WP(C) Nos.19628 and 19661 of 2024 Two writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 19628/2024 and 19661/2024) before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, decided on 7 June 2024 by a Single Judge, deal with renewal of Goods Carriage permits for two vehicles (KL-42R-1635 and KL-42R-1857) hypothecated to Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited. The petitioner contends that for renewal of permits an No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the financier is required; the 3rd respondent received applications on 24.04.2024 but did not issue the NOC. Section 51(7) of the Kerala Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 provides that if there is no response within seven days, the NOC can be deemed issued, enabling renewal applications to proceed in the absence of NOC. The respondent authority, however, has not acted. The Government Pleader argued that the petitioner did not produce sufficient evidence of sending a proper request to the financier; if such proof is produced, the matter can be considered with notice to the financier under Section 51(8). The Court cites Jayamon v. Regional Transport Authority, Cherthala (2015 (2) KHC 685) to hold that Section 51 does not mandate a preexisting NOC, only a request and a declaration if no response. The Court directs the petitioner to submit a declaration along with Ext.P8 applications; the 2nd respondent must consider the renewals in accordance with law with notice to the financier and decide within six weeks, given the two vehicles cannot currently be used. Exhibits P1–P11 in the appendices reflect registration, permits, representations, receipts, and related judgments.
BAIL APPL. NO. 4302 OF 2024 This High Court of Kerala bail application under Section 439 CrPC concerns the sole accused in Crime No. 2013/2023 of Kollam East Police Station, charged under Section 22(c) NDPS Act for allegedly possessing 16.40 grams of MDMA for sale at Kollam Railway Station on 30.12.2023. The court considers whether the petitioner, in custody since 30.12.2023, should be released on bail while the investigation is substantially complete. The prosecution initially alleged MDMA possession, but the State Forensic Science Laboratory’s report dated 16.03.2024 concluded the contraband was methamphetamine, reclassifying the quantity as intermediate rather than commercial. The defense contends innocence and alleges false implication, asserting the material is not in conscious possession of the petitioner and that the contraband is methamphetamine. The petitioner has no criminal antecedents, and the investigation is near completion; thus, detention seems unnecessary. The prosecution opposed bail, citing ongoing investigation and risk of reoffending, but furnished the chemical analysis to support its case. After weighing the submissions and the absence of antecedents, the court, though noting the corrected substance, exercises caution but grants bail, setting a bond of Rs. 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties and standard conditions, including weekly appearances before IO, non-interference, passport surrender, and the possibility of cancellation on breach, in line with Sushila Aggarwal guidance on investigation during bail.
Mat. Appeal No. 294 of 2024 This matrimonial appeal arises from an order of the Family Court, Kozhikode in O.P. No.1502 of 2019, where the respondent father sought custody and guardianship of his minor daughter. The Family Court rejected the prayer for guardianship and permanent custody, but granted the petitioner-mother limited visitation rights and occasional overnight custody during vacations when the father came on leave from his Merchant Navy service. The appellant mother challenges these directions, contending that the court ought to have granted guardianship and permanent custody to her, given that the child is well-settled with her and the father’s prolonged sea-life absence (8–10 months a year) makes him unsuitable for primary custody. The respondent father argues that the child should retain contact with both parents and that denial of custody would adversely affect the child’s welfare; he asserts that both parents play a vital role in the child’s upbringing and education. The High Court, after interacting with both parties and observing the child (approximately 11 years old), reiterates the paramount consideration of the child’s welfare, citing Yashita Sahu, Vasudha Sethi, and Rohith Thammana Gowda to emphasize best interests, and the necessity of maintaining contact through visitation rights. The Court finds no reason to disturb the Family Court’s well-reasoned order and dismisses the appeal, underscoring that the welfare of the child remains central.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 3589 of 2024) before the Hon'ble Justice Bechu Kurian Thomas at the High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam. The petitioner, Jayesh J. Kumar, 1st accused in CC No. 784 of 2017, challenges a common order dated 15.03.2024 passed in CMP Nos. 764/2024 and 765/2024 by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate (EO), Ernakulam. The applications sought summons to produce certified copies of the certificate of registration and memorandum of two minority educational societies, and to summon the Director of the University Academic Audit Cell to produce the affiliation certificates for Adusumilli Vijaya College of Engineering and Research Centre and Adusumilli Vijaya Institute of Technology and Research Centre. The Magistrate dismissed both applications. The court notes that the defence is entitled to adduce evidence and that a fair trial requires the defence be given reasonable opportunity, especially at the defence stage after prosecution evidence has been closed for defence witnesses. Citing Ronald Wood Mathams, Zahira Habibulla Sheikh and Santhosh Kumar, the Court reasoned that rules of procedure exist to ensure justice and must be scrupulously followed; the accused cannot be deprived of a defence. In result, the High Court set aside the impugned order and directed summons to be issued and evidence to be taken on the date of appearance without adjournment. The CRL.M.C is allowed.
