This Regular Second Appeal (R.S.A. No.850 of 2016) before the Kerala High Court arises from a suit for injunction regarding the alleged obstruction to the removal of earth from the plaint schedule property and the level of that property vis-à-vis adjacent lands. The plaintiff, Asokan, contends that the defendants excavated soil from their properties, leaving portions of his property at a higher level and requiring lowering for construction of a boundary wall and safeguarding his land. The defendants counter-claimed that removing soil would deprive their lands of lateral support and invoked agreements (Exts. B3 and B4) and their natural right to lateral support. They also referred to a prior suit (O.S.1 of 2007) dismissed for default. The trial courts rejected both the injunction and the counter-claim, and the appellate court affirmed. On admission of substantial questions of law, the court examined whether removal of soil after suit would affect lateral support, citing Kalyani v. Bhaskaran for the principle that a neighbor’s lateral support rights depend on keeping land in its natural state. Ultimately, the court allowed the Second Appeal, restraining obstruction to excavation only up to the level of the defendants’ properties and subject to statutory and executive restrictions, clarifying that this is not an unconditional permission to excavate.
This Kerala High Court judgment in MACA No. 803 of 2012 revisits a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal award under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The appellant-deceased’s legal heirs challenge the Tribunal’s quantum of compensation awarded to the petitioner (the original claimant) for injuries sustained in a road accident on 22.10.2009. The Tribunal allowed part of the petition, awarding Rs. 2,22,300 against the insurer who admitted coverage but contested some facts; the car’s owner did not contest. The court notes the claimant’s income as a businessman but fixes a notional monthly income of Rs.3,000 for lack of materials, leading to a lower assessment. On appeal, the High Court reassesses the evidence and applies judicial precedents to re-calculate the award. Notable principles invoked include Ramachandrappa (notional income), Sarla Varma (multiplier 14), Raj Kumar (functional disability at 24%), Nagappa and Rajesh (enhancement authority), and Raj Kumar’s related guidance. The court fixes the notional income at Rs.7,000 per month for 2009, increases loss of earnings, disability compensation, and bystander/extra nourishment and pain and suffering components. The final enhancement totals Rs.4,45,040. The insurer is directed to deposit the enhanced amount, to be disbursed 50:50 to the legal heirs after liability adjustments. The appeal is allowed in part with enhanced compensation and costs.
This Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case (Cr. M.C. No. 5141 of 2023) concerns a petition under Section 482 CrPC to quash Crime No. 31 of 2002 of Kilimanoor Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners—nine accused named Sivaprasad, Siddique, Ajayakumar, Mahin, Nazeer, Ribu (Ribu Kochu Cherukkan), Aji, Vijayakumaar (Vijayakumaar Kutttan) and Sumod—were charged under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 365, 324, 323, 368, 387 and 357 read with Section 149 IPC, in relation to abducting the informant’s son on 04-02-2002 and keeping him in illegal confinement. The petition seeks quashing on the basis of amicable settlement, supported by an affidavit from the 3rd respondent, K. Santhosh, the informant’s son. The State, represented by the Public Prosecutor, expresses reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement, noting the seriousness of the offences and public interest, though it concedes no other crimes are pending against the petitioners. The Court cites State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan, Gian Singh, and Narinder Singh to frame the settled-law framework for exercising 482 CrPC in non‑compoundable offences when disputes are resolved. The Court ultimately holds that where the dispute is private, the offences are non‑compoundable but not heinous or grave, and where the settlement is genuine and complete, quashing would not harm society. It proceeds to quash the FIR and all further proceedings, stating that it serves ends of justice and conserves judicial resources.
