Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 485 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
AR No.105/2021

Arbitration Request No. 105 of 2021

AR No.105 of 2021 arises from a dispute between Sindhu Manikkoth and her children (Nikhil Menon and Naina Menon) and Prashanta Majee, concerning a financial transaction in which Vinod Shridharan Menon allegedly lent Rs. 32 lakh. Annexure I contains the loan agreement, and Annexure VII a lawyer’s notice demanding payment and a willingness to arbitrate. The applicants seek the court’s intervention under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 to refer the dispute to arbitration as per the agreement, since the debtor failed to repay. The respondent contests, advancing four main objections: lack of territorial jurisdiction since all transactions occurred in Mumbai; alleged violation of the Money Lenders Act; limitation; and that the entire principal amount has been repaid with only interest outstanding. The court recognizes the existence of an arbitration clause and, after considering the arguments, holds that part of the cause of action arose in Kerala (payments were made from Kerala and the debt is payable there), and thus Kerala jurisdiction applies. It notes that questions about the nature of the debt and the outstanding amount are factual and should be determined by the arbitrator under Section 16, citing Vidya Drolia and Pravin Electricals as guiding authorities. Consequently, the court disposes of the AR by nominating Sri. S. Vijayakumar as Sole Arbitrator provisionally, with procedural directions for disclosure and fee rules.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No.1026 of 2022

Noble Educational and Charitable Trust v Mercy and others

This OP(C) arises from a challenge to a common order in I.A. Nos. 1 and 2 of 2021 in O.S. No.221/2017, Munsiff Court, Muvattupuzha. The petitioner, Noble Educational and Charitable Trust, seeks to set aside orders allowing the first respondent’s next friend to retire and to substitute another next friend. The first respondent, Mercy, is alleged to be mentally retarded and of unsound mind and has filed a suit for declaration that deeds and a will are not binding on her and for recovery of possession of the plaint schedule property, on grounds of alleged fraud by her son and the late E.P. Varkey (father of the fifth respondent). The crucial issue is whether the National Trust for Welfare of Persons with Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Mental Retardation and Multiple Disabilities Act, 1999 overrides Order XXXII CPC. The petitioner argues that the National Trust Act requires guardianship for persons with disability and thus a next‑friend appointment under Order XXXII is impermissible; the respondents contend that the Act does not apply here since the relief sought does not involve acquisition, hold or disposition by the person with disability and that Order XXXII governs the proceedings, including retirement/substitution of a next friend. The High Court notes that Order XXXII Rule 15 requires judicial enquiry to determine whether a person is incapable of protecting her interests; citing Raveendran v. Sobhana and other authorities to define mental infirmity, it holds that the National Trust Act does not override Order XXXII for the reliefs sought. The Court then confirms the retirement of the first next friend but sets aside the substitution of the next friend and directs an enquiry under Order XXXII Rule 15 to determine Mercy’s capacity to sue, with a court‑appointed next friend if necessary, and urges expeditious disposal of the suit.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 16299 of 2022

W.P. (C) No. 16299 of 2022: Kanhangad Co-operative Hospital Society vs State of Kerala and Others

This Public Interest writ petition questions Government Exhibit P1, a Government Order dated 16 March 2022, which permitted Local Self Government Institutions in Kasaragod district to release funds from their own funds to Kanhangad Co-operative Hospital Society for establishing a multi-speciality hospital. The petitioner contends that the order arbitrarily transfers public money to a cooperative society, which is not a State entity, and misuses provisions of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 (sections 212(9), 213, 216) and the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994 (section 283(6)). The concern is that public funds would be diverted to a private/partially private venture, undermining the public exchequer and the health infrastructure crisis in Kasaragod, where government facilities are strained and doctors have struck over deficiencies. The Government counters that health is a State subject and local governments have constitutional and statutory power to expend funds on health; the cooperative hospital is an instrumentality of the State and assets would come under public ownership; the order is a permissive sanction, not a compulsion, and aims to address a district with acute needs. The court held that Ext P1 is not arbitrary and dismissed the petition, emphasizing the need to improve health infrastructure while recognizing local governments’ discretion.

