High Court of KeralaSingle JudgeWrit petition allowed; Ext.P3 set aside; interi...
Mohammed Favaz K.K. and others v. Deputy Director of Education, Malappuram District and Others
Case / Petition Number:WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
Neutral Citation:/null
Case Details & Bench
- Court
- High Court of Kerala
- Hon'ble Judges
- Devan Ramachandran
- Judgment Date
- 2023-12-11
- Court Decision / Holding
- The writ petition is allowed. Ext.P3 is set aside; the interim order dated 06.12.2023 is confirmed; petitioners will be granted all benefits pursuant to their performance in the District Kalolsavam as per law. The district Kalolsavam organizers are directed to publish the final results forthwith.
- Final Disposition
- Writ petition allowed; Ext.P3 set aside; interim order maintained; final results to be published; petitioners to receive benefits as per law.
Parties to the Case
Appellants / Petitioners
- MOHAMMED FAVAZ.K.K.
- MUHAMMED FASEEH
- ABIN HARSHAN P.K.
- SAVAD KAMBRATH
- MUHAMMED JASEEM K.
- SINAN
- MUHAMMED SIDAN K
- MOHAMMED DHANISH T.P.
- MOHAMMED ADNAN
- MUHAMMED NASEEM
- MOHAMMED RAZIN.A
- SANJAY N
Respondents
- Deputy Director of Education / General Convener Programe Committee Malappuram Revenue District School Kalotsavam 2023 Malappuram, Office of the Deputy Director of Education, Down Hill, Malappuram, Malappuram District
- District Educational Officer / Office of the District Educational Office, Up Hill, Malappuram, Malappuram District - 676505
- Assistant Educational Officer / Convener Programe Committee, Malappuram Sub District School Kalotsavam 2023, Civil Station, Malappuram, Malappuram District, Pin - 676505
- State of Kerala represented by Principal Secretary to Government, General Education Department, Secretariat, Thiruvananthapuram, Pin – 695001
Legal Representation & Advocates
Counsels for Petitioners
- • Sri. Ramnath M.P.
Counsels for Respondents
- • Smt. Vidya Kuriakose
Case Synopsis & Summary
This writ petition challenges the denial of advancement in the Malappuram Kalotsavam 2023-24. Twelve petitioners, students from Government Rajas Higher Secondary School, Kottakkal, represented by guardians, contended that though they did not secure first place at the Sub-District level, their merit warranted consideration for the next level, and that the statutory scheme requires proper assessment of every contention, including video evaluation of performances. An interim order dated 06.12.2023 permitted provisional participation, contingent on later formal order. The petition argues that Ext.P3, the appellate order, purportedly evaluated objections but gave no specific reasons and did not confirm a proper evaluation of video recordings, thereby violating due process and the scheme's requirements. Respondents urged adherence to settled law, particularly that once an appeal is disposed of, petitioners have no legal or equitable right to relief, and that Ext.P3 shows all objections were considered. The court noted that the petitioners achieved a rank of No.2 at the District Kalolsavam after the interim order, and that Ext.P3 lacked explicit reasons, especially regarding video evidence. The judge allowed the petition, set aside Ext.P3, and directed that petitioners receive benefits as per law, with final results published forthwith.
Provisions of Law Cited
Right to Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act)Kerala School Kalolsavam ManualKerala School Kalotsavam Manual
Legal Doctrines & Maxims
- Once an appeal is disposed of, the petitioners would not obtain any right either in law or in equity.
Submissions & Arguments
Contentions of Appellants / Petitioners
Counsel for petitioners argued that the petitioners are exceptionally meritorious and have consistently demonstrated their credentials in Kolkali events. Ext.P19 shows the petitioners’ ranking in the District Kalotsavam and the success of others in past events, supporting entitlement to advancement. They contended that the interim order dated 06.12.2023 permitted provisional participation based on merit, and Ext.P3’s denial of advancement did not accord with the Kalotsavam scheme’s due process. They asserted that the appellate order did not provide specific reasons or address video evidence, violating the statutory requirement that every contention be considered. They urged the court to allow the writ petition, set aside Ext.P3, and direct authorities to consider advancement for merited candidates, with final results published and benefits paid.
