This Kerala High Court criminal appeal concerns S.A. Salim @ Abdul Salim, the sole accused, challenging a Kalpetta Court of Sessions judgment (SC No. 292/2014) dated 10.07.2015. The trial court convicted him under Sections 366, 344, 376 and 506(i) IPC, sentencing him to 5 years, 2 years, 7 years and 1 year respectively, with fines totaling Rs. 75,000 and a Rs. 50,000 compensation to the defacto complainant under Section 357(1) Cr.P.C. The sentences were to run concurrently, and set-off for time served under Section 428 Cr.P.C was allowed. The prosecution alleged abduction of a minor girl (PW1), wrongful confinement, multiple rapes, and criminal intimidation beginning in 1995. The appellant’s counsel argued that the trial court erred by blindly accepting PW1’s testimony, highlighting inconsistencies and contending PW3 was not an ocular witness; he also questioned the medical evidence showing no genital injuries and the absence of proof of recent intercourse. The Public Prosecutor maintained the evidence, including PW1, PW2, PW3, and medical testimony, established the offences beyond reasonable doubt. The High Court, after evaluating the evidence and relying on established jurisprudence, upheld the prosecution’s case, distinguishing the appellant’s arguments. The appeal is dismissed, with the conviction and concurrent sentences upheld.
This writ petition challenges SARFAESI Act proceedings initiated by Union Bank of India against the petitioner, a micro/small enterprise (MSME) debtor. Jayaprakash A., proprietor of Evercool Enterprises (MSME registered under MSMED Act, 2006), defaulted on a bank credit facility, leading the bank to invoke the SARFAESI Act. The bank served notice under Section 13(2), issued a possession notice, and a sale notice, with a C.M.P. seeking possession through an Advocate Commissioner. The petitioner sought to invoke MSMED Act protections, arguing its non-obstante effect (Section 24) and RBI guidelines for stressed-asset resolution, claiming MSMED priority over SARFAESI/IBC/RDB frameworks and a civil-tribunal route for inter-se disputes. The Bank contended that MSMED Act does not confer such priority and that Section 26-E of SARFAESI Act (amended 2016) prevails, with non-obstante effect over other laws, and that the MSMED Act lacks a parallel exclusive priority framework. The Kerala High Court examined competing authorities (Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. v. Girnar Corrugators; Abdul Nazer; Mardia Chemicals; Satyawathi Tondon; Radha Krishan) and concluded that the MSMED Act cannot override SARFAESI. It held that there is no repugnancy between MSMED and SARFAESI and that the remedy lies within the SARFAESI framework, while also emphasizing exhaustion of statutory remedies. The petition was dismissed in limine, and no relief against SARFAESI action was granted.
TR.P.(C) Nos. 684/2023, 659/2023, 694/2023 These Transfer Petitions (Civil) arise from matrimonial proceedings pending in the Family Court, Kunnamkulam. The petitions, Tr.P(C) Nos. 684/2023, 659/2023 and 694/2023, were filed by respective petitioners seeking transfer of various original petitions from the Family Court, Kunnamkulam to the Family Court, Thrissur, on grounds of convenience given the petitioners’ residence within the transferee jurisdiction. The petitions relate to O.P. No. 775/2023 (return of gold ornaments and articles), O.P. No. 141/2023 (transfer/relating to another matrimonial matter), and O.P. No. 2107/2023 (visitation/modification issues), among connected petitions. The court cites Sumita Singh v. Kumar Sanjay & another [(2001) 10 SCC 41], to affirm that the convenience of the wife is a vital factor to be considered when determining the appropriate forum for matrimonial disputes. In light of this, the petitions are allowed and transfer of the listed O.P.s from Kunnamkulam to Thrissur is ordered; the transferee court is directed to receive the records forthwith. The order notes service and vakalathes on respondents. The court’s decision emphasizes accessibility, efficiency, and continuity of proceedings by aligning forum with the petitioners’ residence and convenience.
