This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal by the third accused, Pramod, challenging a 2018 conviction by the II Additional Sessions Court, Kollam, for possession and transport of 6.060 kg of ganja under NDPS Act, 1985 (Section 20(b)(ii)(B)). The trial court convicted A1–A3 after considering the prosecution records, including confessional statements allegedly recorded from A1 and A2 by the Excise Inspector, which purportedly linked the 3rd accused to supplying the contraband. The defence contended that the 3rd accused’s guilt rests entirely on the confession of co-accused, with no independent corroboration, and urged that confession statements to an Excise Officer are barred under Section 25 of the Indian Evidence Act. The State responded that the evidence was sufficient and that proper legal procedure was followed. The High Court examines jurisprudence on confessions by co-accused and insists that such confessions cannot form the basis for convicting another accused when barred by Section 25, citing Tofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu and Murukadas @ Murukan v. State of Kerala. The court ultimately holds that the impugned judgment cannot sustain the 3rd accused’s conviction and reverses the verdict, allowing the appeal and directing his release forthwith. The authorities are to be informed of the reversal to effect release from custody.
CRL.A NO. 617 OF 2019; CRL.A NO. 685 OF 2019; CRL.A NO. 798 OF 2019 These are three connected criminal appeals arising from S.C.No.137 of 2014, tried by the Additional Sessions Court-I, Alappuzha, arising out of the murder of Durgesh, a Maharashtra-based gold trader, at Mullackal, Alappuzha on 5 November 2013. The appellants (Accused 1, 2 and 3) were convicted under IPC sections including 120B (criminal conspiracy), 449 (house-trespass in attempt to commit) 302 (murder) and 394 read with 34 (robbery) for Accused-1 and Accused-2, while Accused-3 was convicted under 120B, 302 and 394 IPC. The High Court evaluated a starkly circumstantial case, as no direct eyewitnesses existed. Key issues were whether a criminal conspiracy involving the third accused was proven, whether the first two accused caused Durgesh’s death, whether recovery of gold and cash and the chain of evidence satisfied Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, and whether the circumstances excluded reasonable hypotheses of innocence. The court scrutinized evidence of PW1–PW4, PW8, PW9, PW16, PW18 and the autopsy by PW22, along with the circumstantial links (MO1–MO23). It held that the death was due to smothering and strangulation following head injury, and that the first two accused were found at the scene with the body, with gold/cash connected to the first accused. Consequently, Appeals 617 and 798 were dismissed, while Appeal 685 was allowed, setting aside the conviction of the third accused and ordering his release.
Annie George, the petitioner/accused in CRL.MC No. 2830 of 2023, seeks exercise of inherent power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the proceedings in CC No. 289 of 2017 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Thodupuzha, arising from Crime No. 2247/2016. The accused faces charges under IPC Sections 341, 294(b), 353 and 506(1) for allegedly restraining, intimidating and using abusive language against the de facto complainant, an Assistant Manager of the National Insurance Company, on 27.12.2016. The defence contends that even if the FIR statements are true, the Final Report does not spell out the obscene words, and the ingredients for the offences under Sections 341, 353 and 506(1) are not established, relying on the rulings in Preethimon v. State of Kerala (2008) and Hariprasad v. State of Kerala (2016) for the required triggers under 294(b) and 353. It further argues that the intention to cause alarm, a key element for Section 506(1), is lacking per Manik Taneja. The Public Prosecutor counters, stating no ground to interfere and that the petitioner should face trial. The High Court, applying the cited precedents, finds the words are not clearly spelled out and the statutory ingredients are not established, and thus allows the CRL.MC and quashes the proceedings against the petitioner.
