Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 422 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.5352 of 2023

SIVARAJ K.C. v. MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD and Others

The petitioner, a devotee of Katameri Sree Paradevatha Temple (a controlled institution under the Malabar Devaswom Board), seeks mandamus under Article 226 directing the Assistant Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, to consider Ext.P3 (11.10.2022) and to ensure strict compliance with Ext.P1 notification (30.08.2022) in selecting non-hereditary trustees for the Katameri temple. He contends that respondents 4 and 5—active CPI(M) functionaries—are disqualified under the notification’s clauses, and that due process was not followed. The petition relies on the principle of fairness in procedure, the opportunity to present views (audi alteram partem), and the need for reasoned orders when invoking Section 39(5) of the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951. The respondents counter that the two appointees were selected after an Inspector’s enquiry and based on a Departmental resolution (No.361, 12.01.2023) that found no merit in the petition; they argue Section 39(5) permits appointment when necessary, and that a scheme under Section 58 governs temple administration. The judgment surveys precedents (Sreedharan Nambeesan; Gopinatha Menon; Chathu Achan; Suresh K.; Anantha Narayanan) to delineate fairness and the scope of power. The High Court disposes of the petition, directing disclosure of the Area Committee’s decision, permitting a revision under Section 18, and requiring a reasoned order within specified timelines, while keeping the interim stay in force.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.5114 OF 2023

Moni George and Rajeev @ Manoj v State of Kerala and Station House Officer, Aryanad Police Station, Vineeshkumar and Vishnu @ Balu

The present petition in CRL.MC 5114 of 2023 challenges the final report in SC No. 892/2023, arising from Crime No. 856/2022 of Aryanad Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram. Petitioners Moni George and Rajeev @ Manoj seek quashing under Section 482 CrPC on the ground that the prosecution is founded on a concocted account allegedly fabricated by the de facto complainant, a powerful local figure, in furtherance of a property dispute. They point to annexures including prior FIRs, medical treatment records, and other documents suggesting lack of corroboration for allegations of weapon use and injuries, and they contend that the investigation has been biased in their favor. The State and the police counter that the materials, including witness statements and medical records, establish involvement by the petitioners and that the injuries to victims support the offenses charged (IPC 294(b), 341, 323, 324, 308 r/w 34). The High Court reiterates the limited scope of its Section 482 jurisdiction at this nascent stage and refuses to conduct a mini-trial or evaluate the evidence as would be proper at trial. Citing seminal Supreme Court authorities such as R.P. Kapur, Bhajan Lal, PP Sharma, Zandu, and Neeharika, the court holds that it would be premature to conclude that no offense is established. Accordingly, the petition is dismissed, preserving the trial's natural course and guarding against unwarranted prejudice to either side; the objective is a fair adjudication on the merits.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl). No. 509/2021

Arshika S. v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is filed by Arshika S., widow of Sanjith A., seeking to transfer the investigation into Crime No. 1989 of 2021 of Palakkad Town South Police Station and Crime No. 457 of 2020 of Palakkad Kasba Police Station to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) on grounds of a larger conspiracy involving SDPI and PFI with national and international ramifications. The petitioner alleges that the police investigation has been slow and perfunctory, and that the dealings with the case did not name the extremist organizations in the FIR. She asserts that the murder is part of a pattern of attacks against RSS workers and that the investigation failed to unravel the true culprits and the conspiracy. She contends that the CBI’s intervention is essential to reveal the truth and prevent derailment of justice, citing alleged international links and the need for a credible, unbiased inquiry. The State police defend the investigation as robust, noting the formation of a Special Investigation Team, identification and arrest of main culprits, and a timely final report filed on 10.02.2022. The court, weighing constitutional principles and the available materials, holds that transfer to the CBI is not warranted on these facts and dismisses the petition, while directing fortnightly progress reports on the remaining accused to be filed by the respondent police, and posts the matter for further report on 30.05.2022.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 854/2007