Jayasree S.T., owner in possession of about 7.82 acres of land in Re-survey Nos. 18/3 and 18/4 in Manacaud village, Thiruvananthapuram, seeks police protection under a writ petition (WP(C) No. 25772 of 2022) to ensure peaceful enjoyment of the plaint schedule property. She asserts title through Ext. P1 partition deed and possession evidenced by Ext. P2 possession certificate and Ext. P3 land tax receipt. The petitioner claims that after a civil decree in O.S. No. 524/2022 decreed on 22 July 2022, some outsiders installed unauthorised bunk shops on the public road in front of the petitioner’s property. She contends that the 4th respondent (Attukal Bhagavathy Temple Trust) is attempting to encroach or erect a temporary shed for ambulance parking within the property in possession of the petitioner. The petitioner seeks mandamus-like directions to respondents 1-3 to provide police protection and to act on Exhibits P6 and P7 complaints dated 09/08/2022. The 4th respondent counters that the 0.74 acres claimed by the petitioner is part of land sold under Ext. R4(a) to the Trust and that the suit O.S. 524/2022 is collusive; hence, rights over the property are disputed and police protection cannot decide civil rights. The court ultimately dismisses the petition, holding that the very identity and extent of the property are in dispute and police protection cannot resolve civil disputes, leaving the petitioner free to pursue civil remedies.
The petitioners, six accused in Crime No. 905/2023 of Kottiyam Police Station, seek quashing of the criminal proceedings under Section 482 CrPC on the basis of an amicable settlement with the de facto complainant. The FIR charges include offences under multiple IPC provisions (294(b), 323, 324, 341, 394, 427, 506 read with 34) and offences under Section 320 CrPC, with the possibility of additional references to Section 307 IPC and the Arms Act. The prosecution, while acknowledging the settlement, contends that quashing solely on that basis may not be warranted given the nature of offences; however, it is also indicated that there are no other serious crimes against the accused. The court, after assessing the gravity of the alleged injuries, the accuseds’ antecedents, and the amicable settlement, cites State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and the subsequent law laid down in Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, to delineate the parameters for using its inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC to quash non-compoundable offences where the dispute is private and settlement has been achieved. The judge finds that quashing would not adversely affect society and would serve the ends of justice, especially where ongoing prosecution would be a waste of time. Hence, the petition is allowed, FIR Annexure-A1 and all further proceedings are quashed.
This Regular First Appeal (RFA No.850 of 2013) arises from a suit for partition (OS 520/2007) filed in the Sub Court, Alappuzha, by the plaintiff (son of Muhammed Yafi) against Abdul Khadar Yafi’s heirs and others, including Abdullah Yafi’s successors. Abdul Khadar Yafi had two sons: Muhammed Yafi and Abdullah Yafi; after his demise, Ext.A3 partition deed allocated one half to Abdullah Yafi (with improvements) and the other half to Muhammed Yafi. The plaintiff seeks metes-and-bounds partition of the property, contending joint possession by all co-owners. The respondents-23rd defendant (appellant) contested, arguing tenancy rights under the Kerala Land Reforms Act and that the landlord’s title vested with the Government; thus no subsisting right in the plaintiff. The trial court originally decreed in the plaintiff’s favor. On appeal, this Court (in 2011) remanded for consideration of tenancy and referred the matter to the Land Tribunal under Section 125(3) KLR Act. The Land Tribunal negatived tenancy; the trial court, accepting this, decreed in favor of the plaintiff. The 23rd defendant appeals, arguing that tenancy and Land Reforms benefits should apply. The court ultimately holds that Ext.B1 (1120 ME) lease is valid but did not survive Ext.A8 (1951) compromise; tenancy under Land Reforms Act is not available to the defendants, and joint possession remains in law for co-owners. The appeal is dismissed; the decree of the trial court stands, and the suit for partition under Section 37(2) of the Court Fees Act is proper.
This writ petition, WP(C) No.17968 of 2019, filed in the Kerala High Court, challenges the absorption and related orders concerning the petitioner’s status after his deployment to the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006. The petitioner, a Junior Inspecting Officer in the Central Government since 2000, contends that Ext. P7 (issued 26.3.2012) invited options for absorption into the FSSAI or repatriation to the parent department under Section 90 of the Act and that the absorption date and pension terms were ambiguous and not in accord with Section 90 and CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 (Rule 37-A). He sought quashing of Exhibits P7, P12, P13, P18, P19, P22 and a mandamus to revert him to the FSSAI with all consequential benefits. The 3rd respondent contends that Section 90 merely prescribes tenure and terms for those absorbed, does not fix a six-month deadline, and that Ext. P7 was complied with by the petitioner, who later opted to be repatriated and joined the IT Department in 2016. Calcutta High Court’s interim stay on related issues is noted but not binding here. On facts, the court held the challenge belated and lacking, and dismissed the petition, observing that Ext. P7 was in terms of Section 90 and was acted upon by the petitioner.