Crl.M.C. No. 7885 of 2022 This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC, challenging the continuation of prosecution arising from Crime No. 58/2016 (Kuttiady P.S.) and in SC No. 433/2022 and CP No. 31/2022. Petitioners 1–3 (Akhilesh, Shaju, Anuraj) are accused in the Sessions Court matter; petitioner 4 (Shamil) is accused in the JFCM Nadapuram matter. The offences alleged include 143, 147, 148, 506(i) read with 149 IPC and sections 3 and 5 of the Explosives Substances Act. The prosecution case is that the accused formed an unlawful assembly and attacked the victim’s house with explosive substances. The petitioners seek quashing on ground of settlement; the victim supports settlement and has no objection. The Public Prosecutor expresses reservations about quashing solely on the basis of compromise, though he concedes the matter is settled. The court relies on the Supreme Court decisions in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others, Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, and Narinder Singh, noting that CrPC 482 power can quash non-compoundable offences in private disputes when disputes are fully resolved, subject to safeguards for serious offences. The court finds the dispute private, the settlement genuine, and holds that the proceedings can be quashed. Accordingly, the criminal/misc case is allowed, and all further proceedings against petitioners are quashed.
CON.CASE(C) NO.2167 OF 2019 This Contempt of Court case before the Kerala High Court concerns alleged willful disobedience of directions contained in Annexure I of the judgment dated 12.10.2018 in WP(C) No.32184/2016 and connected matters. The petitioners challenge non-compliance by the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) with the orders related to pension scheme provisions following a 2014 amendment (G.S.R. 609(E)). The Supreme Court’s later judgment dated 04.11.2022 in Civil Appeals Nos.8143-44 of 2022 and connected matters, culminating in AIR 2022 SC 5634, held that the 2014 amendment to the pension scheme is legal and valid, with certain read-down provisions for various categories of employees (including those who did not exercise option earlier). In light of this apex decision, the Kerala High Court directed reconsideration of the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension by the EPFO in accordance with law. The petitioners’ counsel pressed for strict enforcement of the earlier directions, while the respondents argued for orderly compliance under the 2022 judgment. Ultimately, the court closed the contempt petition, reserving EPFO’s right to reconsider entitlement consistent with the Supreme Court’s directions.
BAIL APPL. NO. 3548 OF 2024 Muhammed Hussain H., the sole accused in Crime No.291/2024 of the Pulikeezhu Police Station, Pathanamthitta, sought bail under Section 439 CrPC for offences punishable under Sections 324 and 307 IPC. Arrested on 12.04.2024, the prosecution contends that on 12.04.2024 at around 22:30 hours near Parumala Devaswom Board School, the accused assaulted the de facto complainant’s brother and a friend with a knife, causing grievous injuries to the head, face, shoulder, forehead, neck, and arm. The defense asserts innocence and false implication, alleging that Section 307 was added to deny bail, and highlights the accused’s Bipolar Affective Disorder requiring ongoing treatment. The applicant has already spent 52 days in judicial custody, and investigation is allegedly complete with recoveries effected. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing ongoing investigation and a real possibility of tampering with evidence or witness intimidation if released. Relying on Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, the court emphasizes presumption of innocence and cautions against denying bail solely on past conduct. Dataram Singh v. State of U.P. is cited to reiterate that bail is the rule and imprisonment the exception, to be exercised judiciously and with compassion under Article 21. After balancing the submissions and custody period, the court grants bail, directing bond of Rs.50,000 with two solvent sureties of Rs.50,000 each, subject to conditions including periodic appearance, no inducement or tampering, non-commission of offences, passport surrender, and flexibility to modify or cancel bail under established guidelines (Sushila Aggarwal).
