This is a criminal miscellaneous case (Cr.L.M.C. No. 5541 of 2024) before a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court challenging a common order dated 26.06.2024 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Pattambi, that directed interim custody of a lorry KL-35-L-1557 in connection with Crime No.273/2024 of Chalissery Police Station to the second respondent. Petitioner Kochumol Biju asserts she is the registered owner and entered into Annexure 1 with Sakir Ali (the second respondent); under that agreement the vehicle, along with the original registration certificate and documents, was handed to the second respondent to enable payment of the bank loan, after which he would obtain No Objection Certificate in the financier’s name and effect a name change. The petitioner contends the second respondent defaulted and that the interim custody order ignores Annexure 1’s terms and her earlier possession under a Cheranmagadevi, Tamil Nadu order (Annexure 3). The second respondent claims possession since May 2024, having paid part of the sale price and continued EMI payments, and alleges the petitioner wrongfully filed a 420 IPC complaint. The Magistrate’s order favored the second respondent as the rightful interim custodian. The High Court analyzed the scope of Section 451 Cr.P.C., noting its temporary, custodial nature meant to protect the property pending trial, not to confer ownership. It held the impugned order reasonable and non-perverse, and dismissed the petition, leaving the Magistrate’s order intact.
This writ petition questions a blanket freeze of bank accounts under a police requisition. The Kerala High Court references its earlier decision in Dr. Sajeer v. Reserve Bank of India (2024 (1) KLT 826), where it directed banks and police authorities to avoid indefinite, blanket freezes and to align freezes with the amounts requisitioned by the investigating agency. Here, the first petitioner seeks to prevent any partial operation of accounts by a blanket debit freeze of all sums. The court notes that such unbounded freezes harm account holders’ livelihoods and the banking system, and are deleterious unless strictly necessary for investigation. It emphasizes balancing investigative needs with fundamental rights, including the right to livelihood and routine banking transactions. Following the precedent, the court issues targeted directions: (a) the bank must promptly request the Investigation Authority to specify the exact amount to be frozen or held in lien in the account of the first petitioner, within one month of the judgment; (b) if a particular amount is stated, the freeze will be confined to that sum; (c) if no information is received within two months, the petitioners may operate their accounts fully, subject to any future police information; (d) as an alternative, if the entire account must be frozen for stated reasons, the bank will inform the petitioners and continue the freeze for up to eight months; (e) after eight months, if the requisition is not withdrawn, the petitioners may approach the Court again. The order aims to safeguard the investigation while protecting account holders’ rights.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5103 OF 2024 This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by the second accused, Jhonson P.P., in Crime No. 166/2024 of the Medical College Police Station, Kozhikode, charged along with the first accused for offences punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) read with Section 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act). The prosecution alleges conscious possession of 55.185 kilograms of ganja transported in a car on 04.02.2024, and asserts that the contraband constitutes a commercial quantity, bringing the matter within the rigour of Section 37 of the NDPS Act. The petitioner contends his innocence, argues that there is no material establishing his involvement, and submits that he has already spent about six months in judicial custody, the investigation is complete, recovery has been effected, and the final report has been laid, so further detention is unwarranted. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, highlighting incriminating materials and the commercial quantity of contraband, arguing that Section 37 applies and that prior orders denying bail should not be disturbed. The court is guided by NDPS bail jurisprudence, including Union of India v. Shiv Shanker Kesari and State of Kerala v. Rajesh, and by established bail parameters from Prasanta Kumar Sarkar, while also considering Section 439 CrPC. On balance, the court finds no reasonable grounds to believe the petitioner is not guilty or unlikely to offend again on bail, and dismisses the application.