WP(C) NO. 10612 OF 2024 & con.cases The judgment arises from a batch of writ petitions (WP(C) 10612 of 2024 and connected cases) challenging freezing of bank accounts in cybercrime-related investigations. The Kerala High Court, before single judge Justice T.R. Ravi, consolidates 2024 proceedings involving multiple petitioners (banks, service cooperatives, travel portals, and individuals) whose accounts were frozen by various banks on police notices and cybercrime portal directives. The Court notes that interim directions already issued in related cases require freezing to be confined to the amount disputed in the police/intimation, and that such orders should not indiscriminately immobilize entire balances. The court references a earlier decision in Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661) and a judgment in WP(C) 28155/2023 to frame its directions. On admission, the court directs that respondent banks confine freezes to the exact amounts mentioned in police orders and that police authorities must communicate to banks the justification and time limits for continuance of freezes (up to eight months from the present order). It disposes of all petitions with these uniform directions, while leaving contentions and further orders open for future review if information is not communicated. The bench remains single-judge, delivering a reasoned, uniform set of directives to balance anti-fraud necessities with petitioners’ access to funds.
BA No.4468 of 2024 arises from a bail application by Muneer K.P., the seventh accused in Crime No.321/2024 of Karipur Police Station, Malappuram. The petitioner seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC, asserting innocence and alleging false implication. The prosecution contends a conspiracy to commit dacoity of gold being illegally transported from Doha by the second accused, with the petitioner and others allegedly participating. The second accused reportedly delivered 760 grams of gold to a real agent, but the plan faltered when the gold was not handed over. The petitioner, who claims to have only accompanied accused 1 and 3–6, has been in judicial custody since 1 May 2024. The investigation is stated to be practically complete and recovery has been effected; the petitioner reportedly has no substantial criminal antecedents of a similar nature. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, citing ongoing investigation and the petitioner’s connection with another case under the Kerala Police Act, Sec. 118(a). The petitioner’s counsel emphasized presumption of innocence and that bail is the rule, not jail, especially when the charge sheet is filed and there is no overt act attributable to the petitioner. The High Court, after considering rival submissions, concluded that detention is unnecessary given 34 days in custody, completed investigation, and recovery, and granted bail with stringent conditions, citing Sanjay Chandra and Sushila Aggarwal to justify bail jurisprudence.
BAIL APPL. NO. 3360 OF 2024 This Bail Application (BAIL APPL. NO. 3360 OF 2024) concerns the second accused, Aswin, in Crime No. 5/2024 registered with the Cyber Crime Police Station, Kollam. Under Sec. 439 CrPC, he seeks bail after being in custody since 13.03.2024 for offences under Sections 419 and 420 IPC read with 34, and Section 66D of the IT Act. The prosecution contends that, in concert with co-accused, he induced the defacto complainant to invest ₹42,50,276; funds were allegedly withdrawn from the accuseds’ bank accounts and no profit or return was paid. The applicant argues innocence, asserts the FIR/FIS fail to establish offences, notes 40 days of judicial custody and that investigation is practically complete with recovery effected, and contends no criminal antecedents. The learned Public Prosecutor counters that the offences are grave economic offences and that release could enable further crimes. The Court emphasizes the presumption of innocence (Article 21) and the bail-as-default principle (bail is the rule, jail the exception), citing landmark decisions (Sanjay Chandra; Dataram Singh; State of Kerala v. Raneef; Hussainara Khatoon I) and later references (Sushila Aggarwal). After balancing facts and short detention, the Court allows bail on Rs.1,00,000 bond with two sureties and imposes conditions including regular appearance, non-tampering with witnesses/evidence, no new offences, passport surrender, and potential cancellation for violations.
