Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 682 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 709/2023

Kunheedu v. Mymoona and others

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a suit for permanent and mandatory injunction concerning a B schedule pathway alleged to be an easement of prescription. Plaintiffs claimed the B schedule path was the only access to the plaint A schedule property and sought to restrain the defendant from obstructing it, and, by amendment, to compel restoration of the pathway demolished during litigation. The defendant denied the existence of the B schedule path, arguing it forms part of his property and that the plaintiffs have an alternative route. The trial court decreed in favor of the plaintiffs, directing the defendant to restore the pathway and to refrain from obstructing it, while dismissing another related suit. The appellate court affirmed. The High Court, while examining whether a substantial question of law exists to admit a second appeal, noted that the B schedule path was recorded in commissioner reports (Exts. C1–C12) and that PW1 (power of attorney holder) and CW1 (commissioner) corroborated its existence and utility as an easement under Section 15 of the Indian Easement Act, 1882. The court emphasized that the second appeal requires a substantial question of law and that such a question is not raised here, citing Nazir Mohamed v. J. Kamala and Others, Kondiba Kadam and Government of Kerala v. Joseph. Consequently, the appeal was meritedly dismissed, with all pending interlocutory applications also dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
R.S.A.No.98/2024

Kunjiraman Nair and Others v. Sujesh and Swapna T.

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a suit in the Munsiff Court, Quilandy, by plaintiffs Sujesh and Swapna challenging the defendants’ obstruction to a pathway ( plaint C schedule ) and seeking removal of obstructions. The plaintiffs claim ownership and possession of plaint A and B schedules (lands inherited from the 2nd plaintiff’s father) and assert a right to use plaint C schedule, a public pathway of about 8 feet in width and 150 meters in length, extending from Sishumandiram Road to Chethilthazhe Road, which provides access to the properties. The trial court granted permanent prohibitory injunction against the defendants and a mandatory injunction to remove obstructions in plaint C. The first appellate court affirmed. The defendants argued that plaint C schedule pathway does not exist as described; that the plaintiffs possess excess property; that there is no easement by necessity or by prescription; and that the 8-foot width is not reflected in the Panchayat Asset Register; they offered to provide a 4-foot path instead. The High Court, after examining Ext C1 (commission report) and Ext A4/A5, and relying on provisions of the Panchayat Raj Act (notably Section 169 and the concept of vesting of public roads in the panchayat), held that plaint C is a public road to which the plaintiffs have a right of access. The court dismissed the appeal as meritless, upholding concurrent verdicts and vacating interim orders. It cites several precedents to emphasize the requirement of a substantial question of law for second appeals. The appeal is thus dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
RSA Nos.775 of 2022 & 408 of 2023

Unnikrishnan K.K. v. Kanakam K.K.

This common judgment addresses two Regular Second Appeals (RSA Nos. 775 of 2022 and 408 of 2023) arising from civil suits in Thrissur involving title to the plaint schedule property and the validity of settlement and release deeds. The appellant Unnikrishnan K.K. contends that the 1999 settlement deed Ext. A2 (and the prior release Ext. A1) were procured through fraud and do not vest title in Kanakam K.K. The dispute traces back to a release deed executed by Kochukuttan’s legal representatives in 1991 to facilitate loan arrangements, followed by Ext. A2/Ext. B1, a settlement deed in Kanakam’s favor. Kanakam, supported by others, claims that after the father’s death all parties executed a release to the mother, who then executed Ext. A2/B1, thereby perfecting title in Kanakam and displacing Unnikrishnan’s possession, which was acknowledged as that of a trespasser in the trial and first appellate proceedings. The High Court, after hearing both sides, held that no substantial question of law is made out for admission of the second appeals under Section 100 CPC, citing Nazir Mohamed v. J. Kamala and others, Kondiba Kadam, and later Kerala Supreme Court judgments on maintainability. The court found the concurrent judgments below sound. Consequently, the appeals were dismissed as meritless, with a three-month window for Unnikrishnan to vacate, conditioned on filing an affidavit; all interlocutory orders were vacated.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2318 OF 2024

