Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 476 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.457 of 2019

Jayakumar K.V v. K. Ramamoorthi Charitable Trust, Kannur

This is a rent control revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 (R.C.Rev. No. 457 of 2019) arising from eviction proceedings initiated by the landlord under Sections 11(2)(b), (3) and (4)(v). The Rent Control Court had directed the tenant to deposit admitted arrears and later passed an order under Section 12(3) for eviction after the tenant allegedly defaulted. The Appellate Authority (Additional District Judge-II, Thalassery) dismissed the appeal. The petitioner-tenant challenged these orders on two grounds: first, that the petition building is a government-recognized educational institution entitled to protection under Section 11(11)(ii) of the Act; second, that funds from the Government did not suffice to pay the arrears and hence the Section 12(3) consequence cannot be sustained. The landlord contends the petitioner is not entitled to the protection, as the building was not proven to be a government-recognized educational institution, and default in payment justifies automatic invocation of Section 12(3). The High Court, in a Division Bench, examines Section 12’s deposit regime and Section 11(11) immunity, referencing Narayanan and Shaji M. decisions, and Issac Mathew’s interpretation of 11(11)(ii). The judgment ultimately sets aside the lower orders, remands the matter to restore R.C.P No.227/2016 and directs expeditious disposal, clarifying that the landlord may file fresh Section 12 petitions if arrears persist.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 10612 OF 2024 & con.cases

WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases (Consolidated) - In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This is a consolidated Kerala High Court judgment delivered on 26 March 2024 by Justice T. R. Ravi arising from a batch of writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 10612 of 2024 and connected cases) challenging freezing of bank accounts pursuant to police action and the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal. The petitions involve various petitioners whose accounts were frozen after police intimation across multiple states. The court notes that interim directions were issued at admission to confine freezes to the amounts in dispute and to require banks to act proportionately. It relies on and applies the principle from a prior decision, Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC OnLine 661), extracted in Paragraph 12 of the judgment, to limit the freeze to the disputed amount and to ensure the banks and police coordinate. The court also cites and relies on other earlier orders and judgments (as referred to in appendices and exhibits) to justify its directions, including references to prior Writ Petitions such as W.P.(C) 28155/2023 and W.P.(C) No. 13548/2020, among others. The operative order disposes of the petitions with a set of safeguards: (a) freeze confined to the amount mentioned in the police requisition/order, (b) police to inform banks whether the freeze should continue, (c) the freezing action to be maintained for a maximum period of eight months, (d) petitioners may approach the court again if no information is received. The judgment thus balances criminal investigation needs with protection of petitioners’ legitimate banking interests.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & con.cases

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam - WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases (consolidated)

The Kerala High Court, in a consolidated hearing on 26 March 2024, addressed a batch of writ petitions (WP(C) 10612/2024 and connected matters) challenging the blanket freezing of bank accounts in cybercrime investigations. The petitions, filed by various account-holders and financial institutions across multiple banks and states, challenged freezing orders issued by banks under the influence of police/intimation in cybercrime cases. The Court observed that interim directions were necessary to protect the petitioners’ ability to operate bona fide accounts, while ensuring proceeds of crime could be traced. Drawing on precedent, the Court extracted Paragraph 12 from Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC OnLine 661) and laid down directions to limit freezing to the amount mentioned in the police requisition, requiring the respondent police to inform the banks about the continuation period, and allowing the petitioners to approach the Court if information is not provided. Consequently, the petitions were disposed of with directions to confine freezes, coordinate between police and banks, and retain the petitioners’ ability to transact beyond the disputed sums for a period, in line with due process and legitimate banking needs.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1740 OF 2012

Manjusha K.H and Others v Balakrishnan Kuruvath House and Others

This appeal arises from an award in O.P. (MV) No. 1477/2010, challenging the MACT Ernakulam’s compensation for the fatal death of Thomas Chacko on 14.08.2009, when the deceased rider collided with a bus owned by the first respondent and insured by the third respondent. The appellants—wife, son, and mother—contend that the Tribunal’s quantum was inadequate. They argue that notional income should be higher, the multiplier appropriate to age 29 should be used, and future prospects, along with conventional heads, should reflect current standards. The respondents did not contest and were ex parte. The High Court, applying Ramachandrappa to fix the notional income at Rs. 7,000 per month and Sarla Verma for multiplier 17, calculated a 40% addition for future prospects, and a one-third deduction for personal living expenses per Sarala Verma and Pranay Sethi. It then partially allowed the appeal by increasing the loss of dependency, with adjustments to funeral, loss of estate, and loss of consortium, while striking down a duplicative 'loss of love and affection' head in light of Somwati. Consequently the total compensation was enhanced to Rs. 15,05,300 with interest at 7.5% p.a., to be deposited within 60 days and disbursed among the appellants in the ratio 50:35:15.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 5394 of 2024; 4670 of 2024; 6090 of 2024; 12195 of 2024