This motor-accident appeal by Alivin Jose (a minor) challenges the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Perumbavoor, award in OP(MV)1266/2006 for injuries sustained on 25.04.2006 when a mini lorry struck him while crossing. The Tribunal held the driver liable and directed the insurer and owner to pay Rs.3,35,429 with 8% interest. The appellant contends the Tribunal erred in treating the claimant as a non-earning minor with a monthly income of Rs.15,000, and in using a 40% disability certificate to compute compensation under the disability heads, urging application of the Supreme Court’s Master Mallikarjun framework (2013 KLJ 815) which prescribes lump-sum ranges: up to 10% Rs.1,00,000; 10–30% Rs.3,00,000; 30–60% Rs.4,00,000; 60–90% Rs.5,00,000; above 90% Rs.6,00,000. The appellant produced Annexures A1–A54 (bills, discharge) accepted as additional documents. The insurer contends the 40% figure is not proved for the whole body and notes no cross-appeal. After considering the evidence and the 40% disability, the High Court enhances the compensation by Rs.3,45,688 and awards 8% interest from the date of petition on the enhanced amount, with Rs.84,688 specific to treatment expenses carried on as additional documents; directs NEFT/RTGS transfer within a month and keeps the Tribunal’s other findings intact.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 71 OF 2016 This High Court of Kerala heard a criminal revision under sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. by Mathew Varkey challenging concurrent convictions under Section 138 NI Act that resulted from a cheque issued as security in a chit transaction. The complainant, Sree Gokulam Chit and Finance Co (P) Ltd, claimed the accused, while acting as a surety for Sri Devasia P.D., issued Ext. P8 cheque for Rs. 1,98,059 toward the debt after default. The cheque bounced; notice given; prosecution filed. The trial court found the accused guilty and sentenced four months imprisonment, Rs. 1,98,059 fine, compensation under Sec 357(1), and three months default; on appeal, the Additional Sessions Court modified to pay the amount with three months default. The revision contends that Ext. P8 was not for a loan claim against the accused and that he did not stand as a surety; the defence relies on DWs 1-3 and Exts D1-D6 to show the security arrangement for Mercy Devasia's chitty in 2006. The trial and appellate courts accepted the prosecution’s case and applied the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act, holding the complainant proved the debt and transaction. The High Court refused to reweigh evidence, citing established authority that revision under Cr.P.C. is not a wide de novo review; it affirmed the verdict, holding the presumption remains unrebutted, and dismissed the revision petition. The court directed one-month time to pay compensation and deferred execution to 04.09.2023, with appearance on 05.09.2023.
CRL.R.P. No. 1575 of 2016 This is a criminal revision petition by Nisam alias Samenayi challenging the judgment of conviction under Section 58 of the Kerala Abkari Act and the appellate order. The prosecution alleged possession of illicit liquor for sale on 07.06.2009, leading to a charge under Sections 8(2), 55(a) and 55(i). The trial court convicted under Section 55(a), with two years’ rigorous imprisonment and Rs. 1 lakh fine, acquitting the other clauses. The First Appellate Court re-appreciated the evidence, holding the offence to fall under Section 58 and convicting under that section with a three-month simple imprisonment and Rs. 1 lakh fine, with a default sentence. The revision petition before this High Court attacks the legality of the conviction, asserting that the liquor seized was not proven illicit, since Ext. P9 (chemical analysis) is inconclusive about whether the sample was IMFL/arrack/illicit liquor, and Ext. P1’s seizure particulars lack a specimen impression of the seal. The prosecution’s chain of custody and the arrest timing (the crime number appearing in the arrest memo at the scene) are questioned. Citing Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala and Rafeeque v. Sub Inspector of Police, the court notes defects in investigation (one-man show) and tamper-proof despatch concerns. Consequently, the Court sets aside the appellate judgment, acquits under Section 58, and allows the revision petition, ordering liberty.
This is an OP(KAT) No.92/2023 before the Kerala High Court challenging an interim order of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (KAT) dated 24 January 2023. The petitioner, Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC), moved against a direction in the KAT’s interim order permitting the applicant’s provisional submission for the post of Armed Police Sub Inspector (Trainee) in the Armed Police Battalion, in light of the applicant Arjun Geetha’s transgender status. The applicant claims she is a transgender person with a transgender identity certificate issued by the District Magistrate, Idukki, yet the notification did not specify transgender eligibility and the Special Rules (1984, amended 1992) bar her from posts reserved for men. The KPSC argues that the interim order transgresses the binding recruitment rules and cannot override them. The Respondents rely on the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 to assert protection against discrimination in employment and to justify a broader interpretation of eligibility. The High Court, invoking supervisory jurisdiction over interlocutory orders, notes the Tribunal’s equitable order did not unlawfully deny the applicant a provisional path to apply but emphasizes that the State should align rules with the Act. The court ultimately dismisses the petition, observing that the State must harmonize recruitment rules with transgender protections while preserving established rules for recruitment.”
