This is a Motor Vehicles Act appeal under Section 173 from a Kerala High Court jurisdiction challenging an award of Rs. 87,100 by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, dated in 2006 for injuries sustained by the appellant, Navab, in a road traffic accident on 6 May 2006 near Thoppumpady-Pulimoottu Bridge. The Tribunal held the rider (2nd respondent) liable and the insurer (3rd respondent) liable under a policy, with policy coverage admitted. The claimant claimed Rs. 1,50,000 as compensation. The Tribunal, without oral evidence, relied on Exhibits A1–A8 to compute the award, and fixed a total notional income basis of Rs. 4,000 per month, a figure the appellant challenged as too low given the 22-year-old’s store-keeper role at Choice Sea Foods. The appellant argued that, based on Supreme Court precedents (Ramachandrapa; Syed Sadiq; Minu Rout; Raj Kumar), notional income could reasonably be higher and that additional post-accident expenses (implant removal surgery in 2011 and related discharge summaries) warranted enhanced compensation. The High Court partly allowed the appeal, enhancing the compensation by Rs. 27,846 at 7.5% interest, directing payment within two months, and preserving the rest of the Tribunal’s conclusions.
This MACA is an appeal by The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. against a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal award in O.P.(MV) No.589/2010 arising from a fatal motor accident on 22.07.2010, on Kumily–Munnar road, when Sony, riding a motorcycle, was struck by a bus KL 6C/2871. The Tribunal held the bus driver negligent and awarded Rs 35,56,000 to the claimants, comprising Rs 32,40,000 for loss of dependency; Rs 75,000 for loss of consortium; and conventional heads including funeral expenses, loss of love and affection, pain and suffering, damage to clothing and transportation. The insurer challenges the quantum, contending that the Tribunal wrongly applied a 50% addition towards future prospects based on the deceased’s salary (Rs 15,000) and that compensation for conventional heads is not in line with prevailing law. The court relies on Sarla Verma and Pranay Sethi to recalibrate future prospects (holding 40% for a 33‑year‑old), calculates the dependency accordingly, and adjusts the conventional heads guided by Magma General Insurance and Rasmita Biswal decisions. As a result, the court arrives at a total of Rs 32,39,000 as just compensation, directs payment with 6% interest, and lays down procedural steps for disbursement and deposit compliance.
CON.CASE(C) NO. 694 OF 2014 This Contempt of Court Case (Civil) No. 694 of 2014, instituted by Basil Attippetty, alleges non-compliance with this Court's Anx. A1 interim order dated 02 May 2014 in W.P.(C) No.11964/2014. The interim order directed notice before admission and required the Taxes Secretary to file an affidavit within two months regarding the interim relief sought in the writ petition. The matter traces the Justice M. Ramachandran Commission's liquor policy recommendations, including restricting sale to 11:30 a.m.–10 p.m., requiring purchasers to be 21 or older with identity proofs, and prohibiting new outlets, and the Government's delay in acting due to policy formulation and external constraints, including State of Kerala v. Surendra Das and the Model Code of Conduct. The Court reaffirmed the constitutional framework regulating liquor as res extra commercium, citing Article 47 and related Articles to justify state regulation or prohibition, licensing monopolies, and non-discriminatory restrictions. The petitioner urged enforcement of the Ramachandran recommendations; the Government contended that policy decisions require time and consideration, especially amid political/constitutional constraints. The Court guided the Government to consider the Ramachandran recommendations and the Xaviers Residency guidance, granting a reasonable period for action. An affidavit was filed; ultimately, the main writ was disposed of on 02.06.2023, and the contempt petition was disposed of in light of the disposal of the primary matter.