W.P.(C) Nos. 5394/2024, 4670/2024, 6090/2024 and 12195/2024

The Kerala High Court, in a common judgment by Justice Dinesh Kumar Singh, decided four writ petitions challenging IGST/CGST refunds and demands linked to import/export operations under Advance Authorisation and 100% EOU schemes. The petitioners—Travancore Coir Tuft Private Limited (WP(C) 4670/2024), United Coir Factories (WP(C) 5394/2024), Alleppey Company Ltd. (WP(C) 6090/2024), and Taj Exports (WP(C) 12195/2024)—had remitted IGST with interest and sought amendments of Bills of Entry (BE) to reflect these payments, arguing that Section 149 of the Customs Act, 1962 and Circular No.16/2023-Cus empower amendments post-import, and that denial caused inadvertent financial and data mismatches in GST filings. The respondents contended that amendments to BE after clearance are not generally permissible except via reassessment under Section 128 or via documentary evidence under Section 149’s proviso, and urged reliance on ITC Ltd. v. Commissioner etc. The court extensively analyzes Sections 128, 149 and 154, Rule 96(10) CGST Rules, 2017, and allied provisions, citing Sony India, Dimension Data, Hindustan Unilever, and ITC to support a broader remedial scope under Section 149. It ultimately holds that amendments are permissible, directs the 3rd respondent to consider petitions in light of Telangana’s Sony decision and Circular 16/2023 within 15 days, and orders BE amendments with interest compliance for some petitioners, keeping the others’ compliance in view.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO.1059 OF 2024 & CONNECTED CASES

Bail Applications No. 1059 of 2024 & Connected Cases (Criminal – Section 438 CrPC) – High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This common order consolidates Bail Applications No. 1059/2024 and connected cases arising from Koipuram Police Station, Pathanamthitta, concerning alleged offences under IPC Sections 409 and 420 read with Section 34, and under the BUDS Act (Sections 5, 23, 3 and 21). The petitioners, Sindhu Nair (2nd accused) and Lekha Lekshmikumar (4th accused), seek pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC in respect of four crimes: 102/2024, 104/2024, 107/2024, and 109/2024. The prosecution alleges a family-owned finance business operating under multiple names (PRD Finance -> PRD Financiers Pvt. Ltd -> Pullad Finance Pvt. Ltd -> G and G Finance) that collected deposits from the public without RBI authorization, misappropriated funds, and changed corporate names to conceal the scheme. The petitioners contend they had no direct involvement; they are women; they were prepared to cooperate and accept conditions; they argue the first accused’s ownership implies non-involvement of the petitioners. The State counters that the petitioners were active in management and that 380 cases exist across two police stations; granting pre-arrest bail would impede investigation and recovery. The court acknowledges the gravity of economic offences and cites Supreme Court doctrine emphasizing cautious treatment of anticipatory bail in such cases, but ultimately finds no exceptional grounds for granting bail. It dismisses the petitions, holding custodial interrogation is necessary and recovery should proceed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 45 of 2023

M/S JEEVAN TELECASTING CORPORATION LTD. v. STATE OF KERALA and ASIANET SATELLITE COMMUNICATION LTD.

This matter concerns Crl.M.C. No. 45 of 2023 filed under Section 482 CrPC to quash Annexure-A3 in CC 2924/2015, pending before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-XII, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioner, Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd., contends that even if a legally enforceable debt existed and a cheque was dishonoured, liability was fully discharged by subsequent payments, evidenced by Annexure A4 showing a Rs. 30,00,000 payment via demand draft on 30.12.2015 against cheque No. 286948 for Rs. 5,89,890 dated 07.11.2014. Therefore, the substratum of the complainant’s case purportedly ceased, and continuing the prosecution would be an abuse of process. The second respondent contends that payments were made under an agreement and did not discharge the cheque obligation; bank statements alone cannot establish discharge without examining the bank manager. The court reiterates Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi principles for quashing a complaint, emphasizing that quashing is warranted only when the allegations do not prima facie disclose an offence, when there is abuse of process or absence of essential legal ingredients, and that such power must be exercised with caution. After considering the material, the court held that the substrate persisted and that trial evidence is necessary; accordingly, the petition to quash was dismissed as meritless.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 810 OF 2022

Shinoj.T v. State of Kerala and Sree Gokulam Chit and Fin. Co. (P) Ltd.