High Court of Kerala
DBP 87/2017

Thrikkuratt Sree Maha Devaswom Temple Advisory Committee, Mannar v. The Secretary, Travancore Devaswom Board, Thiruvananthapuram; The Special Tahsildar Travancore Devaswom Board, Thiruvananthapuram; Jayakumar Narayanan Koiyikkal, Kurattissery; Sreekumar Koiyikkal, Kurattissery; Uma Devi Chakrathar ayil, Punthala P.O., Venmony, Pandalam

This Division Bench of the Kerala High Court heard D.B.P. No.87 of 2017 arising from Ombudsman’s Complaint No.61 of 2015 filed by the Thrikkuratt Sree Maha Devaswom Temple Advisory Committee, Mannar. The petition concerns alleged encroachment and trespass on temple land, including about 3.5 acres with 1 acre handed over to BSNL, and the desecration of a serpent grove (Anjili tree) for which the Devaswom Board did not take action. The Ombudsman’s Report No.15/2017 and Report No.97/2016, together with a contemporaneous report of the Special Tahsildar (Land Conservancy), are on record. The Special Tahsildar’s evidence shows that a pattayam was issued in 1989 in favour of Chellappan Nair for 2 acres 17 cents, leaving 8 cents for the serpent grave, and that the subsequent Land Acquisition award in 1995 post-dated the purchase certificate. The Board unsuccessfully challenged the patta through I.A.46 of 1992 and related CRPs; the Supreme Court dismissed the S.L.P. No.13959/1992, and Annexure R1(B) confirms the dismissal. On 5 January 2017 the Court directed action per the 2016 report; ultimately, the Land Tribunal matters are seen as final and no remedy remains to set aside the patta. The Court places reliance on A.A. Gopalakrishnan v. Cochin Devaswom Board and Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair to affirm the Temple’s guardianship rights, but holds that no further action in this DBP is possible, and disposes of the petition.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 37898 of 2022

Krishnakumar K.G alias Sanju Krishna Kumar v. State of Kerala and others

This is a writ petition under Article 226 filed by worshippers of Lord Shiva at Payyavoor Temple, a controlled institution under the Malabar Devaswom Board, challenging a ‘pay and park’ facility operated by the Kudumbasree Pay Parking Team (Cadre under Payyavoor Grama Panchayat CDS). The petition alleges that the Devaswom land in front of the temple was leased for parking without proper sanction and that the Panchayat-form parking scheme is extracting revenue far in excess of the temple’s rent, raising issues of misappropriation and violation of statutory safeguards. Interim relief was granted restraining 9th–13th respondents from using the land, and later the court considered the legality of the lease, the authority of the 9th respondent (Assistant Commissioner) and the Board’s compliance with statutory controls. The court relied on precedents emphasizing that temple properties require protection by trustees and courts (A.A. Gopalakrishnan; Travancore Devaswom Board), and held that any lease of Devaswom land for parking must be justified as necessary or beneficial, sanctioned under law, and executed with due diligence. Ultimately, the court allowed the petition, making the earlier interim order absolute, and directed adherence to statutory safeguards. The judgment underscores the duty to safeguard Devaswom assets and enforces accountability in the management of temple properties.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos. 29772 & 29859 of 2021

W.P.(C) Nos. 29772 & 29859 of 2021 (Sunil Kumar P.G. v. State of Kerala & Travancore Devaswom Board and others; Sumesh Kumar R. v. State of Kerala & Travancore Devaswom Board and others)

