Sivanandan M. v. Union of India and Others

``` INTHEHIGHCOURTOFKERALAATERNAKULAM PRESENT THEHONOURABLEMR.JUSTICERAJAVIJAYARAGHAVANV WEDNESDAY,THE22[ND]DAYOFMARCH2023/1STCHAITHRA,1945 WP(C)NO.26130OF2021 ``` ``` PETITIONERS: ``` ``` 1SIVANANDANM. AGED60YEARS S/O.MADHAVANK.,ASST.FINANCEMANAGER,P.P.NO.KRKKD 00073830,1/562NANDANAM,CHADAYANKADU,PALLATHERI - (PO),PALAKKAD678007. 2ABBASP.S. AGED60YEARS S/O.SAIDUMUHAMMEDP.,ASST.ENGINEER, P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00073800,PATHRAKULAMHOUSE, - NURANIP.O.,PALAKKAD678004. 3MATHEWC.O. AGED60YEARS S/O.OUSEPHM.P.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00073801, ITIEMPLOYEESHOUSINGCOLONY,KADAMKODE,KARINGARAPULLY - P.O.,PALAKKAD678551. 4HARIDASP.K. AGED60YEARS S/O.APPUNAIRT.,ASST.ENGINEER, P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00073027,DWARAKA,26/592-1,DARSINI - ROAD,NEWCIVILNAGAR,PALAKKAD678001. 5GOPALAKRISHNAPILLAI AGED60YEARS S/O.SANKARAPILLAIK.,ASST.ENGINEER, P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00073803,KARTHIKANO.7,KARINGARAPULLY - P.O.,PALAKKAD678551. 6UNNIKRISHNANNAIRM.D. AGED60YEARS S/O.DAMODARANNAIRA.P.,ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00074288,PALAZHI,PUZHAKKAL,KANNADI(PO), - PALAKKAD678701. ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 2 ``` 7KURIYAKOSEA.C. AGED60YEARS S/O.AUGUSTINECHEEKU,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00073396,ALAPPATTHOUSE,AKSHARANAGAR,OPPITILTD., - KANJIKODEWESTP.O.,PALAKKAD678623. 8SUSEELANM.K. AGED60YEARS S/O.KRISHNANKUTTYM.K.,ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00073534,CHELLASADAN,CHADAHYANKADU,PALLATHERI - P.O.,PALAKKAD678007. 9SURESHC.J. AGED60YEARS S/O.JANARDHANANNAIR,ASST.COMMERCIALOFFICER, P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00073499,SREEPAADAM,VADAKKANTHARA, - PALAKKAD678012. 10RAJENDRANNAIRC.S. AGED60YEARS S/O.SANKARANNAIR,ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00073500, POURNAMIII/936,HILLVIEWNAGAR,KANJIKODEWESTP.O., - PALAKKAD678623. 11MADHAVANE.K. AGED60YEARS S/O.KUNHIRAMANNAIRT.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00074692,SREEPARNAM,JN41,KURUDIKKAD,PUDUSSERY - P.O.,PALAKKAD678623. 12KRISHNANN.R. AGED60YEARS S/O.RAMAKRISHNANEZHUTHACHAN,OFFICER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00074308,HARISREE,NAMBILITHODI,PARUTHIPPULLYP.O., - PALAKKAD678573. 13THRESSIAT.A. AGED60YEARS W/O.K.I.XAVIER,ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00074656, KANNAMPUZHAHOUSE,NO.6,ANANDNAGAR,YAKKARA,KANNADI ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 3 ``` - (PO),PALAKKAD678701. 14SHEELAJAK. AGED61YEARS W/O.SUKUMARANM.N.,OFFICERHR.,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072698,G58SOUGANDHGANDHINAGARCOLONY, - CHANDRANAGARP.O.,PALAKKAD678007. 15KRISHNASWAMYA. AGED61YEARS S/O.AYYAPPAREDDIAR,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00074624,KRISHMANIVAS,HILLVIEWNAGAR,OPPITI, - KANJIKODEWESTP.O.,PALAKKAD678623. 16UNNIKRISHNANK. AGED59YEARS S/O.RAGHAVAKURUPM.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072676,SOWPARNIKA,PANDARAKKAVU,KUNNATHURMEDUP.O., - PALAKKAD678013. 17MURALIDHARANV.K.P. AGED60YEARS S/O.RAJAGOPALANNAIRK.V.,FINANCEOFFICER, P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00072700,KANGHINGHATHOUSE, - KAYILIADP.O.,SHORNUR,PALAKKAD679122. 18ABDUSSALAMC.P. AGED59YEARS S/O.KHALIDKUTTY,ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00072771, CPHOUSE,NADUVILANGADI,POOKAYILP.O.,TIRUR, - MALAPPURAM676107. 19HEMAMBIKAK. AGED59YEARS W/O.KRISHNANKUTTYK.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072851,23/37(2),PADMAM,KEERTHYNAGAR,PALLIPURAM - P.O.,PALAKKAD678006. 20PADMINIT.K. AGED60YEARS ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 4 ``` W/O.SATHEESHKUMARS.