Zeenath & Others v. K.P. Ahamed & Others

Case Details & Bench

Court: High Court of Kerala
Hon'ble Judges: Shircy V.
Judgment Date: 2022-02-01
Court Decision / Holding: Appeal disposed of in terms of the settlement agreement; the settlement is incorporated into the decree; court fee to be refunded as per rules.
Final Disposition: Disposed of by mediation; settlement between parties; settlement to form part of the decree; court to refund court fee.

Parties to the Case

Appellants / Petitioners

K. P Ahamed

Respondents

K. P. Abdul Lakoya
K. P Kasim
K. P Safiya
K. P Akbar
K. P Pathibi
K. P Laila
K. P Ashraf
Zeenath
Selma K.P
Ajmal K.P

Legal Representation & Advocates

Counsels for Petitioners

• Sri V. V. Surendra
• Sri P. A. Harish

Counsels for Respondents

• Sri Philip Antony
• Sri P. M. Sebastian

Case Synopsis & Summary

This Regular First Appeal (RFA No. 595/2013) arises from O.S. No. 572 of 2009 before the 2nd Additional Sub Court, Kozhikode. The appellant/plaintiff, K. P. Ahamed, challenged the judgment and decree of the trial court. During the course of hearing, the matter was referred to mediation by the District Mediation Centre, Kozhikode. The mediator submitted a report dated 24 January 2022 detailing a settlement reached between Zeenath and others (the petitioners) and K. P. Ahamed and others (the respondents). The mediation achieved a final agreement, with terms incorporated in the report; the settlement was accepted by the High Court. The High Court, after considering the mediator’s report and terms, disposed of the appeal accordingly. The court directed that the court fee be refunded as per rules, and held that the settlement agreement would form part of the decree. The document also records that the legal heirs of a deceased respondent were impleaded as Additional Respondents by an order dated 10 February 2022 in RFA 595/13. The judgment is delivered by Hon. Shircy V., a Single Judge. The result is a consensual resolution, with no further adjudication on merits.

Provisions of Law Cited

Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC)Code of Civil Procedure (ADR) Rules 2008

Submissions & Arguments

Contentions of Appellants / Petitioners

No substantive arguments are recorded in the judgment; the dispute was referred to mediation and resolved by the mediator's report dated 24 January 2022. The appeal is disposed of in terms of the settlement reached, with terms to be incorporated into the decree.

Contentions of Respondents

No substantive arguments are recorded; the matter proceeded to mediation and resolution by settlement, after which the court disposed of the appeal in terms of the settlement.

Extracted Judgment Text

Exact text extracted from official judgment records.

