Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 490 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.30487,31008 & 31242 of 2022

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam: Lucy Rajan vs State of Kerala & Others; Krishnapriya P.S. v. State of Kerala & Others; Seethalekshmi P. v. State of Kerala & Others

The three connected writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 30487 of 2022; 31008 of 2022; 31242 of 2022) were filed by young women intending to marry partners who are working abroad. They sought permission to solemnize their marriages via video conferencing or online mode, arguing that a Division Bench of this Court had already permitted virtual solemnization during the pandemic and that authorities had consistently allowed such petitions. The Government Pleader countered that the statutory framework—primarily the Special Marriage Act, 1954 and its Rules—mandates physical presence and that the pandemic-era practice should not continue as a general rule. The court engaged with prior case law, noting a split between Single Judges in Paradeep Kodiveedu Cletus v Local Registrar of Marriages (2018) 1 KLT 292 and Dioncey Augustine v. State of Kerala (2019 SCC OnLine Kerala 13112), and observed that the Division Bench’s interim order affirmed the Paradeep Kodiveedu view. The judge concluded in alignment with Paradeep Kodiveedu Cletus, affirming the possibility of solemnization through video conferencing subject to safeguards. The operative directions require witnesses to be present, identities verified, essential documents furnished in advance, and signatures where necessary effected via Power of Attorney, with the statutory period for solemnization/registration extended by two weeks. The order directs Marriage Officers to implement these arrangements expeditiously while complying with statutory formalities.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 2424 OF 2008

M.M. Baiju v. Balachandran, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. and P. Siddique

This appeal arises from MACA No. 2424 of 2008 before the High Court of Kerala (Ernakulam), challenging an award of the Principal Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode, in O.P. (MV) No. 477/2000. The claimant, M.M. Baiju, suffered serious injuries on 21 December 1999 when a scooter, KL-13-632, allegedly driven rashly by the third respondent collided with him. Baiju, a mason with a notional income around Rs. 3–4 thousand per month at the relevant time, claimed compensation of Rs. 3,21,000, of which Rs. 2,00,000 was sought to be payable. The Tribunal partly allowed the petition and directed the second respondent insurer to pay Rs. 52,938 with 7% interest and costs after holding the insurer not liable due to exoneration of the first respondent owner, amid a challenge to ownership and the insured status. The insurer contended that the vehicle’s ownership had passed and that driving by the third respondent without a valid licence voided policy liability. The High Court reassesses the issues: it disallows the insurer’s exoneration, holds that a valid policy remains in force (Exhibit B1) and that liability can attach to the insurer for third‑party claims, while correcting the evidence on ownership. It revises valuation of income, disability, and several heads of compensation to award a total enhanced amount. Ultimately, the appeal is allowed in part.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 13721 OF 2021

PRADEEP K. v STATE OF KERALA & ORS

This Public Interest Litigation challenges the construction of the Chirakkapadi-Kanhirapuzha road, seeking a writ of mandamus to appoint monitors and supervisors from respondents 3, 4, and 7 to oversee the project and to evict encroachments on both sides of the road. The petitioner contends that Ext. P3 (dated 21.06.2019) remains unconsidered and that the road plan, including a 7-meter carriageway, is inadequate for existing density and traffic, with no provision for bus stops, halting stations, or parking for autos and taxis. He argues the project is being executed without proper boundary fixation and that encroachments are impeding progress, leading to waste of public money. Respondents counter that the project is KIIFB-funded with Administrative Sanction (2016), Detailed Project Report, and Financial and Technical Sanctions; 71% progress has been achieved; boundary demarcation and eviction of encroachments have occurred where necessary. They cite monitoring by KIIFB and PWD engineers, delays due to monsoon, COVID-19, and elections, and an extension to 30.09.2021. The court finds no need for further directions beyond ensuring completion and disposes of the petition, directing the respondents to complete the project without further delay.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1246 of 2012

