Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 515 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.A.No. 1621 of 2011

State of Kerala v Kavullapurayil Joju

This criminal appeal is by the State of Kerala challenging an acquittal recorded by the Additional Sessions Judge, Thalassery, in SC No. 1022 of 2014 arising from Crime No. 38 of 2000 (Chakkarakkal Police Station). The sole accused, Kavullapurayil Joju, was charged under sections 302, 307 and 326 IPC for stabbing Sajeevan and injuring two others at a bus waiting shelter near a DYFI-built shelter in Vengilod, Kannur. The prosecution relied on eye-witnesses PWs 1–3, 10 and 11 and on medical and scientific evidence (PWs 4–9, MO1–MO13) to establish a fatal, intentional assault. The defence claimed private defence, contending Joju was attacked by CPI(M) supporters, and that the stabbing occurred during a scuffle outside the shelter; it also contended that the First Information Statement (FIS) and FIR were concocted and that the scene details were misrepresented. The trial court acquitted, and the State pressed the matter in appeal, arguing that the witnesses were credible and that the motive was political rivalry. The Kerala High Court, after reviewing the evidence, found serious inconsistencies, suppression of the genesis of the incident, lack of weapon recovery, and doubts about the FIS, and held that the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed and the acquittal upheld.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 16715 of 2020

Dr. V.G. Pradeep Kumar v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Tirur, Malappuram

Dr. V.G. Pradeep Kumar, the owner in possession of 44.76 acres in Re.Sy.No.87/1 and 87/3 of Thavanur Village, challenged a 2014 District Collector order directing restoration of his land to paddy land under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. The writ petition traces a long procedural arc: original petition W.P.(C)13290/2014, which directed reconsideration after granting hearing; subsequent orders and data-bank processes under the 2008 Act via Ext.P3, Ext.P6, Ext.P10; the Local Level Monitoring Committee's majority finding that the land should be excluded from the data bank; and the Revenue Divisional Officer's Ext.P11 declaring the land 'nilam' and maintaining status quo. The petitioner asserts that the LLMC majority decisions should govern the data bank and that the RD0 has no power to override them, especially where KSREC's report is inconclusive. The court analyzes the 2008 Act's Section 5 and its sub-provisions, including the data-bank duties and the remedy for corrections under the proviso. It emphasizes that LLMC majority decisions are the decision of the Committee and that the RD0's Ext.P11 cannot stand. The judgment quashes Ext.P11 and directs a fresh decision within three months after giving opportunity of hearing, consistent with law and the prior directives. The order preserves the petitioner's possession pending fresh determination.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 7736 OF 2022; 7724 OF 2022; 7739 OF 2022; 7740 OF 2022; 7742 OF 2022; 7749 OF 2022; 7751 OF 2022

Antoney Devasia v. State of Kerala

These are applications for anticipatory bail arising from seven connected cases relating to seven Crime Nos. 42/CB/14, 41/CB/14, 43/CB/14, 44/CB/14, 126/CB/14, 45/CB/14 and 46/CB/14 investigated by Palarivattam Police and later transferred to the Crime Branch/Economic Offences Wing. The petitioner, Antoney Devasia, is alleged to have formed a private company M/s. Wismore Trading & Investment Consultancy Pvt Ltd, through which investors were promised returns higher than banks, leading to wrongful gains and alleged fraud. The prosecution contends a common intention to cheat and defraud and that the petitioner dealt with unlicensed activities during reinvestigation by the EOW. The petitioner contends the activities were legitimate investment/trading; he asserts there was prior custodial interrogation in 2013 and that custodial interrogation is not required now given the long lapse and cooperation. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail citing ongoing investigation and unlicensed dealings. The High Court, noting the long history since 2013, the earlier interrogation, and the lack of necessity for custodial interrogation at this stage, grants anticipatory bail in all connected applications subject to conditions: surrender on 27.10.2022, bond of Rs 50,000 per case with two sureties, appearance before IO, no influence on witnesses, no leaving Kerala without permission, and compliance with other terms; police empowered to continue investigation and recoveries.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 6087 of 2021 and CRL.M.C. No. 6093 of 2021