Contentions of Respondents
Government Pleader submitted that the law is settled by Devna Sumesh v. State of Kerala that once an appeal is disposed of, the petitioner loses any right to relief. She added that Ext.P3 shows every contention was properly considered and that video evaluation, though desirable, is a policy matter to be weighed by the Kalotsavam authorities. The court should respect a reasoned appellate order reflecting due consideration of objections and not substitute its own assessment over the discretionary decisions of the evaluators.
Cited Precedents (1)
| Case Name | Citation | Treatment | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Devna Sumesh v. State of Kerala | 2022 KHC OnLine 8081 | Positive | The court relies on this decision as well-settled law that once an appeal is disposed of, the petitioners' rights to relief are exhausted in law or equity. |
Diagnostic Tool
Does this judgment govern your specific facts?
Don't risk relying on a distinguishable precedent. Enter your facts or proposition below. We will test it against Mohammed Favaz K.K. and others v. Deputy Director of Education, Malappuram District and Others and instantly map out authorities that support, challenge, or govern your position.
Extracted Judgment Text
Exact text extracted from official judgment records.
## **IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM**
## **PRESENT**
## **THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN MONDAY, THE 11[TH] DAY OF DECEMBER 2023 / 20TH AGRAHAYANA, 1945**
## **WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023**
## **PETITIONERS:**
1 MOHAMMED FAVAZ.K.K., AGED 16 YEARS S/O FAISAL KALLANKUNNAN KALLAN KUNNAN HOUSE, PULICODE, 11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM LEADER REPRESENTING KOLKALI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT REPRESENTED BY HIS FATHER AND GUARDIAN/NEXT FRIEND, FAISAL KALLANKUNNAN, S/O.KOYA, AGED 42 YEARS, DRIVER, KALLAN KUNNAN HOUSE, PULICODE, KOTTAKKAL VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676503 2 MUHAMMED FASEEH, AGED 17 YEARS S/O NASEEMA P.I PURAPPATHIYIL HOUSE, PONMUNDAM, 11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM MEMBER KOLKALLI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT REPRESENTED BY HIS MOTHER AND GUARDIAN/NEXT FRIEND, NASEEMA P.I, W/O.ABDUL GAFOOR, AGED 43 YEARS,HOUSEWIFE, PURAPPATHIYIL HOUSE, PONMUNDAM ,PONMUNDAM VILLAGE, VAILATHUR P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676106 3 ABIN HARSHAN P.K., AGED 17 YEARS S/O MUHAMMED BASHEER.P.K PULIYAKODAN HOUSE, SABAN ECO VILLAGE, AMPARA, KOTTAKAL,11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM MEMBER KOLKALLI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT REPRESENTED BY HIS FATHER AND GUARDIAN/NEXT FRIEND,MUHAMMED BASHEER P.K, S/O.MUHAMMED, AGED 53 YEARS,LAB TECHNICIAN, PULIYAKODAN HOUSE, SABAN ECO VILLAGE, AMPARA, KOTTAKAL, KOTTAKKAL VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676503 4 SAVAD KAMBRATH, AGED 17 YEARS S/O BASHEER KAMBRATH KAMBRATH HOUSE, SWAGATHAMADU, CHERUSOLA, 11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM MEMBER KOLKALLI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT REPRESENTED BY HIS FATHER AND GUARDIAN/NEXT FRIEND, BASHEER KAMBRATH, S/O.MUHAMMED KAMBRATH , AGED 59 YEARS, BUISINESS,
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
2
KAMBRATH HOUSE, SWAGATHAMADU, CHERUSOLA,KOTTAKKAL VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676503
|5|MUHAMMED JASEEM K., AGED 16 YEARS|
|---|---|
||S/O SUBAIDA KALODI HOUSE, THOKKAMPARA, KOTTAKKAL,|
||11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM MEMBER KOLKALLI (HSS|
||BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL SECTION,|
||GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL,|
||KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT|
||REPRESENTED BY HIS MOTHER AND GUARDIAN/NEXT|
||FRIEND,SUBAIDA, W/O.HAMEED KALODI, AGED 40 YEARS,|
||HOUSEWIFE, KALODI HOUSE, THOKKAMPARA, KOTTAKKAL,|
||KOTTAKKAL VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL P.O, MALAPPURAM-|
||676503|
|6|SINAN, AGED 16 YEARS|
||S/O SHIHA SHAREEFA CHERUKATTIL HOUSE, PALATHARA,|
||KOTTAKKAL, 11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM MEMBER|
