Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 430 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO.433 OF 2020

Alavi Haji v. Muhammed Haneefa and Others

Alavi Haji, the petitioner, is the 3rd respondent in Final Decree proceedings FDIA 1788/2001 in O.S. No.252/2018 before the Munsiff, Parappanangadi. Before the preliminary decree was passed, the shares of respondents 6 and 7 were purchased by the petitioner, a fact not noticed while passing the preliminary decree or in the final decree. Consequently, the final decree allotted those shares to respondents 6 and 7 instead of transferring them to the petitioner, despite documentary title proof. The petitioner moved I.A.833/2018 under Section 152 CPC seeking correction of the final decree to reflect these transfers. The Munsiff dismissed Ext.P4 on 11.12.2019. The High Court notes that the petitioner produced title deeds evidencing the purchase of the shares and that the transfers among defendants should be accounted for at the time of final allotment. The petitioner relied on a Supreme Court decision, Niyamat Ali - Molla v. Sonargon Housing Co operative Society Ltd. & Others (AIR 2008 SC 225), to support the corrective relief. The court proceeded notwithstanding non-appearance of respondents, and held that the petition should have been allowed. It set aside Ext.P4, remitting I.A.833/2018 to the trial court to pass orders in accordance with law and this judgment, concluding that if the purchase of the shares by the petitioner is undisputed, correcting the decree would not prejudice other parties. The judgment also notes a postscript correction regarding the reference to O.S.252/2018 (later corrected to O.S.146/1999).

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1807 of 2012

BINU P.J. @ VINU v. RAZACK.C.H, NISHAD D.P. and UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD

This High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, hear MACA No.1807 of 2012 filed by the appellant Binu P.J. alias Vinu, challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kalpetta award dated 08.03.2012 in O.P(M.V) No.450/2009 arising from a motor vehicle accident on 14.08.2009 at 2:20 PM, involving auto-rickshaw KL-13/E 8635. The driver and owner did not contest the petition and were declared ex parte; the insurer denied negligence and disputed the quantum, while not adducing evidence. The Tribunal held negligence and awarded Rs.1,51,100 with 7.5% interest per annum, directing the insurer to deposit the amount within 30 days. On appeal, counsel for the appellant argued the compensation was inadequate and the Tribunal ignored evidence of higher salary (Ext. A8) and under-assessed earnings, bystander expenses, nourishment, travel, clothing, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities. The High Court, invoking Ramachandrappa v. Manger, fixed the claimant’s monthly income at Rs.7,000 (instead of Rs.4,000), and recalculated compensation across heads. The court awarded Rs.42,000 for loss of earnings (6 months), increased by Rs.30,000 over the Tribunal’s Rs.12,000 in that head; bystander and nourishment Rs.4,000 each (additional Rs.3,000 each); transportation Rs.5,000 (additional Rs.2,000); clothing Rs.500; pain and suffering Rs.10,000; loss of amenities Rs.10,000 (additional Rs.8,000). Reassessed disability and multiplier yielded total additional compensation of Rs.1,42,900, with 7.5% interest, to be deposited within one month. The MACA is allowed accordingly, enhancing the award."

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO.986 OF 2024

Aswanth M.C. v. State of Kerala

Aswanth M.C., the fourth accused in Crime No.2/2024 of the Meppayur Police Station, Kozhikode, seeks pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The case arises from a New Year night incident on 01.01.2024, when the de facto complainant and friends were returning after a function. The prosecution alleges that the accused halted the scooter, abused the complainant, removed the helmet, and struck him on the nose with the helmet, causing a nasal bone fracture; other accused slapped the complainant. The first accused, not the petitioner, is said to have caused the injury; however, the fourth accused is charged under Sections 341, 323, 324, 294(b), 326 and 506 read with Section 34 IPC. The petitioner contends innocence and argues there is no specific overt act attributed to him in the FIR; Annexure B shows there is no direct linkage; custodial interrogation is unnecessary, and no recovery is to be effected. The Public Prosecutor opposes the relief, contending the evidence indicates the petitioner’s involvement, that grant of anticipatory bail would hamper investigation, and that the petitioner has prior criminal antecedents. The court cites Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre and Sibbia to emphasize that anticipatory bail is discretionary and must be grounded in facts, balancing investigative needs with individual rights. It ultimately holds that no exceptional grounds are shown and denies pre-arrest bail, but directs surrender within 10 days, after which bail can be reconsidered on merits. If he fails to surrender, police may arrest.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1578 of 2012