Rajeshmon K.V. and others v. State of Kerala and others

This is a consolidated criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC before the High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, involving two connected criminal cases (Crime Nos. 238/2020 and 237/2020) at Perumbavoor Police Station. The petitioners ( ten individuals listed in CRL.M.C. No. 6087/2021 ) move to quash the prosecutions on the ground that the disputes with the victims have been settled and the parties no longer wish to pursue the prosecutions; affidavits from the defacto complainants/victims support the settlement. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations but conceded the matter is settled. The court places reliance on State of Madhya Pradesh v Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) and the earlier decisions Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh and others v. State of Punjab, to articulate the guiding principles for quashing non-compoundable offences where settlement exists. The court clarifies that quashing is permissible for offences private in nature with a predominantly civil character when the dispute is settled, while excluding heinous or public-interest offences (e.g., murder, rape, dacoity) and offences under special statutes or against public servants. After examining the facts, the court finds the dispute private and the settlement valid, and accordingly quashes all further proceedings in both crime numbers. The two petitions are disposed by a common order.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.29679/2021

Nishad Mathew v. Reserve Bank of India, Federal Bank Ltd., and Review Committee (Identification of Wilful Default)

The petitioner Nishad Mathew borrowed from Federal Bank Ltd. and faced proceedings to declare him a Wilful Defaulter under RBI Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters. Ext.P1, a show-cause notice, was issued by a Vice President and Deputy Compliance Officer, who is a member of the Committee for Identification of Wilful Defaulters, rather than by the Committee itself as required by the Master Circular. The Committee subsequently declared him a Wilful Defaulter and directed communication to Credit Information Companies. The petitioner challenged Ext.P1 and Ext.P7, arguing non-compliance with Clause 3(b) of Ext.P8 Master Circular, and contended that the evidence of wilful default must be examined by a Committee headed by an Executive Director with two senior officers. He argued that Ext.P1 did not reveal the grounds under Clause 2.1.3 and that the COVID-19 pandemic affected his capacity to repay, undermining the Bank’s assessment. The Respondents maintained that Ext.P1 was issued in accordance with Ext.P8 and that the Review Committee would render a final decision; the petitioner had already invoked Ext.P9 for review. The Court held the petition premature, noting that Ext.P1’s showing was tentative and only final after the Review Committee’s decision, and dismissed the petition. Master Circular provisions gave the Bank binding procedure, but no final determination had yet been made.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 14328 OF 2021

Balakrishnan v. State of Kerala & Others

Balakrishnan, claiming absolute title to 4.0470 hectares in Re-Sy No. 3, Vellarimala Village, seeks mutation in village records, basic tax, and revenue certificates. He purchased the property by Ext. P1 sale deed (23.09.2006) from Sri George K. Varkey; the earlier larger holding was with Malayalam Plantation Ltd. The respondents refused mutation, citing an embargo due to MPL's holdings and proceedings under the Kerala Land Conservancy Act. The petitioner contends the property in Ext. P1 does not form part of MPL’s holdings (as shown by Ext. P6) and relies on Exts. P7–P13 (judgments) and Exts. P3–P4 (basic tax/encumbrance records) to prove title and absence of encumbrances. The court notes that in Harrisons Malayalam Ltd. v. State of Kerala, a Division Bench held that initiation of LCA proceedings was untenable in view of a bona fide title claim, and coordinate Benches have granted relief to assignees in similar cases. Balakrishnan’s title is treated as bona fide; the court directs the competent authority to permit mutation, accept basic tax, and issue revenue records, within time-bound frames, subject to adjudication of title in a civil suit. The petition is disposed of with directions, ensuring due process while preserving the civil remedy for title disputes.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 2756 OF 2011