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072544,INDEEVARAM,BHAGAVATHYNAGAR,PUDUSSERYP.O., - PALAKKAD678623. ``` ``` 21SREEKUMARD. AGED59YEARS S/O.DEVADAS,OFFICER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00072549, SREEKAVYAM,VIDHYANAGAR,KALLEKULANGARA, - PALAKKAD678009. 22KARUNAKARANK. AGED60YEARS S/O.KUNJAN,HEADTECHNICIAN,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00073802, - KOUSTHUBHAM,KANNADIP.O.,PALAKKAD678701. 23ANNAMATHOBIYAS AGED59YEARS W/O.VARGHESEE.J.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072767,ALUVATHINGALHOUSE,MATHANAGAR,CHAKKANTHARA - P.O.,PALLIPPURAM,PALAKKAD678006. 24RAJUCYRIAC AGED59YEARS S/O.CYRIACP.C.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072675,H7,PERUMPALLYOLICKAL,GANDHINAGARCOLONY, - PUDUPPARIYARAMP.O.,PALAKKAD678731. 25SHIJIP.G. AGED59YEARS W/O.SASEENDRANK.N.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072662,AMRITALAYAM,PANAMKALAM,CHANDRANAGARP.O., - PALAKKAD678007. 26DARLINK.V AGED59YEARS S/O.VARGHESEK.P.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072679,KOTTAKKALHOUSE,ULLASNAGAR,CHEDAYANKALAI, - KANJIKODEWEST,PALAKKAD678623. 27BALACHANDRANB. ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 5 ``` AGED60YEARS S/O.BHASKRAPILLAIK.,OFFICER-HR.,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00074575,SREEPADMAM,HOUSENO.14,SASTHANAGAR, - PUDUSSERY,KANJIKODEWESTP.O.,PALAKKAD678623. ``` ``` 28MOHANANK.N. AGED60YEARS S/O.KRISHNANNAMBOODIRIPAD,ASST.MANAGER, P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00074604,HOUSENO.2/50,SOWPARNIKA, - CHEMBADAM,CHANDRANAGARP.O.,PALAKKAD678007. ``` ``` 29ANTONYP.V. AGED60YEARS S/O.VARKEYP.P.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00074638,PUTHAYATHUMOLELHOUSE,OPPKASABAPOLICE - STATION,PUDUSSERY,PALAKKAD678007. ``` ``` 30SURESHKUMARIM. AGED60YEARS W/O.GANAGURUPARANK.,COMMERCIALOFFICER, P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00074627,PRATHYUSHA,SRISATHYASAI - NAGAR,KALLEKKULANGARAP.O.,PALAKKAD678009. ``` ``` 31THANKACHANV.K. AGED60YEARS S/O.KURUVILAV.A.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00074603,VANNILAM,ARUMUGHAMGARDENS,CHANDRANAGAR P.O.,PALAKKAD. ``` ``` 32THOMASJOSEPH AGED56YEARS S/O.JOSEPHO.T.,ASST.ENGKINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072547,ORAVALAKKUDIYILHOUSE,PUZHAKKAL,KANNADI - P.O.,PALAKKAD678701. 33VINODAKRISHNANC.P. AGED56YEARS S/O.RAMANNAIRV.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072500,MANASWINI,KARUNANAGAR,PIRAYIRIP.O., - PALAKKAD678004. ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 6 ``` 34SUKUMARANK.G. AGED56YEARS S/O.GOPALAKRISHNANK.R.,CATH,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072495,KALLEMUCHIKKALHOUSE,THENURP.O.,PARALI, - PALAKKAD678612. ``` ``` 35CHENTHAMARAKSHANM. AGED56YEARS S/O.VASUNAIR,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00072497, 20/435(15),MECHERI,MYTHRINAGAR,THOTTINGAL,YAKKARA, - PALAKKAD678004. ``` ``` 36ALPHONSATHOMAS AGED57YEARS W/O.THOMASA.O.(LATE),ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072701,AYYAMPILLYHOUSE,H/8GANDHINAGAR, - PUDUPARIYARAMP.O.,PALAKKAD678731. 37VIJAYANANDHK.S. AGED57YEARS S/O.SURENDRANK.P.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00073646,KUNNATHHOUSE,KAVASSERYP.O., - PALAKKAD678543. 38JOSEV.K. AGED57YEARS S/O.KURIAKOSEV.N.,ASST.MANAGER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072699,VELIYATHUKUDYHOUSE,HARITHANAGAR, - KAZHCHAPARAMBU,KANNADIP.O.,PALAKKAD678701. 39AJAYAKUMARV.S. AGED56YEARS S/O.SUKUMARANM.K.,ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD00074323, PRASANTHI,KUMBALAKODE,ALATHURP.O., - PALAKKAD678541. 40RAGHURAJC.P. AGED56YEARS S/O.RAGHAVANNAMBIAR,ASST.ENGINEER,P.P.O.NO.KRKKD 00072697,RAJEEVAM,AMBALAPADI,WANDOORP.O., ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 7 ``` - MALAPPURAM679328. 41KUNHIKANNANK.V. AGED60YEARS S/O.KUNHAPPAP.P.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.F.A/C NO.KRKKD00040390000000388,KANNARATHUVALAPPILHOUSE, - KANICHERY,PARASSINIKADAVUP.O.,KANNUR670563. 