Farooq Rasheed, Inzam Ma, and K.H. Shihab v. State of Kerala

The petitioners, three individuals, filed B.A. No.2318 of 2024 under Section 438 CrPC before the Kerala High Court, seeking pre-arrest bail in Crime No.214/2024 of Vengara Police Station, Malappuram, alleging offences under Section 420 IPC and Section 66D IT Act. The prosecution alleges an online investment scam through a portal named Blackrock Angel One between January 23 and February 21, 2024, in which the complainant was induced to invest about Rs 1,08,42,222 in seven transactions; the complainant later discovered the link was fake and claims to have been cheated. The first petitioner is alleged to be the 5th accused; other petitioners are described as participants with alleged involvement in digital currency trading via the app Binance; the prosecution contends that digital evidence will be required and custodial interrogation is necessary to unravel the complex web of transactions and to effect recovery. The petitioners argue they are innocent and falsely implicated; they claim there was no recoverable assets and that custodial interrogation is not necessary. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing that the first petitioner is deeply involved and that the two other petitioners are suspects; the court, citing Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre, Sibbia, Jai Prakash Singh and P. Chidambaram, holds that anticipatory bail is not warranted in the present stage, given the gravity of the economic offence and the preliminary nature of investigation. The bail application is dismissed, but the court grants a 10-day window for surrender, with a direction to consider the bail on merits if surrender occurs.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 2105 of 2023

WA No. 2105 of 2023

This intra-court appeal by the State challenges the judgment dated 17 January 2023 in WP(C) No.28741 of 2021, directing reimbursement of medical expenses incurred by the writ petitioner, K.G. Prasad, who was then Principal of PMSAMA Higher Secondary School. On 12 June 2019 he collapsed with chest pain and was treated first at a Government Taluk Hospital, Malappuram, then urgently referred to Hearts Malabar Super Specialty Hospital, which performed angioplasty and additional procedures from 28.06.2019 to 01.07.2019, incurring Rs. 3,25,000. The hospital was non-empanelled. Ext.P5 denied reimbursement under Circular No.34/2020/Fin and KGSMA Rules; Ext.P2 evidences the medical expenses. The Single Judge allowed the writ petition, holding the government liable to reimburse medically necessary emergency treatment even in non-empanelled private hospitals, given the emergent circumstances and the constitutional right to health. The State contends that reimbursement should be confined to empanelled facilities and that emergency treatment does not override the rules and fiscal constraints. The Division Bench affirms the judgment, holding that in emergent life-saving scenarios, the government cannot deny treatment costs and that the right to health under Articles 21 and related DPSP provisions obligates reimbursement despite non-empanelled status. The appeal is dismissed; the State’s rigid interpretation would undermine a government obligation to protect life and health.

High Court of Kerala
BA No.10825 of 2023

Krishnaj v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by KrishnaJ, the ninth accused in Crime No.310/2023 of Nedupuzha Police Station, Thrissur, for alleged offences under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 27(A) of the NDPS Act, 1985. The prosecution claims a cannabis haul of 220.910 kg was recovered from a car on 5.5.2023, with funds allegedly transmitted by the petitioner to the sister of the third accused, who in turn routed Rs.2.5 lakh to the tenth accused. The petitioner contends total innocence, asserting false implication, and notes that co-accused 1–4 were granted statutory bail by the Sessions Court and accused 5 & 7 were released on bail by this Court; the investigation, including recovery, is largely complete. The Public Prosecutor counters that there is a specific allegation of financing, and Sec.27(A) applies, which would bar bail. The Court observes that the investigation has suffered from laches (Sec.36A(4) not invoked), and that there is no prima facie material connecting the petitioner to the offences; the petitioner has no criminal antecedents. Relying on a recent Kerala High Court decision (Dheeraj Kumar Shukla) and citing Sushila Aggarwal for bail principles, the Court dilutes the rigour of Sec.37 NDPS, and grants bail with conditions (bond Rs.1,00,000 with two sureties), allowing appearance, non-inducement, non-commission of offences, and passport surrender, while noting the ongoing investigative discretion.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2328 OF 2024