M.A.C.A.No.1246 of 2012

This Motor Accidents Claims Appeal arises from a MACT petition filed by the parents of a 17-year-old deceased who died in a road accident when a scooter collided with a tanker lorry. The MACT Ernakulam dismissed the petition, holding that the accident occurred due to the negligence of the deceased himself. The 2nd respondent insurer supported the finding, arguing the deceased, being a minor, rode without a driving licence and that the accident resulted from his own negligence; they sought exoneration of liability. The appellants challenged the Tribunal’s reliance on a police scene mahazar as the basis for attributing negligence to the deceased and urged that the final police report (Ext.A2) and other records show the lorry driver’s fault, a proposition also supported by Pazhaniammal and Jiju Kuruvila line of authorities. The court observed that reliance on scene mahazar alone cannot determine negligence and examined the evidence, including Exts. A1–A13 and Ext.A3 (final police report). It concluded that the lorry driver was negligent, and as the insurer of the vehicle, the 2nd respondent bears liability. The court re-assessed quantum, adopting standard Mohan/Benchmark metrics: monthly income Rs.6,500 (for 2008), multiplier 18, 50% deduction for personal expenses, 40% future prospects, and additional heads for loss of estate, funeral expenses, and loss of consortium, totaling Rs.10,98,800, with Rs.15,000 each for estate and funeral, and Rs.40,000 for loss of consortium, plus small awards for pain/transport. The appeal is allowed, and the MACT award is set aside; the compensation is to be deposited by the insurer within three months.

High Court of Kerala
CRL R.P No. 1661 of 2011

Paul Varghese v. Kerala Vyapari Vyavasayi Ekopana Samithi and State of Kerala

This criminal revision petition, Crl R.P. No.1661 of 2011, before the Kerala High Court (Single Judge: C.S. Dias, J.) arises from a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (N.I. Act) for dishonour of a cheque. The Trial Court (JFCM Kochi, ST No.855/2008) convicted the revision petitioner for issuing Ext. P1 cheque in discharge of a debt, despite a cheque bounce (Ext. P2). The Appellate Court (ADJ-II Ernakulam) confirmed the conviction but modified the sentence and awarded compensation under CrPC 357(3). The petitioner contends that the financial transactions occurred between 1999-2002 and that the debt is time-barred; he argues that blank security cheques were misused to recover a stale claim, and the courts below failed to appreciate this defence. The State and the Samithi contend that the cheque was given on 16.6.2007 to discharge a liability, and the evidence supports the prosecution case. The High Court reviews the legal framework governing prestipulated presumption under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act and the reverse-onus on the accused to rebut such presumption. Relying on multiple Supreme Court authorities (Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan; Rangappa; Kalamani Tex; Rohitbhai Jivanlal Patel; Shree Daneshwari Traders; Ramakrishnan; Krishna Janardhan Bhat), the Court upholds the concurrent findings, dismisses the revision, and directs payment of compensation with a deferment of execution until 27 November 2023.”

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal No. 444 of 2022

Jayaraj R. v. Kavya G. Nair

A husband Jayaraj R. and wife Kavya G. Nair filed a joint petition under Section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 before the Family Court, Thiruvananthapuram, seeking a decree of divorce by mutual consent based on a compromise dated 11.10.2019. The couple had married in 2010, with a son born in 2011. They have lived separately since 2017; The petition was dismissed on 22.04.2021 after Kavya withdrew her consent and the parties remained absent. The appellant challenged the Family Court’s order in Mat.Appeal No. 444 of 2022 under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984. The case involves a detailed survey of the apex court and high court decisions on section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act and the proper application of its two-stage mechanism: (i) the joint petition and (ii) the second motion following a six-to-eighteen month interregnum. The Kerala High Court examined Sureshta Devi (1991) 2 SCC 25; Smruti Pahariya (2009) 13 SCC 338; Anil Kumar Jain (2009) 10 SCC 415; Ashok Hurra (1997) 4 SCC 226; and Rupa Ashok Hurra (2002) 4 SCC 388, among others, to determine whether mutual consent must remain in force until the decree. It held that, on the facts, continued mutual consent is mandatory; unilateral withdrawal defeats jurisdiction, and the appeal is dismissed, upholding the Family Court’s order.

High Court of Kerala
OP (MAC) NO. 61 OF 2021

Sobhana v. Sasi K., Saseendran @ Sasi, and The Manager, New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

This case concerns a motor vehicle accident claim filed by the petitioner, Sobhana, before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Attingal, seeking compensation for injuries suffered. The Tribunal dismissed the original petition as time-barred, holding that Section 166(3) of the Motor Vehicles Act as amended by the 2019 Amendment Act introduced a six-month period from the date of occurrence, and even extended time for Covid-19 lockdowns could not save the claim. The petitioner challenged this, arguing that the 2019 Amendment’s Section 166(3) had not come into force because the required notification did not bring Section 53 into effect, so the pre-amendment Section 166 should govern. The court examined the amendment’s commencement framework and the sequence of notifications. It noted that while some provisions of the Amendment Act were in force from 1 September 2019, Section 53 (which inserted 166(3)) had not been brought into force by the specified notifications. Consequently, the Tribunal was applying the amended provision in error and the original Section 166 stood intact. The judgment cites a parallel Allahabad High Court decision (Shailendra Tripathi) confirming the same view. Accordingly, the petition is allowed, the impugned order is set aside, and the Tribunal is directed to restore the petition and proceed in accordance with law. The court also acknowledged ongoing Covid-19 considerations still binding elsewhere but not to this case’s limitation issue.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 857 of 2020