The Kerala High Court, in WP(C) No.11928/2022, heard a challenge by four petitioners—Baby Joseph, Peter P.J., Mercy, and Praveen Peter—alleging possession of about 3 cents of land in survey No.1279 of Poonithura Village, Kanayannur Taluk, Ernakulam, recorded as puramboke (government) land. They claim possession since 1960 via the late Joseph and his successors, and occupy a residence there. The petitioners sought to quash Exts.P9 and P10, which informed them that the land would be taken for the Kochi Water Metro without compensation under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (the Act). They argued they could establish title by adverse possession, had already filed a suit for declaration of title and injunction, and were entitled to compensation for the land and building under the Act, including rehabilitation under the Second Schedule and solatium under Section 30. Respondents countered that the land is puramboke government land and not subject to acquisition; petitioners are not “landowners” in terms of the Act; there was no notification for acquisition of puramboke land, and a 2009 assignment application was rejected. The court framed three issues: (i) whether long occupancy entitles compensation; (ii) whether Section 77 deposits apply; (iii) whether solatium is payable. Interpreting Section 3(r), the court found the landowner requirement not met since the land is puramboke and title is unestablished; the writ petition was dismissed. It allowed compensation for improvements and rehabilitation already determined and left open the possibility of relief if title is later proven in civil proceedings. Directions were given to deposit or transfer fixed sums and to provide bank details; the court noted that if title is established in pending civil litigation, petitioners would be eligible for Act benefits, including solatium where applicable.
This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA) from the Kerala High Court, arising out of an award by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Tirur, in OA/MV No.985/2013. Hakkim, the deceased in a 26.6.2012 accident, left dependents who challenged the quantum of compensation. The appellants argued that, since the deceased had worked abroad for over a decade (primarily with M/s Morning Star Textiles and Tailors) and possibly held a government-driver post in the Gulf, the Tribunal erred in fixing the monthly salary as Rs. 15,000 despite documentary evidence suggesting a salary of 3,000 Dirhams (about Rs. 45,000) per month. The documents produced (salary certificate and displacement receipts) were photostat copies, not marked, and the appellants contended they should be relied upon, with embassies authenticating the foreign salary. Respondents contended that such foreign salary cannot be reckoned without proper authentication, citingSatinder Kaur’s judgment that embassy authentication is essential and photostat copies cannot be relied upon. The court ultimately found the tribunal undercompensated, adopting Rs.20,000 monthly salary plus 40% future prospects, and reworking various heads of compensation. It partially allowed the MACA, reducing certain amounts (pain and suffering) and funeral expenses, while increasing others (loss of dependency, consortium, etc.), with a total enhanced award of Rs.42,86,000 and an overall increase of Rs.20,86,000 over the Tribunal’s award. The insurer is directed to deposit the enhanced amount with interest.
CRL.Rev.Pet.No.632 of 2022 This is a criminal revision petition under sections 397 and 401 CrPC filed by the accused, Biju T. Chacko, challenging a conviction under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (NI Act) for issuing a cheque of Rs. 1,00,000 that bounced because the account was shown as closed. The trial court convicted him and awarded imprisonment till the rising of the court along with a compensation of Rs. 1,50,000 under CrPC 357(1), a verdict upheld on appeal by the Additional Sessions Judge, Kottayam. The High Court, in revision, examines the scope of its powers under CrPC 397/401, reiterating that revisional jurisdiction is supervisory and not a second appellate jurisdiction to re‑weigh evidence, citing State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri and later Supreme Court authorities. The court discusses presumptions under sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act and the burden on the accused to rebut those presumptions by preponderance of probabilities, citing Rangappa v. Mohan, Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar, Kalamani Tex, and other authorities, including Krishna Janardhan Bhat (noting some observations there may be incorrect). The verdict confirms the conviction and the sentence but grants two months from today to pay the compensation, with execution deferred to 09.12.2022.
WP(C) Nos.4729 of 2023 and 5079 of 2023 These writ petitions challenge a District Magistrate order directing the use of only ‘politically neutral’ colours for Kaliyoottu festival decorations at Major Vellayani Bhadrakali Devi Temple (under the Travancore Devaswom Board). The petitioners, comprising the Temple Advisory Committee and a devotee, seek mandamus to ensure the temple’s saffron/orange decorative scheme and to secure law-and-order protection during Kaliyoottu 2023 (dated 14 Feb to 24 Apr). Respondents include the State, Travancore Devaswom Board and police authorities, who contend that neutral colours are necessary to prevent provocation and ensure safety in a context of past disputes between rival groups and political interference. The court grounds the dispute in the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, the Board’s statutory duties, and established judgments on temple ceremonies and public safety. It holds that temple rites must be conducted in accordance with temple custom, and police interference should be limited to maintaining order; yet authorities may act if untoward incidents threaten safety. The decision relies on Satheesh v. Travancore Devaswom Board and Anil Kumar A.G. v. Travancore Devaswom Board, and directs adherence to those principles while safeguarding pedestrians’ right of way and road safety.