42JOYJOSEPH AGED60YEARS S/O.JOSEPHN.C.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.F.A/C NO.KRKKD00040390000000446,NEDUMKALLELHOUSE, - KELIYANTHARAP.O.,IRITTY(VIA),KANNUR670706. 43PATHROSEK.O. AGED60YEARS S/O.OUSEPHK.R.,DEPUTYMANAGER,P.F.A/C NO.KRKKD00040390000000273,KOZHIKATTAHOUSE,KAPPATHI KAVU,EROORNORTHP.O.,THRIPPUNITHURA, - ERNAKULAM682306. 44RADHAKRISHNANT.S. AGED60YEARS S/O.SREENIVASANT.H.,ENGINEER,P.F.A/C NO.KRKKD00040390000000588,TRIKKURMADOM,SIVAJINAGAR, - MANALI,PALAKKAD678001. 45RADHAL. AGED60YEARS W/O.SWAMINATHANC.S.,ASST.ENGINEER,P.F.A/C NO.KRKKD00040390000000450,SWARASREEHOUSE,PATHIKKAL, - KANNADIP.O.,PALAKKAD678701. 46VISWANTHANV. AGED60YEARS S/O.CHARUNAIR,ASST.ENGINEER,P.F.A/C NO.KRKKD00040390000000465,ITIQTRS,YB2/3,VAZHAKADAVU - ROAD,KARINGARAPULLIP.O.,PALAKKAD678551. BYADVS. ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 8 ``` R.SANJITH C.S.SINDHUKRISHNAH ``` ``` RESPONDENTS: ``` ``` 1UNIONOFINDIA REPRESENTEDBYTHESECRETARY,MINISTRYOFLABOURAND EMPLOYMENT,DEPARTMENTOFEMPLOYMENT, - NEWDELHI110001. 2THEEMPLOYEESPROVIDENTFUNDORGANISATION REPRESENTEDBYTHECHIEFPROVIDENTCOMMISSIONER, BHAVISHYANIDHIBHAVAN,14,BHIKAJICAMAPALACE, - NEWDELHI110066. 3REGIONALPROVIDENTFUNDCOMMISSIONER EMPLOYEESPROVIDENTFUNDSUBREGIONALOFFICE,THE EMPLOYEESPROVIDENTFUNDORGANISATION,BHAVISHYANIDHI - BHAVAN,P.B.NO.1806,ERANHIPALAM,KOZHIKODE673006. 4M/SITILTD.(INDIATELEPHONEINDUSTRIESLIMITED) - PALAKKADPLANT,KANJIKODEWEST,PALAKKAD678623, REPRESENTEDBYITSGENERALMANAGER. BYADVABRAHAMP.MEACHINKARA,SC ``` ``` SRI.MANUS,DSGI ``` ``` THISWRITPETITION(CIVIL)HAVINGCOMEUPFOR ADMISSIONON22.03.2023,ALONGWITHWP(C).35420/2019,THE COURTONTHESAMEDAYDELIVEREDTHEFOLLOWING: ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 9 ## **JUDGMENT** ## This writ petition is filed seeking the following reliefs:- (i) to call for the records leading to the issuance of Exhibits P5 to P44, examine its legality, propriety and quash the same to the extent to which same is prejudicial to the interests of the petitioners to receive monthly pension in proportion to their actual salary, by issuing a writ of certiorari. (ii) to issue a word of mandamus and command respondents 2 and 3 or such other appropriate authorities under the Employees Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 and the Employees Pension Scheme, 1995 to confer to petitioners with all pensionary benefits under the Employees Pension Scheme, 1995, calculated on the basis of average of 60 months’ salary immediately prior to their retirement/exit from membership of the pension fund, as provided under Paragraphs 11 and 12 of the Scheme, 1995 as amended by Amended Scheme 2014 and to complete necessary steps in that regard within a time frame stipulated by this Hon’ble Court. (iii) to issue a writ of mandamus and command the respondents to disburse all pensionary benefits that are lawfully due to the petitioners with interest at the rate of 12% from the date it has fallen due to the date of realization of the said amounts as provided under paragraph 17A of the Scheme 1995, within a time frame stipulated by this Hon’ble Court. 2. When the matter was taken up for consideration, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners herein are also covered by the observations and directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in **EPF Organisation and Another v. Sunil Kumar B** W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 10 **and Others** (2022 SCC Online SC 1521) and requested that directions be issued to the respondents to consider the claim of the petitioners in terms of the directions contained therein. It is submitted that the 4th respondent has submitted Ext.P71 before the 3rd respondent along with the duly executed joint option forms and submitted that the respondents shall act in terms of the directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. 