Two writ petitions challenge the e-tender awards for Kuthaka item No.119, namely maintenance of the Pamba toilet block at Sabarimala Devaswom, for the Mandala-Makaravilakku season of 1197 ME (2021-22). The petitioners contend that the award to the 6th respondent was obtained through irregularities and possible malafide considerations, with irregularities revealed in the tender process and the return of EMDs of other bidders. They seek quashing of the award, a fresh auction, and a comprehensive inquiry into related contracts (items 115, 119, 213) and into the overall tender process, invoking Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution and the parens patriae doctrine. The respondents defend the process as in accordance with law, albeit with earlier concerns about cartel formation noted in related proceedings. The court, noting irregularities and cartel tendencies in prior tenders and the need to protect temple properties and Devaswam resources, directs a detailed external inquiry and reforms for future tenders. It orders the Chief Vigilance Officer to investigate the e-tender for Kuthaka items post-Mandala-Makaravilakku season 1198 ME, place reports before the Travancore Devaswom Board, and overhaul tendering in major temples, including publication of defaulters and IT-related prerequisites, while keeping documents in safe custody and issuing copies to relevant authorities.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1378 of 2012

Thomas S/O Late Antony and Others v. Arunraj S/O Sukumaran and The United India Insurance Co. Ltd.

This is MACA No. 1378 of 2012, an appeal under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, filed against an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ottappalam in OPMV No.372/2010 arising from the death of Mary in a road accident on 03.04.2010. The Tribunal held the owner-driver (first respondent) liable and awarded Rs.1,10,800 with 7% interest. The appellants, four children/heirs (Thomas, Omana, Daisy, and Reetha), challenged the quantum on grounds that the award did not properly reflect the deceased’s lost services as a homemaker and the loss of dependency, as well as funeral expenses and estate. The insurer contested liability and the quantum, contending that the Tribunal’s award was just and adequate. The High Court discussed the standards for determining ‘just compensation,’ citing Sarla Verma and Pranay Sethi, and noted that while exact arithmetic precision is not required, consistency and fairness are essential. Addressing the specific case, the court fixed an annual income of Rs.12,000 for the deceased and, applying a multiplier of 5, calculated Rs.60,000 for dependency, but allowed Rs.35,000 after adjusting the Tribunal’s earlier award. It additionally awarded Rs.11,500 each for loss of estate and funeral expenses, totaling Rs.58,000 as enhanced compensation, with interest at 6.5% p.a. from the petition date. The insurer is ordered to pay within two months, with delay in filing for this enhancement not attracting additional interest. The bench comprises a Single Judge, Justice M.R. Anitha.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1414 of 2012

Jayakumari v. Umesh Narayana Naik, Hasif Iqbal K.A., The Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Company Limited

On 28.06.2007 a bus accident occurred involving a bus KL-14/D 1150 from Cherkala to Kasargod, in which Jayakumari sustained serious injuries, including a Type III B compound fracture of the right tibia and fibula and pelvic injuries, causing permanent disability. She filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking Rs 10,00,000 from the owner and insurer. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kasaragod, awarded Rs 3,09,700 after partly allowing the petition. The appellant contends the Tribunal wrongly fixed notional income at Rs 3,000 per month while she claimed Rs 5,000, and that the disability was scaled down from 28% to 15%. The appellant argues the Medical Board’s Ext X1 shows 28% permanent impairment and, applying the multiplier 18, as approved in Sarla Verma and the functional disability principle noted in Raj Kumar, should yield higher compensation for loss of earnings, disability, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities, as well as appropriate bystander and nourishment allowances. The insurer defends liability, disputes the appellant’s age, income and occupation and challenges the disability percentage. The High Court re-determines income at Rs 5,000/month, confirms the 28% disability, and recalculates, resulting in total enhanced compensation of Rs 6,08,350, with 7% interest and Rs 20,000 costs, to be deposited in 60 days.