WA NO. 1481 OF 2015; connected cases WA 1481/2015, CO 136/2015, CO 180/2015, WA 1480/2015, WA 1515/2015, WA 1538/2015 This batch of writ appeals and cross-objections arises from a common dispute over the retirement age of employees of the Kerala State Beverages (M&M) Corporation. The Beverages Corporation had rules fixing retirement at 55 under Rule 43 of its Employees Service Rules 1986. In 2005, the Board resolved to raise retirement age to 58, aligning with public sector norms, but the State Government rejected this proposal (GO 409/2005). A prior common judgment dated 15.03.2007 granted declaratory relief to extend retirement to 58; the Supreme Court stayed that order in 2007, and later government action led to a 2011 GO accepting the extension for EPF-covered employees. The present judgment affirms that the declaratory relief is effectively in rem, extending to all similarly situated employees, and that the Beverages Corporation cannot deny relief to others merely on the grounds of being late to court, while acknowledging exceptions for laches/delays. The bench holds that Article 14 guarantees equality and that the retirees are entitled to the relief previously granted, including extension to 58 and related pension provisions. Cross-objections seeking full back wages are limited to 50% as determined by the trial court. The appeals and cross-objections are dismissed accordingly, with the retirees receiving the declared benefits.
Petitioners Jobimol Abraham and Bobby, borrowers of two loans from Federal Bank Ltd, approached this Court seeking relief under Article 226 of the Constitution, not to contest the bank’s claims but to obtain accommodation to repay the liability in installments. The petition admits liability for a term loan and a cash credit facility but contends that immediate demand and strict enforcement would cause undue hardship. The Bank contends that the borrowers are chronic defaulters and that the entire outstanding amount as of January 4, 2023, stood at Rs 25,77,422, with no room for indulgence beyond a plan that requires full payment by March 31, 2023. After hearing both sides, the Kerala High Court held that some indulgence could be granted to clear the entire liability in installments, invoking the principle articulated in Sundaram BNP Paribas Home Finance Ltd. v. Nisha that where liability is not disputed relief may be granted in instalments, subject to conditions and without staying SARFAESI proceedings. The judge directed repayment of Rs 25,77,422 in ten equated monthly installments, beginning January 31, 2023, with installments due on the last working day of each month, and allowed the bank to proceed in case of any default, while keeping coercive measures in abeyance. The order makes clear that the One Time Settlement option remains available. The decision reconciles borrower relief with secured lending under SARFAESI and constitutional jurisdiction.
This High Court of Kerala (Ernakulam) decision, rendered on 04 January 2023, concerns O.P.(FC) No.3 of 2023 filed by Sowmya Beegum challenging a Family Court Nedumangad order (dated 24 December 2022) in O.P(GW) No.1171 of 2021. The respondent father Shameer sought a decree declaring himself the legal guardian of his two minor children, Shana Al Shami (8) and Shahan Al Shami (7), and interim custody. The Family Court, after hearing, partly allowed the interim custody petition, directing a 15-day split custody each month (child custody alternating within each month) while the mother challenged the order under Article 227 of the Constitution. The court proceedings note both parents have remarried, and the court considered the welfare of the children, school-going routines, and the need for the children to have contact with both parents. The judgment cites Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan (2020) 3 SCC 67 and Vasudha Sethi v. Kiran V. Bhaskar (AIR 2022 SC 476) to emphasize that the welfare principle is paramount and that visitation rights should be provided to the non-custodial parent to preserve the child’s relationship with both parents. The High Court ultimately modifies the impugned order, granting the respondent weekend custody (alternate Saturdays and Sundays) starting 07 January 2023, with defined pickup/drop times, and leaves scope for modification after two months. The petition is disposed of with directions.
