This Execution Second Appeal arises from a dispute over the execution of a decree in O.S. No.91/2012 in the Munsiff Court, Perumbavoor, and E.P. No.19/2020. Muhammed, the plaintiff in the original suit, obtained a decree in 2015 fixing the northern boundary of a property described in the plaint schedule (old Sy.No. 442/1 and Re-Sy.No.86/5 in Block No.28, Arakkappady Village) and relying on plan Ext.C3(a). The appellant, Najeeb (son of Muhammed), filed E.A.117/2021 in E.P.No.19/2020, asserting that the property in dispute belonged to him by virtue of sale deed No.2728/2005 executed in his favor and that the decree’s execution could not affect his title. The Munsiff dismissed the claim petitions; the Sub Court dismissed the appeal; and the High Court concurred in upholding the dismissal. The central issue is whether the plaint schedule property (as described in the decree) is the appellant’s property or Muhammed’s, considering partition deeds (No.2527/1975) and exchange deed (No.2817/1979), which show Muhammed’s ownership to be broader and including the subject area. Relying on Nazir Mohamed, Kondiba Kadam, and related precedents, the court held that mere misdescription or misalignment of title cannot found a substantial question of law, and the appellate courts correctly concluded against the appellant. The matter reiterates that second appeals require a substantial question of law, and such questions must be strictly formulated and met. The appeal is meritless and is dismissed without admission.
The appellants, who are the dependants of Leejo G. Johnson (deceased), filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, for compensation following a fatal accident on 22 August 2007 on the Kaviyoor-Changanassery road when a lorry, insured with the third respondent and owned by the second respondent, allegedly collided with the deceased’s motorcycle KL-29/1399. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kottayam, granted Rs. 3,74,500 in compensation. The appellants challenged the quantum, contending higher entitlement based on well‑established Supreme Court guidelines for notional income, multiplier, future prospects, and conventional heads. The High Court re‑evaluated material evidence, holding the deceased’s notional monthly income at Rs.6,000 (rejecting abroad employment proof) and applying a multiplier of 18 (Sarla Verma). Future prospects were fixed at 40% with 50% deduction for personal living expenses (Pranay Sethi). Conventional heads were reconsidered: funeral expenses Rs.16,500, loss of estate Rs.16,500, loss of consortium Rs.44,000 each; loss of love and affection and pain and suffering were partially disallowed per New India Assurance v. Somwati and Satinder Kaur. The result was an enhanced total of Rs.10,30,700, with a further allowed enhancement of Rs.6,56,200 at 6% interest, to be deposited within 60 days and disbursed to the appellants in the ratio 40:40:20. The appeal is allowed in part.
This is a Kerala High Court revision petition under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, challenging an eviction order under Section 11(3) of the Act passed by the Rent Control Court and affirmed by the Rent Control Appellate Authority. The petitioner-tenant (Valsan) contends that the landlord (Raphy), who is abroad, has no bonafide need to start a bakery and that there are other vacant rooms in possession that could serve the business, making eviction unjustified and contrary to the second proviso to Section 11(3). The landlord seeks eviction to utilize the petition schedule shop and an adjoining room for a bakery, proposing to merge them into one unit. The Rent Control Court ordered eviction; the Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal. The High Court, in a Division Bench, upheld the findings of bonafide need and rejected the challenge to the factual findings, while clarifying that revisional power under Section 20 cannot function as an appellate re-appraisal of evidence. It granted six months’ time for surrender with conditions (affidavit, arrears deposit, and license compliance) and dismissed the revision petition. The order underscores that the landlord’s necessity and the tenant’s livelihood are weighed with deference to established revisional limits.