Branch Secretary, Kerala Kashuvandi Thozhilali Congress, Central Office, Congress Bhavan (HO), INTUC, Kollam District v Western India Cashew Company Corporate Office; Western India Cashew Company Private Limited; Labour Court, Kollam

This is a writ appeal under Section 5 of the High Court Act, heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court, challenging the order of a Single Judge in WP(C) No. 12490/2018. The Branch Secretary of the Kerala Kashuvandi Thozhilali Congress (INTUC) averred that the Labour Court’s preliminary award, which set aside the domestic enquiry against three Western India Cashew Company employees and permitted the management to lead evidence anew, is erroneous. The three workmen were alleged to have engaged in an illegal boycott, obstructed colleagues, and abused superiors on 27 October 2012, leading to disciplinary proceedings and their retrospective termination. The Labour Court found defects in the enquiry’s natural justice, notably reliance on Ext. M3 without calling the author for cross-examination. It directed fresh consideration by the management. The Division Bench, while upholding the need for fairness, found that the Labour Court’s reasoning lacked specifics and that the enquiry was conducted according to recognised procedure, citing authorities on natural justice (including A.K. Kraipak) and the “useless formality” concept to reject remand as futile. It held that non-examination of Ext. M3’s author does not invalidate the report. The appeal is dismissed, and the Labour Court is directed to dispose of the industrial dispute within six months from copy of the judgment."

High Court of Kerala
Crl.MC.No. 4454 of 2016

Eldhose Elias v State of Kerala & Others

This High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, heard Crl.MC.No.4454 of 2016 arising from CC 650/2016, the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Kothamangalam. Eldhose Elias, the petitioner, stands as the sole accused in a case charging offences under Sections 75 and 76 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, and Section 370 IPC, in connection with establishing a football academy named Beausyfalace International School of Football and allegedly exploiting enrolled students. The complaint, triggered by a student’s report of mental and physical hardship, led to a suo motu FIR by Sub Inspector Sudheer Manohar and a final report (Annexure-A20) before the court. The petitioner contends that the investigation is vitiated since the informant and investigator are identical, relying on Mohan Lal v. State of Punjab to argue that such a setup defeats fair investigation and trial. He also asserts that Sections 75 and 370 IPC are misapplied since students joined voluntarily with parental consent and training purposes, not exploitation. The Public Prosecutor opposed the prayer. The court found that the students admitted themselves with parental consent, participated in competitions, and there was no coercion. It held that reliance on Mohan Lal supports that fair investigation was compromised, and, thus, continuing the proceedings would be an abuse of process. Consequently, the court quashed Annexure-A20 and all further proceedings, allowing the petition.

High Court of Kerala
F.A.O. No. 48 of 2014

SABU N.A. v. TOM

This is a Kerala High Court appeal (F.A.O. No. 48 of 2014) challenging an order dated 11 December 2013 passed in I.A. Nos. 544/2002 and 543/2002 in O.S. No. 652 of 1993 on the file of the Additional Sub Court, North Paravur. The appellant-plaintiff, Sabu N.A., had filed a suit for compensation, which was decreed ex parte in 1996, and later the defendant sought to restore the suit after dismissal for non-prosecution. The plaintiff, who was working in Saudi Arabia, could not appear and adduce evidence on 6 October 2000, leading to dismissal and later attempted restoration under Order IX, Rule 9, with delay condonation under Section 5 of the Limitation Act. The trial court rejected the restoration for lack of sufficient cause. The High Court, invoking Section 5 and the liberal doctrine of condonation—balanced by the ends of justice and potential prejudice—cites Collector, Land Acquisition v. Katiji and Esha Bhattacharjee v. Raghunathpur Nafar Academy to enunciate that “sufficient cause” is elastic and must be exercised with reasonableness. The judgment relies on G.P. Srivastava and subsequent Kerala High Court precedents to emphasize that a liberal approach is permissible but not unfettered. The Court ultimately allows the appeal, sets aside the order, condones the delay with costs, and orders restoration of the suit, directing the Sub Court to proceed within four months.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 13525 & 16933 of 2020