3. Sri. Abraham P. Maechinkara, the learned counsel, submits that the respondents shall act in terms of the directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In that view of the matter, this writ petition is disposed of, directing the petitioners as well as the respondents to act in terms of the directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in **Sunil Kumar B (supra)** and process the request for joint option submitted by the petitioners in accordance with law. Sd/- ## **RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V JUDGE** Sru W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 11 ## `APPENDIX OF WP(C) 26130/2021` ``` PETITIONEREXHIBITS ExhibitP1TRUECOPYOFTHEJUDGMENTDATED10/04/2015IN W.P.C.NO.11790/2015. ExhibitP1ATRUECOPYOFTHEORDERDATED12/07/2016IN SPECIALLEAVETOAPPEALNO.19954/2015. ExhibitP2TRUECOPYOFTHECOMMUNICATIONDATED 16/09/2016ISSUEDBYTHEASSISTANTPROVIDENT FUNDCOMMISSIONERTOTHE4THRESPONDENT. ExhibitP3TRUECOPYOFTHECOMMUNICATIONDATED 20/09/2016ISSUEDBYTHEASSISTANTPROVIDENT FUNDCOMMISSIONERTOTHE4THRESPONDENT. ExhibitP4TRUECOPYOFTHECOMMUNICATIONDATED 14/03/2017ISSUEDBYTHEASSISTANTPROVIDENT FUNDCOMMISSIONERTOTHE4THRESPONDENT. ExhibitP5TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 1STPETITIONER. ExhibitP6TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 2NDPETITIONER. ExhibitP7TRUECOPYOFTHEPENSIONPAYMENTORDEROFTHE 3RDPETITIONER. ExhibitP8TRUECOPYOFTHEPENSIONPAYMENTORDEROFTHE 4THPETITIONER. ExhibitP9TRUECOPYOFTHEPENSIONPAYMENTORDEROFTHE 5THPETITIONER. ExhibitP10TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 12 ``` 6THPETITIONER. ``` ``` ExhibitP11TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 7THPETITIONER. ExhibitP12TRUECOPYOFTHEPENSIONPAYMENTORDEROFTHE 8THPETITIONER. ExhibitP13TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 9THPETITIONER. ExhibitP14TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 10THPETITIONER. ExhibitP15TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 11THPETITIONER. ExhibitP16TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 12THPETITIONER. ExhibitP17TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 13THPETITIONER. ExhibitP18TRUECOPYOFTHEPENSIONPAYMENTORDEROFTHE 14THPETITIONER. ExhibitP19TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 15THPETITIONER. ExhibitP20TRUECOPYOFTHEPENSIONPAYMENTORDEROFTHE 16THPETITIONER. ExhibitP21TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILSOFTHE 17THPETITIONER. ExhibitP22TRUECOPYOFTHEPENSIONPAYMENTORDEROFTHE 18THPETITIONER. ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 13 |`Exhibit `|`P23`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |---|---|---|---| |||`19TH `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P24`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |||`20TH `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P25`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |||`21ST `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P26`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`22ND `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P27`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`23RD `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P28`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |||`24TH `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P29`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |||`25TH `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P30`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |||`26TH `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P31`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`27TH `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P32`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`28TH `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P33`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`29TH `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P34`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`30TH `|`PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P35`|`TRUE `|`COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`31ST `|`PETITIONER.