Cont.Case (C) No. 2500 of 2019 This Contempt of Court case (Cont.Case (C) No. 2500 of 2019) before the Kerala High Court concerns petitioners 3 and 41 in WP(C) No. 2410 of 2017, who filed a contempt petition under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, alleging willful disobedience of the High Court’s Annexure-1 judgment dated 12 October 2018 in WP(C) No. 2410/2017 and connected matters. The petition targets the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) for non-compliance with directions relating to pension benefits under the 1995 Pension Scheme, as amended by G.S.R. 609(E) (22 August 2014). The Supreme Court’s later decision in Sunil Kumar B. v. EPFO (2022) upheld the validity of the 2014 amendment and set out directions on pension-related relief, including extensions for exercise of options and transfer of funds for exempted establishments. The Kerala High Court, after hearing counsel, held that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by the EPFO in light of the 2022 Supreme Court judgment. The contempt petition is then closed, with a direction that the EPFO reconsider the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension in accordance with the apex court’s 2022 directions, leaving open the possibility of further remedies. The order thus reinforces compliance with law and preserves avenues for adjustment under the SC decision.
BAIL APPL. NO. 6259 OF 2024 On 2 August 2024, the Kerala High Court heard Bail Application No. 6259 of 2024 filed by Sajith Kumar M.V seeking release under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, in Crime No. 1630/2023 of Kadavanthra Police Station for offences 406 and 420 read with section 34 IPC. The petitioner claims false implication, innocence, and lack of material substantiating the charges. He had already been in judicial custody since 24.06.2024 and has spent about 47 days in custody; the investigation is practically complete with recovery effected. The prosecution alleges a common intention to seduce the complainant with a visa procurement promise and the payment of Rs. 6,00,000, of which only Rs. 1,00,000 was returned. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that there is no material to show commission of the offences; he argues non-utilization of the money, and that the applicant has been involved in other crimes but was bailed out earlier; thus, bail should be granted. The Public Prosecutor contends that the petitioner is a habitual offender with several cheating cases; bail could facilitate further offences. The court invokes Hussainara Khatoon I, Dataram Singh, and State v. Raneef to emphasize bail as a rule and detention as the exception, and ultimately grants bail subject to conditions, including bond, two sureties, regular appearance, non-interference, and potential cancellation for breach, while allowing police recoveries. It also cites Sushila Aggarwal regarding recoveries on bail.
WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & connected cases This judgment of a batch of writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court (Justice T.R.Ravi), concerns the freezing of bank accounts in the wake of cybercrime investigations. Petitioners, ordinary bank customers and corporate entities, challenged freezes imposed by police authorities and banks under the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal and RBI guidelines. On admission, the court issued interim directions restricting freezing to the amount indicated in police notices, and observed that indiscriminate or excessive freezing causes hardship and can impede legitimate business. The court noted the need to balance anti-crime measures with due process and proportionality. It relied on the principle laid down in Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661), and cited the earlier judgment in W.P.(C) 28155/2023, to support the approach of confining the freeze to the disputed amount and to require authorities to specify boundaries. The court directed that respondent banks confine the freeze to the notified amount and asked police to inform banks how long freezes should continue, within eight months from the date of the judgment. It further directed that if no information is received, petitioners may approach the court again with their case. The petitions were disposed of with these directions, while preserving liberty to seek further relief upon a change of circumstances.
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenges orders on a compounding application under the Kerala Value Added Tax (KVAT) regime for the Assessment Year 2014-15. Fashion Jewellers & Exporters, a two-branch business, paid compounded tax at 50% of the prior year’s liability with an additional 15% (i.e., 115%) thereof in monthly remittances. The 1st respondent fixed the 2014-15 compounded liability at Rs. 1,69,09,226, calculated as 115% of the 2013-14 compounded tax for the Chalakudy and Kollam branches. The petitioner contends that one branch (Kollam) was closed on 20.03.2014, and thus a proportionate reduction in tax from April 2014 onward is warranted. Reliance is placed on Explanation 3 of Section 8(f) KVAT Act 2003, as added by the Kerala Finance Act 2014, which provides a proportionate reduction in payments for the number of business places when a branch closes during the year. While a Single Judge had allowed such a petition, the Division Bench in Assistant Commissioner (KVAT) v. Kunnathukalathil Jewellers held that the 2014 amendment is not retroactive to the unamended provision, and that Explanation 3 applies only prospectively. Following that ruling, the petition was dismissed, with the court emphasizing that the amended explanations clarify the provision rather than back-casting to earlier years.