This is an Income Tax Appeal before the Kerala High Court (ITA No.164 of 2019) arising from the assessment year 2013-14. The Revenue challenges the Tribunal Cochin Bench’s order in ITA 508/Coch/2016, which dealt with deduction under section 80P of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The matter centers on whether a Primary Agricultural Credit Society, registered under the Kerala Societies Registration Act, is entitled to the deduction under 80P(2) and, if so, the scope of income that qualifies for such deduction (80P(2) and 80P(2)(a)). The court notes that Mavilayi Service Co-operative Bank Ltd v. Commissioner of Income Tax (cited) has established that the issue is not res integra, and the decision in Peroorkada/Mavilayi guides the interpretation of 80P(2) and the treatment of income heads. The High Court remands the matter to the Assessing Officer for fresh disposal, remitting the Tribunal and assessment order in light of these authorities. Ultimately, the court allows the ITA for statistical purposes and sets aside the Tribunal/Assessment orders, directing fresh proceedings by the AO. The decision integrates prior Supreme Court and Kerala High Court precedent on cooperative banks and 80P deductions to determine the assessable income under appropriate heads.
George Mathew M., a clerk in an aided school, challenged the respondents’ move to refix his pay and recover alleged excess payments following the grant of a Ten Years Time-Bound Higher Grade (TBHG) in 1994. He had entered regular service as a Clerk on 13 July 1984 after a brief spell as a part-time sweeper, and was granted TBHG in 1994 on completion of 10 years of service. An audit objected that his entry was in a last-grade/part-time post and thus he should be eligible only for TBHG on completion of 23 years, while the respondents claimed that the TBHG had to be refixed and recovery effected. The petitioner contended that he was directly appointed as a Clerk, that TBHG privileges under various Government Orders (GO/P/GO(MS) schemes) extended to aided schools, and that recovery after nearly two decades would be unjustified. The Government Pleader argued the contrary, asserting that TBHG could be granted only if regular promotion posts existed and that recovery is permissible under applicable law. The Court relied on Supreme Court authorities such as Rafiq Masih and Jagdev Singh, as well as Kerala Government orders (Exts P7, P8, P9, P10, P12) clarifying TBHG for non-teaching staff in aided institutions. Ultimately, the Court held that the 10-year TBHG granted in 1994 was valid and that recovery would be iniquitous. The petition was allowed; Exts P1, P4, P5 were quashed, and the respondents were interdicted from refixing salary or recovering sums relying on those extensions.
The petitioner, Ananthu Prasannan, challenges Ext.P1 externment order under Section 15(1)(a) KAAPA (2007) interdicting his entry into Kottayam district for nine months, and Ext.P4 by the Advisory Board reducing externment to seven months with conditions. The petitioner contends that seven criminal cases against him are frivolous and that the police harassment continues; he asserts a long delay between the last prejudicial act (12.01.2024) and the externment order (24.04.2024) destroys the live link essential to justifying preventive action. He was classified as a “known goonda” under Section 2(o)(iii) KAAPA, and he relies on prior directions in W.P. 20961/2022 for non-harassment and on delays affecting the link to the last act and the necessity of measures. The State counters with a detailed procedural timeline showing show cause on 02.04.2024, response on 19.04.2024, personal hearing on 22.04.2024, and service of Ext.P1 on 25.04.2024; the Advisory Board reduced the period to seven months. The court finds that the authority’s subjective satisfaction is based on past conduct and that KAAPA permits anticipatory measures to prevent anti-social activities. It cites Binoy v. Kerala, Stalin C.V., and I.B. Bafan for principles on live link, delay, and the non-justiciability of subjective satisfaction, while distinguishing Asker Ali on delay. The petition is dismissed as the externment is justified and proportionate.
BAIL APPL. NO. 4388 OF 2024 This High Court of Kerala bail application, filed under Section 439 CrPC 1973, concerns Sreekumar, second accused in Crime No. 39/1995 of Mavelikkara Police Station, Alappuzha, who stands charged with offences including murder (Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC). Arrested on 11.07.2023 after a long absence, he contends innocence and argues that the absence of summons from the trial court does not automatically indicate a guilty mind. The prosecution contends that the accused fled for nearly three decades, the case has been protracted due to his conduct, and his release on bail would enable him to abscond again, undermining the trial. The trial had been stalled with the case moved to a long-pending register; the Special Investigation Team traced him to Kozhikode. The petitioner relies on Matru alias Girish Chandra v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1971) to argue that absconding alone cannot establish guilt. The court, while acknowledging the delay and the grave nature of the offence, emphasizes the government’s expenditure in tracing the accused and the risk of delaying justice further, and ultimately denies bail. The judge directs the trial court to expedite S.C. No. 984/2023 and disposes the bail application by the end of 30.11.2024, noting the custodial trial status.