Bibin Babu, the first accused in Crime No. 282/2024 of Binanipuram Police Station, Ernakulam, moves bail under Section 439 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The alleged offences are Sections 457 and 380 r/w Section 34 IPC, for theft of 500 kg of iron pipes, five outdoor AC units and other scrap from the complainant’s company, causing a loss of Rs. 45,000. He was arrested on 02.05.2024 and has been in judicial custody since. The prosecution contends that the investigation is ongoing and that other accused remain at large; the release could lead to further offences. The petitioner asserts total innocence, contends there is no material substantiating involvement, and points to no prior criminal history; he also notes the investigation is nearly complete and that recovery has been effected. The court recalls the principle that bail is the rule and jail the exception, supported by the presumption of innocence. It cites Sanjay Chandra v. CBI for the presumption and cautions against denying bail on sentiments, and State of Kerala v. Raneef for Article 21 protection of undertrials. After considering these and the 27 days in custody, the court finds detention unnecessary, granting bail on specific terms including bond and sureties, reporting, no tampering, no new offences, passport surrender, and recoveries permitted under Sushila Aggarwal guidance.
Amithkumar C.R., the fourth accused in Crime No.1424/2023 of North Paravur Police Station, Ernakulam, moved this High Court under Section 439 CrPC seeking bail in a Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) case involving transport and storage of MDMA. On 3 December 2023, around 8:20 hours, 1.824 kg of MDMA was seized from four packets in the stepney tyre of a car and from the accused’s rented house; the material was allegedly meant for trafficking to Kerala for sale. The defense contends that the Detecting Officer planted the contraband and violated mandatory provisions under Section 52A and the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (Seizure, Storage, Sampling and Disposal) Rules, 2022, particularly the drawing of samples and inventory in the presence of a Magistrate. The five packets were transferred into a single packet, weighed, and produced before the Magistrate, which, according to Vaisakh v. Kerala, taints the chain of custody. The Public Prosecutor counters that whether prejudice was caused is a question for trial and that the contraband qualifies as a commercial quantity, invoking Section 37 and related decisions. The court, after considering the submissions, accepts that serious procedural lapses occurred, but exercises its discretion to grant bail, noting the petitioner’s lack of prior antecedents and the need to preserve the integrity of the defense; the order states observations relate to bail only. The bail is granted on bond of Rs 1 lakh with two sureties, and standard conditions apply.
This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by the first accused, MujeeB Rahman, in Crime No. 486/2008 of Kadakkal Police Station, Kollam, seeking enlargement on bail for alleged rape (Section 376 r/w Sec. 34 IPC). The prosecution alleges that in March 2008, the petitioner, along with the second accused (the victim’s mother-in-law), induced the victim with a false belief about black magic and a supposed hidden treasure in their house, took her to a mosque, and repeatedly committed rape on her. The second accused remains at large. The accused were arrested in March 2024; the petitioner remained in judicial custody for about three months prior to the bail application. The investigation was completed and the final report filed on 21.4.2011. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing the accused absconded and that release could enable intimidation or tampering with witnesses and that the trial should proceed. The counsel for the petitioner contends innocence, false implication, and long lapse (incident in 2008) with no prior criminal record. Relying on Supreme Court precedents like Sanjay Chandra v. CBI and Dataram Singh v. State of UP, the court notes bail is generally the rule and jail an exception, and that Article 21 safeguards the right to bail. After balancing the factors, the court grants bail with stringent conditions: Rs.1,00,000 bond with two solvent sureties for equal amount, periodic appearances before the IO, prohibition on tampering with witnesses, surrender of passport, restriction to jurisdiction, expeditious trial, and potential cancellation for breach of conditions. The order is issued by Justice C.S. Dias."
The Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB) filed DBA No.12 of 2023 seeking an extension of time till 30 January 2024 to submit the Annual Account Statement for the year 2020-21 before the Joint Director, Kerala State Audit and Accounts Department. The matter has a lineage of prior applications (including DBA No.9 of 2023) and orders, with the court noting that the 2020-21 accounts were reportedly submitted on 05 January 2024. The Travancore Devaswom Act, 1950 imposes a statutory framework for administration, audit, and accounting of Devaswoms, including annual audits by the High Court-appointed auditors under Section 32 and related provisions (Sections 25, 31, 32, and sub-sections 1–12 of Section 32). The Devaswom Fund Accounts Rules (Double Entry System) of 2012, particularly Rule 11, prescribe deadlines for finalising Annual Statements (by 30 September of the following year), with the accounting system to be implemented retrospectively from 01.04.2010, coexisting with the earlier system. The court recalled Annexure A1 orders and the need to show sufficient cause for extension; it highlighted the inordinate delay and lack of a satisfactory explanation, conditioning any extension on compliance with the rule-based timetable. Ultimately, the Division Bench declined to grant the extension, stressing public accountability and the Board’s duty to timely furnish accounts. The order closes with the dismissal of the DBA and emphasizes accountability and compliance with statutory timelines.
BAIL APPL. NO. 4160 OF 2024 This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Lefnas, the fourth accused in Crime No.128/2024 of Kadavanthra Police Station, Ernakulam, charged with offences under IPC Sections 120B, 323, 324, 342, 506(ii), 395 and 364A. The petitioner was arrested on 03.04.2024. The prosecution alleges that on 07.02.2024, the accused (1st to 4th) abducted the husband of the defacto complainant in the car of the 1st accused, assaulted him, extracted a sale letter, and received Rs.80,000 via Google Pay and Rs.50,000 by bank transfer as ransom, with further demands for money. The petitioner’s counsel contends innocence and argues that Sections 395 and 364A were added to deny bail; the petitioner has no criminal antecedents and has been in custody since 03.04.2024. Co-accused 1 and 2 have already been granted bail (Annexure A4). The respondents submit that the investigation is ongoing and the charges are serious, justifying denial of bail. Citing Sanjay Chandra v. CBI and Dataram Singh v. State of U.P., the court emphasizes presumption of innocence and that bail is the rule, with imprisonment before conviction being an exception. After considering the 50 days in custody, near-complete investigation and recoveries, the court allows the bail with conditions: Rs.50,000 bond, two sureties, weekly appearances, no tampering with witnesses, surrender of passport if any, and potential modification of conditions, consistent with Sushila Aggarwal. The order concludes with bail granted; the petitioner is to be released accordingly.
This is a review petition under Article 226 of the Constitution filed by Kalodi St. George Forane Church (represented by the Vicar) challenging the Kerala High Court’s February 19, 2024 judgment in W.P.(C.) No.20705/2015 (K. Mohandas and others v. State of Kerala and others), in which Ext.P5 (a patta) was quashed and the government directed to assess market value of the land and inform the 5th respondent for possible purchase. The writ petition concerned assignment of government land and the validity of Ext.P5. The review petitioner argues that Annexures AI and AII—showing historical ownership as far back as 1928/1931 and reflected in the Basic Land Tax Register—were not brought to the court’s notice earlier and thus the decision was based on erroneous facts. They contend they have (or had) tenancy/fixity of tenure under Section 13 of the Kerala Land Reforms Act, and therefore the government has no right to claim market value. The petitioner relies on Poabs Enterprises Private Ltd v. State of Kerala and Lilly Thomas to argue that writ judgments can be reviewed and new evidence can be considered. The government counters that Article 226/227 reviews are not governed by Order 47 Rule 1 CPC, and Annexures AI/AII should not alter the record. The court ultimately held there is nothing to review and dismissed the petition in limine, preserving the writ judgment."