||KOLKALLI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER SECONDARY|
||SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER SECONDARY|
||SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT|
||REPRESENTED BY HIS MOTHER AND GUARDIAN/NEXT|
||FRIEND,SHIHA SHAREEFA, W/O.SHIHABUDHEEN, AGED 40|
||YEARS, HOUSEWIFE, CHERUKATTIL HOUSE, PALATHARA,|
||KOTTAKKAL VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN|
||- 676503|
|7|MUHAMMED SIDAN K, AGED 17 YEARS|
||S/O SAJITHA KOOTHUMADAN HOUSE,|
||PULICODE,KOTTAKKAL,11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM|
||MEMBER KOLKALLI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER|
||SECONDARY SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER|
||SECONDARY SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503,|
||MALAPPURAM DISTRICT REPRESENTED BY HIS MOTHER AND|
||GUARDIAN/NEXT FRIEND, SAJITHA, W/O.SIDDHIQUE, AGED|
||39 YEARS, HOUSEWIFE, KOOTHUMADAN HOUSE, PULICODE,|
||KOTTAKKAL VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN|
||- 676503|
|8|MOHAMMED DHANISH T.P., AGED 16 YEARS|
||S/O HASEENA THENAMPULAKKAL HOUSE, CHANGUVETTY MINI|
||ROAD, KOTTAKKAL, 11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM|
||MEMBER KOLKALLI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER|
||SECONDARY SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER|
||SECONDARY SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503,|
||MALAPPURAM DISTRICT REPRESENTED BY HIS MOTHER AND|
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
3
||GUARDIAN/NEXT FRIEND, HASEENA, W/O.SHAHJAHAN, AGED|
|---|---|
||32 YEARS, HOUSEWIFE, THENAMPULAKKAL HOUSE,|
||CHANGUVETTY MINI ROAD,KOTTAKKAL VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL|
||P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676503|
|9|MOHAMMED ADNAN, AGED 17 YEARS|
||S/O SUBAIDA KALLIYATH HOUSE, SWAGATHAMADU,|
||CHERUSOLA, 11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM MEMBER|
||KOLKALLI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER SECONDARY|
||SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER SECONDARY|
||SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT|
||REPRESENTED BY HIS MOTHER AND GUARDIAN/NEXT|
||FRIEND,SUBAIDA, W/O.HANEEFA, AGED 40 YEARS,|
||HOUSEWIFE, KALLIYATH HOUSE, SWAGATHAMADU,|
||CHERUSOLA, EDARIKODE VILLAGE, CHERUSOLA P.O,|
||MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN - 676510|
|10|MUHAMMED NASEEM, AGED 16 YEARS|
||S/O BASHEER MANDAYAPPURAM HOUSE, THOKKAMPARA,|
||KOTTAKKAL, 11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM MEMBER|
||KOLKALLI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER SECONDARY|
||SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER SECONDARY|
||SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT|
||REPRESENTED BY HIS FATHER AND GUARDIAN/NEXT|
||FRIEND, BASHEER, S/O.KUNJUMUHAMMED HAJI, AGED 54|
||YEARS BUISINESS, MANDAYAPPURAM HOUSE, THOKKAMPARA,|
||KOTTAKKAL VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN|
||- 676503|
|11|MOHAMMED RAZIN.A, AGED 16 YEARS|
||S/O NOUSHAD ADATTIL ADATTIL HOUSE, YAHOO ROAD,,|
||CHANGUVETTYKUNDU, 11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM|
||MEMBER KOLKALLI (HSS BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER|
||SECONDARY SCHOOL SECTION, GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER|
||SECONDARY SCHOOL, KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503,|
||MALAPPURAM DISTRICT REPRESENTED BY HIS FATHER AND|
||GUARDIAN/NEXT FRIEND,NOUSHAD ADATTIL, S/O.POKKER|
||HAJI ADATTIL, AGED 41 YEARS BUISINESS, ADATTIL|
||HOUSE, YAHOO ROAD,, CHANGUVETTYKUNDU, KOTTAKKAL|
||VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676503|
|12|SANJAY N, AGED 16 YEARS|
||S/O SUBRAHMANIAN NILAYANKODAN HOUSE, CHENGOTTUR, ,|
||11TH STANDARD STUDENT, TEAM MEMBER KOLKALLI (HSS|
||BOYS) - TEAM, HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL SECTION,|
||GOVERNMENT RAJAS HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL,|
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
4
KOTTAKKAL PIN 676 503, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT REPRESENTED BY HIS FATHER AND GUARDIAN/NEXT FRIEND, SUBRAHMANIAN, S/O.NEELAKANDAN, AGED 45 YEARS, BUISINESS, NILAYANKODAN HOUSE, CHENGOTTUR,KOTTAKKAL VILLAGE, KOTTAKKAL P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676503 M.P.RAMNATH P.RAJESH (KOTTAKKAL) BEPIN PAUL
