M.F.A(Forest) No.95 of 2005 This is a Forest MFA appeal arising from three OA/Forest Tribunal proceedings (OA Nos. 3/2003, 4/2003 and 5/2003) challenging dispossession from scheduled lands in a vested forest area at Palakkad, Malampuzha. The petitioners—Mathew, Thresiamma (deceased) and T.A. Thomas—along with the LR of the deceased 2nd appellant, claimed separate possession over sub-scheduled plots A, B and C, citing documentary evidence (A1–A26), improvements (house, cattle shed, farm house), and earlier cairns that purportedly excluded the lands from vesting under the Kerala Private Forests (Vesting & Assignment) Act, 1971. The Forest Tribunal held that the department established no valid evidence that the lands were not private forest and rejected the S.3(2) claim for lack of a registered lease document; it highlighted inconsistencies in lease dates and found tax receipts insufficient to prove possession as on 10 May 1971 and noted the lack of title evidence in respect of the 2nd petitioner. The earlier OA (and related suits) were found not to advance a clear ground. The High Court, reviewing the Tribunal’s reasoning, did not find grounds to interfere, and dismissed the appeals with costs, upholding the Vesting Act regime and the department’s position.
This writ appeal is filed by the State of Kerala challenging the learned Single Judge’s judgment dated 05.01.2024 in WP(C) Nos. 2945/2022 and 29569/2021, which quashed several steps in the land acquisition process under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (LARR Act) for widening NH 66. The Single Judge struck down Ext. P14 series orders, Ext. P6 (Expert Group) recommendation, Ext. P7 GO, and Ext. P9 notification, on grounds that the Expert Group evaluating the Social Impact Assessment (SIA) report did not include the mandated two representatives from local bodies (Panchayats/municipalities) as required by Section 7(2) read with Section 7(2)(b) of the Act. The State contends that the Expert Group was constituted in compliance with Section 7, and that GO dated 29.06.2016 authorized district collectors to appoint the Expert Group with multi-disciplinary representation, including a woman member from the local body. Respondents argue that inclusion of Panchayat/Grama Sabha representatives is mandatory and mandatory non-compliance vitiates the process. The High Court, by a Division Bench, dismisses the appeal, holding that the statutory mandate under Section 7 requires two representatives from the relevant local bodies in the Expert Group when land from a Panchayat/Municipality area is involved, and that mere hearing at the SIA report stage cannot substitute this requirement. The court clarifies that if the land involves multiple local bodies, two representatives from each affected body must be included. The appeal is dismissed, upholding the Single Judge’s order. Overall, the decision reinforces the participatory and transparent framework intended by the LARR Act and emphasizes strict compliance with its appointment provisions for Expert Groups.
This Kerala High Court revision concerns fixation of fair rent under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The Rent Control Court, Alappuzha, had fixed fair rent at Rs. 10,000 per month with a 5% annual increase, applying the guidelines in Edgar Ferus v. Abraham Itticheriya. On appeal, the Rent Control Appellate Authority (Additional District Judge-III, Alappuzha) re-appreciated the evidence and, considering the locality and comparables, raised the minimum rent to Rs. 15,000 per month with an 8% annual increase. The tenants (revision petitioners) filed this revision petition under Section 20 challenging the Appellate Order, contending that the petition schedule shop is an old, dilapidated building of about 3,132 sq ft; thus its value and rent should not be high. They pointed to the original rent of Rs. 100 and later increased to Rs. 1,000 per month, and argued that any further enhancement would be detrimental. A commissioner measured the premises; Exts. A1–A3 are notices; Ext. C1 is the commissioner's report, showing area around 3132.18 sq ft. PW1–PW3 furnished local rent comparisons and evidence; the court relied on Edgar Ferus and later Supreme Court decisions, cautioning revisional courts to confine scrutiny to legality, regularity and propriety, not re‑appreciation of evidence. The High Court concluded the Appellate Authority’s quantification was sound and dismissed the revision petition.