This High Court of Kerala, in a motor-accident claims appeal, revisits an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Mavelikkara, dated 24 August 2011 (O.P.(MV) No.328/2002). Buburaj, the injured appellant, challenges both the quantum of compensation and the Tribunal’s finding of 20% contributory negligence, contending that the incident involved rear-end impact by a KSRTC bus and that Ext.A4 mahazar cannot precisely locate the impact; the final investigation report (Ext.A3) attributes rash and negligent driving by the KSRTC vehicle. The Court accepts that the Tribunal’s reliance on Ext.A4 to declare the motorcycle on the wrong side is unwarranted, noting the collision occurred with a vehicle ahead moving in the same direction and that a mahazar does not pinpoint the exact hit location. Consequently, the court sets aside the 20% contributory negligence. On compensation, it applies the notional income principle from Ramachandrappa (2011) to determine notional earnings at Rs.3,500 per month (given 2001 accident), instead of the Tribunal’s figure, and recalculates heads such as loss of earnings, bystander expenses, transportation, extra nourishment, and pain and suffering. Pain and suffering is raised to Rs.30,000; transportation Rs.2,000; bystander expenses Rs.8,000; loss of earnings Rs.7,000; total compensation becomes Rs.78,100, with an enhanced amount of Rs.22,600. The insurer is to pay interest at 7.5% on the enhanced amount from the petition date, with adjustments for delay and NEFT details to be provided by the claimant.
This is a regular bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Sajil M, the fourth accused in Crime No. 777/2022 of Kondotty Police Station, Malappuram. The prosecution alleges that at about midnight on 28 September 2022, accused Nos. 1 to 5 were transporting 92.3 grams of MDMA in a car (KL-71-H-7859) and were apprehended with the contraband; accused Nos. 6 to 9 were later added on the theory of conspiracy. The petitioner argues that he is innocent and merely happened to be inside the car, with no knowledge of the contraband or participation in any conspiracy; he seeks regular bail. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, contending that the contraband constitutes a commercial quantity under the NDPS Act and that the accused including the petitioner were jointly involved, thus bringing Section 37 into play with its twin conditions. The court, after perusing the case diary and IO report, notes prima facie that 92.3 g of MDMA was seized while accused Nos. 1–5 were jointly transporting it, lending similar culpability to the petitioner. Given the commercial quantity, the court applies Section 37 and emphasizes the two required conditions: there must be reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty, and he will not commit any offence while on bail. On assessment, the court finds no basis to satisfy these conditions for the petitioner and dismisses the bail application.
WP(C) Nos.11306/2015 & con.cases; WP(C) No.19570/2016; WP(C) No.22445/2017; WP(C) No.10438/2020; WP(C) No.29160/2020; WP(C) No.20801/2021; Cont.Case No.1719/2021 This is a consolidated wage-petition judgment by the Kerala High Court concerning the Kerala Books and Publications Society (KBPS), a government-owned society, and the pension rights of its retired and in-service employees. The petitions trace the evolution from EPF and Pension Fund schemes to the Pension Regulations, 2014, and the Government actions that culminated in various GO orders aiming to implement a contributory pension scheme for KBPS employees. After years of dispute over funding, refunds from the Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) and the applicability of the KBPS Pension Regulations 2014, the Court examined whether pension is a right and not a mere bounty, relying on constitutional and Supreme Court precedents such as Nakara, Sudhir Chandra Sarkar, and State of Jharkhand on pension as a right or property. The Court noted that the pension fund is constituted under Regulations, with employer and employee contributions and government sanction, but that non-refund of EPF amounts cannot bar pension. The Judgment holds that retirees superannuated before 24.12.2019 are entitled to pension under the 2014 Regulations with full pension and arrears payable in four installments by 2023, and that those in service post-24.12.2019 will continue under EPF or NPS as applicable; in addition, the Contempt case (COC 1719/2021) is closed. The Court directs KBPS to raise funds from profits and revenue to satisfy arrears and ensure timely payment.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No. 7925 of 2022) filed under section 482 of the CrPC to quash Annexure-A3 complaint in C.C. No. 2522/2015 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners-accused Nos.1 and 3 are M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. and its authorised signatory Sheeja Sunny. The respondents are the State represented by the Public Prosecutor and Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. The core allegation concerns cheque No. 197078 for Rs. 3,42,000 issued by the second accused as a signatory of the first accused in connection with a channel carriage agreement. The cheque allegedly dishonoured on 08.09.2015, leading to a complaint under NI Act. The petition argues (A) the second petitioner is only an employee with no control over day-to-day affairs; (B) even if there existed a legally enforceable debt, the respondent’s loss was compensated by subsequent payments, evidenced by Annexure A4, including a discharge of liability through RTGS on 15.07.2016 totaling Rs.34.20 lakh; (C) substrate of the case no longer exists, so continued prosecution would be abuse of process. The second respondent disputes Annexure A4’s chart and asserts that the payments were not towards the charged cheque; it also notes several other NI Act cases and contends the petition is meritless. The learned Judge reiterates Nagawwa principles and other precedents, emphasizing that quashing is a narrow, exceptional remedy. Ultimately, the court dismisses the petition, holding the petitioners’ contentions untenable and denying relief under section 482 CrPC.
WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & con.cases This is a consolidated set of writ petitions under WP(C)10612/2024 and connected cases before a Single Judge (Justice T.R. Ravi) of the Kerala High Court. The petitions largely involve bank customers and financial institutions challenging freezing orders imposed by police cybercrime authorities and the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal in relation to online financial fraud investigations. The judgment notes that interim freezes should be confined to the amount specified in the police requisitions and directs respondent banks to restrict freezes to that limit, enabling petitioners to deal with funds beyond the frozen amount. It requires the police to inform banks about whether the freezing should continue, and mandates banks to implement freezes only to the extent directed, while leaving room to approach the court again if further information arises. The decision cites the principle that freezing should be proportionate to the amount in dispute and to avoid unduly depriving petitioners of access to legitimate funds, drawing on the doctrine established in Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KLT Online 2111) to justify the targeted freezing approach. The petitions are disposed of with directions to confine freezes to specified amounts, to coordinate information with banks, and to preserve the petitioners’ ability to challenge or seek further relief as needed. The order also references prior related orders and ensures eight months’ horizon for possible continuation, if information exists.
WP(C) Nos. 32408/2023; 23185/2022; 30377/2022; 30383/2022; 32074/2022; 33099/2022 This batch of writ petitions before the Kerala High Court challenges the levy of interest on turnover tax (ToT) on parcel sale of Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) during the COVID-19 lockdown period (22.05.2020–21.12.2020 and 15.06.2021–25.09.2021). The petitioners are bar-attached hotels and hotel-licensed licensees who were permitted to sell IMFL in parcel form during the emergency, under Government Orders (Ext.P1) but without a fixed rate of ToT for parcel sales. The Government later issued SRO 297/2022 (26.03.2022) fixing the ToT at 5% for parcel sales, while Ext.P2 clarified the rate. The petitioners contended that, due to the lack of a prescribed rate before 26.03.2022 and portal/system constraints, they could not file returns or remit ToT correctly; some paid at 10% or with delays. The State argued that the ToT rate of 5% was fixed by Ext.P2 and that the Amnesty/Budget announcements do not abrogate statutory liability. The court held that, in the absence of a pre-26.03.2022 rate, the levy was not valid and that interest could be quashed; it remitted the cases for fresh assessments under guidance (i) where returns were filed by 31.03.2022 and ToT paid by 30.04.2022, no interest; (ii) otherwise, interest from 01.05.2022. The petitions are allowed with remand and quashing of impugned orders.