## **RESPONDENTS:**
1 DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION / GENERAL CONVENER PROGRAME COMMITTEE MALAPPURAM REVENUE DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2023 MALAPPURAM, OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION, DOWN HILL, MALAPPURAM, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT,, PIN - 676505 2 DISTRICT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT EDUCATIONAL OFFICE, UP HILL, MALAPPURAM,MALAPPURAM DISTRICT - 676505 3 ASSISTANT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER / CONVENER PROGRAME COMMITTEE, MALAPPURAM SUB DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2023, CIVIL STATION , MALAPPURAM, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN - 676505 4 STATE OF KERALA REPRESENTED BY PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, GENERAL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695001 SMT.VIDYA KURIAKOSE - GP
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 11.12.2023, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
5
## **JUDGMENT**
The petitioners participated in the event “Kolkali” in the Sub District Kalolsavam, but did not secure first place; thus being denied the opportunity to move to the next level.
2. The petitioners say that they preferred an appeal against the results in the Sub District level, which has culminated in Ext.P3 order. They assert that even though the statutory scheme requires that every contention of the candidate be properly assessed, including through a video evaluation of the performance, this has not been done; and hence that they have been constrained to approach this Court through this writ petition.
3. Noticing the afore submissions of the petitioners, this Court had passed an interim order on 06.12.2023 to the following effect:
“The learned Government Pleader will obtain instructions in this matter.
I direct the 1[st] respondent to allow the petitioners to participate in the Malappuram Revenue District School Kalotsavam provisionally.
If the petitioners are deserving of any of the first three places, same shall be declared only after obtaining orders from this Court. ”
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
6
4. Sri.Ramnath M.P. – learned counsel for the petitioners, vehemently argued that his clients are brilliant performers who have consistently proven their credentials in the past and they rely on Ext.P19 in substantiation and that this is manifest from the fact that they have secured the second place, consequent to the afore interim order of this Court, in the District Level Kalolsavam. He thus prayed that this writ petition be allowed.
5. Smt.Vidya Kuriakose - learned Government Pleader, appearing for the official respondents, however, submitted that the law has now been well settled, through the judgment of this Court in Devna Sumesh v. State of Kerala [2022 KHC OnLine 8081], that once the appeal is disposed of, the petitioners would not obtain any right either in law or in equity. She added that the impugned order in the appeal clearly show that every contention of the petitioners had been properly considered.
6. I am afraid that the afore submissions of the learned Government Pleader cannot appeal to this Court in the specific circumstances of this case, since, for the first, it is now clear that the petitioners have performed well and has thus obtained rank No.2. For the second, the appellate order merely says that
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
7
all objections of the petitioners have been evaluated, but without citing any specific reasons. This is more so because, there is no indication therein that the video recording of the performance of the petitioners had been effectively evaluated.
7. In the afore circumstances, I allow this writ petition and set aside Ext.P3; thus confirming the interim order dated 06.12.2023; and clarifying that the petitioners will be granted all benefits consequent to their performance in the District Level Kalolsavam as per law.
As a necessary corollary to the afore, the results of the event shall be published by the organisers forthwith.
