Regular Second Appeal No. 88/2011

Case Details & Bench

Court: High Court of Kerala
Hon'ble Judges: M.R. Anitha
Judgment Date: 2023-01-05
Court Decision / Holding: Appeal disposed in terms with the compromise; the compromise is recorded and the sketch attached thereto will form part of the decree.
Final Disposition: Appeal disposed in terms with the compromise; compromise recorded and sketch forming part of the decree.

Parties to the Case

Appellants / Petitioners

Unknown appellant

Respondents

CHEENAYI PUTHIYA PURAYIL MARIYAM
W/O P.M. IBRAHIM HAJI, Nedovode, Aalakkode Ambsom, Arangam Desom, Talipparamba Taluk, Kannur District
CHEENAYI PUTHIYA PURAYIL NAFEESA
S/O P.M. IBRAHIM HAJI
CHEENAYIL PUTHIYA PURAYIL ZUBAIR
S/O P.M. IBRAHIM HAJI
CHEENAYIL PUTHIYA PURAYIL ASYA
D/O P.M. IBRAHIM HAJI
P. T. MUHAMMED EUSHEER
S/O IBRAHIM HAJI
P.T. HASSAN
CHEERAYI PUTHIYA PURAYIL SUBAIDA
S/O P.M. IBRAHIM HAJI
ADV. SRI.B.PREMNATH

Legal Representation & Advocates

Counsels for Respondents

• Adv. Sri B Premnath

Case Synopsis & Summary

This Regular Second Appeal No. 88 of 2011, before the Kerala High Court, arises from orders in O.S. 256/1996 of the Munsiff Court, Taliparamba, which were carried to A.S. 69/2001 in the Sub Court, Payyannur. The dispute primarily involves family members over property in the Taliparamba taluk, with numerous respondents named in the appeal. On 5 January 2023, during admission, both parties’ counsel informed the court that the entire controversy had been settled amicably out of court by a compromise recorded as Annexure to I.A. No. 1/2022, including a sketch. The court examined the terms of the compromise and found them legal and proper, recording that there is no impediment to recording the settlement. Accordingly, the appeal was disposed of in terms of the compromise, with the sketch attached thereto forming part of the decree. The proceedings reflect a shift toward out-of-court settlement in civil litigation, reducing protracted litigation between co-bargainers. The judgment notes that the compromise is to be incorporated into the final decree, and the parties’ agreement will govern the rights and obligations settled therein, signaling a final resolution without further contestations. The presiding judge is M.R. Anitha, delivering the decision as a single-judge bench.

Submissions & Arguments

Contentions of Appellants / Petitioners

The appellants’ counsel submitted that the disputes between the parties have been settled amicably out of court through a compromise and urged the court to dispose of the appeal in terms of the compromise, recording it and attaching the sketch to the decree.

Contentions of Respondents

The respondents’ counsel supported disposal in terms of the compromise, noting that all issues between the parties have been resolved and requesting that the settlement be recorded and incorporated into the final decree.

Extracted Judgment Text

Exact text extracted from official judgment records.