Jayasree V. and 15 other petitioners (Library Assistants on contract) of the University of Kerala challenged Ext.P2, a Government order dated 20 October 2022 rejecting their plea for regularisation. They contend that although engaged on contract, they followed the recruitment method stipulated for regular Library Assistants and thus their appointments, while not illegal, were irregular. Relying on the Supreme Court decision in Secretary, State of Karnataka and others v. Uma Devi and others (2006) 4 SCC 1, they argue that regularisation cannot be achieved by bypassing constitutional requirements. The Government pleader contends Ext.P2 is based on verified facts showing the petitioners were not recruited through the prescribed process and therefore cannot be regularised under Uma Devi. The University’s Standing Counsel notes the Government’s position that Ext.P2 reflects a decision by the Government under a prior Court order (Ext.P1) and that the University cannot act independently. The petitioners assert there is documentary evidence suggesting they were recruited following a process akin to the regular method; they urge that due enquiry and opportunity to produce documents were required before Ext.P2 was issued. The High Court finds Ext.P2 lacking in adequate inquiry and evidence, sets it aside, and directs the Government to reconsider after hearing and production of documents, within four months, expeditiously, as per the judgment.
BA 11513/2023; BA 11518/2023; BA 11531/2023 These bail applications, under Section 438 CrPC, concern petitioners Sreenivasan.K and Saleem BAI @ Abdul Saleem K.S, accused in Crime Nos. 857, 865 and 866 of 2023 at Mankada Police Station, Malappuram. The State opposes pre-arrest bail, contending the applicants induced others to release vehicles by forging release orders, resulting in loss to owners; Investigations claim involvement in the release and disposal of vehicles as scrap in Tamil Nadu. The petitioners contend innocence, denial of presence at the scene, false implication, and rely on a precedent Annexure A order where co-accused received pre-arrest bail. On 8 February 2024, the High Court, per Justice C.S. Dias, allowed the three bail applications, applying the same rationale as Annexure A and the earlier case 893/2023, noting that the petitioners were not at the scene of occurrence and that their arrest was not necessary for purposes of investigation. The court directed surrender within ten days, bonds of Rs 25,000, cooperation with investigation including deemed police custody, and protective conditions, including non-intimidation of witnesses and ensuring not to commit offences while on bail. The order also clarifies that police may recover on information even when bail is granted, as per Sushila Aggarwal.
The petitioners/accused Nos.1 and 3 to 6 seek to quash Annexure-1 Final Report in Crime No.367/2020 of Pookottumpadam Police Station under S.482 Cr.P.C., contending that the dispute with the de facto complainant Yamuna C (2nd respondent) and the 3rd respondent (injured) has been amicably settled and the de facto complainant desires not to pursue the case against them. The 2nd respondent and the 3rd respondent swore affidavits in support of the settlement. The learned Public Prosecutor stated there is no objection to quashing the proceedings against accused Nos.1 and 3 to 6, while the other accused remains. The Court cites Supreme Court precedents Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, Narinder Singh and Others v. State of Punjab and Others, and State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others, which hold that High Courts can exercise jurisdiction under S.482 Cr.P.C to quash proceedings in relation to non-compoundable offences when the parties settle, if warranted to ensure ends of justice or to prevent abuse of process. It also relies on Lovely Salhotra and Sajeev & Another v. State of Kerala, which acknowledge that quashing against some accused may be permissible depending on facts. The Court concludes the settlement is personal, there is no public-interest prejudice, and continuing proceedings would serve no purpose. Accordingly, the Crl.M.C. is allowed and the FIR/Final Report against accused Nos.1 and 3 to 6 is quashed.