**Sd/- DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN**
**JUDGE**
stu
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
8
## **APPENDIX OF WP(C) 40752/2023**
|PETITIONER EXHIBITS|PETITIONER EXHIBITS|
|---|---|
|Exhibit P1|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES|
||OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR|
||PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB|
||DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 1ST|
||PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS|
|Exhibit P1(a)|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES|
||OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR|
||PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB|
||DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 2ND|
||PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS|
|Exhibit P1(b)|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES|
||OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR|
||PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB|
||DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 3RD|
||PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS|
|Exhibit P1(c)|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES|
||OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR|
||PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB|
||DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 4TH|
||PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS|
|Exhibit P1(d)|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES|
||OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR|
||PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB|
||DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 5TH|
||PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS|
|Exhibit P1(e)|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES|
||OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR|
||PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB|
||DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 6TH|
||PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS|
|Exhibit P1(f)|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES|
||OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR|
||PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB|
||DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 7TH|
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
9
## PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS
Exhibit P1(g) TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 8TH PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS Exhibit P1(h) TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 9TH PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS Exhibit P1(i) TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 10TH PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS Exhibit P1(j) TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 11TH PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS Exhibit P1(k) TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE CERTIFICATES OF MERIT DATED 13-11-23 ISSUED FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE 34TH MALAPPURAM SUB DISTRICT SCHOOL KALOTHSAVAM TO THE 12TH PETITIONER IN KOLKALI BOYS HSS Exhibit P2 TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE APPEAL DATED 15-11-2023 PREFERRED BY THE 1ST PETITIONER AS TEAM LEADER BEFORE THE 2ND RESPONDENT Exhibit P3 TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE ORDER NO. A5/2624/23 DATED 28-11-2023 ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT Exhibit P4 TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE MERIT CERTIFICATE DATED 03-01-2023 ISSUED TO THE FIRST PETITIONER FOR THE 61ST KERALA SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2022-23 JANUARY (STATE
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
10
||YOUTH FESTIVAL) IN WHICH HE OBTAINED A|
|---|---|
||GRADE|
|Exhibit P5|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE MERIT|
||CERTIFICATE DATED 03-01-2023 ISSUED TO|
||THE SECOND PETITIONER FOR THE 61ST KERALA|
||SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2022-23 JANUARY (STATE|
||YOUTH FESTIVAL) IN WHICH HE OBTAINED A|
||GRADE|
|Exhibit P6|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE MERIT|