WP(Crl.) Nos.732 & 734 of 2024 Fathima Fathul P., the sister of detainees Jubair and Junaid, challenges preventive detention under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act (KAAPA), on behalf of two detenus detained under Section 3. Detention orders were issued on 5 April 2024 and detention began on 9 April 2024. The Advisory Board submitted its report on 31 May 2024, but the confirmation orders were issued only on 11 July 2024, well beyond the three-month window contemplated for detention under Article 22(4) of the Constitution. The petitioner asserts a violation of Article 22(4) because, absent a Board opinion within three months, detention becomes illegal; she relies on Malathy Ravi v. State of Kerala and Deb Sadhan Roy v. State of West Bengal to establish the three-month-rule. The Public Prosecutor did not dispute the delayed confirmation. The Court examined KAAPA Sections 3, 9 and 10(4) and cited Deb Sadhan Roy, Joydeb Gorai, Ujjal Mandal and Malthy Ravi to demonstrate that detention cannot continue beyond three months without Board confirmation, and that such detention becomes illegal if not confirmed within the period. Accordingly, the writ petitions were allowed, and the court directed the release of the detenus Jubair and Junaid forthwith if not required in connection with other cases. The judgment was delivered by a Division Bench (Raja Vijayaraghavan V & G. Girish).
This Kerala High Court (Single Judge) criminal miscellaneous case, Crl.M.C. No. 7557 of 2023, concerns quashing of proceedings under Section 482 CrPC in Crime No. 220/2022 of Vatakara Police Station, now pending as CC 514/2022 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Vatakara. The six petitioners—accused Nos. 1–6—are alleged to have formed an unlawful assembly and committed offences punishable under Sections 143, 147, 148, and 324 r/w 149 IPC. The prosecution contends a violent incident resulting in injuries; however, the petitioners contend the dispute has been settled and they wish to end prosecution. The victim has sworn an affidavit supporting settlement, and the victim’s counsel confirms no objection to quashing. The Public Prosecutor, while initially reserving views, concedes that the matter is settled; the court nevertheless examines the law. It relies on the Supreme Court’s decisions in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688, and the earlier Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh and Others v. State of Punjab, to delineate when non-compoundable offences can be quashed under S.482 CrPC, especially where the dispute is private and resolved. After careful consideration, the court finds the dispute private, the settlement genuine, and directs quashing of all further proceedings against the petitioners. The order emphasizes balancing private settlement with public interest and the accused’s antecedents.
The petitioner, Rishada Haris K.P., wife of the detenu, seeks writs of habeas corpus and quashment against a preventive detention order issued by the District Magistrate, Kannur, under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAAP). The detention order, Ext.P6 dated 27 April 2022, followed a sponsoring police report recommending detention to prevent further prejudicial activities. The Government’s approval, Ext.P5, was issued on 7 July 2022, and the matter was referred to the Advisory Board under Section 9, which advised detention on 22 June 2022. The petitioner challenges two main grounds. First, that the detaining authority did not, as required by the first limb of Section 3(3) KAAP, forthwith communicate the detention order and all relevant materials to the State Government; second, that crucial information—the bail cancellation in the seventh crime—was not brought to the detaining authority’s knowledge, rendering the decision making process defective. The court examines these grounds in light of Anupama S.V. and Hetchin Haokip and Dharmendra Chelawat. On contention (a) the court concludes the detaining authority did forward the order and materials promptly, overruling the petitioner’s challenge. On contention (b) the court finds that the bail cancellation had not been considered, rendering the Ext.P6 order vitiated and quashes it. The court clarifies future detention rules, noting that the quashing resets the six-month period, etc.
WP(Crl) Nos.732 & 734 of 2024 The petitioner, Fathima Fathul P, sister of detenus Jubair and Junaid, challenges the detention of the two individuals under Section 3 KAAPA. The detention orders were issued on 5 April 2024 and executed on 9 April 2024. The Advisory Board submitted its report on 31 May 2024, but the confirmation order was issued only on 11 July 2024, clearly beyond the three-month period from the date of detention. The petitioner contends that this delay violates Article 22(4) of the Constitution, and relies on this Court’s decision in Malathy Ravi v. State of Kerala and the Supreme Court’s Deb Sadhan Roy v. State of West Bengal to argue that no detention can be continued beyond three months without Board confirmation. The Public Prosecutor did not dispute that the order of confirmation was issued late. The court reiterates the KAAPA framework (Sections 3, 9 and 10, including sub-section 10(4)) and the constitutional safeguard under Article 22(4), citing prior authority including Joydeb Gorai and Ujjal Mandal to explain the three-month deadline. It holds that the detention’s continuation beyond three months, without timely confirmation, renders it illegal and grants the petitioners’ relief. The writ petitions are allowed, with a direction to release the detenus forthwith if they are not required in connection with any other case.