NCS Auto Hub Pvt. Ltd., a car-dealer operating in multiple districts, challenged a final assessment under Section 126 of the Electricity Act, 2003 by the Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB) for penal energy charges on alleged unauthorised over-drawal after seeking to increase the connected load. The petitioner leased premises under Ext.P1 (dated 11.12.2020) with LT VIIA tariff and load under 100 kW, undertook to pay consumption charges, and applied on 05.08.2021 (Ext.P4) for load enhancement. After a delay, on 07.10.2022, KSEB approved a transformation capacity of 160 KVA and a 180 KVA DG set. In the interim, a provisional assessment dated 29.09.2022 demanded Rs. 8,08,298 under Section 126 for an additional load of 67,605 watts; the final assessment order followed on 08.11.2022. The petitioner contended that penal energy charges should not apply given that fixed charges have already been paid, relying on Sulabha Marketing (P) Ltd. v. Kerala State Electricity Board (217 (3) KHC 563). The court examined precedents including Seetharam Mills’ case to distinguish liability under unauthorised use and the tariff applicable, and ultimately modified the final assessment order: the petitioner is not liable for penal energy charges of Rs. 5,79,818 but must pay Rs. 2,28,480, with stay of disconnection if the amount is deposited within a week. The petition is thus partly allowed.
The appellant, Dejo Jacob, a 26-year-old person with 40% mental disability, challenged the Kerala cooperative milk union’s handling of recruitments for posts namely Technician (General) Grade II and Plant Attender Grade III. He had replied to an earlier notification (Ext.P6, 2016) but no selection ensued; the Union cancelled that notification and issued Ext.P9 (2019) inviting fresh applications for the same posts, stating those who had applied previously need not reapply. The petitioner’s application was processed under the new notification and he appeared for a written test (Ext.P11). He later learned that the Union had fixed a 50-mark cutoff for interviews and that he was not called. It emerged that Plant Attender Grade III had been identified as suitable for persons with disabilities (PWD) while Technician Grade II had not. The petitioner amended the writ petition to challenge the post-identity decision. He contended: (i) the posts identified as suitable for PWD cannot be altered after initial identification; (ii) relying on Ext.P12 Government Order and Ext.P13 Division Bench decision in Ernakulam Regional Co-operative Milk Producers Union Ltd. v State of Kerala, that Technician II should also be treated as a post suitable for PWD. The Union argued the identification was based on Circular 54/2011 and G.O. 27.04.2013. The High Court held that identification of suitable posts is a preliminary step under the PWD Act and that it was not illegal to identify other posts; it directed consideration of the appellant for Plant Attender Grade III in the existing vacancy within two months, while dismissing the claim for Technician Grade II.
WP(C) Nos.5419 & 5571 of 2023 The Kerala High Court, in two linked writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 5419/2023 and 5571/2023), examined PCI’s rejection of D.Pharm course approvals for the 2022-23 session. The petitioners, private self-financing pharmacy colleges, contended that the time-bound directions in Parshvanath Charitable Trust v. AICTE (2013) 3 SCC 385 were not applicable to D.Pharm and that PCI had to consider their applications on merits within the schedule. They argued that affiliation consent was not a prerequisite for approval under the Pharmacy Act, 1948 and that their campuses satisfied infrastructure and teaching requirements, as verified by PCI during inspections; they also relied on the Court’s earlier directions to include them in the list for admissions if PCI granted approval. The PCI defended adherence to the fixed timeline, asserting that Parshvanath’s directions on approvals and admission schedules bind AICTE, the University, and state authorities alike. It asserted that the Supreme Court had extended or clarified deadlines in various orders, and that post-cutoff approvals in some cases were justified by special circumstances. The judge carefully examined these submissions and the relevant precedents, including Parshvanath and related Kerala High Court decisions, and concluded that the principles in Parshvanath apply broadly to ensure standards. The petitions were dismissed, but the court directed PCI to consider the petitioners’ 2023-24 applications in accordance with the law and the prescribed timeline.