This High Court appeal arises from MACA 2157/2012 filed by the petitioners in O.P.(M.V.) No. 66/2006 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Alappuzha. The petitioners, wife and children of the deceased Rajendran, challenged a MACT award under Sec.166 MV Act after their father/husband died in a motor vehicle collision involving a tempo van on 8 November 2005. The Tribunal held that there was contributory negligence by the deceased of 25% while holding the respondents liable jointly and severally. The appellants argued that the police final report (Ext. A7) creates a presumption of negligence against the tempo van driver and that the Tribunal erred in relying on scene mahazar entries. They urged future prospects be considered and that the monthly income be recomputed following Pranay Sethi; they also invoked Magma General Insurance Co. v. Nanu Ram for enhanced consortium. The High Court accepted these contentions to an extent: it set aside the Tribunal’s contributory negligence finding, recomputed dependence with future prospects and enhanced the consortium, funeral expenses, and other heads, resulting in an enhanced total of Rs. 4,58,875 with 7.5% interest from the date of application. The award is to be distributed equally among appellants.
This Kerala High Court bail application arises from Crime No.39/2024 at Mannarkkad Police Station, Palakkad, involving two accused entities alleged to have fabricated a family membership certificate to exclude the names of a widow and two children of late Avarachan, thereby facilitating property interests. The second accused, Sivaprasad K.S., contends he acted only as a scribe and executed the sale deed based on the certificate handed to him by the first accused; he asserts he had no knowledge of the family composition and custodial interrogation is unnecessary, with no recovery contemplated against him. The prosecution counters that he was instrumental in creating the forged document to shield the real beneficiaries, arguing that custodial interrogation and recovery of forged certificates are essential for proper investigation, and that granting pre-arrest bail would hamper proceedings. The court, invoking Supreme Court precedents on Section 438 CrPC, emphasizes that anticipatory bail is an extraordinary remedy to be granted in exceptional circumstances; arrests are to be avoided unless imperative. After examining the materials, the judge finds prima facie incriminating elements against the petitioner and is not persuaded that exceptional grounds exist to grant pre-arrest bail, thus dismissing the application. However, the order directs that if the petitioner surrenders within one week, he shall be interrogated and produced before the jurisdictional Court, which may consider bail on merits thereafter.
WP(C) NO. 10612 OF 2024 & con.cases This judgment of a single bench of the Kerala High Court (Judge: T.R. Ravi) consolidates WP(C) Nos. 10612 of 2024 and numerous connected petitions pertaining to cybercrime investigations and freezing of bank accounts across multiple states and banks. The petitions arise from police/intimation notices freezing account funds due to alleged online financial fraud. The court notes the practice of freezing accounts pursuant to police requisitions and emphasizes that interim measures must confine freezes to the amounts actually mentioned in the police notice, so as to protect petitioners’ ability to carry out ordinary banking transactions. The court cites prior constitutional and High Court precedents (including Dr. Sajeer v RBI, 2023 KHC Online 661) and directs respondent banks and police authorities to adhere to the principle of restricting freezes to the specified sums, while maintaining the option for banks to continue or lift the freeze based on police information. The judgment also records that numerous petitioners, ranging from banks, cooperatives, and individuals across states, have sought relief from bank account freezes. The court disposes of the writ petitions with directions to limit freezes to the amounts in the police requisitions or notifications, and to provide timely information to petitioners; petitioners may approach the court again if freezes persist beyond the notified limits. The decision is a pragmatic remedial framework balancing investigative needs with banking functionality.
Reghuvaran Nair, the appellant, challenged the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram, award in OP(MV) 169/2003 arising from an accident on 30 August 2002 when he was a pillion rider on scooter KEV-5672 and was struck by a bus KL-15-1776 owned by the first respondent and insured by the fourth respondent. Appellant, a timber merchant, claimed Rs 10 lakh as compensation, with Rs 6 lakh sought. The Tribunal allowed part of the petition, awarding Rs 3,68,601 with interest and costs against the insurer. The High Court re-evaluated several heads of compensation, notably fixing the appellant’s monthly income on a notional basis at Rs 5,000 per month in light of limited proof (Ext.A7) and the year 2002, citing Chameli Devi to justify notional income when evidence is scant. It increased loss of earnings to Rs 25,000, fixed disability at 20% per Ext.A6, and, applying the Sarla Varma multiplier of 14, recalculated the loss due to disability, bystander expenses, extra nourishment, pain and sufferings, and loss of amenities, leading to a total enhanced award of Rs 5,11,981 (from Rs 3,68,601). The appeal was allowed in part, granting an additional Rs 1,43,380 with 7% interest and Rs 15,000 costs, with directions for deposit within 60 days and subsequent disbursement to the appellant as per law. The judgment clarifies insurer liability and confirms a modified but substantial compensation uplift.