Giju P Vijayan and others v. Travancore Devaswom Board and others; Ravi Kumar K.R. and others v. Travancore Devaswom Board and others

These writ petitions challenge the Travancore Devaswom Board's contracts governing the right to conduct business at Sabarimala Sannidhanam and Pampa during the 2019-2020 pilgrimage season. The petitioners in WP(C) 13525/2020 are licensees who secured rights by auction for the period 11.11.2019 to 31.10.2020. They contend that the COVID-19 outbreak and subsequent lockdown prevented them from operating from March 13, 2020, reducing their business to zero for much of the term. They seek mandamus to extend their rights for the next season or to refund a proportionate portion of the license fee corresponding to the days lost, after hearing. In WP(C) 16933/2020, other bidders assert that between 11.11.2019 and 31.10.2020, the maximum permissible business days were 139; they managed only 70 days due to the pandemic, and after restrictions there would be no normal resumption by 31.10.2020. They similarly request extension and refund. The court holds that a legal right to conduct business arises only during open pilgrim days and within tender terms; there is no general duty to extend beyond the contract period, and there is no force majeure clause supporting relief. Citing Travancore Devaswom Board v. Thanath International (2004) 13 SCC 44 and Alopi Parshad, the court reiterates that contracts bind the parties and compensation meruit is not available when price is fixed by contract. Consequently, the petitions are dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. Nos. 2679 & 2743 of 2023 (Crime No. 153/2023 Nadapuram PS, Kozhikode)

Bail Applications Nos. 2679 & 2743 of 2023 (Crime No. 153/2023 Nadapuram Police Station, Kozhikode) – Abdulla s/o Moideen; Abdul@Abdulla M.T; Shamsu@Shamsuddeen P.P. v. State of Kerala

On 12 April 2023, the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam heard anticipatory bail petitions in Crime No. 153/2023 of Nadapuram Police Station, Kozhikode, concerning accused Nos. 1, 3 and 5. The prosecution alleges that the accused formed an unlawful assembly with deadly weapons to attack the defacto complainant Vishakh Vinayan and Jasna with the intent to murder, resulting in serious head injuries to Vishakh Vinayan. The offences charged include sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 326, 307 and 506(ii) read with 149 IPC. The defense claims the allegations are false, rooted in a brawl triggered by the complainant’s alleged illicit relationship with Smt. Jasna, occurring at odd hours, and that accused Nos. 3 and 5 are not involved in a crime of such gravity. They offered full cooperation in the investigation. The Public Prosecutor pressed for custodial interrogation and weapon recovery to advance the investigation, supported by a wound certificate showing significant head injuries. The Court held that custodial interrogation and weapon recovery were necessary for the first accused, while the allegations against accused Nos. 3 and 5 were less strong. Consequently, bail was denied for accused 1, but granted to accused 3 and 5 on conditions.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No.1306 of 2018

Krishnan Nair v. State of Kerala

Krishnan Nair was convicted of murdering Satheesan, who objected to the accused’s night-time residence at the temple’s thidappilli. The Trial Court found beyond reasonable doubt that the accused stabbed Satheesan with MO3 on 29.09.2012, resulting in death, and sentenced him to life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC with a Rs. 10,000 fine and…in default, six months’ RI. The prosecution examined 16 witnesses, produced 22 exhibits, and relied on direct ocular evidence (PW2’s testimony of a stabbing), a dying declaration corroborated by PW1 and PW3, and supportive medical and forensic findings. The defense argued alternate theories: the death could have resulted from a fall near the incomplete construction, the accused acted in self-defence, there was no intent to murder, and the recovery of weapon and clothing under a hardboard lacked credibility; the dying declaration was questionable due to the victim’s condition and possible tutoring of witnesses. The High Court evaluated the medical evidence, ocular testimony, and dying declaration, while noting concerns about the recovery’s reliability, and nonetheless held that the combination of direct eyewitness evidence and corroborated dying declaration sufficed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the appeal is dismissed and conviction and the life sentence affirmed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 15257 of 2021