This Regular Second Appeal (RSA 273/2020) challenges the first appellate court’s dismissal of the appeal on a delay-condonation issue and the underlying suit for return of advance money in relation to an agreement to sell the schedule property. On 26.06.2013, Haridas agreed to sell the property to Binoj Mathew for Rs 23,00,000 and received Rs 2,50,000 as advance. The defendant was to produce the original title deeds by 30.06.2013, but could not; he allegedly learned that he had obtained a Rs 10,00,000 loan from Kidangoor Service Co-operative Bank by executing a ‘Gahan’. He later promised to repay the Rs 2,50,000 with Rs 25,000 as compensation by 05.07.2013, but failed to do so. The plaintiff instituted a suit for return of the advance; the trial court decreed Rs 2,50,000 with 6% interest and refused Rs 25,000 for damages due to non-execution. On appeal, the first appellate court dismissed the delay-condonation petition (265 days) and the appeal on merit. The High Court, upholding the first appellate court’s approach, held that the delay was not sufficiently explained and that the evidence supported the finding that the agreement was executed. It cites authorities on condonation of delay and the restricted scope of second appeals, ultimately dismissing the RSA for lack of merit with no costs.
This intra-court appeal arises from a dispute over pensionary benefits for staff of Athurasramam NSS Homeopathic Medical College in Changanassery. The petitioner, Dr. K.N. Balakrishnan Nair, a professor who retired in 1995, challenged Ext.P9, a government order denying him pension on the ground that Direct Payment System (DPS) would count service only from the date of government action for pension calculations, not from before DPS or affiliation. While other colleges (Vaidyaratnam Ayurveda College and Ollur) were allowed to count prior service under DPS-like arrangements, Homeo College staff were treated differently, igniting Article 14 challenges on the basis of equal treatment. The writ petitions traced a history of the DPS implementation, a 1995 agreement (the DPS agreement) with Clauses 18–20, and government orders granting pension in other institutions. The learned Single Judge had directed reconsideration, and the government later passed Ext.P9 denying relief. The High Court here emphasizes that granting benefits under a wrong order would perpetuate illegality and erode taxpayers’ funds. Noting that two wrongs cannot make a right, the court allowed the appeal, set aside Ext.P9, and directed reconsideration of cases after hearing all affected parties, while ensuring no recovery of already paid amounts and preventing extension of the wrongs to similarly placed employees.
This is Bail Application (B.A. No. 1183/2024) by Alif Khan, the sole accused in Crime No. 7/2023 of the Devikulam Excise Range, Idukki, under Sections 20(b)(ii)(A) and 22(c) of the NDPS Act. The petition seeks regular bail under Section 439 CrPC, following three earlier bail petitions (Nos. 1043/2023, 6995/2023, 9904/2024) that were dismissed. The prosecution alleges possession of 7 grams of dry ganja and 0.126 gram of LSD (7 stamps) allegedly recovered while the accused was transporting contraband, rendering the case a “commercial quantity” NDPS offence. The core legal issue is whether bail can be granted in the face of Section 37 NDPS rider, which requires two conjunctive conditions: (i) reasonable grounds for believing the accused is not guilty, and (ii) the accused will not commit any offence while on bail. The court traces the meaning of “reasonable grounds” to Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari (2007) and cites numerous precedents when applying the rider. It notes conflicting decisions (Fasil v. State of Kerala; Jijendran CM v. State of Kerala) and later authority (Vijay Madanlal Chaudhary; Muhammad Kaiz) holding that length of custody is not persuasive to dilute the rider. The judge ultimately finds no satisfaction of the twin ingredients and dismisses the bail petition, while directing adherence to Chaudhary’s ratio over Fasil/Jijendran in future cases.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC arises from CC 600/2016 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court – I, Aluva, in connection with Crime No.278/2016 of Chengamanad Police Station. The petitioners — Arun, Amal, Ananthu and Vishnu — are prosecuted for offences under sections 143, 147, 447, 341, 294(b) and 323 read with 149 IPC, alleged to have formed an unlawful assembly, wrongfully confined the victim, and assaulted while using filthy language. The petition contends that the dispute between the parties is private and has been settled; victims have filed affidavits stating their no-objection to quashing and the prosecution. The Public Prosecutor, while reservations exist about quashing solely on the basis of a settlement, concedes that the matter is settled. The High Court places reliance on Supreme Court dicta, notably State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan (2019 (5) SCC 688) and the earlier Gian Singh and Narinder Singh decisions, to examine when Section 482 CrPC powers may be exercised to quash non‑compoundable offences in private disputes where the entire dispute has been resolved, provided the offences are not heinous or otherwise excluded. After scrutiny, the court finds the dispute private, the settlement genuine, and the public-interest concerns not offended, and therefore allows the petition and quashes further proceedings in CC 600/2016 against the petitioners. The order emphasizes the private civil character of the dispute and the admissibility of settlement in appropriate cases of quashing under inherent powers.