Shinoj.T, the revision petitioner, challenges a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act for issuing a cheque that dishonoured due to insufficient funds. The trial court sentenced him to one month imprisonment and directed payment of Rs. 40,427 as fine, with default imprisonment for one month. The Additional Sessions Court affirmed the conviction and sentence. The High Court of Kerala exercised its revisional jurisdiction under Cr.P.C. sections 397 and 401, hearing the matter and emphasising that revisional power is supervisory, not appellate, and should intervene only to prevent miscarriage of justice or when there is a gross error, perverse finding, or non-consideration of material. The court relied on key Supreme Court precedents (State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri; Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan; Kishan Rao) to reiterate limits on re-appreciation of evidence in revision and to stress that the ordinary effect of revisional power is not to substitute an alternate view. The judgment also discusses the well-settled law on presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act, including the burden on the accused to rebut the presumption, drawing on Bir Singh and Rangappa. The revision petition was partly allowed: the substantive sentence was reduced to one day’s imprisonment, the fine of Rs. 40,427 was to be paid as compensation under Sec. 357(1)(b), and the accused granted one month to pay with surrender by 24.12.2022, with execution stayed pending surrender.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 2960 of 2008

Chandran v. State

Chandran, accused No.2, challenges the Kalpetta Sessions Court’s 27 November 2008 conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possession of 3.5 litres of arrack seized on 14 October 2006. The trial court convicted accused No.2 while acquitting others and imposed two years’ rigorous imprisonment plus a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. On appeal, the defence pressed two core grounds: (i) discrepancy in sample labeling—PW1 marked bottles as A1 and B1, while the Chemical Examiner’s certificate referred to bottles 1 and 2; (ii) lack of any satisfactory explanation for custody and transit of the sample from seizure to laboratory, including non-examination of officials who handled the sample. The defence argued that such gaps cast doubt on the chain of custody and the integrity of Ext.P9 (Certificate of Chemical Analysis). The court relied on apex court authorities emphasizing that merely producing a laboratory report is not conclusive; the sample tested must be co-related with the sample seized, and tamper-proof custody must be established. Consequently, the court found the prosecution failed to prove the link between the contraband seized and the sample analyzed, and held that Ext.P9 has no evidentiary value. The appeal is allowed and accused No.2 is acquitted, with the conviction and sentence set aside.”

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 12884 OF 2022

Asokkumar P.C. v. Superintendent of Police Aluva (Rural) and Others

This writ petition challenges threats to life and property and seeks a writ of mandamus to ensure protection to the petitioner’s possession of approximately 10.11 acres evidenced by Exts P1 (settlement deed) and P2 (sale deed). The petitioner’s father purchased the property from the 4th respondent in 2006; the 5th respondent is the wife of the 4th. The 5th respondent has filed OP No. 1428/2020 in the Family Court seeking cancellation of Exts P1 and P2, while alleging that the house on the property constitutes a “shared household” under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act. She also pursued a residence order, which was refused (Ext P10). The petitioner has lodged police complaints (Ext P6) and produced Exts P11 FIR and Ext P12 final report. Respondents 4 and 5 claim possession of the property and rely on civil proceedings to cancel the titles. The court notes Exts P1 and P2 are admitted and focuses on their validity. Relying on Jithesh v. State of Kerala and Others (2013 KHC 674), the court notes that challengers cannot take the law into their own hands and must abide by the forum’s decision. The writ petition is allowed with directions for adequate police protection, subject to orders in Ext P4 or other proceedings in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.16458 of 2023

SMITHA.S v KERALA STATE HANDLOOM DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION (HANVEEV) and others