This is a bail petition under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhitha, 2023, by Vipin, the sole accused in Crime No. 826/2024 of Tirur Police Station, Malappuram. The incident reportedly occurred on 15 May 2024 at around 2:00 AM, when Vipin allegedly drove a lorry without headlights at excessive speed, with knowledge that it could cause death to others, resulting in grievous injuries to the defacto complainant. Vipin was remanded to judicial custody on 9 June 2024. The prosecution contends that Vipin is a habitual offender; he faces four other IPC offenses (Section 379) connected to the Sand Act (Sections 20 and 23 of the Kerala Protection of River Banks and Regulation of Removal of Sand Act, 2001); there was a preventive detention order under the KAAPA Act from 20.12.2023 for six months, and the present crime occurred just before expiry. The petitioner argues innocence, alleging false implication due to animosity with the investigating officer; the evidence suggests investigation is complete and a final report is filed. The learned counsel for Vipin contends that bail should be granted as per the constitutional guarantee of liberty and the presumption of innocence. The court, after considering well‑established precedents on bail, held that detention beyond reasonable time undermines Article 21 and that bail is the rule; the application is allowed with stringent conditions, balancing public safety with the accused’s rights.
This is an Income Tax appeal (ITA No. 28 of 2017) before the Kerala High Court arising from the assessment year 2008-09. The assessee, M/s Escapade Resorts Pvt. Ltd., challenged disallowances by the Assessing Officer under the Income Tax Act, including a capital expenditure that was treated as current repairs. The CIT (Appeals) allowed part of the appeal, and the ITAT remitted some issues for re-examination. The central dispute concerns whether the claimed expenditure for repairs, refurbishing and establishment of plant and machinery at a Visalam resort constitutes current repairs to preserve an existing asset or constitutes a new capital asset, with depreciation accordingly allowed. The matter also touches on deductions under sections 80IB and the issue of separate unit accounting versus consolidated books. The appellant invoked judgments such as Joy Alukkas India v. ACIT and Indus Motors Co. to bolster the case for entitlement, and the Revenue urged verification of facts with additional documents filed under I.A. 1/2021. The High Court ultimately remanded the issues to the Assessing Officer for fresh consideration in accordance with law, answering substantial questions in the assessee’s favour, while leaving open certain 80IB aspects for future determination.
10612/2024 & connected cases These writ petitions, numbering WP(C) Nos. 10612 of 2024 and connected cases, involve challenges to freezing of bank accounts by various banks following cybercrime notices and police intimations. Petitioners, who are individual account holders or entities, contend that blanket or excessive freezes hamper their ability to conduct ordinary banking and business activities. The petitioners urge that freezes should be limited to the amounts in dispute as per police requisitions, and that banks be directed to allow normal transactions beyond those amounts. The High Court recognizes the friction between preventing proceeds of crime and protecting civil liberties, and emphasizes that police notices and RBI guidelines must be balanced with petitioners’ right to transact. The court relies on established precedent, notably the directions extracted from Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC OnLine 661), and cites a previous judgment in W.P.(C) 28155/2023 to guide its approach to freezes. The bench directs that freezes be confined strictly to the disputed sums, with police informing banks if a greater freeze is required, and banks implementing these directions with due regard to the petitioners’ rights. The petitions are disposed of with uniform directions, creating a framework for handling cybercrime-related freezes across connected matters and ensuring that account holders can operate within the specified limits while investigations proceed.