Rajendran and Saumini v. State of Kerala

Rajendran and Saumini v. State of Kerala is an appeal from a judgment of conviction under Sections 307, 326 and 324 IPC by the Additional Sessions Court (Ad hoc-I), Thodupuzha, arising from an incident on 6 October 2003 in which PW3 sustained injuries. The trial court convicted accused No.1 under Section 307 IPC (three years RI, fine Rs. 5,000; in default one year) and accused No.3 under Sections 326 and 324 IPC (three years RI, fine Rs. 5,000; in default one year). The prosecution relied on the testimony of PW1 (doctor), PW2 (father of PW3) who lodged Ext.P2 FIS, PW3 the injured, and PW8 (treating doctor), with PW4, PW5 as independent witnesses who did not support the case and PW6 partially supporting the defence. The defence argued that the genesis of the incident was not as claimed, that injuries to accused were not explained, and that a counter-case (Ext.D6) was registered but not tried with the main case. The High Court noted unresolved issues: unexplained injuries on the accused, a 26‑hour delay in lodging the FIR, lack of corroboration from independent witnesses, and the lower court’s failure to follow the principle that cross‑FIRs should be tried in one trial. Relying on Mishrilal, Amir, Maydeen A.T. and Lakshmi Singh, the court held that the evidence did not prove the genesis beyond reasonable doubt and set aside the conviction, acquitting the appellants and allowing the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
WA 421/2023; WA 622/2023; WA 955/2023; WA 956/2023

WA Nos. 421/2023, 622/2023, 955/2023 and 956/2023, Mukkom Service Co-Operative Bank Ltd. v. P.T. Hussain and connected matters, High Court of Kerala

These writ appeals arise from an award of the Co-operative Arbitration Court (Northern Kozhikode) in a dispute relating to disciplinary proceedings initiated by the Mukkom Service Co-Operative Bank against its employee, P.T. Hussain. The employee challenged two actions: (i) the order permitting fresh disciplinary proceedings after the previous proceedings were set aside, and (ii) a memo of charges issued after retirement. The Bank challenged the Arbitration Court's setting aside of its charge memo issued by the Disciplinary Sub-Committee. The High Court, by a Division Bench, reconsiders the law after Full Bench Mattanur; it holds that the Division Bench decision in Kodanchery v. Joshy Varghese is not the correct law and needs to be distinguished. The Court remands ARC No.63/2016 to the Arbitration Court for fresh consideration in light of the Full Bench decision, confining the scope to the legality of the first disciplinary proceedings rather than the subsequent discharge. The judgment clarifies that the law laid down by the Full Bench supersedes the Division Bench in Kodanchery. It directs that the Arbitration Court complete the proceedings within six months. The matter addresses the interplay between disciplinary actions taken during service and those issued post-retirement, and the validity of the charge memo.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A 864 of 2009

CRL.A No. 864 of 2009 against the judgment in CC No.32/2003 of Enquiry Commissioner & Special Judge, Kozhikode, High Court of Kerala

This Kerala High Court criminal appeal concerns Dr. V.K. Devayani, accused No.1, who challenged a 2009 conviction under Sections 7 and 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act (PC Act) for demanding and accepting a bribe of ₹600 to facilitate medical termination of pregnancy at Community Health Centre, Nenmara. The trial court convicted the appellant and sentenced her to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a ₹1,000 fine for each section, while the co-accused nurse was acquitted. The prosecution’s case rested on PW1 (the decoy’s husband), PW3 (the patient), PW4, and PW8, with tainted currency notes (MO1/MO2) recovered from the appellant’s MO12 bag and subjected to phenolphthalein testing. The defense argued lack of direct evidence of demand and acceptance, inconsistencies in PW1 and PW3, and false implication in a politically motivated trap. The High Court acknowledged that direct evidence is not always essential and endorsed the principle that demand/acceptance may be established by circumstantial proof where foundational facts are proved beyond reasonable doubt. Relying on Supreme Court authorities cited by the defense, it proceeded to assess the circumstantial evidence, including the trap and the chemical tests. Ultimately, it held that the prosecution proved the guilt beyond reasonable doubt, upheld the trial court’s conviction, and dismissed the appeal, maintaining the sentence.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No.2538 of 2022