Vikas Mathew v. State of Kerala

Vikas Mathew, the sole accused in Crime No.159/2024 of Velikulangara Police Station, Thrissur, approaches this High Court bail application under Section 439 CrPC. He was arrested initially on 24.01.2024 in Crime No.203/2024 by Ernakulam Central Police Station and later formally arrested in the present case. The prosecution case alleges that, with dishonest intent, he induced the de facto complainant to secure an overseas employment visa and, as consideration, received Rs.8,65,000, returning only Rs.3,85,000, thereby committing offences under IPC Section 420. The applicant contends innocence and asserts that the FIR does not attract the offences charged, arguing false implication. He also notes that in BA No.1958/2024 the court had already enlarged him on bail in a similar crime, and that investigation is substantially complete with recoveries effected. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, highlighting the accused’s criminal antecedents and involvement in 11 other cases in different police stations, contending that release could lead to further offences. After hearing counsel and assessing the material on record, the learned Judge concluded that further detention is unnecessary, given the duration of custody since 24.01.2024, near completion of investigation, and material recoveries. The bail order grants release on a bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties of equal amount, subject to typical conditions including reporting, avoidance of tampering with witnesses, surrender of passport, address disclosure, and potential cancellation for violation. The court also notes the principle from Sushila Aggarwal regarding continuing investigation during bail.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) NO. 74 OF 2024

Abhilash R.M. v. Additional Director General of Police, State Crime Records Bureau, Thiruvananthapuram; Director General of Police, Police Headquarters, Irvella-yambalam, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala

Abhilash R.M., a police constable and applicant in O.A. No. 1491/2020 before the Kerala Administrative Tribunal, challenges a disciplinary penalty enhanced after criminal proceedings resulted in acquittal. The tribunal had directed the second respondent to consider his appeal, but did not interfere with the penalty. The High Court of Kerala, in OP(KAT) No. 74 of 2024, notes that the charge memo in the disciplinary proceedings largely mirrors the criminal charges, including an allegation regarding stopping a vehicle; however, the applicant was merely a pillion rider, not the driver, so the alleged “non-stoppage” does not provide a basis for departmental action. The court relies on Section 101(8) of the Kerala Police Act, and on State of Kerala v. Vijayakumar (2021) 4 KLT 35, and O.P.(KAT) No. 314/2019, which hold that once criminal proceedings end in acquittal or are dropped, disciplinary action based on the same facts cannot be sustained. The court therefore holds that there are no independent allegations justifying the penalty, and quashes all disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner. The Original Petition is disposed of accordingly, reinforcing the principle that acquittal bars departmental punishment on identical facts.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2326 OF 2024

Subeesh v. State of Kerala

Subeesh, the fourth accused in Crime No.165/2024 of Kaipamangalam Police Station, Thrissur, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC. The FIR alleges that on 22.02.2024, around 22:00 hours, five accused formed an unlawful assembly; the first accused struck the defacto complainant with an iron pipe, causing grievous hurt, while accused 2 and 3 assaulted with their hands. Accused 4 and 5 damaged the parked bus of the defacto complainant, causing a loss of Rs. 25,000. The offences cited include 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 427 and 308 r/w 149 IPC. The petitioner was arrested on 27.02.2024. He contends innocence regarding the 308 charge; he has been in judicial custody since 27.02.2024; the investigation is practically complete and recoveries have been effected; hence bail should be granted. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, noting ongoing investigation and that the petitioner has eight other criminal antecedents, though not disputing that the 308 act is attributed to the first accused. The court cites Supreme Court precedents emphasizing the presumption of innocence, bail as a rule, and the rights of undertrial prisoners, and ultimately grants bail on specific conditions: bond of Rs.50,000 with two solvent sureties, appearance before IO on Saturdays, no inducement or tampering with evidence, no new offences, surrender of passport, and a provision for cancellation on violation. The order is dated 12.04.2024.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2478 OF 2024