Smitha S, a Quality Control Inspector at the Balaramapuram Production Centre under the Kerala State Handloom Development Corporation (KSHDC), filed WP(C) 16458 of 2023 seeking to quash Ext.P2, a transfer order moving her from Thiruvananthapuram to Kannur. She had joined the present station on 23.02.2021 and alleges she has not completed tenure; the order transfers the only woman employee in the post of Quality Control Inspector, while her juniors are retained in Thiruvananthapuram. The transfer would place her about 410 kilometres away and affects her family—her husband works in Thiruvananthapuram and has two school-going children. She contends the transfer is to accommodate the 5th respondent. The petition relies on Ext.P1 Transfer Guidelines, specifically para 6(ii), which provides that women should not be transferred to distant stations to the extent possible. The 5th respondent had been transferred to Kannur in November 2022 for staffing needs; the petitioner contends the administration should consider family and health factors; interim orders allowed her to continue at Balaramapuram until 29.05.2023. The Standing Counsel contends the transfer policy Ext.R1(a) governs transfers and the petitioner has no vested right to retention. The court noted no statutory rules contravene the transfer, and that the matter requires administrative consideration. It disposed the petition, directing the 1st respondent to consider Ext.P5 and pass orders within two weeks after hearing the 5th respondent, with liberty to file a supplementary statement. The court also observed cadre strengths and administrative convenience in Kannur were relevant factors.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 28369 OF 2014

GeeYem Motors Pvt. Ltd. v. Sreeja Sivadas, The President, Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Thrissur; The State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission; The State of Kerala

GeeYem Motors Pvt. Ltd., a Kochi-based automobile dealer, challenged an ex parte order of the Thrissur District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum (CDRF) that directed the delivery of a new Chevrolet Optra Magnum Diesel car for Rs. 17,520 and imposed Rs. 1,000 as costs. The petitioners contend that Ext. P1 was an ex parte order issued without proper notice and without furnishing a copy, violating due process. They discovered the order only upon receiving a notice of execution (Ext. P2), years after the initial January 2009 directive, and subsequently filed an appeal before the State Forum along with delay-condonation petition (Exts. P17–P18). The State Forum dismissed Exts. P19 and P20 (the appeal and the delay petition). The High Court, after examining the delay submissions, found the State Forum’s Ext. P18 procedure improper but ultimately concluded that delay in filing the appeal should be condoned and that Exts. P19 and P20 could be set aside. It directed the State Forum to dispose of Appeal No. 256/2014 expeditiously and stayed the operation of Ext. P1 until final orders. The judgment references Controller of Examinations v. Sreya to acknowledge that there is an alternate remedy, yet declines to relegate the petitioner entirely to those remedies in the circumstances, preserving interim relief during the appellate process.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 13509 OF 2021

Sagar A.R et al. v APJ Abdul Kalam Technological University and Others

This writ petition challenges the decision of APJ Abdul Kalam Technological University to conduct offline end‑semester examinations for odd semesters I and III (B.Tech), despite UGC guidelines issued in July 2021, which the petitioners contend have statutory force for the 2020–21 academic session. Eight students seek to quash the university’s Exhibits P12, P14, and P15 and request alternative modes of assessment (CGPA-based internal evaluation or online exams) or a re-scheduling of exams in line with UGC directives. The university argues that only three examinations remain and that there is no ready online testing software, asserting that the 2021 guidelines cannot help the intermediates and that offline examinations are necessary to ensure proper evaluation. The court recaps the legal framework: APJ Abdul Kalam Technological University Act of 2015; AICTE guidelines; UGC guidelines (2020–21) and the Supreme Court’s decision in 2020 recognizing UGC guidelines as having statutory force. It concludes that the contested offline schedule (Exhibits P12, P14, P15) conflicts with the binding UGC framework and COVID protocols. The judgment quashes these notifications, holds that examinations must be scheduled strictly as per UGC guidelines, cancels earlier S1 and S3 examinations, and directs the university to issue new schedules with public notice, consistent with health guidelines and safety measures.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.1524 of 2012

Aisha W/o Abdul Khader v Xavier S/O Lonappan, Santosh S/O Adima, National Insurance Company Limited

This MACA challenges the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal’s pay-and-recovery order in OP (MV) No.202/2007 of Perumbavoor, where the Tribunal held that the Insurance Company could recover the compensation paid to the injured from the owner and driver because the driver’s licence was found fake. The appellant-owner contends she bona fide believed the driver’s licence to be genuine and assessed his driving competence at the time of appointment; she argues there was no duty to ascertain whether the original Chennai RTO licence was genuinely issued, especially since the licence presented was renewed locally. The insurer contends that, since the licence was forged and the owner failed to verify its validity, it cannot indemnify the insured, relying on the driver’s liability for the fraudulent act and on case law that permits recovery from the owner when misrepresentation is involved. The High Court relies on Supreme Court and Kerala High Court precedents to distinguish when renewal can or cannot validate a fake licence and to reaffirm that the owner is not required to undertake exhaustive verification of every licence. It holds that the renewal of a potentially fake licence from a local authority does not render it genuine, but the owner’s bona fide belief shields her from restitution of the amount to the insurer. Consequently, the appeal is allowed; the impugned award’s recovery against the owner is set aside, with the insurer remaining liable for compensation to the injured party; no costs are awarded.