## EN CHE HIGH couRai oE acERaLA AI ERNaKULan¢ ## PRESENT TErn HONouRABIE MRs. ousTlcE M.R.ANITHA THURSDAy, THE 5" ray OF bANunRy 2o23 / i5rm pOusHA, ig44 ## esAL ro. ee<OF 2oi.1- AGAINST THE ORDER/OuD®GNT IN As 69/2Ooi OF SUB cOuRT, pA:iryANNUR os 256/igg6 oF MUNslFF couRT, TAI.IPARmdBA ## AppElaANT/REspONDENI/DEFENDANT: oET¥ENTz!RATH-riFlsstJREA, D70. uREERKur:r¥` NIDt7vOI]u,AILAKKaDE AMsOM AND ARANGAM DEsOM, , TALlpARAMBA TALUK, RIINNUR DISTRICT. BY JdJVS. SMT.vlDErrA. A.c SRI . A . C . VENUGOPAL ## RESPOHDENTS7Zi©HizRT7HiA;iN:riff: - CHEENAYI PUTHIYA PURAYIL MARIYAM - W/O. P.M. IBRAIIIM HATI , NEDOvODE ,AI.AKKOI)E AMSOM, ARANGAM DESOM, TALIPARAMBA TAI.UK,KANNUR DISTRICT. 670 571 - CHEENAYIIi PUTHIYA PURAYII. NAFEESA - D./a..p..M-.IBRAHnr m!T., -I)O- -Do- - CHEENAYII, PUTHIYA PURAYII. ZUBAIR - S/O.P.M.IBRAIIIM HAJI, -DO--DO- - CREENA:YII. PUTI]IYA PURAYII. SATHAR -DO- -I)0- - CREENAYIL PUTHIYA PURAYII. ASYA - D/0.P.M.IBRAEIIM HAJI, -I)0--BO- - P. T.MUHA104ED EusHEER - S/0.IBRAHIM HAOI, -I)0--DO- - P.T.HASSAN -DO--DO- - CHEERAYII. PUTHIYA PURAYIL SUBAIDA - I)/a.. p-.M.. IBRall.IM. IIaTI , -DO--DO- - BY ADV SRI.B.PREMNATH E THIS REGUI-AR SECOND APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 05.01.2023, THE couRT oN `TI±E saBdE DAY DEI.I-VIRED TErn FolIsowING:. R-. S . A . No . 8 8 / 2 Oil ## .TtJDen.ENI` This. Reg`ular S.e.comd App`eal has+ b.een directed against,. the~ judgment and decree in A.S.No.69/2001 on the file of Sub Court, Payyannur, which in turn arise out of the judgment and decree in O.S.No.256/1996 on the file of Munsiff s Court, Taliparamba. 2. When the case is taken up, it is submitted by the learned-counsel for the .appel'I`ant as well. as the I.earned counsel for respondents that the parties amicably settled the issue out of coul`tandacompromise.was~eateredinto. 3. I.A.No.1/2022 also filed to accept Annexure AI compromise along with the sketch appended thereto and requested to dispose the appeal in terms with the compromise. 4. On going through the terms of the compromise, I am satisfied that the terms of the compromise are I.egal` and- proper. Parties settled the entire issues out of court and there is no impediment in recording` the. compromise. R`.S`.A..No.88`/`20`1.1. 3 Accordingly, appeal disposed in terms with the compromise. Compromise entered` into -between the parties and. the sketoh attached to it will form part of the decree. S-di- M.R.ENITHA Shg JunGE- 4flunwM- fy -_ # 6nltio}aoco6)e]§ ccB]®9 6>6>OLOGCB6}OscO1 ®!tnl06>to, REsiA.NDo Q8 oF _Loll ill 63oell®nocfrocou en®®1qB3an QO®92lc06)O©l al°lmo®1 al2col® al3©®1ds ®ol®o, ad36)o8: 2. of>ts}nd, 3. tn>coTo>od, 4. tn)26>6>6nld, 5. 6nldi±6ld, 6. mcLfll(S}, 7. @Tg(njl®, 8. tn>}6>6>6n]B - ng)cobcfrotDmlrfuo3 eeedled enacobo®ca6>o®1: ee£\rrv822 @~ **==> picture [319 x 332] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** Q®®5dbrfuq41dbo8: 1 L2Tr m7c3J|qndrfu alrtey|al 2+ftyD 2 ` apr~NIrvL ` @CL A+q# 3 chen\d) :.._::,-:``=::::-:i--:-:. 