BAIL APPL. NO. 4343 OF 2024 Ashraf A v. State of Kerala is a bail petition under Section 439 CrPC concerning Crime No. 264 of 2024, Kuthuparamba Police Station, Kannur, challenging a District Court order in CRMC No. 756 of 2024. The de facto allegations relate to pledging spurious gold weighing 254 grams to secure a loan of Rs. 11,10,000 from a financial institution named Durga Finance; the gold was found to be adulterated. The petitioner, arrested on 28.03.2024, has been in judicial custody and seeks statutory bail under the proviso to Section 167(2) CrPC since the investigation is ongoing and the final report has not been laid. The prosecution contends the investigation is active and the petitioner has criminal antecedents, arguing that release on bail could enable further offences. The court notes that the offence is punishable for less than ten years and that more than sixty days have lapsed without a final report. Relying on the indefeasible right to bail under Section 167(2) CrPC and drawing on Supreme Court precedents (notably Sanjay Dutt v. State through C.B.I., and the principle articulated in Hitendra Vishnu Thakur) as well as Sushila Aggarwal v. State of Delhi, the court finds the petitioner entitled to statutory bail. The bail is granted on a bond of Rs. 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, subject to conditions including appearance, non-interference with witnesses, non-commission of offences, passport surrender, and potential cancellation on breach of terms.
This Motor Accident Claims Appeal arises from an award in OP(MV) No.156/2015 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Pathanamthitta, challenging the appellate award under MACA No. 4444 of 2019. The appellants, legal heirs of V.J. Mathew who died after a rashly driven car struck him on the Thiruvalla–Kozhenjeri Road, contend the Tribunal’s compensation is inadequate. Both sides consented to admit the appeal for final disposal on undisputed evidence. The Tribunal had awarded Rs.12,93,818 out of a claim for Rs.26,30,000. The key issue concerns the deceased’s notional income. The Tribunal had fixed Rs.10,000 with 10% future prospects, following Ramachandrappa, treating the deceased as a “Coolie.” The High Court held the deceased was not merely a Coolie; Ext. A9 (identity card) showed he was a Pastor and also engaged in agriculture. Relying on Rajani and Pranay Sethi principles, the Court adopted Rs.11,000 as notional income with 10% future prospects, and directed a higher amount under certain heads. The Court also treated Loss of Consortium, directing Rs.2,20,000 for the appellant-wife and others, applying Pranay Sethi, while deleting awards under Love and Affection and Pain and Sufferings, per Satinder Kaur. The appellate court partly allowed the appeal, enhancing dependency and consortium awards, while maintaining other heads, with interest at 9% from filing, excluding 196 days, and costs, and required deposit within two months.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5974 OF 2024 Amal Joy, aged 19, petitioner in Bail Application No. 5974 of 2024 in Crime No. 877/2024 of Kothamangalam Police Station, Ernakulam, seeks bail under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, after being arrested on 29.06.2024 in offences under IPC sections 354 and 354A(1)(i) and POCSO Act section 8 read with section 7. The prosecution alleges that on 05.06.2024, at around 17.15 hours, the accused, with intent to commit sexual assault on a 15-year-old girl, embraced and kissed her on her lips and outraged her modesty. The petitioner asserts total innocence, claiming he was falsely implicated due to a contested relationship with the victim, and contends there is no criminal antecedent. He has already spent about 30 days in custody and the investigation is nearly complete with recovery effected. The petitioner’s counsel argues that there is no likelihood of interference with witnesses and that detention should be avoided, given the strong constitutional presumption of innocence. The Public Prosecutor counters, citing incriminating materials and risk of intimidation and tampering if released. The High Court relies on Supreme Court precedents, reiterating that bail is the norm and jail is the exception, while emphasizing Article 21 and the rights of under-trials. After careful consideration, the court allows the bail application on stringent conditions including bond, sureties, reporting, travel restrictions, no contact with witnesses, surrender of passport, and potential cancellation for violations, while noting that merits remain to be decided by trial.