Balasubramanian s/o Narayanan v. V.S. Nazar, Ayshabi Veedappara and The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

This is an appeal under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal Ottapalam’s award of Rs. 3,39,410 for injuries sustained by Balasubramanian in a 22-12-2008 motorcycle accident. The appellant contends that the Tribunal undervalued his claim, particularly by fixed monthly income (Rs. 3,000) and by decreasing the disability to 6% from PW2’s 9%, despite long inpatient treatment and a serious open fracture of the right leg. The High Court reviews the quantum heads—future loss of earning power, loss of earnings, bystander expenses, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities—considering relevant case law (Ramachandrapa; Syed Sadiq; Raj Kumar; Sarla Verma; Reshma Kumari; Pranay Sethi). It accepts a higher monthly income (Rs. 6,000), adopts a 9% whole-body disability (PW2’s assessment), and applies the Sarla Verma multiplier of 11, in light of Reshma Kumari and Pranay Sethi, to compute future loss of earning power. Result: enhanced compensation of Rs. 1,17,670 with 7.5% interest, payable within two months, no costs, liability unchanged. The order affirms insurer’s liability and fixes payment timelines.

High Court of Kerala
ITA Nos. 11/2008; 12/2008; 279/2010; 282/2010; 292/2010

Travancore Sugars and Chemicals Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Cochin

This batch of connected ITA appeals before a three-judge Division Bench of the Kerala High Court concerns the taxation of rental income earned by Travancore Sugars and Chemicals Ltd. (the assessee) from leasing its godown premises to KSBC, Bank/Police etc. for the assessment years 1999-2000 and other periods. The assessee claimed the rent as income from business, arguing that the rental arrangement was integral to its manufacturing business of IMFL and that the rental income formed part of the profits of its business by exploiting a business asset. The AO, Commissioner (Appeals) and the ITAT rejected this classification, treating the rental income as income from property. The matter touched on a contested legal issue: whether income from leasing a commercial asset can be treated as business income, and to what extent the “source of income” test governs classification under sections 14, 9, 10, and 12 of the Income Tax Act, 1962. In response, the Full Bench of this Court referred to a cluster of precedents (Malabar and Pioneer Hosiery; Sultan Brothers; Universal Plast; East India Housing; Karanpura Development; Shri Lakshmi Silk Mills; etc.) to lay down that there is no universal rule, and the determination is fact-specific. Ultimately, the court held that the Tribunal’s and authorities’ findings disallowing business income treatment were correct, and the appeals were dismissed in favor of the Revenue, with the questions answered against the assessee.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2303 OF 2024

Ananthakrishnan P.S v. State of Kerala

Ananthakrishnan P.S., the registered owner of vehicle KL-32-J-7787, seeks interim custody of the vehicle after it was seized on 16.08.2023 in connection with alleged offences under Sections 269 and 278 IPC, and Section 120(e) of the Kerala Police Act, 2011, for dumping septic waste into a public drain. He moved CMP No.4578/2023 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Alappuzha, under Section 451 Cr.P.C. but the magistrate dismissed the application on 10.01.2024, in line with a Division Bench directive in WP(C) No.7844 of 2023 directing that vehicles involved in dumping waste into drains or public places should not be released without the court’s permission. The petitioner challenges that order, arguing the seriousness of the alleged offense should be weighed against the benefit of not detaining a vehicle for an extended period, and that the long detention serves no one’s interests. The High Court acknowledges the public health hazard but also recalls Sundarbhai Ambalal Desai v. State of Gujarat (2002) 10 SCC 283, and Krishnan (2000) 7 SCC 80, to justify imposing safeguards to prevent recurrence. It ultimately imposes stringent conditions: a Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, a Rs.1,00,000 bank guarantee, an affidavit not to transfer, vehicle maintenance obligations, and a clause permitting invocation of the bank guarantee if similar offences recur, and releases the vehicle subject to these terms.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 28592/2019