6 onc2-?rJ f tgiv ;.,...a)edr3 ` B.P C0owsrELibEL TRTz> frEsftyroow **----- End of picture text -----** **==> picture [57 x 23] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** -,wl¢ **----- End of picture text -----** VID"A A , C ' LOuN:;i r:faiirwi NIpwT 4 , / 2- ## enag±1elco.\o®d]@o®l/og)coicB]cha4l/oa)coAca]chadl 63o fll®q§cfroof apco>1qB2m a@®Adbdrmllrfued /@roQ|led coon.\o®d]6>od /QIofflcho3 al`]cooofl ul2col® al!©Ofled ®ol®o, ®co6>de: 2. dLoqBch, 3. (n)co)Od, 4. (n)36)6)6T2Jd, 5. 6ir2Joffld, 6. moll($3, 7. en©crt)l®, 8. cro}6)6)6T2IB ## coedled @rombo®c96>o®i: fero8`]1ou8® `3ZL Q®cO6cfroedd3]03: 1 9g|at9givlq4r6\a/ arfal avo **==> picture [226 x 113] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** 2 thrgivul ,p,b Artyny 3 Guloapicb cde 4 cv+669Or2Jc6 ex 5Gfuojflc6` ne **----- End of picture text -----** 6 cy.Opl.J ggr 7 cde7ct31c9J ,st 8r86]Dodyf3`anan **==> picture [47 x 21] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** •.\j\yr. **----- End of picture text -----** V`r DEN tr A Ci cOINsftyt5try€ty&-appun 8.# c®w`/rzLr¢ELfuep8pOwDevrj EnpEi Gaedcotnlol6>ffl eeedled t8romboQ2>c©6>o®1 63oEiil®cEcfoorg>u t3Tg®ltn3}ancm}o, Qfl)®5co]can]1d3]oB 1. al6Icr7ocol QI!col® al}®coled aol®o, aco6)08 2. of)(P3ch, 3. Cn)asrc)od, 4. (n)26)6)6nJd, 5. 6"rfflld, 6. cDof]1(S}, 7. a3Tg(n)lco>, 8. (r\)|6)6)6nJB g2QI®2o rfu}sl (n)1QJled cosalsl mlaDao 23-00 d9]eulQlco 3-00 al§ ialce,O®O c6T2IOcO18ind36>3tTT7 ®0931 Qo®g31. 1. G®edcotnld combo® co]o®bo t3rocoboco)o iulcolcfroo8 coaaled ulo6"C5 ©O931®0®1 cold(TT)l®lc@6)I(YT)3. cotlled @rombo®c@oo©|: TanQ`fnj8g3 `Lfa ## QocobcfrodJmlcfroo8: **==> picture [220 x 243] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** 1 +1J rn7cfu| ndFfu atf¢|al gflan 2 apAVulrJ @.S /+# 3esapS dr 4 atIrrfe rite 5 6ulosaci , fiae -7 ®edflcey. cf y.6 an~1AVJ ar 8`rrfu6>5yalr3.ekerfuke **----- End of picture text -----** viD"fr trc,i Cxp v Njfu f=rprflagr A72fffl*+mrz3 B.,ng% cOvN5fe>t, F6RTiife P-es PENDe\rT9 4//pe a 2. @rocDboco>asro)led codco6>®3gg QJm5co2 (roo6nJ(Tu)13j cog]1Of carocobococ@6)o®la2>!o Q€)cobcfoconflcfrog2o cB]}sl aombct2]o®o® ®cobm5IAonod ®}(nJo6)co] QJo6Trm! di©2d3]®3o codco6> QJm5co2 tn]d6>q]cO>d Og)O.Qg).tn>ccO>OcricB,2®Od Q®tTT>®06>96>cfo06rfe cog(mu g=och coqpoooco6)}co,®}o 6)al®Vcol©lcB6)a(TT)2. a3raco! iulco3o©o codc©6) QJm5co2 @rog(TT)2 co]6neGS I, 11 g6ae6)cr) ®6n3} €g5o§}d9]gocB6)1 col®lc@6)2db®}o teracoled I-oo in(nJd Gdso§ 10.50 6>tn>nl (4.25 asT®d) m5me]o t3rag]1elco3o®c©6>o®1c©5 6]co,os}c@6i}cfro®}o, lI-oo mtnjd cedo§ 14.90 6>(n)Q§ (6.03 @Tgd) trovmEuo ng)co&rfucrml cB>o8d36>u 6)cfroos2d36>3cB]®2o cfrocB"1cfroo@ 6)6)cfroQJCoo og)S}co6)}co.®3o 6)cB]OS}dJ6)3cO]®3o 6)al®ucol®1c96)2m|. coedlca8 (cracoboaDco6>o®1: ias`@IN8en `± **==> picture [275 x 266] intentionally omitted <==** \:.`,\\`¥.:, touNIS#RE ire-wftet"- ff,/g, 3. (n)d6)q]®d ag)o.Qg).(n)CcOOQ9ZcB]2®Od coqzloooc06)l® dsoch 9PrD ®ogal of)®g3l®!6)s Boor)ao®1 QLoog3®oce6)1®l®lc©6)a(m}. sl g50ch Annexure I @TgcQ)1 ®odce5 6)al®Ucol®1d36)2tTT)3. 4. g2 rD rfe o ©boro)16) eJ Cco]o s ®1 all Eil of cfro cDml cfroo8 tn]of>1co6>!orom2o di©}®ocolein©1dJ6>2(TT)a. cOcO!6>cfo06n§ 6nlof>}®OcO6>8]§ 6>6>Of7Gces>Oscol B®QI! 6>aled;ds5 g2rD ®Og%1 of)®931 01csood(u)Ot86)l cOcO}|alcfoo®o 63®2 oulcA)l d3]eul'allco6)2QIoch cocalcrmld?o!tm2. 