Rugmini Amma filed WP(C) 30611/2019 in the Kerala High Court challenging the erection of a mobile tower by Reliance Jio Infocomm Ltd at Ivarkala East Kollam on Re Sy No 724/3/2 of Kunnathoor Village. The petitioner contends that the project was undertaken without a license or permit and in violation of the 2013 guidelines for installation of mobile towers, as well as the Kerala Panchayath Raj Act and Kerala Panchayath Building Rules 2011, including the absence of a Structural Stability Certificate. The 6th respondent argues that there is a deemed permit under Rule 16 of the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules and that any challenge should be directed to the District Telecom Committee (DTC). The respondents rely on government orders and the DTCs authority to ventilate grievances. The court, citing Indus Tower Limited v. Sub Inspector of Police (2014 (14) KLT 306), states that persons aggrieved must approach the DTC to ventilate their grievances before approaching the court. Therefore the writ petition is disposed with liberty to the petitioner to approach the DTC and the contentions are left open for consideration before the DTC. The decision underscores deference to statutory channels for telecom disputes.
BA Nos. 9006, 9019, 9042 & 9046 of 2022 On 13 December 2022, the Kerala High Court, Viju Abraham J., heard four anticipatory bail petitions (BA Nos. 9006, 9019, 9042, 9046 of 2022) arising from Crime Nos. 1108/2022 and 1111/2022 of Kalamassery Police Station, Ernakulam. Ten accused, students at CUSAT, faced charges under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, read with 149, later supplemented by Section 308, relating to a campus incident on 26 October 2022 at the Sahara Hostel. The petitioners contended they were falsely implicated and had themselves been attacked; they submitted they are students and require anticipatory bail, noting the existence of related crimes and the involvement of multiple persons. The State opposed bail, arguing the gravity of the offences and the campus enmity linked to drug campaigns. After hearing counsel for both sides, the court allowed anticipatory bail with stringent conditions: bond of Rs 50,000 with two solvent sureties, periodic appearance before the investigating officer (every Saturday at 11 am until final report), cooperation with investigation, no tampering with evidence or witnesses, refrain from inducing witnesses or committing further offences, and submission to police procedures. The order also cites the Supreme Court's Sushila Aggarwal decision to confirm that police power to investigate and recover information persists even on bail. The petitions are disposed of with directions to ensure public order while safeguarding the petitioners’ liberty.
This is an Article 227 challenge to Ext.P6 order of the Debts Recovery Tribunal I, Ernakulam, in I.A.1702/2022 in S.A.398/2022. The petitioner Rahiya P, a loan borrower, contends that the mortgaged land, including about 44.60 cents, is agricultural land and therefore not amenable to SARFAESI action. She argues that the Tribunal relied on an undertaking Ext.R1(b) declaring the land non‑agricultural, which, in her submission, would defeat the protective carve‑out under Section 31(i) of SARFAESI. The petitioner pressed that such an undertaking should not be relied upon, as it may contravene statutory provisions; she relied on ITC Limited v. Blue Coast Hotels Ltd (2018) and M/s Concern Readymix v. Authorized Officer (Telangana HC) to contend that undertakings cannot purport to negate agricultural status or the Act’s protections. The respondents contested maintainability, contending an effective appellate remedy before the DRA and that the Tribunal’s order was within jurisdiction. The learned Judge analyzed: (i) the validity of Ext.R1(b) under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act; (ii) whether mere revenue‑record descriptions determine agricultural status; (iii) the policy reason behind Section 31’s exemption. The Court held the undertaking is not hit by Section 23, rejects the approbate/reprobate argument, and upholds the Tribunal’s order, dismissing the petition without costs.
The writ petition (WP(C) No. 36543 of 2009) challenges the Labour Court, Kannur’s Ext. P21 order in CP 35/2005 under Section 33C(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act. The petitioner, Issac Pilathara, seeks quashing of Ext. P21 and a mandamus directing the Labour Court to decide CP 35/2005 on merit, adjudicate the issues, and pass final orders in accordance with law. On 14–16 September 2022 the court noted the petitioner had no representation, and the matter proceeded in his absence. The Labour Court held that the petitioner was not entitled to any monetary benefit, interpreting Sec. 33C(2) as an executing‑like provision that computes money due only where an existing right to that money or benefit has been adjudicated or otherwise provided for. The court cited Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Ganesh Razak (1995) and AIR 1974 SC 1604 (C.I.W.T. Corp. v. Workmen) to emphasize that (i) there must be a pre‑existing right to certain benefits and (ii) Sec. 33C(2) cannot be used to decide entitlement when that entitlement is disputed. The petitioner’s Exhibits (P1–P5, P12–P21) show prior awards/settlements and receipts; however, the Labour Court found no established right, and the petition was dismissed. The writ petition thus fails; Ext. P21 stands, and CP 35/2005 cannot be entertained under Sec. 33C(2).