Kubera Constructions Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition challenges Exts. P15 and P25, which refused payment of GST on top of the contract amount awarded for constructing a building in Techno City, Thiruvananthapuram by KSITIL. The petitioner, Kubera Constructions Pvt. Ltd., contends that under tender documents, correspondence, minutes of the pre bid meeting and the Ext P7 agreement, it was entitled to reimbursement of GST on the service portion of the works contract. It argues that the pre GST clarification and the tender notice contemplated payment of the service tax or GST on the service portion, and that the introduction of GST from 1 July 2017 did not extinguish the right to such reimbursement. The petitioner states it has paid substantial GST on supplies to KSITIL and relies on George C.A. v State of Kerala and Sebastian Jose v State of Kerala to support its position. The 5th respondent contends the case is untenable; the work order Ext P6 shows the award amount inclusive of all taxes. After GST the separate service tax does not exist; the pre bid meeting minutes were not binding on the petitioner, who did not participate; the dispute involves questions of fact and the petition is not maintainable. The court, while noting the letters and contract terms, holds that pre GST clarifications cannot override the GST regime, and that the petitioner is not entitled to relief. The petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 23186 of 2022 & connected cases

W.P.(C) Nos. 23186 of 2022 & connected cases (High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam) – challenging GO(M.S.) No.121/2022/G.Edn. and Plus One admission prospectus for 2022-23

These writ petitions (W.P.(C) Nos. 23186 of 2022 and connected cases) challenge Government Order GO(M.S.) No.121/2022/G.Edn. dated 07.07.2022 and the accompanying admission prospectus for Plus One (Higher Secondary) courses for the 2022-23 academic year. The Government reduced the Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools’ management quota to 20% and introduced a 10% community quota for the community to which the management belongs, with a rider that if a management does not declare its community, the 10% seats would be treated as merit seats under the CAP (Centralized Allotment Process). The petitioners, managers of PAHS, argue that this quota regime violates Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution, runs counter to prior Court directions and established jurisprudence that reservation for a management or community in education is inappropriate. The State defends the policy as a legitimate executive choice aimed at ensuring merit, transparency, and curb corruption, with CAP ensuring merit-based admission. The Kerala High Court, noting the policy-making nature of such decisions but treating them under constitutional scrutiny, holds that while 20% management quota is permissible, the 10% community quota is arbitrary and unconstitutional. It directs that the 10% seats be treated as open merit seats via CAP; adjourned or already-admitted cases under declarations shall stand. The petitions are disposed of accordingly, preserving the policy’s core merit-based objective while striking down the discriminatory community reservation.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 1408/2023

VIKAS KUMAR SAROJ v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a regular bail petition (B.A. No. 1408/2023) filed by the 1st accused, Vikas Kumar Saroj, in Crime No. 1921/2022 of Ernakulam Central Police Station, alleging crime under NDPS Act provisions (Sec. 20(b)(ii)B) and related Sections of COTPA. The police recovered substantial contraband including 7 kg of ganja mixed tablets and various packets, leading to charges under NDPS and COTPA; the final report had not been filed within the statutory 60 days. The petitioner, a first-time offender and a native of Uttar Pradesh, argued for bail on grounds that continued detention beyond the statutory period would be unwarranted, and sought conditional release pending investigation. The State contended that although there are no noted criminal antecedents, the final report was still pending and releasing the accused without safeguards could risk flight and tampering with evidence, especially given the scale of seizure and origin from outside Kerala. The Court considered the expiry of the statutory period but proceeded to assess risk and safeguards. It allowed bail on stringent conditions to secure the trial process and the accused’s appearance, including bond, Kerala-based sureties, identity documentation, and restrictions to prevent flight or interference with witnesses, while ensuring cooperation with investigation and adherence to court directions.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 99 of 2007