The High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam hears OP(C) No.103 of 2020, filed by the petitioner Sainarani (defendant No.3 in OS No.495/2008) challenging an order dated 17 December 2019 in I.A. 3743/2019 connected to a suit for declaration of title and fixation of boundary. The suit involved a Commissioner to measure the properties based on title deeds, aided by a Surveyor, with Ext.C2 series report, mahazar and plan forming part of the record. The plaintiff contends that the location of plaint A schedule item No.2 lies to the west of item No.1 and that the commission report inaccurately reflects this, seeking modification. The petitioner contends that the plaint was amended to align with the report and plan, and, relying on the deposition of the Surveyor, argues that the court is not competent to set aside the report. The trial court held that setting aside the report, already part of the evidence under Order XXVI Rule 10(2) CPC, was not necessary and directed a fresh local investigation under Order XXVI Rule 10(3) CPC, noting the need to clarify actual locations. The petitioner relies on Laly Joseph v. Francis (2023 (2) KLT 516) to demand cogent reasons for remitting, while the respondents press that further inputs are essential. The High Court, citing Laly Joseph, clarifies that a court may remit or appoint a fresh commission when dissatisfied, and, exercising Order XXVI Rule 10(3) CPC, confirms the order and dismisses the petition, directing expeditious trial within eight months.
BAIL APPL. NO. 1292 OF 2024 Salil Kumar.K.P., the sole accused in Crime No. 22/2023 of the Iritty Excise Range Office, Kannur, files a second bail application under Section 439 CrPC seeking release during trial for an offence under Section 22(c) NDPS Act, alleging possession of 100 grams of MDMA on 21 March 2023 near the Iritty-Koottupuzha road. The prosecution contends the contraband constitutes a commercial quantity, thus triggering the rigour of Section 37 NDPS Act; the case relies on the earlier Annexure A1 order, and there has been no change in circumstances since. The petitioner maintains innocence and argues misidentification or false implication, pointing to nearly a year in custody, completed investigation, and a final report. Counsel for the petitioner emphasises the prolonged detention, the absence of evidence of flight risk or tampering with witnesses, and the need to balance liberty with culpability. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, stressing the severe consequences of NDPS offences and the commercial quantity, arguing that Section 37(b) applies. The High Court recalls the standard tests for bail under NDPS Act—‘reasonable grounds’ to believe the accused is not guilty and not likely to commit an offence on bail—referring to Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari, Mohd. Nawaz Khan, and Prasanta Kumar Sarkar. On weighing the circumstances, the court finds no reasonable grounds to grant bail and dismisses the application, while directing expedited disposal of S.C.No.106/2023 by 30.06.2024.
MACA 1878/2012 arises from a MACT petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, concerning the death of Alice, mother to the appellants, in an auto-rickshaw collision on 22 March 2008 near Ayarkunnam Junction on a road in Kottayam. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal awarded Rs. 3,06,250 to the claimants and held the driver liable, with the insurer bound to indemnify; the owner having appeared ex parte. The appellants contended that the compensation was understated and that the Tribunal erred in selecting the appropriate income, multiplier, and conventional heads. They relied on precedents for notional income (including Syed Sadiq), and urged the use of Rs. 6,500 per month as notional income given the deceased’s age and service status (57 years 10 months at death) and two months of service left before retirement. The insurer argued that the Tribunal already awarded just and reasonable compensation and that the typical multiplier approach had to be followed. The High Court reevaluated: refraining from using 3,500; applying a notional monthly income of Rs. 6,500 with 15% future prospects, adopting a 9-year multiplier appropriate for age 56–60, following Sarla Verma and subsequent authorities; and applying 10% escalation for conventional heads per Pranay Sethi and Rasmita Biswal. The court increased the total enhanced compensation to Rs. 3,27,300 with a 7.5% interest rate, and directed apportionment 30:30:40 among claimants, with the insurer paying within two months.