High Court of Kerala
MACA.No.2663 OF 2010(C)

SREEDEVI KANAMKUMARATH HOUSE v. V.N. ASOKAN, VIJAYAKUMAR, THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD.

This appeal arises from an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thrissur, in OP(MV) No.2443/2004. On 01-10-2002 the appellant, then 46 years old, sustained serious injuries when a motorcycle (KL 8 H 2983) driven rashly by the 2nd respondent struck her while she was crossing a public road. The appellant, a milk trader, claimed a monthly income of Rs. 4,000 and permanent disability; the Tribunal found the 3rd respondent insurer liable but awarded only Rs. 63,100 with 8% interest, directing recovery from the 1st respondent for breach of policy. Dissatisfied, the appellant challenged the quantum in MACA 2663/2010, contending that notional income and heads of compensation should reflect actual loss and the extent of disability. The respondents contend the accident occurred due to the appellant’s crossing, that the 2nd respondent did hold a valid license, and that the claim of liability and damages was excessive; they emphasize policy breach and argue the award should not be enhanced. The High Court relies on Supreme Court precedents like Pranay Sethi, Ramachandrappa and Syed Sadiq to recalibrate notional income and assess damages under the principles of fairness, reasonableness and equitability. After reappreciating the evidence, it fixes notional income at Rs. 3,500/month, holds disability at 16%, and enhances several heads of compensation, ultimately allowing the appeal in part and directing an additional Rs.95,800 with 8% interest, to be deposited within two months.”

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 162 of 2019

Ayyappan v. Jacob, United India Insurance Company Ltd., Ammini Chackappan, Jancy Jose and Joseph Jose

The appellant, Ayyappan, seeks enhancement of compensation awarded in O.P.(MV) No.99 of 2016 by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakuda, arising from a motor-vehicle accident on 07.02.2015 in which an auto-rickshaw he drove was struck by a car driven by the 1st respondent. The Tribunal held the claimant 25% contributorily negligent, awarded Rs.3,26,592, and directed the insurer (2nd respondent) to deposit Rs.2,44,944 with 8% interest and costs. The appellant challenged the contributory negligence finding and the adequacy of compensation, while the insurer questioned the negligence and liability issues, arguing lack of licence, fitness certificate, and insurance for the auto. The High Court, while noting Exts A1–A9 and Ext X1, found merit in the appellant’s grievance on contributory negligence, applying Pazhaniammal’s principle that police final reports, in the absence of contra-evidence, should guide negligence findings; Ext A3 showed the First Respondent’s involvement, and mere absence of licence or fitness cannot by themselves fix negligence. The Court also re-evaluated quantum, accepting a higher monthly income of Rs.13,000 for 2015 given the driver’s skilled status, and applying 17.6% permanent disability. This yielded an additional sum of Rs.2,96,272 to be deposited by the insurer within three months. The appeal is allowed in part, with enhanced compensation and directions to deposit."

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl) No. 321 of 2022

M. GOPALAKRISHNA PILLAI v. STATE OF KERALA AND OTHERS

The petitioner, M. Gopalakrishna Pillai, is an accused in a Vigilance case (VC No. 2/2005/SCE) under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, who seeks judicial intervention under Article 226 of the Constitution to compel further investigation into the allegations recorded in the final investigation report. The matter traces to CC No. 36/2011 before the Special Court at Thrissur, subsequently transferred to CC No. 351/2016 at Muvattupuzha. The petitioner contends that the Investigating Officer ignored vital documents that could show no offence and argued that exhibits such as Exts P2 (bank passbook for his wife), P3 (sale agreement dated 24.01.2005), P5 (lease/rent documents), and P6–P7 representations, among others, reveal that the assets and income alleged to be disproportionate could be lawful or not conclusively proven, and that omitted materials should have been considered. The Special Government Pleader counters that the investigation already weighed the materials and that matters of evidence, including those cited by the petitioner, can be addressed during trial. The Court endorses the principle that investigation may be continued to uncover further evidence post-filing of a report, citing Apex Court precedents on the scope of further investigation under Cr.P.C.173(8) and related authorities. The petition is allowed in part: VACB is directed to conduct further investigation within the prescribed framework, the petitioner may produce materials, and the trial shall be deferred until the further report is submitted, with a three-month deadline for completion of the investigation after certification of this judgment.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 9201/2019