Criminal Appeal No. 99 of 2007 (Kerala High Court)

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal by appellants Kochu Mani and Jinu (accused nos. 3 and 5) challenging a conviction recorded by the Additional Sessions Judge (Adhoc) III, Kollam, for offences including theft following burglary at the residence of PW1, with gold ornaments and cash valued at approximately Rs. 1.55 lakh stolen on 10 March 2004. Though final report referred to Section 395 IPC, the trial court framed charges under sections 380, 454, and 461 read with Section 34 IPC, and convicted the appellants while others were acquitted. The prosecution relied on evidence of PWs 1-15, with recoveries of gold ingots under disclosure statements under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, affecting subsequent recoveries from PW2, PW4, PW11, and later. Several witnesses were hostile; several recoveries depended on the testimony of PW10 and PW13 alone. Amicus Curiae (Adv. Pooja Pankaj) attacked the conviction as based merely on Section 27 disclosures, arguing there is no independent corroboration linking the recovered items to the theft and stressing the limitations of Section 27 as explained in Rajeesh v. State of Kerala, Pulukuri Kottaya, and Muhammed Yousaf. The State maintained the recoveries and official witnesses’ testimony sufficed. The High Court accepted these submissions, held that conviction solely on Section 27 recoveries is unsafe, and allowed the appeal, acquitting the appellants and setting aside the trial court verdict.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 3004 OF 2013

Jacob Varghese v. The Commissioner of Land Revenue, Public Office Building, Thiruvananthapuram, and Others

This writ petition challenges the cancellation of a mutation effected in favour of the petitioner over land in Aluva East Village, following a decree and subsequent land records. The petitioner, Jacob Varghese, purchased 53.81 ares based on sale deeds in 2008 and obtained a possession certificate; tax receipts and mutation records indicated the land belonged to him from 2009. The State Bank of Travancore asserted title to 62 cents of the same land on the basis of a decree in OS 37/1977 and sought mutation of old survey nos. The mutation cancellation order Ext.P12 dated 14.11.2012, and the corresponding reports Exts.P13–P15 from the Land Revenue Commissioner, Deputy Collector (Vigilance) and Village Officer, were challenged as unjust and violative of natural justice. The Bank has also filed suit for declaration and possession (O.S. 141/2011) in which identity of the property remains contested; the petition notes that mutation does not confer title but is only a fiscal entry. The learned Judge held that the cancellation and the associated reports were made behind the petitioner's back and without due process, and that mutation cannot prejudice pending civil proceedings. The writ petition is allowed, with directions to quash Ext.P12 and Exts.P13–P15, and to refrain from revisiting mutation until finality of the civil suit, acknowledging the ongoing dispute over identity and title.

High Court of Kerala
L.A.A. No. 657 of 2014 & con. cases

L.A.A. No. 657 of 2014 & con. cases

These appeals and cross-objections arise from a batch of references under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1984, for lands acquired for the KINFRA Knowledge Park at Ramanattukara following a notification under Section 4(1) on 29.02.2008. The Land Acquisition Officer classified the lands, including wetlands abutting Panchayat roads, and fixed an initial value of Rs. 36,751.23 per Are, which the Reference Court enhanced to Rs. 80,000 per cent, a fixation challenged by both State and claimants. The State, represented by the Special Tahsildar (LA), contends that Ext. A1 (a 1996 sale deed) is the only document supporting the enhanced value but is dated long before the notification, and that higher, consistent values in other similar cases and mediated settlements (Rs. 95,000 to Rs. 99,750 per cent) should inform fair compensation. The claimants argue the reference court’s value is unreasonably low and rely on Ext. A1 and other material to justify higher compensation, noting the 12-year gap since notification and market realities. The Court cites Rajalakshmi v. Special Tahsildar (LA) Koyilandy, SC 2023, endorsing consideration of negotiated prices for identical lands, even if not binding. Ultimately, the Division Bench approves a balanced approach, fixes Rs. 2,22,300 per Are for the instant cases (subject to statutory benefits), dismisses most appeals, and allows cross-objections in several connected matters, with LA.A No. 369/2014 partially allowed, while closing pending interlocutory applications.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 16911/2021 and 17318/2021