AS No. 266/2001; CRP No. 2105/2001; CRP No. 2106/2001 This is a consolidated appeal (AS No. 266/2001) with connected Civil Revision Petitions (CRP Nos. 2105/2001 and 2106/2001) in the Kerala High Court. The appellant/defendant is the proprietor of M/s Accurate Extrusions, challenging a trial court decree that granted the plaintiff a sum of Rs. 1,86,490 as commission and related orders directing release of Rs. 10 lakhs from court deposit upon furnishing a bank guarantee. The respondent/plaintiff is N. Jayachandran, proprietor of M/s Hydro Aids. Addl. Respondent 2 is the Kerala Water Authority represented by its Managing Director. The core issue is whether it is permissible to employ a third person on a commission basis in a public auction/tender conducted by a state authority and whether such an arrangement violates public policy under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act. The court discusses that public tenders must be transparent and free from commissions to third parties, as such arrangements would inflate tender costs and undermine public policy. Relying on Gurmukh Singh v. Amar Singh, the court holds that agreements among bidders to obtain commission or to influence tender are against public policy and unenforceable. Consequently, the decree is set aside and the suit dismissed; the connected CRPs are disposed of accordingly.
This appeal, heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court, concerns enhancement of compensation awarded by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, in O.P.(MV) No.1826/2006, following the death of the injured in a road accident on 07.02.2005. The appellants are the legal heirs of the deceased, who died after four years of treatment. The court allowable grounds include the proper determination of the deceased’s notional income, future prospects, and the correct multiplier, guided by Supreme Court precedents. The Tribunal had fixed a monthly income of Rs. 3,500; the High Court, applying Ramachandrappa, held the notional income for 2005 at Rs. 5,000. The court adopted a 40% addition for future prospects in line with Pranay Sethi and Sarala Verma, and deducted 50% for personal expenses since the claimant was a bachelor. It recalculated the dependency, revised the multiplier from 9 to 17, and granted consortium to the parents (Rs.40,000 each) while striking off love and affection and pain-suffering awards in light of Kehlon. Funeral expenses were enhanced to Rs.15,000 and loss of estate Rs.15,000. The total compensation became Rs.9,54,376, with an enhanced amount of Rs.5,80,000. The insurer must pay interest on the original amount at the Tribunal rate and 8% on the enhanced amount from the petition date, with NEFT/RTGS transfer within a month after furnishing bank details.
MACA Nos.151 & 1002 of 2012 These MACA proceedings arise from the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Manjeri, awarding Rs. 40,28,000 for the death of Panali Basheer, a non-permanent Gulf worker. The appellants, being his wife, children, mother and siblings, challenge the award as inadequate; the insurer cross-appeals contending the amount is excessive. The High Court re-examines the deceased’s income; the Tribunal relied on Ext.A17 (bank statement) showing Rs.8 lakh annual income, but the court notes lack of authenticated salary certificates from Saudi Arabia and that Gulf employment is non-permanent, so Indian standards should apply (Valsamma v. Binu Jose). The court applies Pranay Sethi (2017) to award 25% future prospects for a businessman and, following United India/Satinder Kaur, deducts 50% for personal living expenses, bringing the Indian annual income to Rs.5 lakh (Rs.10 lakh minus 50% and tax). With a multiplier of 14 (age 43), the loss of dependency becomes Rs.63 lakh, higher than the Tribunal’s Rs.40 lakh. The court also revises heads for love and affection, estate, funeral expenses and loss of consortium, resulting in a total enhanced compensation of Rs.65.30 lakh. The court holds that only appellants 1–5 are entitled to compensation (6–11 are not dependents). MACA No.1002/2012 is dismissed; MACA No.151/2012 is allowed to the extent described, with orders on deposit and interest. No costs.