M. Daniel v. State of Kerala & Others

Petitioner M. Daniel, an M.Phil holder and post-graduate in History and English Literature, was appointed as a Guest Lecturer (History) in the Sree Sankaracharya University of Sanskrit on 10 June 1997, with interruptions, and continued in service in the same capacity up to the last academic year. He seeks regularisation of his service on a permanent post on the basis of long service and consistency with other similarly situated lecturers who have been regularised in the past. The writ petitions filed over the years reveal a pattern of contract-based appointments prior to the coming into force of the University Statutes and Rules, which this Court had instructed to cancel and for the University to enact Statutes and Rules thereafter; subsequent practice, however, involved regularisation for certain open vacancies under UGC regulations. The Court has repeatedly allowed petitions by other guest lecturers, directing the University to consider regularisation in accordance with law and the established policy, while noting that regularisation must be consonant with constitutional requirements and sanctioned posts. In several petitions, the University had taken a stand based on Uma Devi (Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi) that regularisation cannot bypass the constitutional framework. The petitioner points to post-2016 decisions and representations (Ext.P16–P17) and a 2021 notification inviting regular vacancies, arguing a “pick and choose” pattern in regularising some while denying others. The Court, examining authorities’ conduct and prior jurisprudence, directs the University to consider the petitioner’s representation and pass orders in accordance with law after notice and hearing within three months of the judgment.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.531 of 2020 and connected cases (532/2020, 537/2020, 540/2020, 541/2020, 544/2020)

Gopakumar v. State of Kerala

This High Court of Kerala heard six connected criminal revision petitions filed by Gopakumar challenging his convictions in separate cases arising from crimes registered at Peringome Police Station, Kannur. The petitions question whether sentences awarded across these distinct trials should run concurrently or consecutively, a matter that affects the total punishment. The petitioner relies on Benson v. State of Kerala (2007(3) KHC 882) to argue for concurrent execution, urging that a uniform approach to sentencing should apply given concurrent convictions and the overall balance of justice. The court begins by confirming that there is no reason to disturb the concurrent findings of conviction by the trial court and the first appellate court, and notes that the sentences confirmed on appeal reflect a proper balance between aggravating and mitigating factors. The pivotal issue then becomes the lawfulness of running sentences from different trials concurrently. Citing Section 427 Cr.P.C., the court explains that ordinarily, different sentences in separate trials shall run consecutively unless there is an explicit direction to run concurrently. No such direction was issued in these six petitions, and cross-case set-off or credit is not permitted except in overlapping circumstances. Accordingly, the court dismisses the revision petitions and holds that the six sentences must run consecutively.

High Court of Kerala
OP (CAT) Nos.188/2014, 95/2015, 189/2014 and 124/2015

OP (CAT) Nos. 188/2014, 95/2015, 189/2014 and 124/2015 v Union of India and others

This batch of Original Petitions (OP CAT) challenges orders of the Central Administrative Tribunal (Ernakulam Bench) directing financial upgradation of Grade Pay within the next promotion hierarchy for personnel of the Naval Armament Depot and All India Radio cadre. The petitioners, i.e., Union of India and related authorities, contend that the Tribunal’s directions are inconsistent with statutory pay structures and the DoP&T guidelines governing revised pay rules. The respondents are the individual employees who sought such upgradation. The matter was heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court (Justices S. V. Bhatti and Basant Balaji Thurday) on 23 March 2023, with the court noting that the core issue is whether the respondents are entitled to the financial upgradation at the subsequent promotion level. Counsel for the petitioners invoked the Supreme Court’s later decision in Union of India v. M. V. Mohanan Nair (2020), which the bench treated as controlling, indicating the batch petitions should be resolved in the petitioners’ favour. The petitioners anchored their position on the Central Civil Service (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 and related DoP&T guidance. The respondents argued for upgradation based on Tribunal orders and policy instruments. Ultimately, the court held that Mohanan Nair governs and allowed the petitions, reversing the Tribunal’s orders and denying the requested upgradation. The decision clarifies that financial upgradation at the next promotion level is not automatically warranted in these cases.

High Court of Kerala
R.S.A.No.1099 of 2007

Pappachan and Antony v. Alex, Binoy, JAIMON, Prince and The Vicar, St. Joseph's Church, Erappumpara

The appellants, Pappachan and Antony, seek a decree declaring and enforcing a prescriptive right of way along plaint C schedule, a five-foot wide path along the northern and western sides of the respondents’ property that abuts a public road. They claim continuous use for over 35 years, with a bifurcating route from the road to A and B schedule properties, one leg south to A schedule and another west to B schedule. The respondents contest that no such path exists; they contend the disputed strip is a ridge of a paddy field, now dry land, and that walls and gates were erected to block access. The trial court dismissed the suit; the first appellate court affirmed. The Regular Second Appeal raises two substantial questions of law: whether a dominant owner can prescribe right of way along a reclaimed paddy-field ridge, and whether the lower courts’ findings are perverse. The High Court held that the courts below misidentified the true pathway and that reclamation alters land characteristics, allowing prescriptive easement if 20 years of use is proven with precise pleadings. Referencing precedents such as Cherootty Balan and Justiniano Antao, the court concluded the appellants have established a right to a three-foot-wide C schedule path along the disputed corridor, invalidated the blockades, and directed the decree to include Ext. C3(a) with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No. 235 of 2016