WP(C) Nos. 16911 of 2021 and 17318 of 2021 – SnehaJ Kumar D.B. and others v State of Kerala and others

These are two connected writ petitions filed by teachers of M.C.H.S.S. Koottukalkonam, Neyyattinkara, challenging disciplinary actions arising from 2014-15 inspections that led to suspensions on charges of fake admissions. After a prolonged process, the Deputy Director of Education issued a charge memo and the petitioners were suspended in 2014 and reinstated in 2015. In 2020 a notice sought to recover Rs. 2,48,86,609 from teachers collectively for alleged government losses and to permanently deprive them of two increments as a major penalty. The Government later rejected revisions (Exts. P9/P10; P6/P8 in the other petition). The petitioners contended that the penalty was imposed without following due procedure under Rule 75, Chapter XIV(A) of the Kerala Education Rules (KER), and without a regular inquiry. They relied on Kerala decisions (Exts. P11/P12) and Kulwant Singh Gill’s dictum that “two increments with cumulative effect” amounts to a major penalty, requiring proper inquiry. The Court held that the impugned orders are unsustainable for lack of due procedure, and that there is no provision in KER to recover losses from a Headmistress. The petitions were disposed with directions, quashing the challenged orders and offering liberty to pursue salary arrears through proper channels, if applicable.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.36074 of 2022

NIRANJANA C. v. STATE OF KERALA & ORS

Niranjana C., a minor X standard student of SVHSS, Clappana, challenged Ext.P2, an order of the 3rd respondent (the Kerala School Sasthrolsavam Appeal Committee) which dismissed her appeal regarding participation in the Kerala State School Sasthrolsavam 2022-23 under the event ‘Still Model.’ Niranjana and her companion, Gouri, had participated in the Kollam Revenue District Social Science Fair 2022-23, with Niranjana and Gouri reportedly securing lower ranks (the petitioner contends that respondents 5 and 6 were ranked 1 and 2 in Ext.P1). The petition contends that the School Sasthrolsavam Manual, 2022-2023 restricts participation to the 1st prize A Grade winner, and that the ‘Still Model’ submission by Niranjana and her friend was superior and deserved higher marks. Counsel for the petitioner argues that school-level or appellate judges are not qualified to assess students’ performances, and that the ‘Still Model’ was the best. The Government Pleader counters that the evaluation was conducted by experts, considering creativity, originality, design and other factors, with higher marks allocated to higher-scoring entries. The Court, citing the need to avoid substituting its own view in academic matters and relying on expert evaluation, declines to interfere, referencing a principle from the Supreme Court (Maharashtra State Board v. Paritosh Bhupeshkumar Sheth). The writ petition is dismissed with no order as to costs, underscoring judicial restraint in educational matters.