`| W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 14 |`Exhibit `|`P36`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |---|---|---| |||`32ND PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P37`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`33RD PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P38`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`34TH PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P39`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`35TH PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P40`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |||`36TH PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P41`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`37TH PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P42`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |||`38TH PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P43`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS OF THE`| |||`39TH PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P44`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER OF THE`| |||`40TH PETITIONER.`| |`Exhibit `|`P45`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS`| |||`PERTAINING TO BALASUBRAMANIAN M.`| |`Exhibit `|`P46`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS`| |||`PERTAINING TO A K.SHYAMALA.`| |`Exhibit `|`P47`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS`| |||`PERTAINING TO N ASHALATHA`| |`Exhibit `|`P48`|`TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS`| |||`PERTAINING TO B HARSHAN.`| W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 15 ``` ExhibitP49 ``` ``` TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOC.SATHEESH. ``` ``` ExhibitP50TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOCFGEORGE. ExhibitP51TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOKASIVANKUTTY. ``` ``` ExhibitP52TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOKBSUGUNAN. ``` ``` ExhibitP53 ``` - `TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS PERTAINING TO K K VISWANATHAN.` ``` ExhibitP54TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOKPRAJENDRAN. ``` ``` ExhibitP55 ExhibitP56 ExhibitP57 ``` - `TRUE COPY OF THE PPO ENQUIRY DETAILS PERTAINING TO SEBASTIAN C JOSEPH.` ``` TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOTHOMASZACHARIAH. ``` ``` TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOM.GOPALAKRISHNABHAT. ``` ``` ExhibitP58 ``` ``` TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOCSREEKUMARANNAIR. ``` ``` ExhibitP59TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOANNIECHERIYAN. ``` ``` ExhibitP60 ``` ``` TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOMALIKUNHU. ``` ``` ExhibitP61 ``` ``` TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOABDURAHIMANM. ``` W.P.(C) No.26130 of 2021 16 ``` ExhibitP62TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOV.T.PARAMESWARAN. ExhibitP63TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOBALAKRISHNANM.A. ExhibitP64TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOK.MARIAPPAN. ExhibitP65TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTONARAYANANN. ExhibitP66TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOAGPRABHAKARAN. ExhibitP67TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTORADHAKRISHNANK. ExhibitP68TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTODKRAMESAN. ExhibitP69TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOSHAJIVARUGHESE. ExhibitP70TRUECOPYOFTHEPPOENQUIRYDETAILS PERTAININGTOSANTHAKUMARIV. Exhibit-P71TRUECOPYOFTHELETTERBEARINGREFERENCENO. ITI/PKD/HR/2023/0035DATED03/02/2023ISSUED BYTHE4RDRESPONDENTTOTHE3RDRESPONDENT. ```