K P Sinto Thomas v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application (Section 438 CrPC) filed by K P Sinto Thomas, the second accused in Crime No.128/2024 of Ernakulam Town South Police Station, pending in the High Court of Kerala. Five persons are alleged to have attacked the de facto complainant near a Kadavanthra tea shop on 19 January 2024, resulting in grievous injuries; the accused are charged under IPC sections 323, 324, 325, 326 and 308 read with 34. The applicant contends innocence, false implication by the complainant who is alleged to be a history sheeter; he asserts no recovery and argues custodial interrogation is unnecessary; he also claims involvement of an extortion demand of Rs.8 lakh to settle the case. The learned Public Prosecutor submits that medical records show facial fracture and head injuries; other accused have surrendered or had bail rejected; granting anticipatory bail would impede the investigation. Citing Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra and Sibbia, the court reiterates that anticipatory bail is not to be bound by rigid guidelines but must be decided on facts with careful discretion, balancing investigation needs with individual liberty. The court ultimately finds no exceptional grounds for pre-arrest bail and dismisses the application, but directs surrender within 10 days for interrogation; thereafter, the bail petition may be considered on merits if surrendered.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 7311 OF 2024

MANOJ KUMAR P v. THE SUB COLLECTOR AND RDO CIVIL STATION ERNHIPPALAM KOZHIKODE; THE AGRICULTURAL OFFICER KRISHIBHAVAN CHATHAMANGALAM KOZHIKODE DISTRICT; THE COMMISSIONER OF LAND REVENUE

The petitioner, Manoj Kumar P, has approached Kerala High Court in WP(C) No. 7311 of 2024 challenging Ext.P8, an order of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) rejecting his Form 5 application for removal of land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. He asserts ownership of around 0.3008 hectares (about 76 cents) in Sy. No. 85/1, Chathamangalam, Kozhikode district, and contends the property does not fall within paddy land or wetland definitions under the Act, and that it has been wrongly included in the Data Bank. Ext.P8 relied on a site inspection by a Junior Superintendent and a report indicating land features resembling paddy land and water channels, without an independent assessment of the land’s status as on the Act’s date. The petitioner argues the KSRSEC report was misquoted and that the RDO was not bound to accept junior-officer findings; Rule 4(4E) and 4(4F) permit obtaining professional reports and, if needed, satellite imagery or direct inspection. The court cites Muraleedharan Nair v. RDO, Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO, and Sudheesh v. RDO to stress independent assessment, and holds that mere neerchals or water presence cannot determine paddy/wetland status. It sets aside Ext.P8 and directs reconsideration of Form 5 in light of Ext.P5 (KSRSEC) and a possible site inspection, within two months, with disposal of the petition.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 10865 OF 2023