Abdul Khader @ Balan Kurup v State of Kerala and Rahiyanath

The petitioner Abdul Khader alias Balan Kurup, a Muslim husband, challenges a conviction for cruelty to his wife under Section 498A IPC, as affirmed by the Sessions Court and the appellate process culminating in the Kerala High Court. The prosecution case is that the couple married in early 2003 and cohabitated briefly in Parat, Kolavallur. The accused allegedly took away eight sovereigns of his wife's gold ornaments on 10.03.2003 and, after demanding the remaining seven sovereigns, allegedly assaulted her on 06.04.2003 when she refused. The incident led to FIR No.134/2003 and ultimately a conviction under 498A, with a one-year imprisonment and a fine. The High Court, examining whether the prosecution proved “cruelty” as defined in the Explanation to 498A IPC (two limbs: (a) causing grave injury or danger to life/health; (b) harassment to meet an unlawful demand for property or security), scrutinized the evidence in light of Supreme Court precedents. It cited Niyas, Satish Kumar Batra, Onkar Nath Mishra, Rajendran, M. Srinivasulu, Preeti Gupta, Subbharao, John Idiculla and Reema Aggarwal to define the scope of “harassment” and the concept of “husband” under 498A, emphasizing that mere sporadic quarrels or non-coercive demands do not meet the charged offence. The court ultimately held that the prosecution failed to prove the requisite elements of 498A, and acquitted the petitioner, set at liberty with bail obligations discharged.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.1914 of 2008

BIJU @ VIJU P.POULOSE v. C.R.PRINIL and others (MACA No.1914 of 2008)

This is a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal under MACA No.1914 of 2008, challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thrissur’s award in O.P.(MV) No.2171/2000. The appellant, BIJU alias VIJU P. POULOSE, sustained serious injuries in a June 2000 road accident involving an autorickshaw; he sought compensation of Rs.10 lakh under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The Tribunal awarded Rs.5,88,950 with 7% interest and there was a contest on the quantum under multiple heads. The appellant contends that his permanent disability, measured at 84.16% by a medical board, ought to be treated as 100% functional disability since he is confined to home and requires a bystander/attendant assistance for all movements, with consequential loss of earning capacity. He also asserts that the income and heads such as loss of disability income, bystander expenses, and loss of amenities should be enhanced, relying on recent Supreme Court and Kerala High Court authorities, notably Jithendran v. The New India Assurance Co. Ltd, Ramachandrappa, Pappu Deo Yadav, Kajal v. Jagdish Chand, and Ramachandrappa-style reasoning. The respondents oppose a 100% disability assessment and challenge the higher figures, citing policy conditions and evidence of income. The High Court ultimately allows the appeal, adopts a 100% functional disability, recalculates disability income with a 40% uplift, awards substantial bystander/attendant and loss-of-amenities extras, and fixes total compensation at Rs.22,68,150, with insurer-rights of recovery clarified.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 3676 OF 2008

Suganthi (D/o Sarada) v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision in which Suganthi, the accused in S.C. No. 210/2000 before the Assistant Sessions Court, Neyyattinkara, challenges a conviction under Section 58 of the Abkari Act. The trial court sentenced her to three years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with a default sentence. On appeal (Crl.Appeal No. 104 of 2005), the appellate court modified the sentence to simple imprisonment for six months and maintained the fine. The revision grounds focus on serious statutory noncompliances: absence of arrest memo/arrest intimation, lack of specimen seal affixed on the mahazar, non-descriptive seal details, and no forwarding note. The petitioner contends these defects undermine the prosecution’s link evidence between the accused and the contraband. The High Court emphasizes the Abkari Act’s stringent formalities and recalls precedents such as Baburaj v. State of Kerala, D.K. Basu, Ramankutty, Rafeeque, and Udayan that noncompliance undermines guilt beyond reasonable doubt. It also discusses the necessity of proper seizure procedures (seal, mahazar linkage, forwarding notes, and chain of custody) and corroborates through Vijayan, Nadarajan, Gopalan, Prakasan, Ramachandran, Moothedath Sivadasan, Sasidharan, Vijay Pandey, and Vijayan that mere lab reports or unproven sample transfer do not suffice. Ultimately, the court allows the revision petition and acquits the petitioner, with bail cancellation and refund of any deposit as applicable.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 598 of 2022