SREEKANTH SASIDHARAN v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case filed to quash Annexure A1 FIR No. 401/2019 of Peramangalam Police Station under section 482 Cr.P.C. The petitioner, Sreekanth Sasidharan, is accused in offences under sections 406, 420 and 376 IPC. The prosecution alleges that, between 2010 and 31 March 2019, the petitioner, by giving a false promise of marriage, had sexual intercourse with the 4th respondent on several occasions in India and abroad, and that he induced her to part with Rs. 15,00,000 and five sovereigns of gold; thereby allegedly committing cheating and criminal breach of trust, and rape. The defence contends that the relationship was consensual, the material does not reveal all the ingredients of the charged offences, and quashing is warranted because the FIR does not disclose a cognizable offence on the face of the documents. The High Court scrutinises the scope of its inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C., citing Kurukshetra University v. State of Haryana, Muniswamy, Bhajan Lal and subsequentNil prsent authorities, emphasizing restraint and the rarity of quashing. It notes that Neeharika and related decisions limit the court to assessing whether cognizable offences are disclosed, not the merits. After examining the evidence (including FI statements and 164/161 Cr.P.C materials), the court finds the allegations insufficient to constitute rape, cheating, or criminal breach of trust, and concludes the ongoing prosecution would not serve ends of justice. Consequently, the FIR is quashed and Crl.M.C. is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P.No.699/2005

Vasanthakumari and Ratheesh v. State of Kerala

Vasanthakumari and Ratheesh faced trial for offences under sections 326, 324, 323 read with section 34 IPC, arising from an incident on 30.4.2001 at Konnerikunne where PW1 sustained injuries and PW2 was assaulted. The trial court convicted them and imposed imprisonment and fines; the Sessions Court, on appeal, affirmed the conviction but reduced the sentences. The present criminal revision petition challenges the conviction, contending that the prosecution’s case rested on the testimony of PW1, whose account contained serious inconsistencies with his police statements and was not fully corroborated by PW2–PW4 and PW8; the alleged starting point of the assault was not supported by independent witnesses. The High Court scrutinized the evidence in light of the safeguards for a fair trial and the obligation to put material facts separately to the accused under section 313 Cr.P.C. It held that despite the trial court’s credibility findings, the case rested on contradictions and omissions in PW1’s account and on a flawed examination under 313 Cr.P.C. The court invoked its revisional powers under Cr.P.C. sections 397 and 401 to correct manifest illegality or miscarriage of justice and concluded that the conviction and sentence cannot stand, acquitting the petitioners. The decision underscores stringent requirements of the 313 Cr.P.C process and the scope of revisional intervention.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 28461 of 2018 (and connected cases)

WP(C) Nos.28461/2018 & connected cases, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This batch of writ petitions challenges the termination of provisional empaneled KSRTC employees (drivers, conductors, mechanics) and seeks regularisation under the 2008 Bipartite Settlement between KSRTC and its unions and government directives. The petitions trace the regulatory path: in 2011 the Government issued GO 22/12/2011, conditioning regularisation on ten years of service; in 2013 GO 21/11/2013 added a requirement of 120 days of duty per year. KSRTC later terminated many employees in 2018 for not meeting the 120-day-per-year criterion by 21.12.2011, despite prior regularisations obtained through various orders and judgments. The petitioners argued that several employees had already secured regularisation through earlier judgments and that applying the 120-day requirement retrospectively would nullify vested rights. They also contended that the Supreme Court had, in Civil Appeals Nos. 4435-4438/2017, held that the government’s 21.11.2013 conditions could be applied; the High Court’s prior view in Suresh Kumar (2013) was thus superseded, and the retrospective effect of GO 21/11/2013 needed scrutiny. The present judgment, by Justice Devan Ramachandran, clarifies binding effect under Article 141 and the Supreme Court’s declarations. It sets aside the impugned termination orders, directs a hearing with documentary verification, and lays out a framework: if a petitioner proves ten years of service and 120 days per year by 21.12.2011, regularisation should be ordered within three months; otherwise, termination may follow. Pension and family benefits are addressed for those already superannuated or deceased.