High Court of Kerala
WA 358/2022

SUDARSHANAN and P. SURENDRAN v UNION OF INDIA and OTHERS

The writ appeal concerns a challenge by two landowners (Sudarshananan and P. Surendan) to the land acquisition actions taken by the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) under the National Highways Act, 1956, for NH-66 in Kollam district. The learned Single Judge had dismissed the writ petition, holding that the action to acquire land was in accordance with law and that the petitioners had failed to challenge the declaration under Section 3D. The appellants contend that Ext. P1 (Section 3A notification) lapsed and Ext. P3 (fresh notification dated 25 June 2019) acquired more land than initially proposed, with a changed alignment, which should have required a fresh DPR and another Section 3A process. They further argue that Section 3B surveys do not identify exact land and that excess land cannot be acquired without following the formal stages, including due notice and DPR. The respondents, including the Union of India and the NHAI, maintain that a fresh 3A notification is permissible when the earlier one lapses, that the described land is required for widening the highway, and that Section 3C/3D procedures were properly followed, including objections and vesting in the Central Government. The Division Bench validates the procedure: the fresh 3A notification is legally permissible, alignment changes are within the court’s limited scope, and the appeal is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 26333/2021

SHEIKH PREM SAMEER v. MINISTRY OF TEXTILES, NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF FASHION TECHNOLOGY (NIFT) & OTHERS

This writ petition (C) concerns a B.Arch graduate who joined NIFT Kannur for a Master of Design (M.Des) program and faced a disciplinary process culminating in expulsion. The petitioner alleges that the conduct alleged by several female classmates led to a campus disciplinary action under NIFT’s Academic Manual (Ext.R1(a)); however, crucial procedural requirements were not followed. Key issues include: whether the Students Grievance Redressal Committee and the Campus Disciplinary Committee adhered to the manual’s detailed process (5.5, 5.5.1–5.5.3, 5.7, etc.), whether the complaint copies were supplied prior to expulsion, and whether the procedure was fair given the potential lifelong consequences for a student. The petitioner contends that material documents, including the complaint and evidence, were not supplied until after expulsion, that a copy of the complaint was not provided before Ext.P13, and that the hearing did not satisfy natural justice. The Court, after considering arguments, held that the procedure fell short of the guaranteed fair process and that several orders (Exts. P3, P13, P24) were unsustainable. It directed the competent authority to reconsider in accordance with Ext.R1(a), provide copies of any new documents, and complete the process within three months, ensuring due process and hearing. The judgment emphasizes that disciplinary actions in academics should conform to natural justice and proportionality, and not extinguish a student’s future without fair procedure.

High Court of Kerala
ITA 247/2019; 255/2019; 259/2019; 256/2019; 260/2019; 258/2019; 10/2020; 3/2020; 13/2020; 4/2020; 8/2020; 11/2020; 12/2020; 16/2020

Hillwood Group of Assessees v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle, Kochi (Batch ITA appeals)

This batch judgment disposes of ITA Nos. 247/2019, 255/2019, 259/2019, 256/2019, 260/2019, 258/2019, 10/2020, 3/2020, 13/2020, 4/2020, 8/2020, 11/2020, 12/2020, 16/2020 arising from block assessments based on data seized during searches on 04.12.2013 and a survey on 14.07.2014 at the Hillwood group premises and at the residence of one Riyaz. The ITAT dismissed the challenges and allowed certain grounds/evidence under Sections 65A and 65B of the Indian Evidence Act read with the Second Schedule of the IT Act. The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench led by S.V. Bhatti and Basant Balaji Thakur, addressed three substantial questions: (1) whether the survey under Section 133A at Riyaz’s residence violated 133A; (2) whether the ITAT erred in admitting additional grounds under 65A/65B with Section 93 and the Second Schedule; and (3) whether the Hash Value Report generated in 2014 could be relied upon when the pen drives were opened in 2014. The Court held that the 2017 Explanation to 133A broadens the definition to include residences, making the Riyaz survey permissible, but ultimately held the ground to challenge 133A unsustainable. It upheld the Tribunal’s discretion on additional grounds/evidence and, noting delays and prima facie lack of bona fides for new evidence, declined to admit further evidence. All appeals were dismissed, with no costs, and the Revenue’s block assessments were sustained.