Director General of Central Industrial Security Force & Inspector General, North Sector CISF v. S. Surendran

This intra-court appeal arises from a writ petition field by S. Surendran challenging Ext.P12, a 2019 order that rejected his claim for compassionate allowance under Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules. Surendran, a former CISF employee, was discharged in 1984 for unauthorized absence after disciplinary proceedings. He sought pension benefits and, more controversially, compassionate allowance under Rule 41, alleging that he faced hardship and depended on his wife and family. The Single Judge had directed the first respondent to reconsider Ext.P10 (application for compassionate allowance) in light of the Supreme Court’s Mahinder Dutt Sharma decision (2014) and to decide in accordance with law. The appellants challenged Ext.P12 as arbitrary and illegal, arguing that compassionate allowance may be granted in exceptional circumstances where there is special consideration, including mitigating factors. The respondents countered that relief should be denied due to substantial delay, the petitioner’s adequate financial condition, and lack of exceptional circumstances. The Division Bench affirmed the Single Judge, held that the impugned Ext.P12 was correctly set aside and remitted for fresh consideration in line with Mahinder Dutt Sharma’s criteria, and dismissed the writ appeal. The court also clarified that any retrospective or prospective grant would be governed by law and the competent authority’s discretion under Rule 41.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No.70 of 2016

FAO No.70 of 2016

This First Appeal From Orders arises from an appeal by the plaintiff in O.S. No.3 of 1999 against an order dated 15 September 2015 by the 1st Additional District Court, Thrissur, rejecting I.A. Nos. 2953/2014 and 2954/2014 (restoration of the suit and condonation of delay of 895 days) under Order IX Rules 9 and 13 CPC. The suit for injunction against passing off under Section 105 of the Trade Marks Act, 1958 was filed by K.L. Poly (deceased) and his legal heirs. The suit was dismissed for default on 29 February 2012 after the plaintiff’s absence on 22 February 2012. The plaintiff sought restoration and condonation of delay; the Trial Court rejected both applications in 2015. This Division Bench of Kerala High Court, on 19 July 2023, allowed the appeal, set aside the impugned order, and condoned the delay by imposing costs (Rs. 10,000) to be paid to several respondents. The suit is restored to file, and the court is directed to proceed and dispose it expeditiously within four months, with appearance before the trial court on 21 August 2023. The judgment relies on liberal interpretation of “sufficient cause” and the discretionary power in restoration/condonation, citing leading authorities on limitation, prejudice, and justice.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.10392 of 2023

Rajan P.N. and N. Krishna Kurupp v. State of Kerala and others

The petitioners, devotees of the Pulpally Sree Lava-Kusha Temple, filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging actions connected with the temple’s land and administration. They contended Ext.P2 (HR&CE Act proceedings) and Ext.P9 (a lease of temple land) were issued without proper consideration or hearing and that the 9th respondent, the temple’s hereditary trustee-cum-executive officer, has mismanaged temple assets. The petition asserts that the temple once held extensive land (allegedly 14,000 acres) but now possesses only about 20-22 acres, and that Ext.P9 seeks to lease 73 cents of land from RS No. 602/3 to the 10th respondent Grama Panchayat for 33 years, with a plan to develop a bus stand and shopping complex, which would not benefit the deity. The petition also cites prior litigation (O.S. No. 57/2023) and alleges encroachments and unlawful conduct by the 9th respondent. Respondents counter that the temple administration follows the scheme settled by the Malabar Devaswom Board; Ext.P9 was issued after due procedure, with opportunity for hearing, and the rent was justifiable. The High Court held Ext.P9 to be vitiated for lack of objective market-based rent assessment and due process, quashed it, and directed a fresh decision in accordance with law while leaving other contentions open; the relief to remove the 9th respondent was declined. The judgment underscores guardianship of temple properties (doctrine of parents patriae) and the trustees’ fiduciary duties.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P. No. 202 of 2022