Suresh Kumar v. State of Kerala

This is Bail Application No. 10865 of 2023 before the High Court of Kerala, filed by Suresh Kumar, the ninth accused in Crime No. 38/2021 of the Ernakulam Excise Range Office. The applicant sought regular bail under Section 439 CrPC in connection with a Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act offence involving 1.085 kg of MDMA seized on 19 August 2021. The investigation linked accused Nos. 1–9 to the transport of the contraband based on CCTV details at Marhaba Apartment, Vazhakala. Earlier bail petitions (BA 10321/2022 on 27 January 2023 and BA 3370/2023 on 8 August 2023) were dismissed. The prosecution opposed bail on the ground that the offence relates to a commercial quantity under NDPS and that the accused had involvement in another NDPS crime (Crime No. 36/2021); CCTV and other records allegedly establish involvement. The Court examined Section 37 of the NDPS Act and its rider, noting that bail in such cases requires two conjunctive conditions: (i) reasonable grounds for believing the accused is not guilty of the commercial quantity offences, and (ii) that he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail. Relying on Kesari and a line of NDPS judgments, the court rejected the plea to dilute the rider and held the petition meritless, dismissing it and directing expedited trial within four months. It observed that there are materials in abundance to connect the petitioner to this crime including CCTV footage, and cannot hold him innocent of the allegations; hence bail was denied.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No.2763 of 2023

Murukan v. Raveendran and others

Murukan, the second judgment debtor in E.P. No. 29/2015 of the Principal Sub Court, Kochi, challenges Ext. P-8, the order dismissing his objection under Section 60(1)(c) CPC to the attachment/execution of his dwelling. In OP(C) 2763/2023, he contends that as a labourer occupying the house in the property he is entitled to the exemption under 60(1)(c), and he relies on a single-judge decision in Vasanthakumari v. Raichal Banitta (2009) and on Exts. P-10 and P-11 to show a fishing livelihood. The respondents argue that the petitioner has repeatedly sought to deflect the decree’s fruits, has been offered security options (Bank Guarantee) but failed to comply, and that a prior claim by his children asserted only a one-third right; the execution was proceeded against accordingly. The Sub Judge dismissed the exemption objection, and this Court reviews. On evaluation, the Court finds that the pleadings do not establish that the petitioner is a labourer within the meaning of Section 60(1)(c). The evidence—Exts. P-10 (passbook) and P-11 (cooperative society letter)—does not prove salaried or dependent labour, nor a defined livelihood; by distinguishing Vasanthakumari, the Court concludes that the facts are different. Therefore, the original petition is devoid of merit and is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2465 OF 2024

Akhil A and Aji v. State of Kerala and The Station House Officer, Sooranad Police Station

This is a pre-arrest bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed by two petitioners in Crime No. 363/2024 of Sooranad Police Station, Kollam, arising from allegations of offences under Sections 323, 324, 294(b) and 427 r/w Section 34 IPC, with Section 326 IPC later incorporated. The prosecution alleges that on 18.03.2024, around 10:30 PM, after an altercation in front of the first accused’s house, the first to third accused and five others restrained and assaulted the defacto complainant; the fourth accused struck the complainant with an iron rod, causing a nasal bone fracture, and the complainant’s motorcycle was damaged to the tune of Rs.50,000. The petitioners contend their innocence, noting that Annexure A1 FIR did not originally allege Section 326, which was added later based on the treatment certificate alleging nasal fracture attributed to the fourth accused; they argue no overt act by them to attract 326 and that custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, claiming common intention and necessity of custodial interrogation, supported by the treatment certificate. The court, after considering the materials, finds no specific overt act against the petitioners to attract 326 and holds custodial interrogation is unnecessary, granting pre-arrest bail with conditions including surrender within ten days, bond of Rs 50,000 with two sureties, passport surrender if present, cooperation with investigation, and compliance with other conditions, while citing the principle that investigation can continue during bail.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No.2773 of 2023