This is a writ petition filed in the Kerala High Court challenging the implementation of the Malayalam Language Learning Act, 2017 (Act 8 of 2017) in Idukki district and seeking relief to appoint petitioners as Part-Time High School Assistants (Malayalam) in Government High Schools, in line with the rank list (Exhibit P3) and RTI disclosures (Exhibit P4(a)). The petitioners allege that Malayalam must be taught as a compulsory language in all schools, per the Act, and that there are about 12 government schools in Idukki district where Malayalam is not taught. They seek an implementation of Exhibit P1 (Malayalam Language Learning Act) in full scope, appointment of rank holders from Exhibit P3 to indicated posts, extension of the validity of the rank list, and reporting of vacancies that would arise if Exhibit P1 had been implemented, from 10/4/2018 to 22/4/2024. The respondents deny maintainability in this court, arguing that the matter falls under the Kerala Administrative Tribunal and that the State may pursue a phased, policy-driven approach, including daily-wage appointments for Tamil/Kannada medium schools under Act 2017 objectives. The court surveys settled principles: recruitment is an invitation, not an indefeasible right to appointment; a balance must be struck between merit and policy; and tribunals may review constitutional validity but a writ petition in this court is not maintainable for recruitment matters. It ultimately holds that the petition is not maintainable under S.15(1) of the Administrative Tribunals Act and directs returning the petition, with permission to approach the Kerala Administrative Tribunal. No costs."
W.P.(C) No. 23389 of 2021 The petitioner, Travancore Devaswom Employees' Sangh, filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging Ext.P2, a notification dated 01.10.2021 issued by the 2nd respondent calling for a referendum to grant recognition to the petitioner’s union under the Travancore Devaswom Board, and Exts.P7 and P8 orders issued by the 1st respondent. It also sought a mandamus to postpone the referendum previously scheduled for 28-30 October 2021 due to the disturbed state of the state, and a direction to the 2nd respondent to consider Ext.P6 representation after affording hearing. The petition, admitted on 27.10.2021, was accompanied by urgent notices to respondents 4–8. The court issued an interim order allowing postponement subject to outcome of the petition. By 2022, issues arose concerning the admissibility and completeness of Ext.P1, with admissions of non-disclosure of full documents, and the petitioner’s counsel conceding the reliefs had become infructuous. Relying on principles from R. v Kensington Income Tax Commissioners (1917) and Prestige Lights Limited v. State Bank of India (2007), the court held that suppression of material facts and lack of candor justify exercise of writ jurisdiction with caution. Ultimately, the writ petition was dismissed as infructuous, with strong censure of the petitioner’s conduct in withholding facts.
WP(C) Nos.23186 of 2022 & connected cases These connected writ petitions, filed by managers of private aided higher secondary schools in Kerala, challenge Government Order G.O.(MS.) No.121/2022/G.Edn. dated 07.07.2022 and the Plus One admission prospectus for 2022-23. The key controversy centers on the Government’s policy to fix the management quota in private aided higher secondary schools at 20% (reducing from 30%), while providing for a 10% community quota for the declared community of the management, to be admitted on merit. Petitioners contend this scheme violates Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution and distorts merit and secular principles; they seek quashing of the 10% community quota and restoration of 30% management quota without community carve-outs. The State counters that the policy corrects historical anomalies, enhances transparency, and ensures merit through the Centralized Allotment Process (CAP). The Court, led by Justice Raja Vijayaraghavan V, holds that: (a) GO(MS.) No.121/2022/G.Edn. fixing 20% management quota is not liable to interference; (b) the 10% community quota and the rider that non-declarant managements must convert that seat to merit are unconstitutional as violative of Article 14 and 15; (c) admissions already made under declarations shall stand; (d) the 10% seats should be treated as open merit seats and filled through CAP. The petitions are disposed of with directions to implement the open-merit remedy for the annulled community seats.