M.K. Abdurahman v. State of Kerala and A. Saleena Abdu Rouf

This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. by M.K. Abdurahman challenging a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (NI Act) for dishonour of a cheque for Rs. 5 lakh. The trial court convicted the accused; the Sessions Court confirmed the conviction and modified the sentence by directing compensation of Rs. 5 lakh under Cr.P.C. Section 357(3) with a further default sentence and additional costs. The revision petition contends that there was no legally enforceable debt and that crucial notice under the NI Act may have been defective due to an incorrect address; it also questions the veracity of Exts. P1–P6 and the surrounding evidentiary chain, including a possible misuse of blank cheques by a third party. The court discusses the scope of revisional power, reiterating that it is supervisory and not a second appellate jurisdiction, citing State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri and later decisions (Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan, Kishan Rao, Rangappa v. Mohan, Kalamani Tex) to emphasize that re‑appreciation of evidence is generally impermissible unless there is gross miscarriage of justice or non‑consideration of material facts. The High Court ultimately holds that the concurrent conviction and sentence are within the ambit of revision, and the petition is dismissed, with directions regarding payment and the timing for the sentence.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No.627 of 2009

Kesavan Pillai Lekshmanan and Mohanan alias Subramonia Pillai Mano Mohanan v. Nanu Nadar Chellakuttan

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a suit for specific performance of a sale contract in respect of ~750 square links of land. Plaintiff Nanu Nadar Chellakuttan claimed entitlement to specific performance against defendants Kesavan Pillai Lekshmanan and Mohanan (alias Subramonia Pillai Mano Mohanan) after paying Rs 35,000 as advance on 13.05.1998 and sending a cheque for Rs 25,000 towards the balance. The agreement fixed a six-month period for performance; the defendants allegedly failed to perform, leading to a suit which the Trial Court dismissed for lack of clean hands. The First Appellate Court reversed and decreed specific performance. On second appeal, the appellants contended that the First Appellate Court relied on amendments sought by IA No.1778/2001 under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC without giving them an opportunity to contest; that Exts.A6 and A7 admitted under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC were received without opportunity for rebuttal, causing prejudice; and that time-essence of the contract and alleged collusion should defeat relief. The respondent/plaintiff argued entitlement to relief, having satisfied all requirements, and that the appellate process should allow due record and final relief as prayed. The High Court found irregularities in the appellate proceedings, invoked a cited Supreme Court principle on additional evidence, and allowed the Second Appeal, remanding the matter to the First Appellate Court for fresh consideration.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 9296 of 2022

Vineeth (2nd accused) v. State of Kerala

This is a regular bail application (B.A. No. 9296 of 2022) moved by Vineeth, the 2nd accused in Crime No. 26/2022 of Mavelikara Excise Range, registered under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of the NDPS Act, 1985. The Excise party, acting on information from the Intelligence Bureau, allegedly found the accused with ganja in a car (Reg. KL 31 M 8049) and at the house of the 1st accused following search. Prosecutors claim 10 gms of ganja were recovered from Vineeth’s person, 50 gms from the car dashboard, and 21.112 kg from the 1st accused’s house based on the latter’s statement, with the investigation continuing. Vineeth contends that he has been falsely implicated and that there are discrepancies in dates and times across occurrence reports and related documents. He asserts non-compliance with Section 50 NDPS Act, alleging lack of notice to be searched before a magistrate or gazetted officer and a missing response, and argues Section 29 NDPS would not apply since there is no abetment or conspiracy. He relies on several decisions (e.g., Dileep, Baldev Singh, Dayalu Kashyap, Baljinder Singh, Parmanand) to challenge the legality of the search and the admissibility of recoveries, seeking bail on the ground of limited stage of investigation and lack of direct evidence of possession. The State argues compliance with Section 50, presence of a gazetted officer, and the substantial, commercial quantity of ganja invoking stringent NDPS norms. The court, after hearing, refuses regular bail, noting the commercial quantity and the early stage of investigation, while cautioning that observations are limited to bail and not merits of the trial.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 26309 of 2022