||CERTIFICATE DATED 03-01-2023 ISSUED TO|
||THE FOURTH PETITIONER FOR THE 61ST KERALA|
||SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2022-23 JANUARY (STATE|
||YOUTH FESTIVAL) IN WHICH HE OBTAINED A|
||GRADE|
|Exhibit P7|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE MERIT|
||CERTIFICATE DATED 03-01-2023 ISSUED TO|
||THE SIXTH PETITIONER FOR THE 61ST KERALA|
||SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2022-23 JANUARY (STATE|
||YOUTH FESTIVAL) IN WHICH HE OBTAINED A|
||GRADE|
|Exhibit P8|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE MERIT|
||CERTIFICATE DATED 03-01-2023 ISSUED TO|
||THE EIGHTH PETITIONER FOR THE 61ST KERALA|
||SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2022-23 JANUARY (STATE|
||YOUTH FESTIVAL) IN WHICH HE OBTAINED A|
||GRADE|
|Exhibit P9|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE MERIT|
||CERTIFICATE DATED 03-01-2023 ISSUED TO|
||THE NINTH PETITIONER FOR THE 61ST KERALA|
||SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2022-23 JANUARY (STATE|
||YOUTH FESTIVAL) IN WHICH HE OBTAINED A|
||GRADE|
|Exhibit P10|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE MERIT|
||CERTIFICATE DATED 03-01-2023 ISSUED TO|
||THE TENTH PETITIONER FOR THE 61ST KERALA|
||SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2022-23 JANUARY (STATE|
||YOUTH FESTIVAL) IN WHICH HE OBTAINED A|
||GRADE|
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
11
|Exhibit P11|TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE MERIT|
|---|---|
||CERTIFICATE DATED 03-01-2023 ISSUED TO|
||THE ELEVENTH PETITIONER FOR THE 61ST|
||KERALA SCHOOL KALOTSAVAM 2022-23 JANUARY|
||(STATE YOUTH FESTIVAL) IN WHICH HE|
||OBTAINED A GRADE|
|Exhibit P12|THE TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE|
||APPLICATION DATED 04-12-2023 FILED BY THE|
||PETITIONERS' TRAINER HARIS RAHMAN M.P|
||BEFORE THE 2ND RESPONDENT|
|Exhibit P13|THE TRUE PHOTO COPY OF THE REPLY LETTER|
||DT 04.12.2023 BEARING NO.DEOMPM/2624/|
||2023-A5 ISSUED BY THE PUBLIC INFORMATION|
||OFFICER/ 2ND RESPONDENT IN PURSUANCE OF|
||EXT P12|
|Exhibit P14|THE TRUE PHOTO COPY OF THE SCORE SHEET OF|
||THE BOYS HSS GENERAL EVENT PERTAINING OF|
||KOLKALI INCLUDING THE SCORES OF THE|
||PETITIONER'S WITH THE NAME OF 1ST|
||PETITIONER WHO IS THE LEADER AND THE ONLY|
||OTHER TEAM OF DUHS PANAKKAD, MALAPPURAM,|
||WHICH PARTICIPATED IN THE EVENT AT THE|
||MALAPPURAM SUB-DISTRICT KALOLSAVAM 2023-|
||2024 AS ISSUED FROM THE OFFICE OF THE 2ND|
||RESPONDENT UNDER RTI ACT|
|Exhibit P15|THE TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE DIARY|
||SUBMITTED BY THE STAGE MANAGER IN|
||ANNEXURE-V AS PER THE KERALA SCHOOL|
||KALOLSAVAM MANUAL IN RESPECT OF THE EVENT|
||"KOLKALI" BOYS HSS GENERAL HELD ON|
||15.11.2023 AS ISSUED FROM THE OFFICE OF|
||THE 2ND RESPONDENT UNDER RTI ACT|
|Exhibit P16|THE TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE JUDGES|
||RESPONSE STATEMENT (PRATHIKARANA|
||PATHRIKA) IN ANNEXURE-VI AS PER THE|
||KERALA SCHOOL KALOLSAVAM MANUAL IN|
||RESPECT OF THE EVENT "KOLKALI" BOYS HSS|
||GENERAL HELD ON 15.11.2023 PERTAINING TO|
||THE PETITIONERS' TEAM PERFORMANCE, AS|
WP(C) NO. 40752 OF 2023
12
||ISSUED FROM THE OFFICE OF THE 2ND|
|---|---|
||RESPONDENT UNDER RTI ACT|
|Exhibit P17|THE TRUE PHOTO COPY OF THE SCORE SHEET OF|
||THE BOYS HS GENERAL EVENT PERTAINING OF|
||KOLKALI INCLUDING THE SCORES OF THE TWO|
||TEAMS THAT PARTICIPATED UNDER THE|
||LEADERSHIP OF SALMAN-UL-FARIS (GRHSS|
||KOTTAKKAL) AND OF JIBIN SULAIMAN P.K.,|
||(AKMHSS KOTTOOR) WHICH PARTICIPATED IN|
||THE EVENT AT THE MALAPPURAM SUB-DISTRICT|
||KALOLSAVAM 2023-2024 AS ISSUED FROM THE|
||OFFICE OF THE 2ND RESPONDENT UNDER RTI|
||ACT|
|Exhibit P18|THE TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE ORDER|
||NO.A5/2624/23 DATED 28-11-2023 ALLOWING|
||THE APPEAL FILED BY THE SECOND PLACED|
||TEAM (AKMHSS KOTTOOR) PASSED BY THE 2ND|
||RESPONDENT AS THE CHAIRMAN OF THE APPEAL|
||COMMITTEE AND ISSUED BY THE 2ND|
||RESPONDENT UNDER THE RTI ACT|
|Exhibit P19|THE TRUE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE ITEM WISE|
||PARTICIPANTS DETAILS, HSS GENERAL -|
||WINNERS IN 993-KOLKALI (BOYS) IN THE|
||MALAPPURAM DISTRICT KALCTSAVAM 22023|
||-2024 AS PUBLISHED BY THE 1 ST RESPONDENT|