# IN "E HIGH COURT 0F KERALA AT ERNAKULAM # PRESENT THE neNOuRABLE MRs. .usTlcE slilRcy v. ## Tl+URSDAY, THE 1®" DAY 0F FEBRUARY 2®22 / 21ST MAGHA, 1943 RFA NO. 595 0F 2®13 AGAINST "E JUDGMENT IN 0S 572/2009 DATED 27.®3.2®13 0F 11 ADDITIONAL ## SUB COLJRT, KOZHIKODE ## AIPELLANT/PLAINTIFF : -_ ## K . P . AHAMMED S/0,ABDURAHIMAN, KUNNUMMAL HOUSE, 3/2434, VELLAYIL KALLADINTAKAM PARAMBA, KALATHINKUNU AMSOM, P.O. NADAI(I(AV, KOZHIKODE -11. BY ADVS. SRI . V . V . SURENDRAI\l SRI . P . A . HARISH ## RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS : - ## K . P . ABDU L LAKOYA ## S/0.ABDURAHIMAN, SONIYA NIVAS, PO0ZHIYIL, BHAT ROAD, KACHERI AMSOM DESOM, P,0.WEST HILL, KOZHIKODE-673®®5. - K . P . KASIM - S/O.ABDURAHIMAN, THAPPARAPPIL HOUSE, PuTHUR, PUTHIYAMGADI AMSOM BESOM, - P. 0. PUTHIYANCADI, KOZHIKODE-673021. - K . P . SAFIYA - D/O.ABDURAHIMAN, KURUPPANVEED PARAMBA, - NADAKRAV P.O, , KALATHINKUNNU AMSOM DESOM, KOZHIKODE -673011. - K . P . AKBAR ## S/O.ABDURAHIMAII VEllGALI, PUTllIYANIRATH, - P.0.ELATHUR, ELATHUR AMSOM DESOM, KOZHI KODE -6733©3 . - K . P . PATHIBI - D/0.ABDURAHIMAN, ROUSHEEF MANZIL, P00ZHIYIL, BHAT ROAD, RACHERI AMSOM DESOM, P.O.WEST HILL, KOZHIKODE-673®05. RFA NO. 595 0F 2®13 ## *6 K.P.ABDU [DIED] ## S/0.ABDURAHIMAN, KUNNATHTllAZHAM VAYAL, KALATHINKUNIIU AMSOM BESOM, KOZHIKODE P.O. , NADAKKAV, KOZHIKODE-673011. ## K . P . LAI LA ## D/0.ABDURAHIMAN, NEAR TALIKULANGARA MADRASA, P.0.MANIIAV, VALAYANAND AMSOM BESOM, KOZHI KODE -673007 . ## K . P . ASHARAF S/0.ABDURAHIMAN, KUMNUMMAL IIOUSE, 3/2434, VELLAYIL, KALLADINTARAM PARAMBA, KALATHINKUNHU AMSOM DESOM, P.0.IIADAKKAV, KOZHIKODE -673011. - *9 ADDL.R9 T0 Rll IMPLEADED :- ZEENATH, W/O ABDU K.P, AGED 49 YEARS, 3/2434 KUNNUMMAL, NADAKKAVU S.0, KALATHINKUNNU AMSOM AND DESOM, KOZHIKODE TALUK & DT. , KOZHIl{ODE-11. *10 SELMA K.P, D/0 ABDU K.P, AGED 30 YEARS, SELMA MANZIL, 3/969-8, KUNNUMMAL THAZHAMVAYAL NADAKKAVU, MADAKRAVU S.0, KALATHINKUNNU AMSOM AND AMSOM, KOZHIKODE TALUK & DT., KOZHIKODE -11. *11 AJMAL K.P, S/0 ABDU K.P, AGED 24 YEARS ## KUNNUMMAL THAZHAMVAYAL, NADAKRAVU NADAKKAVU S.0, RALATHINKUNllu AMSOM AND DESOM KOZHIKODE TALUK & DT., KOZHIKODE -11. *LEGAL HEIRS 0F DECEASED 6TII RESPONDENT ARE IMPLEADED AS ADDITIONAL R9 TO Rll VIDE ORDER DATED 10.02.2022 IN RFA 595/13. BY ADVS. SRI.PHILIP ANTONY CHACK0 SRI . P . M . SEBASTIAN THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION 0N 1®.©2.2®22, Tl+E COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: RFA NO. 595 0F 2®13 ## JUDGMENT This appeal has been filed by the appellant/plaintiff against the judgment and decree in O.S.No.572 of 2009 of the 2nd Additional Sub Court, Kozhikode. 