This writ appeal arises from the State of Kerala challenging a learned Single Judge’s order in WP(C) 5476/2016 and Ext.P7, a Government order directing recovery of salary and other allowances paid to the second respondent and directing that she be approved and paid consequential benefits under Ext.P1. The second respondent, a Hindi High School Assistant, had been placed in various NSS High Schools and later placed in an uneconomic vacancy; Ext.P1 (31.03.2015) directed her appointment as Part Time H.S.A. (Hindi) from 10.10.2012 and to continue, though salary had not been paid. Ext.P2, Ext.P4 attempted notional and later substantive appointments, while Ext.P7 ordered recovery of the monetary loss and directed proper appointment in line with Ext.P1. The Single Judge held that there were no grounds to initiate proceedings under Rule 7(4) KER since salary payments were automatic and not a monetary loss. The Division Bench disagreed, holding that Clause 4 of Rule 7(4) of Chapter III KER is attracted when denial of rightful re-appointment causes monetary loss; it found malafides in the first respondent’s conduct, set aside the Single Judge’s view, and restored Ext.P7, while confirming directions to appoint the second respondent and grant consequential benefits. The appeal is allowed in part.
This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA) arising from an award under the Workmen’s Compensation Act by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Alappuzha. On 8 October 2003, the appellant, Unnikrishnan Nair, riding a scooter on the Alappuzha–Cherthala National Highway, was struck from behind by a lorry (KL-01/P 2100) driven by the first respondent, resulting in severe injuries and eventual amputation of his left limb. He was treated at the Medical College Hospital, Alappuzha and subsequently at Specialists Hospital, Ernakulam, for about 105 days. He claimed approximately Rs. 9,90,919 as compensation; the Tribunal awarded Rs. 4,08,500, fixing the disability at 50% under the Workmen’s Compensation Act and ordering recovery from the respondents with 6% interest. The insurer challenged, contending that the accident occurred due to the appellant’s negligence and that the injuries were minor, limiting the compensation. In appeal, the High Court undertook a reappraisal guided by the Supreme Court’s Pranay Sethi decision on ‘just compensation’, and invoked notional income guidelines from Ramachandrappa, Syed Sadiq, and Pushkar Mehra to recalibrate earnings. The court recalculated loss of earnings, bystander expenses, and disability using a multiplier approach, increasing total compensation to Rs. 6,50,100, and allowed the appeal in part, directing deposit of the enhanced amount with interest and costs. The judgment reflects a measured balancing of fairness, adequacy of compensation, and MV Act principles.
B.A.Nos.4521 & 4577 of 2021 Moosa Kunnugothi, a 47-year-old seaman accused of multiple POCSO offenses involving minors, seeks regular bail in two connected cases arising from Lakshadweep. The offences alleged include rape, unnatural sexual assault and circulation of videos/photos, allegedly committed with the help of his wife (2nd accused). He has remained in judicial custody since 14.08.2016. Earlier bail pleas were dismissed by coordinate Benches due to the extreme brutality of the allegations, tender ages of the victims, the likelihood of absconding, and the lengthy trial. The Lakshadweep Administration entrusted the investigation to the CBI, which confirmed charges already levelled by the Lakshadweep police; the CBI report also noted that the acts lacked international ramifications. The petitioner’s counsel argued for bail on medical grounds, highlighting multinodular goitre and the need for surgical treatment at mainland facilities; the health reports indicated normal parameters and a short post-operative stay. The prosecution emphasized the severity of the crimes against very young victims and the risk of absconding given his wealth and status, as well as the trial’s delay due to the pandemic and logistical issues across islands. The High Court balanced liberty with public interest, citing established Supreme Court bail criteria, but concluded there was no justification to enlarge the petitioner on bail and dismissed the applications, directing rapid disposal of the trial.
This Kerala High Court judgment, delivered by Judge M.R. Anitha on 30 November 2021, concerns a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.M.C. No. 2949 of 2021) filed by the State challenging an order of the Additional Sessions Court-V, Thiruvananthapuram in SC 1576/2019. The core issue is whether the prosecution was entitled to direct the accused to stand close to the witness box for identification of the accused by PW35, given the witness’s vision impairment. The Sessions Court had initially allowed the request but later disallowed it after defense objections. The State argued that it is the prosecution’s fundamental duty to prove the identity of the accused beyond reasonable doubt and that proper identification is essential in a criminal trial; a failure to identify would not only deprive the prosecution of crucial evidence but would also tilt the scales in favor of the accused. The Defense contended that the order was inappropriate and that the witness’s visual limitations make such identification impractical. The Court relied on established authorities (Mohammed v. State of Kerala; Vayalali Girishan; Rafeeque; Crl.A.1456/2005; Crl.A.1461/2005) to hold that identification by the witness is a pivotal part of the prosecution’s burden and that the procedure adopted by the Sessions Judge was illegal. It therefore allowed the Crl.M.C and directed recall of PW35 solely for the purpose of identification, to preserve the integrity of trial proceedings.