Vijayamma v. Nandakumaran Pillai and Aravindakshan Pillai

The appellant-plaintiff Vijayamma filed FAO 235 of 2016 challenging two interlocutory orders of the Sub Court, Mavelikkara passed in O.S. No. 46 of 2012: I.A. No. 1166 of 2014 under Order IX Rule 9 for setting aside a dismissal for default, and I.A. No. 1162 of 2014 under Section 5 of the Limitation Act seeking condonation of delay of three days. The suit for specific performance based on an alleged oral agreement with Defendant 1 was dismissed for default on 20.08.2014. The Sub Court, on 02.09.2015, dismissed both interlocutory applications; the condonation application followed on the same day. The appellant contends that the delay is minimal (three days), the absence on the date of hearing was not malafide, and the court should exercise its discretion in her favour, restoring the suit. The respondent argues that valid reasons were stated for dismissal and there was no sufficient cause to condone the delay. On appeal, the High Court, applying liberal interpretations of “sufficient cause” and relying on precedents such as G.P. Srivastava, Peeves Enterprises and M. Shivananda, held that interference is warranted with a condition to pay costs. The appeal restores the suit to file with a cost payable to the first respondent and directs expeditious disposal given the suit’s long pendency. The 2nd respondent did not appear.

High Court of Kerala
WA 1752 of 2022

Cheereth Metals v. Deputy Superintendent of Police, Puthencruz; Head Load and General Workers Union (A.I.T.U.C), Puthencruz Unit; C.I.T.U Head Load Workers Union Puthencruz; I.N.T.U.C Head Load Workers Union Puthencruz; Head Load Workers Welfare Board Puthencruz

This writ appeal arises from a Kerala High Court decision denying police protection to Cheereth Metals to engage its own registered headload workers for loading and unloading in its establishment. The appellant relies on Rule 26A of the Kerala Headload Workers Rules 1981, asserting that it can employ three registered workers to carry out loading/unloading, and that Ext. P5 (a Division Bench decision) and related precedents recognize an employer’s right to engage attached workers principally employed for such work. The respondents argue that the area falls under a Scheme for headload workers established by the Kerala Headload Workers (Regulation of Employment and Welfare) Scheme 1983, giving pool workers exclusive claim and a bipartite Ext. R2A agreement governing employment and wages, which restricts an employer from engaging non-pool workers unless they are registered under Rule 26A. The Single Judge found Ext. R2A binding and declined police protection. On appeal, the Division Bench holds that registration under Rule 26A permits attached workers for loading/unloading, and that the pool under the Scheme must be given priority, but an owner may engage three registered workers. The Court sets aside the Single Judge’s order, allowing three registered workers to work, while any additional work must go to pool workers; obstruction to these workers may invite police intervention. The writ appeal is allowed with these observations.

High Court of Kerala
WA 1717/2022

Ansa Mathew v State of Kerala & Others (W.A. No. 1717 of 2022)

This intra-court appeal challenges the order passed in W.P.(C) 926/2021 (and related proceedings) concerning pay protection and fixation for Ansa Mathew, a retrenched teacher who, after service in the High School Assistant (HSA) grade, was reverted to a lower post (UPST/LPST) during staffing changes. The writ petitioner claimed continued pay protection under Rule 52 of Chapter XIVA of the Kerala Education Rules (KER) and challenged Ext. P8 (1.6.2020) directing pay recovery and re-fixation; internal audit objections, and later objections by the DEO and Deputy Director of Education formed the crux of the dispute. The learned Single Judge had accepted Rule 52 and rejected the Government Circular of 2012 (G.O. No.1237/2012) which sought to restrict pay protection when reappointment occurs in a lower category. The Division Bench, applying Anneuxre-A (W.A. 2157/2018) and State of Punjab v. Rafi Masih (White Washer case), held that pay protection cannot be claimed in a higher scale on reappointment to a lower category, and that no recovery should be effected in the circumstances before retirement. The appeal was allowed, and the judgment of the Single Judge set aside. The court directed fixation of pay and pension per entitlement and immediate release of terminal benefits after fixation.