Neenut, wife of the detenu Kalesh, challenges detention under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act (KAAPA), 2007. The detention order Ext.P1 was issued on 26.03.2024 and executed on 28.03.2024. The primary issue is whether the order of detention and its confirmation complied with the three-month limit from the date of detention. The petitioner relies on Deb Sadhan Roy (supra) and Malathy Ravi (supra), which hold that if the Board’s confirmation is not provided within three months from detention, the detention becomes illegal. The Government contends that the confirmation was issued on 17.07.2024. The court examines KAAPA Sections 3(3), 9 and 10, and Article 22 of the Constitution. Section 3(3) requires reporting to Government and DG of Police with records within a short period; Section 9 requires the Advisory Board to be informed of grounds and representations within three weeks; Section 10 empowers the Government to confirm detention based on the Board’s opinion. Article 22(4) imposes a three-month ceiling on preventive detention unless the Board reports sufficient cause and Parliament’s law allows longer detention. The court cites Deb Sadhan Roy and Malathy Ravi to insist that detention cannot extend beyond three months without timely confirmation. In this case, Ext.P2 (17.07.2024) falls beyond three months, leading to the conclusion that the continued detention is illegal. The writ petition is allowed, directing release of Kalesh forthwith if not required in another case, with communications to the Central Prison, Viyyur.
CRL.M.C. No. 8189 of 2023 This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC, challenging the continuation of criminal proceedings in S.C.No.861/2019 (Thrissur) arising from Thrissur West P.S. Crime No.523/2018. Eight petitioners/accused—Sourav Raj, Adithyan K M, Amal Krishna V S, Dheejith P D, Vishak K K, Gauthyam Raj, Hemanth K H and Ajhishek P V—are charged with offences under sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 325 and 308 read with 149 IPC. The prosecution claims they formed an unlawful assembly and assaulted the victims. The petitioners contend the dispute has been settled and affidavits filed by victims show no objection to quashing. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on settlement, though the matter is settled. Relying on State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) and the law in Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, the court recalls that CrPC 482 can quash non‑compoundable offences in private disputes if the entire dispute is resolved and public interest is not affected, while not permitting quashing for heinous offences or certain statutes. The court finds the dispute private and the settlement acceptable, and thus quashes further proceedings in S.C.No.861/2019, ending the case.
This bail application, B.A.No.9395/23, arises from Crime No.1255/2020 of Anthikkad Police Station, Thrissur, in which accused Nos.1 to 6 are said to have conspired to kill the brother of the de facto complainant; the seventh accused (the petitioner) is sought to be released on regular bail. The prosecution contends that the offences include 341, 302, 392, and 506 r/w 34 IPC; the petitioner was arrested on 20.10.2020 and has remained in custody for over three years. The matter had seen earlier bail applications rejected. The petitioner’s counsel submits that there is no specific overt act attributed to him and that several co-accused have already obtained bail; he also asserts willingness to cooperate with trial and to comply with stringent conditions. The Public Prosecutor counters by highlighting the accused’s eight criminal antecedents and the likelihood of delay in trial if released. The magistrate notes both sides’ submissions and cites Supreme Court authority on the right to liberty and speedy trial, including Union of India v. Najeeb and the 1994 Supreme Court Legal Aid Committee decision, as well as Prabhakar Tewari and Sanjay Chandra. Finding that prolonged incarceration without trial undermines liberty and that timely trial may still be possible, the court grants bail on strict conditions, including bond, two sureties, appearance, no witness tampering, no further offences, and travel restrictions.
This appeal arises from an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Palakkad in OP(MV) No.1588/2018, arising out of a motor accident on 07.02.2018 in which Ramakrishnan died following injuries sustained while travelling in an autorickshaw (KL-49-B-2416) hit by a lorry (KL09-AC-8824). The petitioners, seven legal representatives of the deceased, sought compensation of Rs. 15,00,000, challenging the Tribunal’s quantum and the allocation of fault. The Tribunal held the lorry driver negligent and awarded Rs. 6,18,500 with interest at 8% p.a. and costs. The 3rd respondent insurer admitted the policy but contested negligence attribution and the quantum. On appeal, the appellants argue that the monthly income (Rs. 11,500) and the dependency deduction (1/3) were misapplied, and that, under Pranay Sethi and related jurisprudence, the conventional heads deserve higher compensation; they also urge applying the Sarla Verma multiplier (7) rather than 3 and that 10% increments for loss of estate, funeral expenses, and loss of consortium are warranted. The respondents contend negligence of the autorickshaw driver, not the lorry, and that the Tribunal’s award was reasonable. The High Court ultimately recalculates the compensation, modifies the multiplier to 7, applies 1/4 deduction, and grants additional awards, leading to a total enhanced benefit to the appellants with interest.