W.P. (C) Nos.38632/2018, 38633/2018 & 37030/2018 These writ petitions challenge a 22.04.2017 staff-fixation revision issued by the District Educational Officer, Chavakkad, revising the staff strength for 2007-08 to 2009-10 on an audit objection raised by the Accountant General. The petitioners, teachers at High School Pengamukku, contend that audit objections cannot nullify fixation orders already issued under Chapter XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules (KER) and that the original fixation had become final through approvals and salary payments. They rely on Usuvathunnisa v. Asst. Educational Officer and Somanatha Panicker v. State of Kerala to argue that audit findings cannot override statutory orders and that any correction must follow the statutory channels (Rule 12, 12C, 12D, 12E(3), 12F) and provide an opportunity for representation. The counter-affidavit asserts that the AG audit uncovered bogus admissions, transfers, and removals, justifying the revision to align staff with actual enrolment. The court, applying the Kerala Education Rules framework and the cited precedents, holds that audit objections alone do not render fixation illegal; the remedy lies in the statutory revision process by higher authorities. Consequently, the impugned orders are quashed and the petitioners are entitled to relief, including disbursement of salary and related benefits within three months.
TR.P.(C) Nos. 227/2022 and 466/2022 Two transfer petitions, TR.P(C) Nos. 227/2022 (filed by the wife Indu S. against her husband Suneesh C. and his mother Lakshmikkutty Amma and Sunil Kumar M.C.) and TR.P(C) Nos. 466/2022 (filed by the husband against the wife), are disposed of by a common order of Justice C.S. Dias. The petitions relate to transfers of connected matrimonial proceedings: O.P.1019/2020 before the Family Court, Pathanamthitta (claims for return of gold ornaments and other belongings) and O.P.(HMA) No. 766/2022 before the Family Court, Ernakulam (for divorce). Indu S. contends that she has secured employment in Ernakulam and has a child studying in Pathanamthitta, making it difficult to attend proceedings there; she seeks transfer to Ernakulam for convenience and consolidation of proceedings. Respondents argue that Indu S.’s permanent residence remains in Pathanamthitta, that the Ernakulam address is not proven, and that the child’s schooling is in Pathanamthitta; they contend there is no bona fide basis for transfer and accuse the petitions of harassment. The Court relies on Silpa Shaji and Vidya Mundekkat to caution against automatic transfer on convenience alone and to emphasize discretionary transfer under Section 24 CPC. Ultimately, TR.P(C)227/2022 is dismissed, while TR.P(C)466/2022 is allowed: transferring O.P.(HMA)No.766/2022 from Ernakulam to Pathanamthitta, with liberty to consolidate, and records to be transmitted to Pathanamthitta.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5110 OF 2024 This Kerala High Court bail petition concerns a sole accused, Aboobacker Siddique, in Crime No. 249/2024 of Kumbla Police Station, Kasaragod, charged with offences under Sections 376(2)(n) IPC and Section 6 r/w Section 5(j)(ii)(l) of the POCSO Act, allegedly committed in the night between 7-8 January 2024. The applicant, who was remanded on 27 May 2024, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC on grounds of innocence, lack of concrete material tying him to the crime, and the fact that investigation is now complete with the final report laid on 29 June 2024; he has no prior criminal antecedents, and detention for roughly two months is unwarranted. The State counters that the offences are heinous and there is a real possibility of intimidation of the victim or tampering with witnesses if released, though it concedes that the investigation is complete and there is no antecedent. The court, invoking the bail principles under Dataram Singh, and the Article 21 jurisprudence in Hussainara Khatoon and State of Kerala v. Raneef, notes that bail is largely the rule and detention is an exception. After balancing the rival submissions and the stage of trial, the court grants bail conditioned on bond and multiple undertakings, including appearance on Saturdays, non-interference with witnesses, passport surrender, and restricted proximity to the victim’s taluk, while keeping the meris of the case open for future consideration.