ARB.A 17 OF 2021; ARB.A 21 OF 2021 These Arbitration Appeals challenge a common judgment dated 25 August 2020 of the Additional District Court-1, Pathanamthitta, which set aside portions of the Arbitral Award dated 9 August 2011 in O.P.(Arbitration) Nos.54/2011 and 33/2012 concerning the CRF works on Kadambanadu–Mannady–Enathu–Ezhamkulam Road in Pathanamthitta District. The contract, dated 25 May 2004, fixed ₹9,18,44,495 and faced hindrances in land acquisition and utilities; site handover and time extensions were addressed by supplemental agreements. The Arbitral Tribunal delivered a majority award on 9 August 2011 and a minority award on 15 May 2011. The majority allowed several heads of claim but disallowed others, ultimately directing payment of ₹1,92,35,130 to the claimant out of a larger claim. The Addl. District Court partly set aside the award, notably regarding claim nos.1(5) and 5(2)–5(6). Aggrieved, the contractor-petitioner appealed, contending the impugned judgment misread the award and contract, and exceeded Section 34 limits. The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench, allowed the appeals, set aside the common judgment, and restored the majority award, holding that the court below overstepped jurisdiction and erred in altering the arbitral price adjustments and compensation events. The decision cites Ssangyong, J.G. Engineers, Associate Builders, P.R. Shah and other authorities to emphasize limited judicial interference and the primacy of arbitral interpretation of contract. The appeals are allowed with costs, and pending applications are disposed of.
This Criminal Misc. Case (Crl.M.C. No.2964 of 2023) challenges the proceedings in Crime No.297/2022 of Peruvamthanam Police Station, pending as CP No.12 of 2023 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Peermade, in which accused Nos. 1 to 4 are charged under IPC offences: 323, 324, 341, 294(b), 308, and 506(i) read with 34. The petition, filed under section 482 Cr.P.C., contends that the disputes between the parties have been amicably settled, supported by Annexures A2 and A3 filed by the 2nd and 3rd respondents, and seeks quashing. The court directed the IO to record statements from the victim and assess the genuineness of the settlement and whether there are any impediments or antecedents that would affect quashing. The Public Prosecutor raised reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but acknowledged no other complaints against the petitioners. The judge places reliance on a line of Supreme Court precedents (Gian Singh; Narinder Singh; Laxmi Narayan; Deepak; Manish; Rajveer Singh; Parbatbhai Aahir; Kalyan Singh; Dhruv Gurjar; Ramesh Kamath; Shambhu Kewat) to articulate the modern test under 482 Cr.P.C. for quashing private, non-compoundable offences where civil disputes have been settled, while excluding heinous offences or those under special statutes. On weighing gravity, injuries, antecedents, and the settlement, the court holds quashing would promote ends of justice and not adversely impact society, and accordingly vacates the proceedings. The petition is allowed and final report Annexure A1 is recorded, quashing the proceedings.
Common order of the Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, by Justice C. S. Dias, dated 5 August 2024, disposing Bail Applications No. 6133/2024 and 6177/2024 arising from Crime No. 504/2024 of Chavakkad Police Station, Thrissur. The accused, five individuals, are under investigation for offences punishable under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 308, 506(i) and 201 read with Section 149. The petitions, filed under BNSS 2023 Section 483, were consolidated since they arise from the same crime; the accused were remanded on 17.07.2024. The prosecution asserts ongoing investigation and the risk of witness intimidation, though it concedes the accused have no criminal antecedents. The defense contends innocence and argues that the Investigating Officer deliberately included Section 308; the investigation is nearly complete with recoveries. The court anchors its analysis in the presumption of innocence (Sanjay Chandra v. CBI), the principle that bail is the rule and imprisonment before conviction is an exception (Dataram Singh v. State of U.P.), and the general aim that bail should secure appearance at trial. It also cites Sushila Aggarwal for standard bail conditions. The court notes that only the third accused has a specific overt act causing grievous injuries; the others lack such overt acts and are held eligible for bail with bonds of Rs.50,000 and two solvent sureties, subject to statutory conditions, while the third accused’s bail is denied. The order is a common disposition granting bail to accused 1, 2, 4, 5 and dismissing bail for accused 3.