High Court of Kerala
ITA Nos. 247/2019, 255/2019, 259/2019, 256/2019, 260/2019, 258/2019, 10/2020, 3/2020, 13/2020, 4/2020, 8/2020, 11/2020, 12/2020, 16/2020

Hillwood Imports and Exports Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle, Kochi

This batch judgment disposes of a cluster of linked income-tax appeals filed by the Hillwood group challenging block assessments arising from searches and surveys conducted in 2013–14 under Section 133A of the Income‑Tax Act. The appeals arise from orders by the Deputy Commissioner, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), and the ITAT in relation to the block assessment years 2008‑09 to 2013‑14, with reliance on documents and pen drives seized from Riyaz, an employee connected to the Hillwood group. The central issues focus on (i) whether the survey of Riyaz’s residence under Section 133A was legally valid, (ii) whether the Tribunal was correct in dismissing the assessee’s request to raise additional grounds under Sections 65A/65B of the Evidence Act read with Section 93 and the Second Schedule of the IT Act and (iii) whether the Hash Value Report generated on 22–23 July 2014—based on data from the pen drives—was properly admitted and used to determine suppressed turnover. The High Court, after detailed analysis, answered the questions against the assessee and in favor of the Revenue, holding that the Tribunal did not err in its approach and that the data from the pen drives, the survey, and the pre‑assessment notices formed a valid basis for the assessments. The batch appeals are dismissed with no order as to costs.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1212 OF 2016

MACA NO. 1212 OF 2016

This Motor Accident Claims Appeal arises from an award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Alappuzha, in OP(MV) No.1223/2010, concerning the death of Nandanan in a road accident on 9 May 2010. The bicycle ridden by the deceased was struck by a car owned by the 2nd respondent and insured with the 3rd respondent; the 1st respondent driver was negligent. The appellants, as widow and children, challenged the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal (Rs. 8,94,500 with interest at 9%). They argued that the Tribunal undervalued the deceased’s monthly income (claimed Rs. 6,000 but found Rs. 5,000), failed to apply future prospects, and did not sufficiently compensate for loss of dependency, funeral expenses and loss of estate. The 3rd respondent insurer contested policy conditions and quantum issues. The High Court, relying on jurisprudence from Ramachandrappa, Syed Sadiq, Minu Rout and Pranay Sethi, recalculated the monthly income for 2010 at Rs. 7,500 (with Rs. 500 increments per year) and applied a 40% addition for future prospects for a person under 40. The court also awarded Rs. 5,000 for funeral expenses and Rs. 15,000 for loss of estate, resulting in an additional Rs. 7,62,500. The amount already awarded by the Tribunal was Rs. 6,75,000. The appeal was allowed, with the award modified and the insurer directed to deposit the enhanced amount within three months at 8% interest.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 33322 OF 2016 & Conn. cases

WP(C) No. 33322 of 2016 & Connected Cases - Batch challenges to age restriction in the Integrated Five-Year LL.B Course admissions (Kerala High Court)

The batch of writ petitions challenges the age restriction imposed for admission to the Integrated Five-Year LL.B Course (2016-2017) under Clause 28(a) of the Legal Education Rules, 2008. Petitioners, including V. Anju and several others, contended that the upper age limit of 20 years, added after the examination process and publication of the provisional rank lists, is arbitrary, unconstitutional, and violative of the Advocates Act and fundamental rights. They relied on the prospectus and the notification of 28 July 2016, which, at that stage, did not impose an upper age limit, and argued that changing the rules mid-process deprived them of a fair opportunity. Respondents argued the validity of Clause 28 had been upheld by the Madras High Court in Santhosh Antony Vareed and that the Supreme Court had dismissed related SLPs; they cited Bar Council actions and government amendments, including GO/Orders, to justify the age restriction. The Court observed that the notification and prospectus did not initially contain an upper age limit and that the later amendments were made after the examination; noting the interim orders and admissions already effected, the Court held that continuing the interim position would best serve justice. The Court ultimately made the interim order absolute, closed the petitions, and directed that successful candidates receive their certificates."

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 39224 of 2022

Anamika v. State Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities & Ors.