BA Nos. 7913, 7981, 8006, 8059, 8203, 8239, 8606, 8754 & 8763 of 2022 These consolidated bail petitions arise from two crime numbers involving Sri Lankan refugees/foreign nationals apprehended for alleged trafficking-related offences and illegal immigration. The High Court, presided by Justice Viju Abraham, dealt with eight bail applications filed on behalf of refugees and foreign nationals awaiting adjudication, and connected matters arising from two police stations (Pallithottam and East Kollam). The court reviewed interim bail orders issued in Oct–Nov 2022 directing the petitioners to remain in open detention or transit facilities given the sensitive refugee status and ongoing investigations. It also considered proposals to repatriate petitioners to refugee camps in Tamil Nadu and to place some in transit homes (e.g., Gandhi Bhavan Trust, Pathanapuram) with educational provisions for children, healthcare, and police surveillance. The court sought instructions from state/central authorities and Tamil Nadu authorities on detention centers and cadges for refugees. Ultimately, it disposed of the bail applications with directions to implement interim bail conditions, to ensure detention/transit arrangements, and to facilitate education and healthcare for the petitioners’ dependents, while directing final reports and speedy trial timelines.
This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 4151 of 2023) under Section 482 CrPC filed by the petitioners, Ashraf Mukkatt, T. K. Nasar, and Moyyilkareem, challenging proceedings in Crime No. 713 of 2022 (Koyilandy Police Station, Kozhikode District). The petitioners are accused of offences punishable under Sections 447, 427 and 153 read with Section 34 IPC for trespassing and damaging a stone plaque at Edu Village on 30.10.2022. The petition relies on a settlement between the parties (Annexure-2) and contends that continuing prosecution is unwarranted, serving only disruption and a waste of resources. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations but acknowledged absence of other serious crimes against the petitioners and that the victim does not harbor lasting grievances. The court cites a series of Supreme Court decisions (Gian Singh; Narinder Singh; Laxmi Narayan; Deepak; Manish; Ramesh Kamath; Rajveer Singh; Parbatbhai Aahir; Kalyan Singh; Dhruv Gurjar) to articulate the principle that Section 482 CrPC can quash non‑compoundable offences with private/settled disputes, subject to carve-outs for heinous offences and certain statutes. After weighing gravity of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and the amicable disposition, the High Court holds that quashing would advance ends of justice and accordingly allows the petition, quashing the FIR and all further proceedings.
This is a bail application (BA 5157/22) filed under Section 438 Cr.P.C. by Niyas M, the sole accused in Crime No. 1097/2021 of Ramapuram Police Station, Kottayam, involving offences under IPC 354A(1)(ii)(iv), 354A(2), 354A(3); POCSO Act, 2012, Sec. 12 read with Sec. 11(ii)(iv); and Sec. 67B(b) of the IT Act. The applicant, aged 27, contends he went to Dubai on 4.4.2021 for employment and the crime was registered on 27.9.2021, after his departure; Look Out Circular was issued, and the investigation has since concluded with a final report and charge-sheet (10.11.2021). He asserts absence of mala fide intent to evade due process, and undertakes full cooperation with authorities, including surrender of his passport and appearance before the police and PoCSO Court, if bail is granted. The State opposes bail on the ground of a serious offence profile and potential flight risk, though the LOC and travel restrictions are considered. The matter culminates a reference by a Single Judge to a Division Bench on whether an abroad-accused can maintain anticipatory bail under Sec. 438; interim bail was granted (10.10.2022) in this and related matters. The Division Bench ultimately held, relying on Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia, Sushila Aggarwal, and related cases, that Sec. 438 bail is maintainable for abroad-accused, and made the interim bail absolute with conditions, disposing of the main petition. The final order emphasizes access to justice, fundamental rights, and the distinction between jurisdiction and its exercise.