OT.Rev No. 84/2018 (and connected OT.Rev Nos. 75/2018, 78/2018, 77/2018, 79/2018, 80/2018, 82/2018, 81/2018, 86/2018, 91/2018, 92/2018, 94/2018) This batch of OT.Rev revisions challenges the common order dated 5.3.2018 of the Kerala VAT Appellate Tribunal (TAVAT) in VAT appeal No. 564/2014 and connected cross-objections, all arising under the Kerala Value Added Tax Act, 2003. The Full Bench of the Kerala High Court, in a judgment dated 29 July 2022, clarifies the scope of reassessment under Section 25 KVAT in the context of a dealer who has opted for a compounded tax rate under Section 8. The court reviews divergent precedents (including Cholayil Pvt. Ltd.; Joy Alukkas Traders (I) Pvt. Ltd.; C.C. Sebastian v State of Kerala; State of Kerala v A.M. Muhammed Ali) and ultimately holds that Section 25 empowers reassessment for several contingencies such as escaped assessment, under- assessment, and misapplication of rate, and that acceptance of a compounded tax rate does not immunize the Revenue from reopening, where misrepresentation or erroneous facts are involved. The court overrules the proposition laid down in A.M. Muhammed Ali, aligning with the Revenue’s position and the Joy Alukkas rationale that deemed assessments or compounding do not extinguish reassessment powers. The bench directs that the O.T. revisions be allowed and the matters remitted to the Tribunal for fresh disposal on merits, expeditiously, preferably within four months from receipt of the order. The decision is conveyed by a Division Bench (S.V. Bhatti, J. and Basant Balaji, J.).
This High Court of Kerala (Division Bench) disposed of an Original Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution challenging a Family Court order (Ext. P5, dated 01.08.2022) in GOP No. 227/2022. The Family Court had allowed the petitioner’s former spouse (the mother) to take the minor children abroad for a three-year psychiatry fellowship opportunity, with conditions including verification of employment documents and permitting the father to interact via video calls on alternate days and to have custody during vacations when the children are in India. The petitioner-father contended that the Ext. P5 relief exceeded the scope of I.A. No. 3 of 2022 in GOP No. 227/2022, and/or misapplied interim custody powers; the respondent-mother’s position was framed around the children’s welfare and the benefits of the mother’s fellowship opportunity. The court, applying well-settled supervisory principles under Article 227, referred to a catena of Supreme Court precedents emphasizing that custody decisions must prioritize the child’s welfare, and that Article 227 does not operate as an appellate review. It concluded that the Family Court’s reasoning was not perverse or irregular, upheld Ext. P5, and disposed of the petition with observations about the nature of the order. The welfare of the children remains the court’s paramount concern.
This writ petition, filed by K.K. Muraleedharan, President of Kudayathoor Service Co-operative Bank Limited, challenges Ext. P9, the Joint Registrar’s show-cause notice under section 32(1) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969, issued after a Section 65 inquiry into alleged irregularities by the Society’s former and current managing committees. The enquiry culminated in Ext. P5 dated 15.11.2019, leading to Ext. P3 (13.01.2020) under section 32(1). The petitioner challenged Ext. P3 in W.P.(C) No. 2435 of 2020; that petition was dismissed, and the Division Bench did not interfere with the Single Judge’s ruling. The matter was carried to a Full Bench to resolve the correctness of the law on service of Section 65 reports and the interpretation of Rule 66(5) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules. The Full Bench in Reji K. Joshy (and others) held service of the Section 65 inquiry report is mandatory, a view echoed by the Division Bench in WA No.1751 of 2020, which required the Joint Registrar to provide the material and allow written submissions before deciding under Section 32. The present judgment aligns Ext. P9 with these directives and dismisses the petition, while directing the Joint Registrar to proceed under Section 32 after providing reasonable opportunity to be heard, in light of Sanjay Nagayach. The petition is dismissed with no order as to costs.