This Public Interest Litigation, WP(C) No. 34606 of 2022, challenges Cochin Municipal Corporation and local officers for alleged encroachment of government lease land and unauthorized construction at Thoppumpady, Ernakulam. The petitioner, a senior citizen, contends that a flat is being constructed in a backwater area in violation of the Kerala Municipality Building Rules, Civil Aviation Rules, and CRZ regulations, encroaching lease land and endangering nearby structures, livelihood, and the environment. He has filed numerous representations to authorities and produced interdepartmental correspondence and documents—some reportedly signed by a minister—yet asserts no action has been taken. The petition relies on RTI-like access to documents and seeks mandamus to compel the State and its agencies to restore land to its original condition and to prevent regularisation of the unauthorised construction. The court recalls Supreme Court precedents holding that writ petitions against internal correspondence are not maintainable, and that unsigned or non-executable notings do not bind the Government unless followed by a communicated order. It directs scrutiny of document provenance, requiring an affidavit establishing source under RTI to justify reliance on Xeroxed materials. Ultimately, after hearing, the court finds no prima facie case and dismisses the petition, with pending interlocutory applications, if any, closed. The decision reflects careful balance between PIL principles and procedural restraints on challenging internal government communications.
This is an appeal under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (LAA 306/2017) arising from an award in LAR No. 35/2012 before the Sub Court, Thiruvalla, for the doubling of the railway line from Chengannur to Chingavanam. About 7 acres of the claimant’s 15.20 acres were acquired on 18.07.2009 under Section 4(1). The Land Acquisition Officer classified the lands into six categories; category I lands near main roads were valued at Rs 1,17,072 per Are (20% above the basis value), category II at Rs 1,05,364 per Are (10% above), and category III at Rs 78,048 per Are (20% below). The reference court enhanced the category II value to Rs 5,93,000 per Are. The appellant contends the land’s strategic locality warrants much higher compensation (Rs 8,00,000 per Are) and seeks compensation for injurious affection due to the reduced remaining land. The State did not press for enhanced land value, and the appellant later refrained from pursuing enhanced land value, per submissions. The court cites Sivarama Pillai Purushothaman Nair v. State of Kerala (2012) 2 KHC 631 to affirm that Section 23(1)(4) permits compensation for injurious affection to unacquired property. It finds the remaining 8.20 acres diminished in width and shape, warrants compensation for injurious affection of 20% of the remaining property’s value, and accordingly grants Rs. 9,72,520 for injurious affection while leaving land value unchanged. Interlocutory applications are closed.
RSA 581/2021; RSA 582/2021 This Regular Second Appeal arises from concurrent custody of litigation over possession of a scheduled shop under a mortgaged property. Plaintiffs-filed O.S.365/2007 seeking permanent injunction restraining eviction; defendants filed O.S.696/2008 for recovery of possession. The trial court dismissed the injunction suit but decreed possession in favor of the defendants, and the first appellate court affirmed. The High Court, while examining the interplay between the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 (Rent Act) and security/mortgage regimes, held that the tenants (plaintiffs) who were inducted prior to or during certain mortgage transactions cannot be summarily evicted under certain securitisation provisions, but are bound by the statutory framework governing tenancy. It relied on Section 65A of the Transfer of Property Act and the Rent Act to determine whether a lease survives post-mortgage and post-auction. The Court traced jurisprudence from Antony v. Kerala Financial Corporation (overruled by Pushpangadan) and cited Harshad Govardhan Sondagar, Bajarang Shyamsunder Agarwal, and Meenachil Co‑operative Bank to articulate that mortgage and securitisation statutes cannot automatically defeat pre-existing tenancy rights. Ultimately, the High Court upheld the concurrent findings and dismissed the regular second appeals, affirming the defendants’ right to possession and denying injunction to the plaintiffs.