Tess Thomas v. State of Kerala and Vargheese Mathew

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No.2538 of 2022) heard by a learned Judge of the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam. The petitioner Tess Thomas, accused in ST 1472/2020 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Ramankari, seeks to quash Annexure-A1 (the complaint) under Section 482 Cr.P.C. in a case arising under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. The essential factual matrix is that the petitioner allegedly issued a cheque for Rs. 9,00,000 dated 14.08.2020 to discharge liability for loans supposedly advanced in 2018, which bounced on presentation. The complainant claims that the petitioner had borrowed sums in 2018 on the premise of employment for the complainant’s daughter; the cheque was issued to discharge those liabilities, and the notice demanding payment was ignored. The petitioner contends Annexure-A1 is a false complaint and that the cheque was not issued for any liability. The court cites the principle from Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa and subsequent cases to define the narrow circumstances under which a magistrate’s process can be quashed, emphasizing that the power to quash should be sparingly used and that a complaint may be quashed only if it does not disclose a prima facie offence or is a gross abuse of process. On factual/mere doubtful allegations, however, the court declines to quash and proceeds to uphold the prosecution, while directing expeditious trial. The court dismisses the petition and allows the trial to proceed, with a mandate to dispose of the NI Act case within three months from receipt of the judgment copy, in line with statutory timelines.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 1253 OF 2023

Nawshad A.A. v. State of Kerala

The Kerala High Court, exercising its inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC, examines whether to quash the ongoing prosecution against Nawshad A.A., accused in Crime No. 221 of 1992 (Sasthamcottah Police Station) and connected to SC No. 731/2016 pending before the Additional Sessions Court-IV, Ernakulam (CBI-II). The petitioner faces charges under Section 3(1) of the Arms Act, 1959, Section 3 of the Explosive Substances Act, 1908, and Section 10 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, based on a 13.12.1992 FIR relating to a declared unlawful association, the Islamic Seva Sangh, and a meeting allegedly convened by several accused in a building rented by the 18th accused, with possession of a country-made revolver and ammunition. After a five-year investigation, charges were framed; at trial, accused 3, 4, 7, 15, 17 and 18 were acquitted on the benefit of doubt, while others were split up for separate trial. The petitioner argues that since most co-accused were acquitted, the substratum of the prosecution against him has eroded; therefore the proceedings against him should be quashed. The State contends that acquittals are based on evidence specific to those trials and do not automatically deny the prosecution’s case against the petitioner. The Court finds significant deficiencies in the evidence (including lack of proof of a meeting, ownership, or possession of a revolver) and, relying on Moosa, Vipin and Kaushal Verma, holds that the substratum has been lost and that continuing the prosecution would amount to abuse of process. Accordingly, the proceedings are quashed and the Crl.M.C. is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.4034 OF 2023

Mohammed Shafil TV v State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC, filed by Mohammed Shafil TV, the 1st accused in CC 478/2018 of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Perinthalmanna, arising from Crime No. 632/2017 of Perinthalmanna Police Station. The offences alleged are under Sections 341, 323, 324 and 506 r/w 34 IPC. The 2nd and 3rd accused were juveniles and were referred to the Juvenile Justice Board; the petitioner’s case remains pending as CC 478/2018. The petitioner contends that the parties have amicably settled their disputes and do not wish to pursue the prosecution; Annexure A4 is filed to substantiate this claim. The investigating officer was directed to verify the settlement and report on any impediments, including the petitioner’s criminal antecedents. The Public Prosecutor raised reservations about quashing solely on the basis of a settlement, urging caution under the inherent powers of Section 482. The court then invokes the Supreme Court’s settled law, citing State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and a line of decisions led by Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, and Parbatbhai Aahir, among others, to emphasize that quashing may be appropriate for non‑compoundable, private offences where disputes are settled and the settlement is genuine. After weighing factors—nature of allegations, gravity, injuries, antecedents, and the amicable relation between the parties—the court concludes quashing will not harm public interest and will serve ends of justice. Result: Annexure A2 final report and all further proceedings in CC 478/2018 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
F.A.O.No.111 of 2020