The petition challenges Ext.P13, an order of the District Telecom Committee (DTC) granting permission to Summit Digital Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. (7th respondent) to install a mobile telecommunication tower on property belonging to the 8th respondent, within Karumalloer Grama Panchayat, Ernakulam district. Petitioners, residents of Ward No.3, contend that the proposed site is near their homes and an Anganwadi; the tower’s proximity, height difference between properties, and land conditions (muddy, saline, at risk of erosion or landslide) raise safety, environmental and public health concerns. They argue the stability certificate Ext.P3 lacks Foundation details and that the site may be rust-prone due to saline water. They allege violation of the Kerala Coastal Zone Management Act and question the adequacy of the District Telecom Committee’s hearing, noting expert presence and the sufficiency of Ext.P10 subsoil report. Public grievances were entertained earlier via Ext.P6/7 and a prior court direction in W.P.(C) 25103/2021; Ext.P9 refers to that outcome. The respondents counter that permit was issued under the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules, EMF certificate (Ext.R7(d)) confirms radiation compliance, and that DTC function is advisory, with remedies before statutory bodies. The court ultimately holds Ext.P13 inconsistent with law and sets it aside, directing a fresh decision after proper hearing within a month.
W.A.No.1827/2022; W.A.No.1936/2022; W.A.No.1950/2022 This common judgment of a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court disposes of three writ appeals challenging the Airports Authority of India (AAI) employees’ Medical Attendance and Treatment scheme. The 2003 Regulations define key terms (Employee, Family, Medical Attendance, Treatment) and set conditions for dependency, along with restrictions on reimbursement (e.g., no reimbursement for diet, conveyance, or attendants). The core issue is whether two employed spouses can separately claim medical reimbursement for themselves and dependents under the same AAI scheme, or whether spouses must be treated as a single unit to prevent duplication of benefits. The case traces prior litigation: Ext.P2 (notification) restricted duplicate claims; Ext.P3 advised recovery of duplicate payments; Ext.P4/Judgment (Single Judge) found Ext.P2 could not enable both spouses to claim; the Division Bench later read down that policy to prevent duplication, but the Supreme Court dismissed the SLP. In 2019, AAI issued Ext.P9 and Ext.P11, offering two schemes (A and B) under a revised medical policy; the petitions argued this reintroduced duplication contrary to the 2003 Regulations. The High Court ultimately holds that the 2003 Regulations contemplate treating husband and wife employees as a single unit for medical reimbursement. Ext.P11 circulars reintroducing dual claims and recovery of duplicate payments are impermissible to the extent they undermine this framework. The appeals are dismissed, upholding the Single Judge’s reasoning and the principle that there cannot be arbitrary discrimination or duplication of claims based on marriage.
This writ petition, filed by the State of Kerala through its Special Secretary, General Education Department, challenges a Kerala Lok Ayukta order dated 19.03.2014 in Complaint No. 885 of 2013. The Lok Ayukta directed the Government to pay damages by way of interest on gratuity (DCRG) at 10% per annum for the period 13.01.2013 to 13.06.2013 and to fix liability for the delay, with recovery from the officers responsible for the delay in issuing the NLC. The petitioner contends the Government was not a party to the complaint and that delay attributed to a Head Master/AEO should be disregarded since gratuity was disbursed within a satisfactory period; more so, the Lok Ayukta exceeded its jurisdiction by directing the Government to bear damages for a matter not solely within its control. The Government argues gratuity was paid within one year of retirement and there is no statutory basis to award interest; a decision against a non‑party would set an unconstitutional precedent. The court, after analyzing the facts, finds delay in disbursement but holds no jurisdictional error in the Lok Ayukta’s order; accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed and the Lok Ayukta’s order is sustained, with a direction to pay interest within two months, guided by longstanding jurisprudence on jurisdictional facts and judicial review.