Radhamoni, the revision petitioner, challenges a conviction under the Kerala Abkari Act (Sections 8(1) & 8(2)) for possession of 2 litres of arrack on 11 December 2007. The trial court convicted her and sentenced three years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with default imprisonment. On appeal, the sentence was reduced to one year with the same fine. The revision petition contends that crucial documentary particulars are missing or defective: Ext.P10 forwarding note does not contain the name of the Excise Guard or the date of dispatch, and Ext.P9 does not reveal who sent the sample for analysis or when; reliance on Kumaran P. v. State of Kerala is invoked to show gaps in the chain of custody. The petitioner also raises delay in filing the final report (occurrence 11.12.2007, final report 14.07.2008). While revisional jurisdiction is limited, the court can scrutinize compliance with statutory formalities under the Abkari Act. Citing Baburaj v. State of Kerala and Sathi v. State of Kerala, the court underscores strict compliance and non-application of the presumption under Section 114(e) of the Evidence Act when acts are not properly shown. The court finds the forwarding-note and sampling procedure unproven due to non-examination of the Excise Guard/thondi clerk and acquits the petitioner, also directing refund of any deposited amounts and cancelling bail bonds.
Mahin, a 22-year-old inmate, stands as the 7th accused in Crime No. 970/2023 registered at Viyyur Police Station, Thrissur. He seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC, asserting his innocence and arguing parity with three co-accused already enlarged on bail. The prosecution alleges that on 11.11.2023, within Central Prison, Viyyur, an unlawful assembly assaulted a convict named Siyad with deadly weapons and with the intent to murder, while the Assistant Prison Officer (APO) who attempted to intervene was deterred from discharging official duties. The accused are charged under multiple IPC sections (143, 341, 323, 324, 353, 308, 506(ii) read with 149) read with Section 149 IPC. The petitioner has been in judicial custody since 08.01.2024; the prosecution contends he is an inveterate offender with several other cases and that proximity to a potentially dangerous offense justifies denial of bail. The defense contends the 308 IPC charge was wrongly added to sustain detention; other co-accused have been granted bail, creating parity. The court, citing Hussainara Khatoon, Sanjay Chandra, Satender Antil, Nikesh Tarachand Shah, Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia, and Maneka Gandhi, emphasizes the presumption of innocence and the bail doctrine. It ultimately finds that detention is unnecessary, noting complete investigation and no current recoveries, and grants bail on stringent conditions under oversight of the trial court.
The petitioner, Najiya, challenges Ext.P3, the Revenue Divisional Officer’s (RDO) Form 5 decision, which rejected removal of her land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. The Land covers 13 Ares 38.5 square metres in Pulamanthole, Perinthalmanna Taluk, Malappuram. The RDO relied solely on an Agricultural Officer’s report, denying removal, despite the Act’s emphasis on the land’s status as of the date of its coming into force (12.08.2008) and its suitability for paddy cultivation. The petitioner contends the order is vitiated for non-application of mind and for not obtaining independent assessments, including a KSRSEC report, to ascertain the land’s status on 12.08.2008 and its potential for paddy cultivation. The court cites Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala, Muraleedharan Nair v. Revenue Divisional Officer, and Aparna Sasi Menon v. Revenue Divisional Officer to emphasize the need for independent assessment of the land’s status and the predominant factor: whether paddy cultivation is possible. The judge holds Ext.P3 unsustainable, sets it aside, and directs the RDO to reconsider Ext.P2 with a KSRSEC report at the petitioner’s expense within two months, with the petitioner to obtain the KSRSEC report within two weeks and present the judgment before the RDO.
ITA Nos. 115/2019 and 174/2019 This is a Kerala High Court judgment in ITA Nos. 115 and 174 of 2019, arising from the Assessment Years 2013-14 and 2014-15, challenging the ITAT Cochin Bench orders dated 30-11-2018. The appellant is The Kerala State Homeopathic Co-operative Pharmacy Limited, represented by its managing director. The core issue is eligibility for deduction underSection 80P(2)(d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, in relation to interest income earned from the Aleppey District Co-operative Bank. The appellant contends that since the Aleppey bank is registered under the Banking Regulation Act and is a cooperative society, its interest income should be deductible under 80P(2)(d). The tribunal’s finding is criticized for not applying the ratio laid down in Mavilayi Service Co-operative Bank Ltd v. Commissioner of Income Tax and in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax v. Peroorkada Service Co-operative Bank Ltd, which the court treats as binding on the interpretation of 80P(2)(d) and the classification of income as business income or income from other sources. The court followed these authorities, stating that the questions must be decided in the assessee’s favour. Consequently, the Tribunal’s orders are set aside, and the matters are remitted to the Assessing Officer for fresh disposal in light of the cited jurisprudence.