2. Now the dispute has been settled between the parties in mediation. Pursuant to the settlement, the mediator has filed a report dated 24.01.2022. The settlement agreement has also been attached along with the report. The report dated 24.01.2022 is accepted with the terms incorporated therein. Therefore, this appeal is disposed of in terms of the settlement agreement entered into between the parties. Refund the court fee as per the rules. The settlement agreement shall form part of the decree. Sd/- SHIRCY V. JUDGE SMA 08733 **==> picture [8 x 4] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** Ej' **----- End of picture text -----** DistrictMediat§GnCentre, CourtC®mplex, Dated:j||o`\tKizhikode \``t``=-`iiH-` ` ` , Fi.,om Theco-®rdinator/(Sub-Judge) DistrictMediationCentre. i-i EiiE! "......-'.-.-......................-...-.-.........."..-.........-....... .......`."..-..--..I.....I..a.......,.....-............--.....,I........`.. Sir, :::.i-{¥%;:t::nRef:- 1, Or **d** =+Rer d **a** ealp°rt,°hfM_edi,a`to`r-ForwahrdLngof-Res.tes..„„l all 2. Report of Mediator of that Court. datea'...3„l...T=,.,I `=='.c±-a.............'-.-.. o,RTEeore;®4trcT,h5Med!at°"oefg,8hra:"::„:b`;h:he:ir',::':orf€:r::dr`::i::€,:ant,cC.a:e i`,er €ife`e ®rde,r c!t`ed ls` under rti`ference, is f€}rwarded her ew!th for information a~mf r reeessaryacEion. **==> picture [74 x 10] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** yours fajthful!y **----- End of picture text -----** £-,. / rl ## KOZHIKODE MEDIATION CENTRE MEMORANDUM of Agreement U/s. 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure with Rule of the Civil Procedure (Alternative Dispute Resolution) Rules 2008. R- ln RFA No. 595/2013 ## Pending before Hon'ble HIGH COURT OF KERALA Between: ZEENATH & Others Petitioners And: ## K.P.AHAMED&others - Respondents. The above said case was referred to mediation for resolving the dispute between the Parties. In the course of mediation, they have resolved their dispute and have agreed to the following terms and conditions. €aco3 cr)on6 €cEb(n)a EE2(a3 Gocoo ®>d3ig]1d3>93o cog:f]co8 tn]otn>o®1alcoltmco3cn)®1gj' coo6>9 calcn)®cooQj]q Of6"cuncoda,cfid=]co3tro®1al col6cfioof®1dso8on8. 1. E9®8 @ocoo d3>d3&glldbg3o cocalco3 col®8aoof]Hcolc[T)cD8(n)®1H° tgTacT)jo® a[5]d3> or(ro°co3 orQod3>o3 9 cocoaoce;I col®1g] terg®colafa 63®8 i3ocoo (cTacojoce)d=)O®CT)Oa2) 6)d}.Qfl. (araof)ca8° a®Cmon@d=)|o GC©a£]o 7 GOCoo CQJcold3>§OQ2) 1) 6)d9..aj}. (8ra6nl°e89gGd5)O®, 2) 6)db.af]. d3>Ocnjlo, 3) 6)d}.Qj]. (n)QnlQ2) 4) 6)d3>.aj]. a5rad}°6nJ@ 5) 6)ce>.aj]. aloarml6nn 6) 6)e>.aj7. 