The petitioner, Anamika, an 18-year-old girl with 40% locomotor disability, sought admission to MBBS under NEET-UG-2022 in the PwD quota. She underwent disability assessment on 27.09.2022 by the State Medical Board, Kozhikode, and Ext. P5 (dated 15.10.2022) recorded 55% disability and held her not eligible for MBBS. The writ petition challenged this outcome, arguing that disability cannot bar education and citing the Right of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 and the Kerala decision Aswathy v. Union of India to press that disability should not entail exclusion. The government contends that while candidates with 40–80% disability are eligible, the final suitability for a course is determined by the State Level Committee under the National Medical Council guidelines; in this case, the Committee found the petitioner not suitable due to congenital left-hand transcarpal deficiency and poor hand function. The prospectus (G.O.MS 170/2022/HEDN) and Clause 5.3, along with Annex XXIV(i) of the NMC guidance, govern PwD admissions and require that the State Level Committee’s medical assessment be respected. The court emphasizes deference to expert medical boards, citing Vidhi Himmat Katariya and Others v. State of Gujarat to justify not reappraising expert findings, and distinguishes the cerebral palsy case W.P.(C).No.27225 of 2020 as inapplicable. Consequently, the writ petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl.) No.910 of 2022

WP(Crl.) No.910 of 2022, Binu Babu v. State of Kerala and Others

The Kerala High Court, in a writ petition (criminal) filed by Binu Babu, the brother of the detenu Bibin Babu, challenges Ext.P1 detention order under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007. The petition seeks habeas corpus and certiorari to quash the order dated 14.06.2022 detaining Bibin Babu under Sec.3(1) and to produce him before the court. The petitioner contends that the detenu was already in judicial custody as on the date of Ext.P1, a crucial fact not known to the detaining authority, rendering the detention vitiated. The court examines settled jurisprudence on detention of persons in custody, tracing the lineage from Dharmendra Suganchand Chelawat v. UOI (1990) and Abdul Sathar Ibrahim Manik v. UOI (1992), which require that the detaining authority be aware that the detainee is in custody and that there exist compelling or cogent reasons showing that, if released, the detenu would likely indulge in prejudicial activities. The respondents’ case that the detenu’s last prejudicial act occurred on 19.04.2022 is examined against the production warrants and bail history, which showed the detenu could not be released until 14.06.2022 due to pendency in multiple cases. Relying on Union of India v. Dimple Happy Dhakad, Ankit Jalan, Huidrom Konungjao Singh, Veeramani, Senthamilselvi, and Kamarunnisa, the court holds that the detaining authority lacked the required awareness and cogent material, quashes Ext.P1, and directs release of the detenu forthwith, noting the need for proper application of mind and adherence to established constitutional safeguards.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev. No.211 of 2019

Pachan Venu v. Kammadam Haridasan and ChettiYodan Rajeev

R.C.Rev. No.211 of 2019 arises from eviction petitions under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 relating to a petition schedule building in Kozhikode. The Rent Control Court (Additional Munsiff-II) granted eviction under sections 11(2)(b) (arrears of rent) and 11(4)(i) (subletting) and rejected 11(3) (bona fide need). The Rent Control Appellate Authority (Addl. District Judge-II) upheld eviction under 11(2)(b) and 11(4)(i) but allowed the landlord’s cross-appeal and directed eviction under 11(3). The tenant/petitioner challenged these orders in a revision under Section 20, and the High Court admitted the revision and stayed proceedings for a period. The judgment surveys the interplay between arrears, bona fide need and subletting, and traverses a welter of Kerala and Supreme Court precedents on what constitutes bona fide need, the provisos to 11(3), and the proof of subletting. It emphasizes that the landlord’s claim of bona fide need must be genuine and that subletting requires exclusive possession by the third party, often proven through inference. Ultimately, the High Court dismisses the revision, confirming eviction orders, but grants four months to vacate with conditions due to Covid-19, including arrears deposit and continued rent payments.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl.) No.296 of 2023