Saji Kumar v. Santosh alias Santoshkumar and Prasanna

This is a first appeal under Section 104 read with Order XLIII, Rule 1(na) CPC, challenging the Sub Court, Chengannur’s 30.09.2020 order dismissing O.P.(Indigent) No.2 of 2019. The appellant, Saji Kumar, sought indigent status to avoid court-fee liability for instituting the suit. The matter arose after the District Collector’s asset report and the Tahsildar’s LR on income and assets were placed on record in 2022. The trial court had rejected leave to sue as indigent on the basis of PW1’s evidence that he engaged seven workers in a tiling business and had recently sold 10 cents of land, concluding he lacked sufficient means to pay court fees. The appellant contends the trial court failed to obtain a Government report and that the reasons for denial were unsustainable, arguing that the Government’s report and proper consideration of income/assets were essential under Order XXXIII Rule 6. The respondents concede the government report was not obtained but contend that the record shows the appellant is not indigent. The court cites Jagadamma v. Sheela and another and Paulose @ Paulo v. Elias K. Varghese to interpret “sufficient means” and directs a fresh assessment, noting that “sufficient means” does not require total destitution but rather capacity to raise funds from realizable assets. The court remits the matter for fresh decision after considering the Tahsildar’s report dated 24.03.2022 and giving both sides and the Government Pleader an opportunity. The aim is a just determination respecting constitutional dignity and access to justice.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.1240/2023

Arun v. State of Kerala

This is a regular bail application (B.A. No.1240/2023) filed by the petitioner Arun, accused no.2 in Crime No.1035/2022 of Vizhinjam Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, under sections 22(c) and 29 of the NDPS Act, read with 439 CrPC. The contraband allegedly seized on 15.01.2022 during a Vizhinjam police search consisted of 9.30 grams and 6.45 grams of MDMA found in joint possession of accused 1 and 2 while travelling on a bike. The prosecution contends offences under the NDPS Act involving a commercial quantity, invoking Section 37, which imposes stringent bail constraints. The petitioner contends lack of any connection to the crime, absence of criminal antecedents, and his ongoing custody since 15.10.2022 justify bail. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing that the joint possession and the quantity render the case one involving commercial quantity, triggering Section 37’s stringent conditions. The court notes the contraband was seized in joint custody, explains that the quantity involved is not to be treated in isolation, and thus Section 37 applies. Relying on Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari and subsequent rulings, the court emphasizes that ‘reasonable grounds’ must be more than prima facie and that the two twin ingredients under Section 37(1)(b) are sine qua non for granting bail in such cases. After evaluating the materials and arguments, the court held that there are no reasonable grounds to believe the petitioner is innocent or will refrain from offences on bail, and dismissed the bail petition.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 107 of 2017