6)6)e[e] 7) 6)d3,.all. asTacH°oQI]° rL6)cTir)or6d=)° 1/9 ter@oud5.oc®o QflcoQJ8o, €coogfldso8cm .I/9 63ocLo®1 @ocoo a®1H 6)d3,.Qj]. co6nife8 cL®cIT)ou®86)s a5IaQJdJ.ocold3>9o® 1) f3o®j. crolcT)coo, 2) ad3,c6 6)on)aj3a 3) gd3,a3 ©rase°aco3 a®cTT)or6cf5)a 63§06)db 1/9 63oof)col ®raoudinocoQJ8o 6)ce.Os3da5)3clnr)colco° a®g!o aloasld¥.o®8o cocaled tn]ocroo®1al col©8aocDe]8. 2. cocojo®oj§1ce, Q]crooco8 orof)d3.o3 QfledcHco cT]scol taTg®col6>cE Qflel a¢)g!o G>dBiendg.98o eeQJ®or®86)S 630of)®1 QflanlcoaJmlcmco3Cn)@1gj' n®S8d5)3QJOcr)8o col®8aocr)1E3. 3. 6aco3 col®8aocDocald3,o®o oucro°co8 Qj]edd¥cD6]q2> crt>o6"oujl€g]o, orcro°co8Qfl6]cB Qfler6.® (n)o6mcrun€q]o, Ep®8 alo6§1dsoo®8o ®06)coo®3 co@das)cor398o 9cmQ2jld=)8CrT)6)g!(m8o Qfledd]cO oj®cro°al®o in)aJ)dg.®1cco8 )I. •:::-ii:-:==;i;:i:---I_:-i-A'.P k1.e a-a-¢a di~rf#rfuEL L=oigch;Z€Uptsfty r++ J co3n 7ngf) xp r3e#chiFLHcff`'bLHI`ffh=yu#wl# Rr= A . N a . 5ci s I aei3 . F+fart, ' RAshn; .V I rfl echalFEL [E4:] DLS4`k:®8hwlcch f6/ i LLL 8eesehag D*£A . K®gwheck R_epch+ I)'Ld b3 4dv. R63hn)`, r"cJ)bth I /,yl RF i+ iriD , €c95 / z©i2>. I`n R P. rS c.. GA] I 2,I in if€F4 .NQ . 5C9S I I a , I trthd eivdr JJtt mall::£h c,+The ft\Q pajLh`eA A S''^' i cjuch crfu«pQi'y`|~Qd ah a m`ed;oJfyLC3mcl cseffdral !|`jL aise^t7e TmifefL omc^ c^r`r> __ cAgrelr+: ulev5 ©r€:^hed F=l-:N:::::..tl` :::::4 o#ur#!,the.,benul="ffdgivtr#±fty ul£##c``3rmngng##nd£#S#rfu 4 Ljrmha3 Qjcit^ . `'`Sb± J :qu:1#±.. --_I_ -- / J=i`Lp.c} aT+ cS2}) -|~c52j822.1 BedrdLi Fhi His th th`qu cQLul-cstr kefuha Eyn KF A-. rg® . scis ) zQi3 rvlecL`tho¥` ', I, 4.€aco3 calco°cooQfle] col®8aocDcoTtDlcmco8cro®1ef EE!9 a®ccol6>ac#cr)CT)8cro®1ef 63®3 Qflaj]®OQj] GaaB CT)Cm6 Gd}co® dispose 6)ialqp8Cmcolco° a®g!o dbdhgfldb§8o coa£1co3 crootn]o®1al EE2 colcT>oed tn]cacole±t®1d5]8(TT>8. 5. caco3 (ngor(rmd}o3 a®6)coG}1eJ3o ce.dhfndB]cA Qflg°al or®8asro)8(maJag]o Qflg°jal or®8oro)3(in a[06§1 ag8 d}dhgf]d3.936)S G.aifscDog]°s6cr3o8dso° E!co®oroB1 ®oou8tTT)aDo6rT]°. e.3so6)co ggq> Q®ccol6.2cgr caid3,o®o cT]sco]1 d5,1§8cmaDlcD° €dhoscol6)Q2) (n)alaj] d3;)oou8crT) co8ao6TT)°. Datedthisthe 24th dayof January,202 RE=EEBEEREEERE n H EEEEE_DIRE /d;¢J± JEN 2. Selma 6)aedalQi. ggr K.p.Ah;mmed 2. Selma 6)aedalQi. 3. Aim9i cTbtt5t2gtofrfe illH 4 > 4. _K.P. Abdullakoyg r/,:#drprJ®&45. Kap p. p 67; ndl 4. _K.P. Abdullakoyg 6. K±E=± K. P rfvqjl> fr 7. K.P. Akbar cgr2>ed RE cRE{&'a 8. K.p. patheebi r7Lrfe 7 Gngl7,ai"| EEL > 9. K.P.Laila --:--:=T=:I-iT/- 10. K.P. Ashraf ®