This intra-court writ appeal (W.A. No.1522 of 2021) arises from a challenge to the order dismissing W.P(C) No.23397/2021 by a single judge. Anees C.K., a contractual Overseer under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) with the Vazhakkkad Grama Panchayath, contends that his termination and the subsequent selection notification (Exts P3 and P4) were illegal and unlawful. The Panchayat had decided to earmark one Overseer post for Scheduled Caste candidates (Ext P7) and to invite fresh contractual appointments, thereby displacing him after years of renewable service beginning in 2012. The petitioner seeks quashing Exts P3 and P4 and renewal of his contract under Exts P11 and P12, arguing these government orders, especially during the Covid-19 period, authorize continuation of contractual employees in local bodies. The respondents counter that Ext P7 and subsequent clarifications, along with Ext P11/12, do not extend to the petitioner; the contractual term ended on 31.03.2021, and the SC/ST reservation must be effected against vacant posts, not occupied ones. The High Court, citing Noorjihan v. State of Kerala and earlier Division Bench decisions (W.A Nos.807 & 925/2021 and W.A Nos.81 & 82 of 2022), avoids deciding merits at this stage and directs that the matter be resolved by the 5th Respondent Director of Panchayats after hearing, with interim relief permitting the petitioner to continue temporarily. It further notes GO 758/2022 (dated 26.03.2022) allowing continued contractual appointments up to 30.06.2022 and disposes the appeal with directions.
This is ITA No. 178/2019 before the Kerala High Court arising from the ITAT Cochin Bench order dated 20-04-2018 for AY 2012-13, with tax effect below the CBDT ceiling. The Revenue challenges the Tribunal’s application of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, arguing for conformity with Supreme Court precedents such as Commissioner of Income Tax v. Surya Herbal Ltd, Tarun R. Tahiliani, and S.C. Naregal v. Commissioner of Income Tax, to hold that the circular should govern. The respondent bank’s position is that there is no cascading effect and that the circular’s reach to pending matters must be read in light of two caveats laid down in Surya Herbal and later refined in Naregal. The court also invokes the Supreme Court’s decision in DIT v. S.R. M. B. Dairy Farming (P.) Ltd. and the principle laid down in Mavilayi Service Co-operative Bank Ltd v. Commissioner of Income Tax to frame the issue. Ultimately, the bench holds that the appeal falls within the monetary limit prescribed by Circular No. 3/2018 and should be dismissed, subject to observations in the 04-10-2018 Civil Appeal No. 7526/2011. The decision reflects adherence to the circular’s ceiling while acknowledging the caveats from Surya Herbal.
The Cochin Devaswom Board (CDB) filed this division-bench application seeking permission to rent out stalls/pavilions erected pursuant to a prior court order (Annexure A1, 29.07.2022 in DBP No.31 of 2022) for conducting a Christmas/New Year exhibition in Thrissur’s Thekkinkad Maidan. The Board had earlier obtained permission for Onam exhibition/trade fair in 2022 (Annexure A1/A3 chronology) and contends that the Devaswom’s acute financial crisis (exacerbated by Covid-19) necessitates diversifying income. The Ombudsman’s report (CDB Report No.18 of 2022) and precedents, notably Abu K.S. and T. Krishnakumar, require the Board to generate proper income from Devaswom properties and to exercise due diligence as a prudent trustee, not as a mere landlord. The respondents oppose a freely granted lease without transparent tendering and seek compliance with statutory protocols. After considering affidavits, counter-affidavits, and case-law, the court directs a transparent public auction for the right to conduct the Christmas/New Year fair (15.12.2022–15.01.2023) in Thekkinkad Maidan, with strict adherence to the Annexure A1 framework, Ombudsman approvals, and audit by the State Audit Department. If the 2nd respondent is not the highest bidder, stall removal within a week is mandated, and anti-cartel safeguards are required. The judgment emphasizes fiduciary duties and revenue-maximizing stewardship of Devaswom land.