T. Madhura Meenakshi v. T. Kamalam, Kunjumadhavi, and T. Sulochana

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a partition suit in which plaintiffs sought partition of plaint schedule property with each plaintiff and defendants 1 and 2 entitled to 1/4th share. Defendant No.2 (appellant) claimed exclusive allotment of the dwelling house alleging she spent Rs.1,00,000 for repairs and that the house was constructed by her father, invoking equitable principles to reserve the dwelling house from partition. The trial court granted a preliminary decree allocating 1/4th shares to all co-owners, and allotted the dwelling house to defendant No.2 subject to valuation and distribution among all co-owners. The District Court affirmed this outcome. On admission of the Regular Second Appeal, the High Court examined two substantial questions of law: (i) whether the claim of reservation in respect of the dwelling house could be relegated to final decree proceedings, and (ii) whether the dwelling house could be reserved in favour of the appellant in light of the evidence. Relying on Pathumma v. Muhammed and Santhosh Kumar v. Baby, the Court held that reservation of a dwelling house is not legally sustainable without exclusive rights and consent, and may not be decided by equity alone. Consequently, the appeal is meritless and is dismissed, upholding the trial and appellate decrees and directing valuation and distribution among co-owners.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 9022 OF 2023

Untitled Judgement

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case under section 482 CrPC challenges the order in CC 1665/2017 arising from Crime No. 221/2016 of the Ernakulam Central Police Station. The six petitioners/accused faced charges under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 323, 324, and 326 (r/w 149) for forming an unlawful assembly, assault, and grievous injuries. The prosecution acknowledges some accused have prior antecedents. The petitioners contend the dispute is private, the offences are minor, and the parties have settled their differences; affidavits by victims support quashing. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations, but with the parties' settlement, the situation warranted consideration. Relying on the three-judge Supreme Court decision in State of Madhya Pradesh v Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) and earlier rulings Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, the court reiterates that Section 482 CrPC can quash non-compoundable offences in private settlements, provided the offences are not heinous or under special statutes, and that the court must assess the nature of the offences and the accused's antecedents. After examining all records, affidavits, and the nature of the offences as private, the court holds the dispute private, the settlement genuine, and the offences minor. Consequently, the proceedings in CC 1665/2017 are quashed and the petition is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
DBP No.77 of 2022

DBP No.77 of 2022 in the matter of Travancore Devaswom Board – Report No.34/2022 in Complaint No.79/2021 – Petition for Transfer of Complainant – Suo Motu Proceedings Initiated – Reg.

This is a Division Bench of the High Court of Kerala dealing with a Devaswom Board Petition (DBP No.77 of 2022) arising from Report No.34 of 2022 of the Ombudsman for Travancore and Cochin Devaswom Boards, and Complaint No.79 of 2021. The complainant is the Melsanthi of Chittadeeswaran Devaswom in the Rameswaram Sub Group under the Travancore Devaswom Board, who sought a transfer under Clause (14) of the general transfer norms. He contends that, having less than one year of service before retirement, he should be transferred to a temple near his residence, preferably Thrikkadavoor Devaswom or Ashramam Devaswom, while those with longer remaining service have been posted elsewhere. The Ombudsman’s reports and the Devaswom Commissioner’s replies show that several facts were examined, including the presence of senior applicants for the two preferred stations and the need to interpret transfer norms. The court recalls the scope of the Ombudsman’s powers as laid down in a 2007 order (O.P No.3821 of 1990) and the later amendment (Clause 9A in 2015) extending consideration to personal grievances of employees in certain contexts, but clarifies that personal grievances cannot be entertained at will where the issue concerns transfer postings with seniority. The court cites Kamalam v. Cochin Devaswom Board to emphasize that Ombudsman’s remit is public-interest oriented, not a forum for resolving personal grievances. The petition is disposed of with directions related to the exercise of personal-administrative grievances, and the complainant’s transfer claim must be challenged through appropriate fora if applicable.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) Nos. 507/2023 and 521/2023

O.P (KAT) Nos. 507/2023 and 521/2023, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