This Regular Second Appeal, filed under Section 100 read with Order XLI, Rule 1 CPC, challenges the Sub Court, Sulthan Bathery’s decree in O.S.293 of 2007, which sought a decree of redemption in a suit concerning a plaint schedule shop room. Ext.A1 is described in the pleadings as a mortgage deed, executed on 31.12.1979, entrusting possession of the shop room to the defendant/appellant in exchange for a lump sum and monthly payments characterized as a share of profits with redemption rights for the landlord. The trial court found Ext.A1 to be a mortgage and, since the suit was within limitation, granted redemption in favor of the plaintiff-respondents. On appeal, the first appellate court upheld the decree, and the defendants challenged this finding in the High Court. The central issues are: (i) the appellate court’s power to admit additional evidence under Order XLI, Rule 27, when due diligence could not locate documents earlier; and (ii) whether Ext.A1 constitutes a lease or a mortgage, considering the predominant intention of the parties as inferred from recitals, terms, surrounding circumstances, and conduct. The High Court relies on established precedents to hold that the transaction described in Ext.A1 is a mortgage rather than a lease, rejects the late-produced rent receipts as evidence, and ultimately dismisses the appeal. It also directs possession surrender within three months from the date of judgment.
The High Court of Kerala, in a Criminal Misc. Case (CRL.MC 4820 of 2023) arising from an FIR registered at Aranmula Police Station and cognizable as CC 862/2020 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Pathanamthitta, examines whether to quash proceedings under Section 482 CrPC in light of a settlement between the parties. The petitioners—Sameer, Abinu, and Godwin—are accused of offences under Sections 341, 323, 324 read with 34 IPC. The State, represented by the Public Prosecutor, and the private respondents submitted that the parties have amicably settled, with respondents 2–5 supporting quashing the case to restore peace and avoid protracted litigation. While acknowledging reservation to terminate proceedings solely on settlement, the Court surveys jurisprudence including State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, as well as Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, to articulate the governing principle: Section 482 CrPC may be invoked to quash non‑compoundable offences with predominantly civil character when the entire dispute is settled between the parties, especially where the offences are private in nature and do not gravely affect society. It cautions against quashing for grave offences (e.g., murder, rape, dacoity) or for offences under special statutes. After weighing factors such as gravity of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and the parties’ amicable settlement, the court concludes that quashing would not adversely affect society and would serve ends of justice. Accordingly, the petition is allowed and the final report and proceedings in CC 862/2020 are quashed, bringing the matter to an end.
MFA (ECC) No. 76 of 2020; ECC 116/2017 This appeal under Section 30 of the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923, arises from an order of the Employees' Compensation Commissioner, Kozhikode, awarding compensation to Abdul Razaque O.V., a loading–unloading worker who sustained injuries while loading a coconut tree into a tipper lorry KL-56/6300 on 8 October 2015. The insurer, United India Insurance Co. Ltd., has challenged the award contending that the policy does not cover loading/unloading workers in a goods vehicle and that the claimant was neither the vehicle driver, conductor nor cleaner. The Commissioner had ordered payment of Rs. 1,04,000 plus 12% interest from 8 October 2017 and treatment expenses of Rs. 2,55,962. The appellant relies on the first proviso to Section 147(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, Clause (c), arguing that even for a stationary vehicle, only certain categories of employees are covered and that a loading/unloading worker does not fall within this clause unless he is carried in the vehicle as a passenger. The respondents contend that Clause (c) of the proviso includes ‘any person carried on a goods carriage’ and thus covers loading/unloading workers. The court surveys several precedents, holding that the coverage extends to loading/unloading workers, especially where loading/unloading is integral to the vehicle’s purpose, and ultimately upholds the Tribunal’s interpretation and dismisses the appeal.