2 5.10. 202 2 ## cog]1ch tBracDbo®ce6>o©1: Te`toch INam r3a± **==> picture [315 x 68] intentionally omitted <==** a, **==> picture [178 x 41] intentionally omitted <==** - •::,::-,JJl`-i,`i9J.:3(-\£.:- - 8 ral6fflrdB . ife NNxp?' v7D in fr fr t, cOuN¢Fi , Fisp:+rna uepeLnri\iT **==> picture [79 x 11] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** --::--i:-::--i.-- **----- End of picture text -----** **==> picture [193 x 12] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** co v ^rgeL, feprm}+5 rLe5p6 ^ne^iz **----- End of picture text -----** /.,//,',.` ® G®6>e]g2col®6>coo6>d36>®}o 6ro>68T3926)s tnJJ(ro)olQJlds6)edsco}o tnJ cob ®06> 6m(m2 o (n) ocon±b 6> ed s2 asTo>1 gptmu gp col ed ®gltlotn]led 6>Q]3j 63q±n§}. 25.1o.2o22 coalled teracobo®c©6>o©1: tTas>@fh8D r© o®co6c8.coalce,o8 1 rf\rmafl24flalfty~ap gnfro '#vi **==> picture [224 x 164] intentionally omitted <==** 6 giv7aplfyJ 9y9~ 7 apdrJ\ev`4* 8 rdopchB,as NJxp VtDmtr frrc. touNr;gLFTng/2i=ifeftypL1{A;f i-:-:---_:.--i-, •4,/r.=`-` c6moajlale]2: - . .2022 Qnalo®6m: - .2022 6mQo2aom6>ed§ €ch®9 6)6)ooccooscol a2ono6)ch I.A.No /2022 Ei ## IN ## R.S.A.No.88/2011 **==> picture [21 x 20] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** .a **----- End of picture text -----** O®dJ@O®| 63oEiil®nlrfecov engofqB2m ## OO®Arfueddnd al°icDodrl al2col® Q12®cofled ri aol®o, ®d36)o8: .2. QoqBch, 3. cOcood' 4. crt>36)6)6T2Jd, 5. 6T2Jof]1d, 6. cOQJ]1qB, 7. noco1®, 8. cO26)6)6"B S cDchoonol6>ei eeedled @racobo®d}@o®1aD}o o®cobchcenll cB.9}o tfo251 mjlQnct msoLlst col®oo 23-Oo dsEEaJm 3-Oo al§ €6moedalco!On ®Och LQJcho®o ao®ga. **==> picture [30 x 72] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** / **----- End of picture text -----** **==> picture [495 x 733] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** ./b\ DESOM : ARANGAM DISTRICT : KANNUR AREA I = 4.`25 ARE (10.50 CENT) TALUK : TALIPARAMBA 11 : 6.03 ARE (14.90 CENT) VILLAGE : ALAKODE DATE : 22-09-2022 R.S : 1/.: NAME : P00MANGALORAKATHUMADATHIL MARIYAM flrvNS*PP.B -I Poomangalorakathu Madathll Mariyam & 7 others 1. ctpe`1or`giv 9. rtlo.456rtyB\` ± Pazhuthadathll Thomas u'-a 7]. a:2'3 Ollntakathu Poomangalorakathu Madathil -t? E Ayisha Marlyam & 7 others Ollntakathu Ayisha Poomangalorakathu Hamsa ` s%zrc8ap + 79:9ffl778zjz3 SANTHOSHKUMAR.M.A. i.-fl Matheparambil, Nellipara P.`O, e-:-"eyJor _- •6?057^, Reg: Certificate No:.416/89, p'OJNe`\ippara Mob : 9446262835. Scale lcm=5M **----- End of picture text -----** •+,;`\+ •,%uus#`%"„#-criraj.wf **==> picture [205 x 29] intentionally omitted <==** **----- Start of picture text -----** cOuN58L'fopr{tifyap3prtyti' -, **----- End of picture text -----** R..S`.A`.No.88./.20.1.1. ## APPENDIX ## RESPONI)ENTS 'ANNEXURES : ANNE.xuRE` Ai. > TRI}E. cOp¥ ®F` THE` SAI.D. cOMPRomI`sE. pEq!I.TroN` EN"=RED. I.Nq}®.13E`TWEEN` THE APPELIENTS AND THE RESPONDENTS ENTERED IN R.S.A.NO.88 0F 2011, DATED 25.io.2022 AIONG wlTH Tim SKETCH AppENDED THERETO.