Two original petitions (OP(KAT) Nos. 507/2023 and 521/2023) were filed by young doctors challenging Kerala Administrative Tribunal orders that denied them permission to apply for posts (Assistant Professor in Radiodiagnosis) due to lack of the prescribed senior residency experience on the last date for application. Dr. Athira P. and Dr. Arya G. Krishnan had taken maternity leave during their MD Radiodiagnosis and were expected to complete senior residency only in January 2024, whereas the PSC’s notification dated 16/10/2023 required one year of senior residency as a qualification by 15/11/2023. They argued that maternity-related delay should be accommodated and that denying them application would discriminate against motherhood, violating formal and substantive equality and reproductive rights. The Tribunal had held they could not be permitted to apply, though an interim order allowed provisional applications. The High Court framed the issue within constitutional equality, balancing formal equality with the need to redress gender-based disadvantages, invoking substantive equality, indirect discrimination, and reproductive rights through constitutional provisions and international norms. The bench ultimately allowed the petitions, set aside the impugned orders, and directed that the petitioners produce the required experience certificates within the PSC’s timeframe, effectively permitting their candidacy while preserving recruitment standards.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 39671/2022

W.P.(C).39671/2022

This writ petition concerns a 17-year-old, mentally challenged girl who became pregnant following rape by a neighbour. The pregnancy had progressed to roughly 25 weeks, beyond the usual window for medical termination, necessitating a court order under the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971. A Government Medical College Kannur Medical Board examined the survivor and concluded that termination should be considered, citing severe mental health risks: likely depression and psychosis, and the possibility that the baby could be born alive with uncertain prognosis. The board also noted the constraints of gestational age, viability guidelines, and the possibility that termination would require surgical methods. The petitioner invoked Article 21’s protection of reproductive liberty and relied on the MTP Act, Rules, and earlier judicial pronouncements that have permitted termination in similar circumstances, including ABC v. Union of India, W.P.(C) 23092 of 2022, and X v Union of India. After considering the board’s opinion and the mental state of the survivor, the High Court granted permission for termination in a Government hospital, directing the hospital to constitute a medical team, to receive the petitioner’s undertaking, and to ensure post-birth care if the child is born alive, with state support under the Juvenile Justice Act. The order emphasizes the woman’s right to reproductive choice against the background of constitutional and statutory protections.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.12933 & 25308 of 2017

WP(C) Nos.12933 & 25308 of 2017 — AW Hospitality Private Limited v. Kottukal Grama Panchayath and others; D. John Paul Louis v. State of Kerala and others

AW Hospitality Private Limited (the petitioner in WP(C)12933/2017) and D. John Paul Louis (the petitioner in WP(C)25308/2017) challenge building permits and environmental clearances for a hotel-cum-apartment project on land partly falling within the Coastal Regulation Zone. The petitioners allege that Ext.P11, a communication by the Kottukal Panchayath canceling the Building Permit, is a non-speaking order issued without reasons and without hearing, violating principles of natural justice and the settled law that statutory orders must be reasoned (Mohinder Singh Gill v. CEC; Alexander Machinery Dudley Ltd. v. Crabtree). The project had obtained multiple approvals: SEIAA Kerala Environmental Clearance (Ext.P6) with CRZ-related conditions, Chief Town Planner layout approval (Ext.P7), PCB consent (Ext.P8), Fire clearance (Ext.P9), and height clearance from the Airport Authority (Ext.P10). The Panchayat’s cancellation (Ext.P11) is contested, with respondents arguing CRZ applicability and the need for KCZMA concurrence before any construction in CRZ areas. The High Court held that the CRZ applicability dispute should be referred to KCZMA, directing the Panchayat to forward records to KCZMA within a month and KCZMA to decide within two months. EC and related approvals were held subject to KCZMA’s decision. Both petitions were disposed of with directions consistent with the KCZMA process, and issues concerning title disputes left for competent courts.