This appeal (F.A.O. No.30 of 2022) arises from O.S. No.608 of 2012 in the Principal Sub Court, Palakkad, challenging an ex parte decree and a long delay in filing I.A. Nos. 3020 and 3021 of 2015 under Order XLIII, Rule 1(d) CPC. The Sub Court dismissed these applications on 8 November 2021. The appellants argue that the original defendant Thanka, an elderly, illiterate widow with rheumatism and asthma, could not appear due to illness and hard personal circumstances, and that summons were not duly received; she sought relief under Section 5 of the Limitation Act on sufficient cause. The respondent contends she received summons and notice in the attachment proceedings and that she acted with wilful negligence, constituting laches. PW1’s testimony is relied upon, and the respondent points to Exts. B1–B4 as proof of notice. The High Court, while acknowledging the long 1048-day delay, concludes that justice warrants permitting the appellants to contest on merits. Citing Lanka Venkatesaralu v. State of A.P. (AIR 2011 SC 1199) and Katiji (1987) 2 SCC 107, it affirms that “sufficient cause” is elastic and must serve ends of justice, and that liberal, reasonable conduct is required but not a license to ignore the law. It also recognizes the hardships of Thanka and family. The appeal is allowed with a Rs 10,000 cost, the ex parte decree is set aside, and the suit is restored for disposal within four months, with the parties to file written statements.
This criminal appeal challenges an order on an anticipatory bail petition filed by the first accused in Thiruvalla Police Station Case No. 1404 of 2022. The appellant, Akhilesh Sukumaran, faced charges under IPC sections 341, 294(b), 323, 427, 506 and 34, and under the SC/ST Act, 1989 (amendment 2015) sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s). He sought anticipatory bail under Cr.P.C. 438 before a Special Court under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, which was dismissed. The High Court, upon hearing the matter, noted that the First Information Report and additional statement did not prima facie establish that the accused insulted or intimidated a member of the Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe, nor did they show caste-based abuse in public view. Consequently, there appeared to be no prima facie case under the SC/ST Act, and the statutory bar under sections 18 and 18(A) of the SC/ST Act would not preclude considering anticipatory bail. The court relied on the ratio in Prathvi Raj Chauhan v. UOI to grant bail. It held that IPC offences are bailable and antecedents do not preclude bail in these circumstances. Accordingly, bail was granted subject to conditions: surrender by a specified date with interrogation before the IO, bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, and compliance with non-interference and trial-cooperation requirements. The court also clarified that its observations on lack of prima facie SC/ST offences do not bind trial and do not restrict further investigation or the eventual trial.
W. A. No. 1643 of 2021 & W. P. (C) No. 21078 of 2021 This is a consolidated challenge to the removal of a sandbar at the Thottappally Spillway in Alappuzha district and the concurrent segregation of atomic minerals from beach sand. The writ appeal by the petitioners in WA 1643/2021 and the public interest writ petition in WP(C) 21078/2021 are—by court order—materially connected due to the sandbar removal and the extraction/segregation of atomic minerals from the coastal sands. The appellants contend that sand removal amounts to mining without the necessary statutory clearances under the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 ( Act 1957 ), and under Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) notifications, 2011 and 2019, as well as under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986; they further argue that the State Government invoked the Disaster Management Act, 2005 to legitimize a mining-like activity, bypassing required clearances. The respondents—government departments and public sector undertakings KMML and IREL—contend that the sandbar removal is a disaster-management measure to ensure free flow of floodwaters in the Kuttanad region, supported by expert studies, and that DM Act, particularly Section 72, provides overriding effectiveness over inconsistent laws during disasters. The High Court held there is no mining lease and upheld the action as a disaster-management necessity. The petitions were ultimately dismissed, upholding the state’s approach to disaster mitigation and flood control.
BAIL APPL. NO. 9912 OF 2023; BAIL APPL. NO. 9920 OF 2023 The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, delivered a common order on 10 January 2024 in Bail Appl. Nos. 9912 of 2023 and 9920 of 2023 arising from Crime No.39/2023 of the Chevayur Police Station, Kozhikode, under the NDPS Act. The petitioners, Muhammed Assarudheen and Safnas, were arrested on 17 January 2023 in a case alleging possession of ganja amounting to roughly 27 kg, including 19.640 kg seized from a car and an additional 5.366 kg recovered from the house of the second accused, based on the alleged conspiracy among four accused. They contend they are innocent and falsely implicated; they emphasize that the initial quantity was only intermediate and not commercial, there are two other accused, and they have no criminal antecedents, having spent nearly a year in custody. The State Public Prosecutors conceded lack of antecedents and completed investigation but argued that the large quantity brings the matter within Section 37 of the NDPS Act, which disfavors bail. After examining the F.I.R. and materials, the court found reasonable grounds to believe the petitioners did not commit the offences and are not likely to re-offend on bail, thus diluting Section 37’s rigour. The applications were allowed, with bonds of Rs.1,00,000 and two solvent sureties each, and conditions including appearance before the IO, no tampering with witnesses, surrender of passports, addresses, and possible recoveries by the IO. The order cites Sushila Aggarwal for using bail conditions and IO recoveries.