Universal Tele Service vs The Chief General Manager (Telecom), BSNL Kerala Circle; The Assistant General Manager (Administration), Office of the General Manager (Telecom), BSNL; The Sub Divisional Engineer (Vigilance), BSNL

Universal Tele Service, a Kerala-based contractor engaged in infrastructure maintenance for BSNL, approached the Kerala High Court challenging a one-year debarment from bidding in Palakkad Business Area. A tender for infrastructure maintenance at major BSNL stations was issued (Ext. P1). An external agency, by mistake, uploaded the petitioner's credentials along with those of M/s S&S Security Agency; S&S was awarded the contract, which was later cancelled when the tender documents were found not to belong to the awardee. The petitioner, who did not participate in the tender, was served with Ext. P4 show-cause and Ext. P5 debarment order. Counsel for the petitioner alleged that debarment cannot be based on a mistake by another person, there was no material establishing fraud by the petitioner, and the show-cause notice did not specify charges with precision, violating principles of fair procedure. The BSNL countered that the petitioner signed and uploaded the documents, suggesting knowledge and connivance, and that debarment is justified under the guidelines (Appendix I, Section IV Part A). The court ultimately held that debarment requires a detailed inquiry and proper opportunity to respond, set aside Ext. P5, and allowed the writ petition, while preserving BSNL’s right to initiate fresh proceedings if advised.

High Court of Kerala
RFA No. 238 of 2010

P.A. Chacko v. V.M. Andrews

This Regular First Appeal arises from a suit for specific performance of a contract for sale of property (Ext. A1). The trial court dismissed the suit on the independent ground that the defendant was mentally incapacitated at the time of execution. On appeal, the Kerala High Court clarifies the distinction between unsoundness of mind under IPC Section 84 and the standard under Section 12 of the Indian Contract Act. It holds that in civil contracting, complete insanity is not necessary; impairment of mental capacity to form a rational judgment suffices under Section 12, and even self-induced intoxication or aberration that affects judgment can be relevant. The court observes a change in civil law posture compared to criminal liability and emphasizes that proof of unsoundness must relate to the time of contracting. The court also critiques the trial court’s reliance on Ext. B3 (medical certificate) and on DW2/DW3 without corroborative records, noting no inpatient/medical treatment records. It cites Sona Bala Bora to illustrate abnormal conduct as a factor in determining contracting capacity and cites Anappath Parakkattu Vasudevakurup and Her Highness Maharani Shantidevi Gaikwad as supportive authorities. Ultimately, the appeal is allowed; the decree is set aside and a new relief is granted: Rs.10,00,000 as compensation (no interest for three months, then 6% p.a.); plus Rs.2,00,000 as advance with 6% interest from suit/date of recovery; the sum is charged on the plaint schedule property; no costs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 12783 of 2021

Y.R. Vincent and others v. Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies (G) & others, WP(C) No. 12783 of 2021