SANTHA KUMARI v. STATE OF KERALA & OTHERS

This writ petition (Criminal) before the Kerala High Court concerns the custody and welfare of an autistic ward, Priya S., aged about 39, who was left in the care of the ward’s father and later the fifth respondent Grace Home Charitable Society after the father secured guardianship under Section 14 of the National Trust for Welfare of Persons with Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Mental Retardation and Multiple Disabilities Act, 1999. The petitioner, the ward’s mother, asserts that she is capable of providing round-the-clock care and seeks custody of the ward. Following the death of the ward’s father in March 2023, the ward’s custody has been with the fifth respondent institution, with the local District Administration and Grama Panchayat reportedly not concurring to transfer custody to the petitioner. The petitioner filed an affidavit detailing her assets, fixed deposits, income, and support from her elder daughter to demonstrate her capacity to care for Priya S. The respondents argued that the ward’s custody was being managed by a registered organization under the Act, and that the guardianship already assigned by the prior order should be respected, while ensuring the ward’s welfare. The court, however, held that guardianship provisions do not bar a parent from seeking custody and invoked the parens patriae doctrine, deeming this an exceptional case. It ultimately disposed of the petition by directing the District Administration to entrust custody of Priya S. to the petitioner.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 20265 of 2021

Dr. A.V. Sajeev v. Revenue Divisional Officer / Sub Collector, Kochi and Others

The petitioner Dr. A.V. Sajeev, owner of 7.59 acres in Sy.No.226/1 and 3.23 acres in Sy.No.226/2 at Poonithura, Kanayannur Taluk, challenged the government’s fee regime under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 for changing the land’s nature under Section 27A. The lands, previously belonging to Vylopilly Tharavadu with Kudikidappukars, were pursued for conversion to residential/commercial use via Form 9 (Rule 12) and related Forms 6 for different parcels, after prior attempts through W.P.(C) No. 8356/2021. The Government circulars Exts. P8 (25.02.2021) and Exts. P14 (revised) imposed fee exemptions or levies based on an aggregate area—an approach challenged as unconstitutional by the petitioner, who contends that Section 27A imposes no limit on the total extent that may be converted and that the fee should be linked to the individual extents of separate properties and not the combined total. The petition relied on the court’s prior stance and the Baby M.K. decision (2021) noting the unconstitutionality of the later circulars. The court ultimately held that Section 27A does not cap the total extent for conversion; the fee schedule is applicable to the extent involved, and exemptions cannot be denied by aggregating separate applications. The order quashed Ext. P15, declared the petitioner’s entitlement to change of land use without fee, and directed refunds and revenue-record corrections, with purayidom treatment.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 680 of 2020

Surendran v. Respondents (RSA No. 680 of 2020)

This Regular Second Appeal concerns a dispute over the plaint schedule property before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam. The appellant Surendran (1st defendant) challenges judgments in the suit for permanent injunction arising from O.S. No.127/2010 and later A.S. No.123/2015, involving properties formerly owned by Thomson Nadar. The trial court held Thomson’s title absolute and decreed the injunction against the defendants; the First Appellate Court affirmed the injunction but held Ext.A1 (the sale deed) not proved, noting the trial court should not have decided title in an injunction suit. The suit describes a plaint schedule of 44.5 cents, while Ext.A1 (No.1474/1971) records 32.5 cents; the defendants dispute the boundary and title, citing Re-survey Nos. 527/7, 527/6-2, and 527/6-1 with altered demarcations. PW1, PW2, and a Commissioner’s report supported possession of the entire 44.5 cents with long-standing boundaries, and the defendants produced documentary materials to show a smaller extent and different tenure. The High Court addresses substantial questions about the interplay of oral possession evidence and documentary title, and cross-objections under Order XLI Rule 22 CPC post-1976 amendments. Ultimately, the High Court upholds the concurrent findings of possession and boundary, rejects the appeal, and dismisses the second appeal; the injunction remains in force in favour of the plaintiffs.