeks pre-arrest bail, contending his innocence, lack of material linking him to the offence, and claiming that arrest would subject him to custodial torture and impose severe hardship as the sole breadwinner. The Public Prosecutor opposes the bail, arguing that the seized liquor and prima facie materials establish involvement and that granting anticipatory bail would jeopardize the investigation; she also invokes Section 41A of the Abkari Act. The court notes the long-standing view that anticipatory bail is an extraordinary remedy and examines authorities including Srikant Upadhyay v. State of Bihar, HDFC Bank Ltd. v. J.J.Mannan, and Jai Prakash Singh. After weighing the gravity of the offence, the likelihood of tampering with evidence, and the necessity for custodial interrogation under Section 41A, the court is not persuaded to exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction under BNSS. The bail application is dismissed, but the court directs surrender within seven days and, on surrender, for the merits to be considered by the jurisdictional court; failure to surrender permits arrest.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.22555/21

Chaitanya S. Nair (minor) v. Union of India and Others

This writ petition concerns a minor (Chaitanya S. Nair) who seeks a passport without requiring consent from her biological father, and also requests that details of her stepfather (through her mother) be considered. The parents dissolved their marriage by mutual consent; custody of the child was awarded to the mother, who intends to take the child abroad. The Regional Passport Office refused the application, insisting on consent of the biological father, citing Passport Manual 2020 and other formalities. The petitioner’s mother and family argued that the consent of both parents is not legally mandatory for a passport to a minor where custody lies with one parent, and that the child is Indian by birth under the Citizenship Act, 1955, Section 3. The second respondent contended that if one parent has renounced Indian citizenship or is otherwise unable to consent, the guardian’s status and documents must determine eligibility. The court examined citizenship-provisions, renunciation vs termination concepts, and the jurisprudence on guardianship and nationality. It held that a minor born in India retains Indian citizenship by birth even if the other parent is a foreign citizen and that Annexure-C (or Annexure-D) arrangements allow issuing a passport without both parents’ consent where custody lies with one parent. The petition was allowed, directing the passport authority to issue the passport promptly with the mother as guardian.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C). No.360 of 2022

W.P.(C). No.360 of 2022

Petitioners, eight headload workers from Kumaramputhur/Changaleeri area in Palakkad, challenge threats and obstruction to their loading and unloading activities by rival union members (respondents 5–9) in Changaleeri. They allege that despite being issued identity cards by the Assistant Labour Officer, their work is persistently obstructed by the respondents, who are themselves headload workers. FIRs have been registered (Exts. P9 and P10), but police action has allegedly been lacking, prompting the filing of this writ petition seeking effective police protection. The petition also notes that the 4th respondent, Kerala State Head Load Workers Welfare Board, and others are involved in disputes over card cancellations; the petition mentions a challenge to the cancellation of cards in a separate W.P. (No. 23347 of 2022). The court recalls the mechanism under the Kerala Headload Workers Act, especially Section 21, which contemplates conciliation conferences by the Assistant Labour Officer, investigations by the Conciliation Officer, reports to the appellate authority, and binding outcomes, with an appeal right. The court cites a previous decision in M/s. R.K.Ventures v. District Superintendent of Police, Ernakulam (2024 KHC 883) to emphasize that police protection cannot be granted without exhausting the statutory remedy. Accordingly, the court makes the interim order absolute and disposes of the petition, directing the petitioners to pursue Section 21 remedies while maintaining police protection to prevent law and order issues.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) NOs. 444 OF 2022, 107 and 129 of 2023

OP(KAT) Nos. 444 of 2022, 107 of 2023 and 129 of 2023, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These interconnected matters arise from backlog vacancies claimed by candidates with locomotor disability for appointment as Medical Officer (Ayurveda) under notifications issued by the Kerala Public Service Commission. The Kerala Administrative Tribunal had directed the petitioners to report the total number of vacancies for the locomotor disability category from 07.02.1996 to 18.04.2017, a direction challenged by other rank-list candidates. The judgments extensively consider the Rights of Persons With Disabilities Act, 2016, particularly Section 34(2) on reservation, and draw on the principles of carry-forward of vacancies drawn from the earlier 1995 Act (Section 36 of the repealed Act). The Apex Court authorities cited in the judgment (Govt Of India Through Secretary v. Ravi Prakash Gupta & Anr; Union of India v. National Federation of Blind & Others) hold that reservations must be identified with reference to the Act’s date of operation, and that carry-forward or lapse only arise where posts are identified. The court notes that reservations were identified in earlier notifications and that the Tribunal’s order to set apart vacancies from 1996 onwards is illegal. Accordingly, the impugned judgment is set aside, directing PSC to advise strictly based on the present notification and vacancies in the record, with the Original Petitions disposed accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 13731 OF 2020

M. M. Paulose and others v Union of India and others

This writ petition filed in the Kerala High Court by 51 retired employees under the Employees’ Provident Fund Organization seeks higher pension under the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 and the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995. The petitioners contend pension must be calculated by considering the average monthly pay drawn during the contributory service period, for a period of 12 months prior to exit, and by including 8 1/3% of the full contribution made by the establishments they were connected with (10th to 13th respondents). They urge removal of any artificial wage ceiling and seek arrears and revised pension on the basis of pre-amended para 11 of the Pension Scheme. The Respondents, led by the Standing Counsel for EPFO, rely on a Supreme Court ruling in EPF Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B and Others (2022) SCC Online SC 1521, arguing the issue is settled and must be decided in line with that decision. The Court disposed of the petition by directing the competent respondents to re-consider the petitioners’ claims in light of the Supreme Court dictum within three months from receipt of a copy of the judgment. Exhibits include prior judgments (P1–P4).