BAIL APPL. NO. 2694 OF 2024 ROJIMON.M.V @ ROJI MATHEW, the second accused in Kalamassery Police Station Crime No. 317/2024, seeks anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The FIR, registered on 12 February 2024, alleges that on 10 February 2024 the accused and six others formed an unlawful assembly and, while impersonating Narcotics Cell officers, restrained the defacto complainant and administered an injection, causing him to fall unconscious. They abducted him and took him to Nair's Psychiatric Hospital, admitting him as an inpatient against his will to present him as a mental patient. The offences charged include sections 143, 147, 328, 341, 365 and 419, read with 149 IPC. The petitioner contends total innocence, arguing he acted only on hospital staff instructions to accompany the complainant, and asserts that Section 365 cannot be connected to him; custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor counters that there is prima facie material demonstrating participation in the crime, with prior animosity between the first accused and the complainant’s brother; the acts were committed in furtherance of their common intention and require investigation, with recovery to be effected. The District Court had denied pre-arrest bail. The High Court relies on Supreme Court authorities that anticipatory bail is exceptional and must be exercised with caution, noting the nascent stage of the investigation. After due consideration, the judge holds that custodial interrogation is necessary and the case does not meet the exceptional criteria for pre-arrest bail, accordingly dismissing the application.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5639 OF 2024 This is a Kerala High Court bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed by accused 5 and 7 in Crime No. 457/2024 of the Vanchiyoor Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram. The petition seeks pre-arrest bail in relation to offences under IPC Sections 294(b), 341, 323, 324, 506(i), 308 and 212 read with 34. The prosecution claims that, on the night of 16.05.2024, in furtherance of a common intention, the accused allegedly restrained the de facto complainant and his friend, with the 1st accused attempting to stab the complainant with a knife; the other accused allegedly assaulted the complainant, resulting in injuries, including a stab wound to the right eye. The petitioners contend they are innocent and that Annexure A1 (FIR) shows no specific overt act attributable to them under Section 308; they argue custodial interrogation is unnecessary and no recoveries are to be made. The Public Prosecutor counters with the asserted injuries and the presence of specific acts by the petitioners, urging continued investigation. On weighing the materials, the court notes there is no specific overt act against the petitioners for 308, though the matter will be decided at trial. The court, therefore, grants pre-arrest bail under Section 438 subject to conditions (surrender within two weeks, Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, appearance as directed, no tampering, passport surrender, no new offences) while clarifying the order does not resolve merits.
BAIL APPL. NO. 6262 OF 2024 This is a bail application filed by petitioners Nos. 2 and 3 in Crime No.353/2024 of Murikkassery Police Station, Idukki, under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, alleging offences under Sections 406 and 420 read with 34 IPC. The petition seeks statutory bail under Section 167(2) CrPC on the ground that petitioners have been in judicial custody since 03.06.2024 (about 63 days at the time of hearing) and the investigation is not complete with no final report yet filed. Prosecution claims the petitioners, along with the first accused, induced the de facto complainant to transfer Rs 5,00,000 on the promise of securing an employment visa to Israel; the visa was not provided and the capital not returned. The petition argues innocence and lack of material tying them to the offences, while the Public Prosecutor opposes bail, citing ongoing investigation, the likelihood of re-offending, and 15 other similar crimes evidenced against the petitioners. The High Court considers the scope of Section 167(2), citing Uday Mohanlal Acharya v. State of Maharashtra (2001) 5 SCC 453, Sanjay Dutt v. State through CBI, Bombay, and Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) to affirm that an indefeasible right to statutory bail accrues when investigation cannot be completed within the prescribed period. The application is allowed; the petitioners are directed to be released on bail on bonds of Rs.50,000 each with two solvent sureties, subject to conditions including appearance, non-interference, no tampering with witnesses or evidence, surrender of passports, and potential cancellation/modification of bail if violated.
W.A. No. 370 of 2023 & W.A. No. 398 of 2023 These intra court appeals challenge a common judgment (07-12-2022) dismissing writ petitions filed by two respondents for the post of Meter Reader/Spot Biller in KSEB. The petitioners contended that the PSC rank list included candidates with higher qualifications (degree/diploma in Electrical Engineering) not qualifying under Ext.P2, which prescribed National Trade Certificate (NTC) in Electrician/Wireman/Electronics as the technical qualification. They argued that degree/diploma holders in the same faculty presuppose the lower NTC and thus should be eligible. The PSC and government argued that higher qualifications can be treated as equivalent only if specifically allowed by KS&SSR rules or Government orders; Jyoti K.K. had held that higher qualifications in the same faculty presuppose the lower qualification, but the court distinguishes this on facts. The court also examines Ext.P11 (01/2022) government order declaring KGCE electrical diploma as a higher qualification and finds it cannot have retrospective effect vis-a-vis Ext.P2. The court cites Suma A. to limit PSC’s power to recognize equivalence unless provided by rules or government orders, and notes that Ext.P11 cannot alter Ext.P2. The judgment ultimately holds that NTC is not presupposed by diploma/degree in engineering and directs recasting of the rank list to include only those with the prescribed Ext.P2 qualifications, thereby allowing the writ petitions.