Thressia and Wilson v. Reji Joseph and Thekumkara Grama Panchayath

This is a Kerala High Court Original Petition (OP(C)) challenging the correctness of Ext.P7 in OS 1017/2014 of the Munsiff Court, Vadakkancherry. The petitioners, Thressia and Wilson, as defendants, contend that Ext.P4, the second Commissioner's report, cannot stand because the measurement of the property was not carried out from the survey stone located at the south‑eastern corner, as requested in the work memo. They urge the court either to remit Ext.P4 or to appoint a fresh Commission to measure based on the survey stone and consistent with the private surveyor’s inputs. They also rely on a Division Bench decision of this Court in Laly Joseph @ Laly Sebastian v. K.U. Francis (2023 (3) KHC 678). The respondents counter that an earlier Commission was conducted with the consent of both parties and that the second report reiterates findings that a portion of the plaintiff’s property is in the possession of the defendants; the report attributes its measurements to title deeds, survey records and possession. The court notes the explanations given in Ext.P4 about why the survey stone was not used. It concludes that, for the sole reason that the survey stone was not used, a Commissioner's report cannot be set aside; it also declines a further opportunity to examine the surveyor and disposes of the petition, upholding Ext.P7 and dismissing the Original Petition.

High Court of Kerala
OP (FC) NO. 689 OF 2023

PRADEESH v. S.M. SHEEBA RANI & Others

This High Court of Kerala, in OP (FC) 689/2023, reviews the Family Court’s order on maintainability of O.P. 1544/2017 and determines the jurisdiction to entertain proceedings arising from a matrimonial-property dispute. The petitioner in this OP is PRADEESH, the 11th counter-petitioner in the main Family Court petition, who challenges the Family Court’s finding that the petition is maintainable before the Family Court. The original petition, filed by the wife against her husband, sought realization of Rs. 5 lakhs, the return of 75 sovereigns of gold, and a decree to set aside Exts. P3 to P15 sale deeds. The respondents, numbered 1 to 11, are assignees/purchasers of the properties and contend that they are bona fide purchasers and that the Family Court cannot entertain the reliefs against them as non-parties to the marriage. The Court analyzes Section 7(1) of the Family Court Act, including Explanations (c) and (d), to determine jurisdiction, concluding that the reliefs touch property of the parties to the marriage and the transaction chain (Exts. P3–P15) is interconnected, requiring the Family Court’s exclusive jurisdiction. It cites Suprabha v. Sivaraman for the interpretation of “circumstances” arising out of marital relations and Satheedevi v. Prasanna for Court-fee principles. Ultimately, the impugned order upholding the Family Court’s jurisdiction is sustained and the OP is dismissed. The decision is by a Division Bench of Justices Anu Sivaraman and C. Pratheep Kumar.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 2367 of 2024

Anesh v. State of Kerala

Anesh, a 21-year-old accused in Crime No.1213/2023 of Nedumkandam Police Station, Idukki, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC. The offences alleged against him include sections of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) 328, 363, 376(1), 376(2)(j), 354 and 34; offences under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO)—sections 3(a)/4(1), 5(i)/6, 7/8 and 16(2)/17; the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (sections 3(1)(wi), 3(2)(v)); the Information Technology Act, 67B; and the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 (section 77). The petitioner, arrested on 29.12.2023, contends innocence and argues that the overt act pertains to the first accused only; his role is limited to the use of the second accused’s mobile to record the incident. He has been in custody for about four months, and the investigation is practically complete with recovery effected. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, citing ongoing investigation and the likelihood of intimidation or tampering with evidence. The court notes that the overt act is alleged against the first accused, and given the four months’ custody and completed investigation, is inclined to grant bail with stringent conditions, including bond of Rs.1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, reporting to the IO on Saturdays, no contact with the victim, travel restrictions, surrender of passport, and potential cancellation on violation. It cites Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh, State of Kerala v. Raneef, and Hussainara Khatoon to emphasize the presumption of innocence and bail as the general rule.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2330 OF 2024