This High Court of Kerala, in MACA No. 1586 of 2012, reviews an award under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, arising from a motor accident on 16.06.2008 involving buses KL-12B/5002 and KL-12B/4126. The minor claimant, represented by a guardian, sustained injuries and a 9% permanent whole-body disability. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kalpetta, held the 4th respondent (driver) negligent and the 2nd respondent (owner) vicariously liable, with the 3rd respondent (insurer) liable to indemnify the owner. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 41,650. The appellant contends that the quantum is inadequate, especially given the child victim’s disability and the need for non-pecuniary damages beyond the Second Schedule, urging reliance on Master Mallikarjun v. Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd., and related precedents to grant a lump-sum additional compensation for pain, suffering, loss of amenities, and future disability. The insurer argues the Award is just and no enhancement is warranted. The High Court elaborates on child-specific compensation, citing Mallikarjun and prior SC decisions (Hattangadi, Sapna, Irana, Michael) to emphasize non-pecuniary heads in multipronged damages. It ultimately allows the appeal, directing enhanced compensation of Rs. 67,750, with 6.5% interest from filing, payable by the insurer within two months, and requires the claimant to furnish bank details.
Geetha S., the absolute owner of 43.60 acres in Re-survey No. 309/5, Meenadu Village, Kollam, seeks to have the land re-classified in revenue records under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Rules, 2008 (Rules, 2008) by Ext.P1 Form-7, to change the land’s nature from paddy land to another category. She argues the land is a compact plot with coconut and other trees up to 25 years old and is wrongly described as paddy in revenue records. Ext.P1 was filed on 11.12.2019. The Village Officer’s Ext.P3 Mahazar notes the presence of long-standing trees and that the land is not suitable for paddy cultivation, while Ext.P4 suggests conversion of 39.24 acres upon payment of ₹7,06,320, a fee the petitioner contends is based on the market value of neighboring land and is illegal. The 7th respondent opposes, asserting suppression of material facts (including the petitioner’s crusher unit) and contending a boundary dispute manifests in O.S. Nos. 9/2018 (Sub Court, Kollam) and related proceedings, which would bar consideration of Ext.P1. The State contends the competent authority must decide in accordance with law. The court, while noting the pendency of related suits, holds that the petitioner’s statutory application remains capable of being considered under Rule 12 of the Rules, 2008. It directs the 3rd respondent to adjudicate Ext.P1 within one month and clarifies that findings in this judgment do not affect the pending disputes. The petition is allowed.
WA No. 1433 of 2022; WA No. 1510 of 2022; WA No. 1511 of 2022; WA No. 1585 of 2022 These intra-court appeals arise from a common judgment dated 13 July 2022 by a learned Single Judge dismissing writ petitions challenging Ext.P1, a Government notification amending the Kerala Education Rules, 1959 (KER) by inserting Rules in Chapter XXIII to curb bogus admissions and to regulate staff fixation in aided schools. The petitioners, comprising managers and teachers of several aided schools, contend that Rules 12(3), 12(4), 12(8) and accompanying provisions (including Rule 12(1)(i) rider, Rule 15, Rule 15A, Rule 17) are arbitrary, violative of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 (RTE Act) and inconsistent with the Kerala Education Act, 1958 (KEA) and KER. They argue the amendments impede rights under the RTE Act and undermine safeguards in the parent statute. The Government defends Ext.P1 as a valid exercise of rulemaking under Section 36 of KEA, aimed at preventing a drain on public funds due to bogus admissions and misrepresentation of pupil strength, and maintaining proper pupil-teacher ratios with UID-based verification. The High Court, applying established principles from Suresh C. v State of Kerala, Maharashtra State Board v Paritosh Kumarsheth, and Saregama India Ltd. v Next Radio Ltd., held that subordinate legislation need not be rejected for being unwise; it must accord with the parent statute and constitutional norms. It also discussed State of SNV UP (A.I.R. 2013 SC 1254) for validating UID-based verification and cautioned against impractical police involvement. The appeals are dismissed, upholding Ext.P1 and the rule amendments as valid.