High Court of Kerala
RFA 626 of 2013

Mundanthara Subramanian v. Kaatholil Madhava Menon and others

This Regular First Appeal arises from a suit for specific performance of a sale agreement (Ext. A1) dated 21 February 2011 for a sale consideration of ₹50 lakhs, with an advance of ₹15 lakhs. The Subordinate Judge, Kozhikode, partially decreed the suit, directing refund of the ₹15 lakh advance with 12% interest and costs, while denying specific performance. The plaintiff-appellant contends a valid and concluded contract existed, he was ready and willing to perform, and the defendant breached by withholding conveyance; the plaintiff had funds evidenced by Ext. A2 and Ext. A5 (funds in his daughter’s bank account) and had arranged for the balance purchase price via funds from his daughter. The defense contends plaintiff lacked ready cash and sought to undervalue the property (Ext. A4) and claimed damages for the defendant’s loss on a separate project. The High Court, after examining evidence, held that readiness and willingness under Section 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act had been established and that the plaintiff’s readiness was not negated by non-disclosure of a daughter’s involvement. The court rejected the argument that time was the essence to defeat relief, noted the parties extended the time by mutual endorsement, and concluded the balance of equities favors granting relief. Consequently, the appeal is allowed and the decree modified, directing deposit of the balance sale consideration plus an additional amount for escalation, with transfer of the property on payment, or alternative compensation and return of the advance plus costs.

High Court of Kerala
OP((KAT)No.149 of 2022

S.P. Shibu v. State of Kerala and Others

This High Court of Kerala hears OP(KAT) No.149 of 2022 challenging the Kerala Administrative Tribunal's dismissal of OA 167/2022, which concerned the transfer of S.P. Shibu, a Grade Sub Inspector in the Rural Police, from Nedumangad Police Station to Idukki. The petitioner contends that the transfer on a 'public ground' was a pretext to punish him without any disciplinary proceedings, arising from alleged professional disputes and a purported illicit relationship allegation. He asserts that an enquiry (Annexure A8) indicated the allegations were false, and that the parties behind the transfer manipulated evidence to dislodge him. He further contends that the Tribunal failed to scrutinize the genuineness of the report and that the transfer, while labelled in the public interest, effectively punished him without due process. The respondents defend the transfer as a legitimate administrative measure driven by exigencies of service, noting that transfers in public interest need not follow a misconduct inquiry and need not stigmatize the employee. The Court cites Divyamol.R.S. v. The Director General, Central Industrial Security Force and others to emphasize that interference in such transfers is limited and permissible where administrative necessity governs the relocation. Ultimately, the Court agrees the Tribunal’s stance may not be disturbed but directs regard to a potential retransfer and assures that unfounded accusations (as per Ext.P5) will not form the basis of future action.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC 5367/2023 & 5368/2023

Criminal Miscellaneous Case Nos. 5367/2023 & 5368/2023: Vishak P.R. et al. v. State of Kerala; Jebin John Abraham et al. v. State of Kerala

Two Criminal Miscellaneous Cases (CRL.M.C. Nos. 5367/2023 and 5368/2023) before the Kerala High Court were heard on 17 October 2023 by a Single Judge. The petitions were filed by accused persons in two Aranmula Police Station cases, seeking to quash the prosecution on the basis of settlement between the parties. In Crl.M.C.5367/2023, petitioners Vishak P.R., Thaslim P.I., Joel Jayakumar, and Nithin Kumar sought to quash Crime No. 772/2022; in Crl.M.C.5368/2023, petitioners Jebin John Abraham, Anu.H, and Amit Jacob Sunil sought to quash Crime No. 777/2022. The victims supported the settlements, and the Public Prosecutor, while reserving views about quashing solely on the basis of settlement, acknowledged that the matter was settled. The court examined the authoritative principles from the Supreme Court on quashing non‑compoundable offences under Section 482 CrPC, notably State of Madhya Pradesh v Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019), which relied on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, to outline when quashing is permissible. The court held that where the offence is private in nature and the dispute is settled, quashing can be allowed, subject to its exceptions for serious/heinous offences and offences under special statutes. Consequently, both Crl.M.C.5367/2023 and 5368/2023 were allowed, quashing all further proceedings including the final reports in Crimes 772/2022 and 777/2022, respectively.