High Court of Kerala
Mat.Appeal No.810 of 2022

Mat.Appeal No.810 of 2022

The Kerala High Court heard Mat.Appeal No.810 of 2022 challenging a Family Court order dated 03 November 2022 (I.A.5 of 2022 in O.P.780 of 2021) that recorded a compromise decree arising from a settlement between the wife (appellants) and the respondents in a matrimonial matter. O.P.780/2021 had been filed seeking to set aside a gift deed (No. 914 of 2019) and involved multiple related disputes including dissolution of marriage petitions, guardianship for the children, and maintenance matters. The Family Court recorded the compromise Ext. P1, and allowed the petition to the extent of the compromise, stating that the compromise would form part of the decree and that attachments would be lifted, while listing several other cases between the parties as being settled by the terms of the agreement. The appellants contend that Annexure A1 (the agreement) was misread; Annexure A2 (the judgment) purportedly states that all disputes between the parties are settled, which they argue extends beyond what was agreed, and was obtained by fraud. They seek review under Order XXIII, Rule 3 CPC, citing Ajanta LPP v. Casio and Janakiammal. The respondents argue the parties understood the terms and that once a compromise is lawful, courts must record it and decree accordingly; fraud permits recall by interlocutory application. The court, citing Sindhu P.K. and Thriloki Nath Singh, upholds that compromise must be recorded if lawful, but finds noncompliance with leave for minors and errors in Annexure A2, ultimately allowing the appeal and directing further proceedings in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 73 of 2020 (and connected cases: WP(C) Nos. 126/2020, 97/2020, 100/2020)

M.A. Latheef v. Appellate Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 & Controlling Authority (Pallikkere Islamic Education Society) – WP(C) Nos. 73/2020, 126/2020, 97/2020 & 100/2020, Kerala High Court

These connected writ petitions, filed by M.A. Latheef, Secretary of Pallikkere Islamic Education Society, challenge the orders of the Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and the Appellate Authority confirming gratuity awards to teachers who asserted continuous service in the Pallakkere Islamic Education Society’s school. The Controlling Authority found the teachers to be employees and the society to be their employer, computing gratuity on the basis of last drawn wages and proven periods of service. The petitioner failed to appear before the authority, while witnesses established that the teachers had worked for the statutory period and were entitled to gratuity. The Appellate Authority dismissed the appeals on the ground that they were filed beyond the statutory period under Section 7(7) of the Act. The Court had previously, in 2019, set aside a related order in W.P.(C.) No. 2198/2019 & Connected cases, directing disposal within a time frame. The petitioner argued that teachers are not employees under the Act and that private schools may be outside its ambit; they also claimed lack of opportunity to present evidence. Respondents contended that teaching staff are covered by the Act and that the authorities’ findings were properly supported by material. The Court, recognizing the Act as social welfare legislation to be liberally construed, found no error in the challenged orders, and dismissed the petitions without costs.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) Nos.197 & 201 of 2019

C. G. Varghese v. Alias Thomas

These Original Petitions (OP(C) Nos. 197 of 2019 and 201/2019) arise from a suit for specific performance (OS No.190 of 2006, Sub Court, Mavelikkara) and related counter-claim. The suit was dismissed for default on 6.11.2011, adjourned to consider the counter-claim on 30.11.2011 when no party appeared, and the counter-claim was decreed ex parte. The plaintiff filed I.A.1108/2014 and I.A.1109/2014 to restore the suit and condone the delay, along with I.A.1103/2014 and I.A.1104/2014 to set aside the ex parte decree in the counter-claim and condone further delay. The trial Court dismissed these applications, and the Additional District Court-I, Mavelikkara, confirmed the orders. The plaintiff contends that non-appearance was due to serious cardiac illness requiring bypass surgery, and thus was not wilful laches; he relies on medical exhibits to prove disability and asserts sufficient cause under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, and requests condonation of delay and restoration. The respondent contends that the plaintiff had notice of the execution and delivery proceedings, and that the delay is inordinate and not bona fide. The High Court, applying the liberal but principled test for ‘sufficient cause’ and the constitutional limits on engrafting limitation principles, held that the plaintiff failed to establish sufficient cause or bona fides, and dismissed the petitions. The matter was decided by a single judge, Justice K. Babu, on 08.04.2025.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 766 OF 2021

Shibin v. Kannan P.H. and Shanmughadas and Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd.