WP(C) No. 18942 of 2024 (and connected cases) These three writ petitions filed in the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam concern the elections to the Managing Committee of the Mukkom Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. The petitions assortedly challenge membership and voters-list issues and the proposed election venue. WP( C) 18942/2024 seeks removal of certain names from the respondent Society’s membership list granted after Ext.P11; WP(C) 23870/2024 alleges a large number of ineligible persons have been included in the voters list; WP(C) 22575/2024 seeks alteration of the proposed election venue for lack of proper facilities. The State Co-operative Election Commission (EC) and the Administrative Committee submit that elections have been notified and final voter lists are not yet published, rendering some challenges premature, and that venue arrangements are to be kept under EC scrutiny. The petitioners urge corrective action to preserve electoral fairness, arguing that flawed lists and venues could vitiate the process. The court, citing the Supreme Court decision Shri Sant Sadguru v. State of Maharashtra and others, notes that once elections are underway, the High Court’s capacity for interference is limited and that the EC, under the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, controls electoral rolls and infrastructure. Consequently, the petitions are disposed of without the requested relief, but the petitioners may approach the EC for any pending applications, to be considered in due course within the statutory framework, with liberty to proceed as allowed by law.
WP(C) Nos. 20866 of 2024; WP(C) Nos. 17678 of 2024 The judgment concerns a challenge by candidates who claimed they should receive marks for Question 63 in the Kerala TET (K-TET) examination held in March 2023. The petitioners contended that the question “A tool which is not commonly found in a First Aid Kit?” had a plausible alternative answer: ‘Safety pin’ (Serial No.2) even though the official key marked ‘Stethoscope’ (Serial No.3) as correct. The petitioners argued that Ext.P1 notification and Ext.P10 (a Division Bench order in W.A. No. 539/2024) acknowledged that candidates, who answered in line with a permissible alternative, should be given the marks. The court observed that since the petitioners had provided the same answer as in the extant case (Safety pin), they are entitled to one mark for Question 63 if their response matches the second option. The judge directed the 1st respondent to grant one mark to petitioners who answered ‘Safety pin’ for Question 63 and to issue certificates reflecting pass, disposing of the petitions with directions. The decision reflects a consistency with a prior Division Bench ruling and ensures fairness in granting marks where a reasonable alternative answer exists.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal under Section 14-A of the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989, arising from Crime No.177/2024 of Kulathupuzha Police Station. Appellants 1–3 are charged with offences including unlawful assembly, hurt, and insult, and with sections 3(1)(r), 3(1)(s) of the Act, in addition to IPC offences (Sections 341, 294(b), 324, 506) with Section 34. The defacto complainant belongs to the Scheduled Caste and the appellants are not. The Special Court at Kottarakkara rejected anticipatory bail for the appellants, prompting this appeal. The prosecution asserts that the bar under Sections 18 and 18-A of the Act applies to appellant No.1, and that bail should be denied given antecedents and the serious nature of the alleged offences, including threats and public humiliation of a caste-based nature. The appellants contend delay in registration, lack of prima facie evidence under the Act, and that the offences under the Act are not attracted for appellants 2 and 3. The court surveys jurisprudence on anticipatory bail, including Prathvi Raj Chauhan, Subhash Kashinath Mahajan, Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia, Siddharam Mhetre, and Sushila Aggarwal, noting that subsequent decisions have refined the scope of conditions and bar considerations. It ultimately holds that appellant No.1 is not entitled to anticipatory bail, while appellants 2 and 3 qualify for pre-arrest bail on specific terms, with detailed directions for appearance, bonds, and witness protection.
BAIL APPL. NO. 3590 OF 2024 Praveen, a 24-year-old accused in Crime No. 2111/2023 of Venjaramoodu Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC while the case proceeds in SC No. 318/2024. He is charged with offences under IPC Sections 376, 376(2)(f), 342, 354, 354B, and under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (Sections 4 read with 3a, 6 read with 5n, 8 read with 7, and 10 read with 9n). The incident occurred on 6 December 2023 when the victim, aged 16, visited her grandfather’s home; the accused, who is her grandfather’s sister’s son, allegedly photographed the girls, lured the victim to a bedroom, locked the door and subjected her to penetrative sexual intercourse. He was arrested on 11 January 2024 and a final report has been laid in SC No. 318/2024; the trial has not yet begun. The petitioner contends innocence, lack of incriminating materials, and five months in judicial custody with investigation complete; the State counters the gravity of the offence and the danger of witness tampering, though it concedes the investigation is complete. The court emphasizes presumption of innocence and Article 21 rights, and the principle that bail is the rule and jail the exception. Balancing the interests, the court grants bail subject to stringent conditions, including bond of Rs 1 lakh with two sureties, reporting, stay on contacting witnesses, and restrictions on travel, with IO oversight and potential recoveries where necessary, following established jurisprudence including Sanjay Chandra, Raneef and Sushila Aggarwal guidance.