Vikas Mathew v. State of Kerala

Vikas Mathew, the sole accused in Crime No.101/2024 of Chalakudy Police Station, Thrissur, approached the Kerala High Court by Bail Application No. 2330 of 2024 under section 439 CrPC, seeking enlargement on bail in a case registered for offences under sections 506 and 420 IPC. The prosecution alleges the accused, with dishonest intent, induced the de facto complainant to secure an overseas employment visa and received Rs. 8,00,000, of which Rs. 3,28,000 was returned, with the visa arrangement not materializing. The petitioner was initially arrested in Crime No.203/2024 by Ernakulam Central Police Station and was formally arrested in the present crime; he has been in judicial custody since 24.01.2024. The defense contends innocence and false implication, asserting that the FIR would not attract the charged offences. He relies on a previous bail order in B.A. No.1958/2024 dated 20.03.2024 in a similar crime to support release. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, highlighting the petitioner’s criminal antecedents and involvement in about 11 other similar cases across the state, arguing that bail could invite repetition of offences. After considering rival submissions and records, the court found continued detention unnecessary as the investigation is practically complete and recoveries have been effected, and granted bail on a Rs.50,000 bond with two solvent sureties of equal amount, subject to standard conditions, including appearance, non-tampering with witnesses, surrender of passport, and the court’s power to cancel or modify bail, while citing Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and Anr. as guiding authority on recoveries while on bail.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.13109 of 2024

WP(C) No. 13109 of 2024 (Petitioners: Binoj Thomas; Francis M.J; Viji Thomas; Benny Paul; K.A. Amjad; Sajeev Jacob; Puthiyaparambil Joseph Joseph; Abraham Manuel; Jothy Thomas; Gee Thomas; Muhammad Rasheed M.I.; Joshy Thomas; Rony John; Respondents: District Magistrate / District Collector Palakkad; District Magistrate, Thrissur; District Magistrate, Idukki; Station House Officers of Kalladikkode, Vadakkencherry, Cherpu, Mathilakam, Vellathooval police stations))

This writ petition challenges a directive to deposit licensed firearms held by the petitioners in the run-up to the Lok Sabha Elections 2024. The petitioners, all licensed arms holders, argue that surrender ahead of the election would imperil their safety and defeat the purpose of licensure, since licenses are issued for protection and the return of arms would occur only after election results—often a two-month horizon. They invoke the Election Commission’s Circular of 01.09.2009, which lays down procedural safeguards before directing surrender, and rely on the decision in Joseph K. A. v. District Collector, Kottayam (2019) to insist that orders mandating surrender must be grounded in compliance with the Circular. The respondents contend that a Screening Committee has been constituted to assess exemptions, and that licensees seeking to retain arms can apply for exemption. The court observes that pleadings are not fully developed and that a detailed ruling would require time; accordingly, it disposes the petition with a provisional mechanism. The court directs that the petitioners may apply for exemption to the Screening Committee within two days, and if filed with the judgment copy, the arms need not be surrendered pending the Committee’s decision. This order balances security concerns with licensees’ safety needs.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 2634 OF 2024

Girish v. State of Kerala

Girish, the sole accused in Crime No.239/2024 of Nedumkandam Police Station, moves for bail under section 438 CrPC in a case alleging offences under sections 454, 354, 354B, 392, and 427 read with 34 IPC. The prosecution states that on 01.03.2024, the accused along with two others reached the defacto complainant’s residence at Birdmetty Bhagam, Nedumkandam, Kalkoonthal village, trespassed into her house, demanded money, and during the incident the second accused tore the complainant’s nightie, causing alleged outraging of modesty, while the petitioner allegedly robbed Rs.20,000 from her bag and a half-sovereign gold chain worth Rs.20,000. The FIR was registered on these allegations. The petitioner contends there was a money transaction with the complainant and that the case is false; he is ready to abide by strict conditions if released on bail. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, highlighting grievous offences. The High Court, applying the basic bail jurisprudence, notes that bail is a rule and detention is the exception, citing Chidambaram P. v. Directorate of Enforcement. While granting bail, the court imposes stringent conditions: appearance for interrogation within ten days; post-interrogation bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties; prohibition from entering Nedumkandam jurisdiction for 30 days; non-communication or intimidation; restriction on leaving India; and a general non-commission of similar offences. The court also preserves the power to cancel bail if conditions are violated, following Sushila Aggarwal v. State.