This Kerala High Court MACA arises from an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thrissur, in OP(M.V) No. 2709/2011, dated 03.07.2020, awarding compensation for injuries sustained in a motor accident on 06.09.2011 caused by a car registered KL 08 AT 2683 colliding with the appellant’s bicycle. The appellant, Shibin, challenged the Tribunal’s award seeking enhanced compensation of Rs 14,00,000, arguing that the Tribunal erred in notional income assessment, and in undercompensating for transportation, nourishment, bystander expenses, loss of amenities, and permanent disability. The insurer and respondents contended the accident involved negligence by the claimant’s own factors, that the policy required timely notice, and that the compensation awarded was not excessive; the 1st respondent-driver contested negligence; the 3rd respondent-insurer contested policy primacy and correctness of income details. The High Court found the accident occurred due to rash driving by the 1st respondent and undertook a detailed reassessment. It corrected the monthly income from Rs 5,000 to Rs 8,000, added 40% for future prospects under Pranay Sethi (for an 18-year-old), and increased the disability to 40% per Ext. A12. It recalculated loss of earnings, transportation, nourishment, pain, loss of amenities, disfigurement, and future prospects, resulting in a total enhanced compensation of Rs 8,12,680 with 7.5% interest and costs, directing payment by the insurer within two months and in accordance with Circular No. 03/2019.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.36914/2023

Rajesh Kumar C. vs State Co-Operative Election Commission and others

The petitioner, Rajesh Kumar C., a candidate for the managing committee election of the 8th respondent — Thiruvalla Primary Co-Operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank Ltd. (A159) — approached this Court alleging manipulation in the election process and seeking protective measures. The bank’s electorate exceeds 11,000, yet the practice prevalent for years involved bringing non-members from outside the society to cast votes, aided by polling officers, which allegedly facilitates bogus voting and impersonation. The election to be held on 12.11.2023 is thus seen as potentially fraudulent due to limited identity verification and the involvement of non-members. The petitioner cites earlier instances where Advocate Commissioners were appointed in related elections, with Exts. P2 and P3 (Advocate Commissioner reports) indicating irregularities. He sought police protection on polling day, appointment of an Advocate Commissioner, installation of CCTV cameras at the polling station entrance, videography of the entire polling process, and verification of voters’ identity using Form-6A and the 6B register. He also urged verification of Aadhaar-like credentials, and asked the District Collector and Returning Officer to ensure identity verification through available devices. Respondents contend that precautions are already in place (polling officers, candidate agents) and that verification would occur only on challenge. The court, relying on prior decisions and the Larsen & Toubro doctrine, disposed of the petition in part, directing police protection, CCTV coverage, and identity verification to safeguard the process while maintaining secrecy.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev Nos. 84/2018; 75/2018; 78/2018; 77/2018; 79/2018; 80/2018; 82/2018; 81/2018; 86/2018; 91/2018; 92/2018; 94/2018

State of Kerala v. Raphel T. Joseph

The batch OT.Revisions (OT.Rev Nos. 84/2018 and connected cases along with OT.Rev Nos. 75/2018, 78/2018, 77/2018, 79/2018, 80/2018, 82/2018, 81/2018, 86/2018, 91/2018, 92/2018 and 94/2018) challenge a common order of the Kerala VAT Appellate Tribunal dated 5 March 2018 in T.A.(VAT) Nos. 564–569/2014 and Cross Objections Nos. 2/2016 and related matters. The petitions arise under Section 25 of the KVAT Act, 2003. The Tribunal’s impugned order followed a Division Bench view in Cholayil Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner, prompting the matter to be referred to a Full Bench. The Full Bench, by its 31 March 2022 order, held that reassessment under Section 25 covers multiple contingencies—escapes, under‑assessment, or tax at a lower rate—and that deemed self‑assessment and compounding at a rate under Section 8 do not immunize the Revenue from reopening where misrepresentation or fraud is involved. It rejected the proposition in State of Kerala v. Mohammed Ali A.M. (2017) 25 KTR 73 as incorrect, aligning with Joy Alukkas Traders (I) Pvt. Ltd. The Court thus set aside the Tribunal’s common order and allowed the OT revisions, remitting the matters to the Tribunal for fresh adjudication on merits, with a direction to dispose expeditiously, preferably within four months.