This writ petition before the Kerala High Court (Ernakulam) challenges an order of surcharge under Section 68 of the Cooperative Societies Act, with consequential disqualification and appointment of an administrator in respect of Arayoor Service Co‑operative Bank Ltd. Following a Section 66 inspection (covering 01.04.2013 to 31.03.2018) that found losses due to management lapses, the Registrar initiated surcharge proceedings under Section 68(1)–(3), culminating in Ext.P11 (the surcharge order). The petitioners argue multiple defects: (a) the surcharge probe extended beyond the inspection period; (b) surcharges were imposed on persons who assumed office after 31.03.2018; (c) liability for the entire period against those who were not in management for the whole period is unsustainable; (d) liability against surviving members for others’ conduct is erroneous; (e) no opportunity to pay off liability to avoid surcharge. The court explains Section 66’s period, the scope of Section 68, and the personal nature of liability under 68, including the need to specify each member’s liability under Rule 66(7)(ii)(b). It distinguishes grounds (b)-(d), holds that certain aspects require fresh orders, and ultimately quashes Ext.P11 and the related disqualification and administrator appointment, directing fresh orders after hearing within a month. The court cites E.J. Thomas v. Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies (Writ Appeal No.1447 of 2021) to support that no provisional recoupment remedy is provided post-surcharge.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.23186 of 2022 & connected cases

W.P.(C) Nos.23186 of 2022 & connected cases

This batch of writ petitions challenges a Government Order, GO(MS) No.121/2022/G.Edn., dated 07.07.2022, and the related Plus One (Higher Secondary) admission prospectus for 2022-23, in Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools in Kerala. The petitioners, managers of PAHS, contend that the policy reducing management quota to 20% and the requirement that schools declare the community to which they owe allegiance, with 10% seats reserved for that community (community quota), are unconstitutional and violate Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution, the Kerala Education Rules, and prior court judgments. The State counters that the GO is a policy measure to curb irregular admissions, ensure merit, and bring uniformity across institutions, arguing the executive has latitude in policy decisions. The court, in a single-judge decision by Raja Vijayaraghavan V, upheld the 20% management quota (GO 121/2022) but struck down the 10% community quota as unconstitutional for arbitrary discrimination, directing that those 10% seats be converted to open merit and filled through the Centralized Allotment Process (CAP). It noted that admissions already made on community declarations would not be disturbed. The judgment traces the historical context since the early 1990s, discusses precedents on policy review and reservations, and emphasizes that while policy decisions are generally non-justiciable, discrimination against individuals or communities in admissions must have a rational nexus with the stated objective. The petitions are disposed of in terms of these directives, with the 20% management quota remaining intact while the 10% community quota is removed from the tally.

High Court of Kerala
AR NO. 93 OF 2021

M/S ROJER MATHEW & CO. v. DELHI METRO RAIL CORPORATION LIMITED and KOCHI METRO RAIL LIMITED

M/s Rojer Mathew & Co., a civil engineering contractor, approached this High Court under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, for appointment of an arbitrator to resolve disputes arising from the contract for construction of entry/exit structures at Changampuzha Park Metro Station under LOA No. DMRC/Kochi/KC3-DR/3477 (dated 10.12.2015) and Annexure A2 GCC-based Agreement (dated 25.01.2016) between the applicant and the 1st respondent, DMRC, on behalf of the 3rd respondent. The work proceeded and payments allegedly became due but were withheld for years, giving rise to disputes regarding the contract terms and payments. Clause 17 of Annexure A12 GCC provides that disputes are to be resolved first by conciliation and then by arbitration. The applicant pressed Annexures A8 and A9 (conciliatory requests) and Annexure A10 (Section 21 reference for conciliation) in response to which no action was taken, prompting Annexure A11 (arbitration request). Respondents contended that the applicant violated Clause 17.5 by bypassing conciliation, and argued that Kochi Metro Rail Limited (KMRL) is not a party to A2 and that DMRC’s seat is Delhi. The Court examined the GCC dispute resolution provisions, the seat issue, and pre‑and post‑2011 arbitration jurisprudence (TRF v. Energo; Perkins Eastman; Tulsi Developers), ultimately holding that non‑signatories’ nomination rights are restricted but allowing the arbitration request to proceed. The Court nominated a sole arbitrator, directed disclosure, and fixed appearance.