BAIL APPL. NO. 1705 OF 2024 Jerrin C.G., the fourth accused in Crime No.134/2024 of the Aroor Police Station, Alappuzha, petitions the Kerala High Court for bail under Section 439 CrPC. The charges allege offences under Sections 324, 326 and 307 read with Section 34 IPC, arising from an incident on the night of 5 February 2024 in which accused 1–3 allegedly assaulted the de facto complainant, causing grievous injuries, with accused 4 and 5 helping by restraining him. The petitioner asserts his bona fide innocence, arguing that his only alleged overt act was to catch hold of the complainant and facilitate the attack by others, and that the specific act of the main assault lay with accused 1–3; he contends the prosecution’s Annexure A1 shows no clear case under Sec. 307 against him. He surrendered after Annexure A2 and has been in judicial custody since 22 February 2024; the investigation is stated to be practically complete and no criminal antecedents exist. The Public Prosecutor opposed the application, though she conceded that the primary assault was committed by accused 1–3 and sought dismissal of the bail plea. The court, after weighing material on record and noting the petitioner’s custody period, ordered bail with a Rs. 50,000 bond and two solvent sureties, subject to conditions including regular IO appearances, no tampering with witnesses, no new offences, surrender of passport, address and contact details, and potential cancellation on violation; it also cites that investigation may continue on bail per a Supreme Court precedent (Sushila Aggarwal).
The petitioners, Lijo K John and Kavitha P.C., both UPSAs at St. John’s Jacobite Syrian Higher Secondary School, Kanniattunirappu, Ernakulam, challenged the non-approval of their appointments from the date of their initial appointments in 2008–2009, made during a period of enforced ban on appointments in additional division vacancies. They sought quashing of Ext. P4 to the extent denying approval from the initial appointment date and prayed for directions to consider Exts. P6 and P7 representations. The petitioners relied on Go orders: GO (P) 317/2005/G.Edn (dated 17-08-2005) banning appointments in additional division vacancies; GO (P) 10/10/G.Edn (dated 12-01-2010) lifting the ban with conditions; and GO (P) 199/2011/G.Edn (dated 01-06-2011) implementing a comprehensive teacher package that included the petitioners. They contended that judgments of this Court had directed that appointments from the date of initial appointment be approved by deeming that managers had executed the required bonds, aligning with protected teachers. The Government Pleader argued for 1:1 apportionment of appointments in additional vacancies and emphasized bond execution requirements under GO 10/10/2010, noting ongoing Apex Court proceedings. The Court held that petitioners are entitled to relief, citing the Division Bench decision in Suma Devi (W.A. No.2111/2015) that non-execution of bonds could be deemed execution and bonds should be honoured in proportion to the ban-period approvals. Directions were issued to consider Exts. P6–P7 and to act expeditiously, within three months, while preserving Apex Court orders. The petition is disposed of accordingly.
This writ petition challenges the pension reckoning of a long-serving school attendant in Karavaram Vocational Higher Secondary School. The petitioner, Raveendran Pillai S., began as Full Time Menial in 1987 and was intermittently engaged through various spells due to staff shortages and fluctuating student strength, with a continuous service record ultimately claimed from 1 December 2000 to 30 April 2021 amounting to 30 years, 11 months and 14 days. Pay scales and selection-grade provisions granted during this period (Exts. P2–P6) reflect recognition of long service, culminating in a desire to count the entire period towards pension. The core dispute centers on whether broken/leave-vacancy spells prior to regular appointment should count as qualifying service for pension, in light of corrections and amendments to Rule 14E(a)/Part III of the Kerala Service Rules (KSR) and related Government Orders issued in 2018–2019 (G.O. (P) No.128/2018; G.O(MS) No.401/2019). The government contends that such periods, if not part of pre-regular appointment service, should not be counted post-amendment; the petitioner argues that his pre-1990 breaks were tied to regular appointments and should count. The court examined earlier decisions (W.P.(C) 30167/2016 and connected cases; W.A. 978/2021; W.A. 1235/2018) and concluded that Ext. P8 (verification) cannot bar pension, quashed it, and held that the petitioner is entitled to pension with due regard to his long/regular appointment from 22 August 1987. Fresh pension orders should be issued by Respondent 4.