BAIL APPL. NO. 3918 OF 2024 Sunil Kumar, the first accused in Crime No.1398/2023 of Kattakkada Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, filed Bail Application No.3918 of 2024 under Section 439 CrPC in the Kerala High Court challenging an earlier order in Bail Application No.1995 of 2024. The case involves two accused and offences under sections 341, 294(b), 323, 324, 326, 307, 302 and 506(i) read with Sec.34 IPC. The petitioner was arrested on 5 September 2023. The prosecution alleges that on 5 September 2023 at around 16:00 hours, in furtherance of their common intention and due to longstanding animosity with Jalajan (deceased), the accused restrained him, uttered obscene words, and attacked him—first accused with a concrete piece weighing about 2.28 kg, causing fatal injuries; second accused kicked and stamped on the chest, leading to death. Postmortem confirms ante-mortem injuries, including skull fractures and fragmentation. The petitioner contends innocence and argues that his earlier dismissal ( Annexure A3 ) cannot justify indefinite incarceration, violating Article 21. The state opposes bail, citing seriousness and risk of witness intimidation; the court notes the gravity, and, examining the authorities cited from Prasanta Kumar Sarkar, Kalyan Chandra Sarkar, and Mahipal, holds there is no change of circumstances warranting bail. The application is accordingly dismissed.
Jayesh J. Kumar, the first accused in CC 1031/2017, challenges a common order dated 15 March 2024 passed by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate (Economic Offences), Ernakulam, which dismissed two applications (CMP 768/2024 and CMP 769/2024) seeking summons for defence witnesses and production of documents. The prosecution’s case concerns offences under Sections 406, 419 and 420 read with Section 34 IPC. After prosecution evidence closed in June 2023, the defence sought to summon witnesses and obtain documents; the magistrate refused. The petitioner argues that in criminal trials the defence is entitled to adduce evidence and must have a reasonable opportunity to prove its case; refusal to grant process infringes the right to a fair trial. The High Court reiterates that Section 243 Cr.P.C. allows issuing process to defence witnesses, subject to limited exceptions, and that the accused cannot be deprived of the opportunity to present a defence. It relies on decisions including Ronald Wood Mathews v. State of West Bengal and Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh v. State of Gujarat, and Santhosh Kumar v. State, to stress that procedural safeguards exist to ensure justice and must be observed. On this basis, the court holds that the challenged order is erroneous and sets it aside, directing the magistrate to issue summons to the witnesses listed in the two applications, and to examine them on appearance without adjournment, and to complete related examinations promptly.
This Regular Second Appeal before the Kerala High Court arises from a mortgage redemption suit O.S. No.78 of 2018 (Munsiff Court, Perambara) and the corresponding appeal A.S. No.21 of 2022 (Sub Court, Quilandy). The plaintiff, Dr. Rajan Nambiar, sought redemption of a mortgage on the plaint schedule property originally entrusted to the first defendant and later to the second defendant at the instance of the first. The plaintiff deposited the mortgage money as a precondition for redemption. The defendants resisted, contending that the second defendant is not a mortgagee but a tenant. The trial court held that the plaintiff is entitled to redemption and decreed accordingly; the appellate court affirmed. On admission, the appellants argued that if the second defendant is a lessee, eviction under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act would be the proper remedy, not redemption. The High Court reviewed the evidence and concluded that the second defendant possesses rights of a mortgagee by virtue of succession from the first defendant and is bound to redeem on payment of mortgage money. Consequently, the lower decrees stand. The court cited Nazir Mohamed, Kondiba Kadam, Santosh Hazari, Biswanath Ghosh, and Government of Kerala v Joseph to emphasize that a second appeal is maintainable only when a substantial question of law is formulated and that no substantial question was raised here. The appeal is dismissed; three months to vacate, with conditions, and interlocutory applications are also disposed of.